Why do some Walstad aquariums develop problems over time? Is gravel or sand the better choice for capping soil in a dirted aquarium?
In Solving Walstad Problems, Father Fish explains why he prefers sand over gravel in natural planted aquariums and what can happen when nutrients move from the soil into the water column.
Father Fish discusses the advantages and disadvantages of gravel-capped substrates, why some dirted tanks experience declining pH, and how soil composition affects long-term aquarium stability.
He also shares lessons from his approximately 27-year-old natural aquarium, including how it continues growing plants without added fertilizer.
Questions answered in this video:
• Why does Father Fish recommend sand over gravel?
• What causes cloudy water in newly established dirted tanks?
• How does a sand cap help retain nutrients in aquarium soil?
• Why can pH decline in an established Walstad aquarium?
• What happens when aquarium plants remove nutrients faster than they are replenished?
• How can a natural planted aquarium remain productive for decades?
Learn how substrate choices, nutrient cycling, and water chemistry influence the long-term health of a natural aquarium.
Lou Foxwell, known as Father Fish, is a pioneer of natural aquarium keeping and the creator of the Father Fish Method. Why do some Walstad aquariums develop problems over time? Is gravel or sand the better choice for capping soil in a dirted aquarium?
In Solving Walstad Problems, Father Fish explains why he prefers sand over gravel in natural planted aquariums and what can happen when nutrients move from the soil into the water column.
Father Fish discusses the advantages and disadvantages of gravel-capped substrates, why some dirted tanks experience declining pH, and how soil composition affects long-term aquarium stability.
He also shares lessons from his approximately 27-year-old natural aquarium, including how it continues growing plants without added fertilizer.
Questions answered in this video:
• Why does Father Fish recommend sand over gravel?
• What causes cloudy water in newly established dirted tanks?
• How does a sand cap help retain nutrients in aquarium soil?
• Why can pH decline in an established Walstad aquarium?
• What happens when aquarium plants remove nutrients faster than they are replenished?
• How can a natural planted aquarium remain productive for decades?
Learn how substrate choices, nutrient cycling, and water chemistry influence the long-term health of a natural aquarium.
His approach to planted aquariums focuses on building balanced, self-sustaining ecosystems using soil substrates, natural processes, and minimal maintenance. The Father Fish Method draws inspiration from the Walstad Method and the natural aquarium philosophy of Takashi Amano.
Before entering the aquarium industry, Lou spent 25 years as a missionary, serving a congregation of deaf worshipers. He later opened a tropical fish store, where he adopted the role of Father Fish.
His passion for fishkeeping began in childhood, inspired by his grandmother from Berlin, Germany. He went on to become a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, where he helped shape its early development and leadership.
With decades of experience across the fishkeeping world, Father Fish shares practical knowledge on planted aquariums, dirt substrate systems, and natural ecosystem balance. He also provides plants, soil supplements, and tools to help hobbyists create thriving aquariums with less effort and fewer water changes.
All clips and images are used for illustration purposes only. Learn how the natural aquarium approach changed the hobby forever. This video explores the foundational book behind the method.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video discusses the pros and cons of using gravel versus sand as a substrate cap in a Walstad-style natural aquarium. While gravel allows for faster initial nutrient availability for certain plants, sand is recommended for long-term stability, preventing soil leaching, and maintaining a nutrient-rich environment over decades.
Aquarium gravel, rather than sand, is a cap for dirt.
It's doing really well in my CO2-injected tank.
I don't know where to begin.
Welcome to Father Fish and the Natural Aquarium.
I do not recommend gravel because,
with the Walstad method,
And routine water changes are required
in the early stages of setting up the tank.
Simply because the substrate,
it gets into the water column.
If you have any flow at all from a filter, anything,
even an air stone, they're creating a flow.
That flow is going to very easily go through the gravel,
down to the soil, pick it up and bring it back out in the water column.
So it gets muddy, it gets dirty very quickly in a new situation.
It usually requires two
or three water changes in order to clear that mess out.
But what is continuing to happen is that the nutrients
in that soil are being leached into the water.
Sand prevents that from happening.
Now, it's not an unhealthy environment.
In point of fact, it's a very healthy environment.
You can raise anubias or other tuber plants that grow on rocks
or hardscape in that kind of an environment much more easily and
much more quickly than if you had sand as a cap over the substrate.
It takes much longer for that tank to develop the food web on the
surface of the sand in order to be able to provide those nutrients
in the water column if you're using sand rather than gravel.
So there are some benefits to using gravel.
I think long-term, however, the benefit goes to the sand
because it allows you to maintain that system with a rich,
increasingly nutrient-rich substrate for the life
of the system, for the life of the aquarium.
As many of you know, I have a tank that was set up
with a deep substrate and the sand cap 27 years ago.
Around the year 2000, I have had to remove substrate from it twice
because it builds up over a period of a long period of time.
I've done that twice.
I have never added anything to it other than
a bit more sand to restore the cap
after taking half of it out.
But I've never put any fertilizer in it.
I've never enriched the soil.
Nothing like that.
and it it's growing plants continuing to grow plants
the only time it stopped growing plants
was when i was using it as a resource for growing plants
and pulling them out routinely
it was growing valerian in area like just a like a weed bed
and i was pulling them out every
every month or so i'd pull two-thirds of them out i did
that for oh six to eight months at least
and they stopped growing they didn't
die but they stopped growing nearly as fast and i realized i
was pulling all the nutrients out i was depriving it of nutrients
so i stopped doing that and it
has restored itself. The other issue is the CO2.
A Walstad system uses whatever is in the backyard
or in the potting soil bag or otherwise
is commonly available. Maybe it's soiled from a
garden. At best, it would be soiled from a garden.
That soil depletes, and it depletes because
it doesn't have long-term the kind of, for example,
the kind of carbonates that are needed
in order to be able to sustain an alkaline pH.
And so one of the problems
with the Walstad system doesn't happen all the time, but it
does happen when there are low levels of carbonate in the soil,
it becomes acidic.
And when it becomes acidic,
it begins developing acids in the substrate,
which kill the roots of plants and ultimately will drive the pH down
to the point where you won't be able to add new fish to the tank.
The fish that are in it will probably be fine.
They have accommodated to that condition gradually,
but putting new fish in will be virtually impossible. They'll die.
and they'll die quickly
because they can't tolerate going from alkaline to acidic instantly.
The other way is fine, not a problem.
But if you take a fish out of 7.5 pH, put it in 6.0 to 6.2,
6.3, it'll die in a matter of minutes.
It'll just start spinning.
And the reason is because the water pressure is changed
to such an extent that the cell walls expand.
And as they expand in that softer water and that less
is in that more acidic water, which is softer water typically,
as they expand, they rupture and the fish die.
Every cell in your body suddenly ruptured, you'd be dead pretty quick.
wouldn't wouldn't last a minute so um you know
if you're happy with the way the tank's going
that's great not a problem at all keep an eye
on the pH make sure it doesn't drop that
probably will be your biggest enemy
and then long term you might need to fertilize if you
know this planting language have a wonderful day
be sure to subscribe so you can get more of
this vast and vital knowledge for your hobby
and hit the like button because we know you loved it
and don't forget to share sharing is caring
the more you share the more we are able to reach out
reach out to the world beyond
and touch many lives with the great and powerful wisdom
of Bob's Fish.
Bye for now.