I Found The BEST Under $15 Costco Red Wine | Costco Wine Showdown

Sip & Style
1 follower
1 Video View·Oct 27, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
I went to Costco and bought every single
red wine they sell for under 15 bucks.
I ended up with 16 of them
and today we're gonna find out which one is the
absolute best. To do that we're pitting
them against each other in a head-to-head
bracket style tournament.
That means in each round only one wine can move on.
And because all of the wines cost so little,
more or less the same,
I really don't think there's any risk
of me being swayed by the price tag.
So we're not gonna do this one blind.
We're gonna raw dog this bad boy live.
Are you ready?
Let's get to boozing.
We have got a Beaujolais Nouveau from the legendary Louis Jadot.
This is 100% Gamay, which is a super light type of grape.
It's from the Burgundy region,
which is particularly known for Pinot Noir,
but this one little village.
They make Gamay, and they do it in a style that's very young.
These are young, youthful wines.
On the other hand, we have Chateau Saint-Michel Cabernet Sauvignon
from Columbia Valley, Washington.
These are a very traditional Bordeaux-style blend,
so should be a very, very different sort of wine,
a very different drinking experience.
I'm going to try my absolute best here for y'all.
My goal is not to just figure out necessarily
which one is, like, the best.
best at this moment what I'm trying to figure out
because they're so different is like which
is the more successful style.
Okay like which one is living up to what those sorts of wines tend to
be. So with all of that let's get going.
That wine is shockingly good. There wasn't too much to talk
about in the nose there
and it has a little bit of like an overly alcoholy sort of through line
but I am certain with some air this is going
to open up quite a bit. This one was ten dollars
And it's pretty good.
Okay, but conversely,
let's try this lighter Gamay wine and let's see, already it has way
more to smell on the nose, like it has a heaviness,
it has a little bit of like an olive sort
of thing, like it's seductive, it's elegant.
This was bold and brash.
You know, let's see how this one turns out.
Oh man.
Wow.
These are, wow.
This is an incredibly difficult first round right out of the gate.
Let me just start by saying that this feels
so rare for these sort of tastings that
two $10 options are both really pretty good.
I think that for the average person,
the everyday Joe, the good old
You know, like a good old Joe the Plumber type of meat-loving American.
You're probably going to get more mileage out of this wine.
It's just a bit more traditional.
It has more in common with the wines that we know
and love from places like California and Bordeaux.
This wine, on the other hand, is way more alluring and seductive,
and it just feels Burgundian.
And I just have to say, for me, this is the more interesting wine.
It's the one I want to get to know a little bit more.
But God.
Damn, this is really, really close.
This is excellent wine for $10,
but this wine is just a bit better for $11.
So with that being said.
Let's move on.
All right.
And before we begin this next round, allow me to introduce myself.
My name is Dustin and I've tasted thousands of wines
and I have a level one sommelier
certification.
But most importantly, I believe that wine shouldn't be so buttoned up.
It should bring you joy.
So while I am by no means the most expert wine guy,
I promise to be the most fun.
So if you haven't subscribed yet,
now is a great time to do so because by the end of
At the end of this video, you will know
the single best red wine you can buy at Costco
For under 15 bucks.
Let's keep going.
This is a particularly interesting matchup.
And what I mean by interesting,
I mean is like wild, crazy, and kooky.
These couldn't be more different in style.
A Tempranillo from Rioja.
100% the same grape.
Spent a ton of time in oak.
Decades of tradition.
All that stuff.
This proprietary red blend from Bogle
is not from a single place.
It is from California, right?
This is from a small part of Spain.
This is from the...
Biggest state in the country.
And this is gonna be a mix of Bordeaux blend grapes.
This is obviously Tempranillo.
There's just a whole different philosophy
of these two things.
So we're evaluating these in terms of their style,
not necessarily just in terms of which one is better
at this exact moment.
But let's see.
Let me give this one a go.
Bogle.
Wow, that smells so like concentrated, syrupy grape.
Like it's coming across a little bit of a flaw.
It's coming across as like a little bit of an overly sweet.
grape thing. Like it's not messaging to me as a mature,
sophisticated type of wine,
but it happens time and time again where
the way it smells is not the way it tastes. So let's give
it a taste.
Okay. Good news. All of the people
in the comments who really like Bogle,
you're onto something. This wine has something to it.
It actually has that backbone of pepperiness
that I find to be really,
really successful in alluring in Bordeaux blend wines. Bordeaux blend
wines are wines that are primarily Cabernet Sauvignon,
Merlot, Cabernet Franc, et cetera.
Okay. This is pretty successful.
I don't like love that syrupy sweet thing on the nose,
I suppose, but overall,
That came together way better
and the the little flaws that are there are managed pretty well.
That's pretty good. That was nine dollars if I recall
and that is that's hard to
to to be you know to sneeze at for nine bucks.
So let's check out this Rioja next.
Okay this has a far more old world nose like
in my mind it it has the smell.
Of like a muddy field with rocks in it,
which doesn't sound good, but it smells like you're
smelling nature.
Like it just smells like it's incorporated
into nature in a really pretty way.
It has a heaviness to it, like a thickness.
So I'm excited to give this a taste.
Here we go.
Also, look, the bottle gives us the cheat code.
So it does spend three years being aged,
but specifically it's two years in oak barrels
and it's one year in the bottle.
So it does get to three years.
I was right up in three years.
It's just kind of the allocation of those years
is a little different.
This is another tuppy.
This wine is remarkably available
to be accessible and drinkable.
Like anyone who's buying this to just like take it home
and...
Pop it and drink it.
This is excelling in that.
It was instantly good.
This wine tastes like a more sophisticated wine.
It's grown from an area of higher elevation.
You know, if you don't know, higher elevation wines have
a particular advantage over lower elevation wines.
That advantage is that they tend
to be from vineyards with lower yields.
What that means is that all the way up there in the mountains,
they can't plant as many vines
as they can on the valley floor where you can get
these perfect rows next to each other and
you get tons and tons of grapes per acre.
You just implicitly get less on the top of
of a mountain because it's all rocky and craggly and so
Those grapes tend to get more minerality.
They tend to get more of the earth for them.
They tend to end up better grapes.
In fact, if there is one little hack
that you might be able to use
to get better outcomes for you
whenever you're at the wine store,
it might be to search for wines that have elevation.
I think that's an interesting little tack
that helps find wines.
Here's the thing though.
This wine is just a little rough right now.
I think with some time and some air,
It would probably wake up.
I really believe that it would.
There's nothing implicitly wrong with it.
It's just so uptight right now.
Man, it's a 2018 and it's been aged for three years
and it's still this tense.
So.
If you haven't yet seen it,
I totally recommend you check out my I Try 100 Years of Wine video
where I taste the same Bordeaux wine
from the same producer at different vintages.
I tasted a 5-year-old, a 10-year-old, 15-year-old, 20-year-old,
even a 100-year-old of the same wine from the same producer.
What you'll see is that it really matters how long some
of these wines age.
And in this case, this tastes like a wine
that just needs more time.
Like the three years has not been enough.
It's so tense.
Most people are going to be put off by it.
Even though I know it's the better wine.
This is the better wine.
It is like, there is heritage.
There's probably a vineyard passed down by generations.
Like there's so many reasons to pick this.
But as far as like,
It's drinkability now, like it's success.
It isn't ready yet.
And so if you're going to buy it to drink it in a few years,
yeah, you should buy that.
It'll probably be a banger in three.
But as it stands right now, this Bogle is the better one to buy.
All right, let's move on.
All right, up next, we have another improbable matchup
that I'm very excited about.
We have a blended Grenache Syrah Mouved Southern Rhone wine
that is the Kirkland Signature brand
versus Kirkland Signature's Malbec from Mendoza, Argentina.
These are two Kirkland Signature wines
that I think are pretty great.
If you check back to the, I...
rank every Costco brand wine video.
This one wasn't in it. It wasn't available at the time,
but my memory of it, having had it a few times,
is that it's quite good for the money.
And this did very well too. So this is very exciting to try these both
side by side. Let's check out this Southern Rhone wine first.
Here we go. This one's pretty light.
It's like a little,
a little through line of pencil shavings and graphite minerality.
A little bit of like a black cherry thing going on,
but it's not totally very expressive on the nose,
but let's give it a taste.
That is a really lovely Rhone wine.
That is a great GSM.
A GSM is a Grenache Sra Louvert blend.
This is a classic blend from the Rhone Valley.
They've replicated across the world.
You can get GSM blends from California and the like.
This wine is really pretty spectacular for 12 bucks, I think.
I think it has like a tart.
cherry but honestly like a burst of strawberry
but tons and tons of minerality and depth like
this is a pretty sophisticated wine. I really like this.
So this Malbec has its work cut out for it
but this is you know if there is a wine
that might be able to do it it could be this one.
Mendoza is legendary for having some
of the best value wines on the planet. It's just a
Part of the world that really got bought up very quickly
by prominent French and American winemakers
30-40 years ago for pennies on the dollar
for these remarkable inured sights. And so there's a
chance that this wine might be able to outdo it.
Let's take a look. Okay, pretty like plummy, no flaws
on the nose, like plummy but simple,
but also just has like a depth and alluringness. I'm excited to try it.
Okay. This has been so much better than the white wines.
Oh my God. So far, statistically speaking,
I can say it's a pretty good chance that if you buy
a red wine under $15 at Costco, you're probably
going to have a good time. These are both great.
This wine's like seven bucks. This one's like 12.
Okay. Listen, I feel like this wine is very successful.
It is peppery. It is robust. It is
Interesting. It has a zestiness that I find to be really,
really pleasurable, but I just,
at the end of the day, if we're looking at the style,
a Malbec is typically like a pretty heavy, serious experience.
Like it's a wine that you can kind of chew on stylistically.
Like this is a pretty light interpretation of a Malbec.
It doesn't mean it's bad. It's very, very good.
But when I think of a Malbec, this isn't really what I'd think of.
This tastes a little bit like a
Watered down, maybe a little bit more mass-produced,
but it's still really good.
I'm stunned at how good this is,
knowing that it's like seven bucks.
But this is Southern Rhone GSM.
This is what that area tastes like,
and it's doing so really without compromises.
So for me, this one is the more successful wine,
but that does not mean that this is a failure.
This is a great option for $7.
I also recommend it.
Let's move on.
Here we go. All right.
Up next, we have two pretty, this is, this is the less of a crazy
mashup. I like this one. Okay.
So on one hand we have a classic Kirkland signature brand,
a Costco brand Cabernet Sauvignon.
This is their Alexander Valley. So Sonoma County Cabernet. On
the other hand, we have a Malbec.
Uh, this is also from Mendoza, Argentina. And so this
Clearly different wines
but as far as stylistically they're both going to be loud,
you know, brash big wines
so I don't think it's as crazy to match them up. But what I'm most
interested in is that this one claims it
is a 96 point score that it received from Decanter.
Like 96 points in my opinion is an excellent wine.
All right let's pour out this small bag.
Already, can I just comment that I am not of the mindset,
typically, that it's so important
that you look at the wine.
Oh, it's like, oh, you gotta see it.
You gotta look at it.
But what I've noticed, especially after doing
so much more of these budget wines on the
program to kind of cast a wider net with the audience,
there is a look that just seems
to be more apparent with cheaper wines.
There's like a sheen to them.
There's just like a little bit, it's hard to describe.
Wines that are more expensive, they're more concentrated,
like light doesn't pass through them as much.
There's just more sediment stuff.
It feels like there's more to chew on.
And so when a 96-point Malbec pours out and looks like this to me,
like it doesn't give me the best.
Immediate feeling like I don't know if that's true
because it just looks so smooth and glossy and ultimately like my wife
And I went to Mendoza, Argentina about two years ago,
and we visited Vina Cobos
Which is a legendary priestess from Paul Hobbs in California.
We had their 100 point wine. It's like $300 a bottle
Okay, it's a few points less than this
I am certain that if I pulled
that and poured it out next year, it would be like
It's dark as night.
It is pitch black.
It would be heavy and thick and chewable.
This wine is the first,
one of the first times I'm really like looking
and being like, oh, this is where sight really might matter.
But let's just see if that plays out.
So here we go.
Yeah, it just kind of smells like simple and traditional.
Kind of smells like Josh Cabernet Sauvignon to me.
Like it just kind of smells like red wine.
Okay, but it does taste pretty good.
It's not like.
Damn right, my toes aren't curling, but like pretty good.
It's not the most sophisticated thing,
but it's pretty good.
That's pretty good.
This has surprised me.
I would never in a million years have guessed
that this was a Malbec grape.
It tastes exactly like a traditional French Bordeaux blend.
So that's cool, that's good.
It's like a little fruitier.
It does not taste like a 96 point wine to me,
but it tastes like a pretty good one.
Like a 91, 90, 91.
I don't know, but I would probably give like,
A weak B. Here we go. This wine smells like cigarettes.
This wine smells kind of like the,
like an old pool hall, you know, like an old billiards hall.
In a way that I find to be kind
of cool. This smells really, really nostalgic and cool in a fun way.
It doesn't necessarily
give me the feeling that it's going to be great wine,
but it is great to smell. So let's give it
a taste.
It kind of a little bit tastes like an old billiards room.
It's honestly, it's okay.
It's not terrible.
I find that wines, sometimes they droop.
It's almost like someone working their way
down a piano scale.
Like they're ending a song and they're like,
boom, boom, boom, boom.
And you're like, okay, it's over.
But they're just like, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom.
And you're like, is it over?
Boom.
And you're like, oh, it just keeps going.
He's getting lower and lower and like not better.
Like we're kind of ruining what was there.
So all that being said, this has some flaws.
It's kind of not showing up totally well,
but it's not a total failure.
But in this case, I gotta give Decanter some credit.
They were able to pick the better wine in this case.
And so it's moving on, and so are we.
All right, up next we have,
I think like from a price standpoint, a very even matchup.
We have the classic grocery store treasure,
Menage a Trois.
And over here we have another Costco Cabernet Sauvignon.
This one is from Columbia Valley, Washington.
It's cheaper, I think it's $7 or so.
And hey, look at that, a screw top.
Or a stelvin is the technical term.
So to be clear, you know,
sugar is an essential component of the winemaking process.
Like, we need sugars.
I mean, in most cases, they don't need to be added.
But it's not the worst thing in the world if the winemaker needs
to add more sugar to get the fermentation started.
Imagine, like, they're just...
Especially in places like champagne,
where the wines are so dry,
they don't have a lot of natural sweetness.
This is a part of the process.
So it's not always like,
oh my God, there's sugar being added.
But yes, I agree with you, Richard.
Like they are adding it to a point
where they're creating a style, an intentional style.
And that style is one of like sweet approachability.
Let's see how they actually turn out.
Here we go.
This Ménage à Trois smells like a boring Ménage à Trois.
There's not really anything going on to smell,
which I would imagine Ménage à Trois should smell hot.
They should smell like musty with dislike, animal desire.
Like this wine isn't giving me any of that.
It just kind of smells like a,
like a, just like just nothing.
It's a boring, a little sweet,
a little sweet on this note.
So let's give it a taste.
Okay, that's pretty sweet.
It's not like so sweet.
I think that we've had some other wines on the channel
that might be sweeter.
Like I'm looking at you, like Miomi Pinot Noir.
Like my memory of that was that it was just like
someone took tablespoons of sugar into it, but it's sweet.
I think to great effect to mask the flaws that are present.
It's not that good.
I don't really like it.
This would have to really, really screw the pooch
to not make it to the next round.
There's also not much to smell here,
but it doesn't have any sweetness to smell.
I don't hate sweet wines,
but this is clearly being used to mask a problem
and not an intentional choice to be like,
oh, I want to express the beauty of these grapes
in a sweet way.
This is like, we need to give these grapes
every fighting chance they have.
So let's just like pack these with domino sugar.
Here we go.
This isn't even like a contest.
This is by no means the best wine I've had so far,
but it is grown up adult wine.
It has some roughness around the edges,
but boy oh boy, it is better than at least this
Ménage à Trois. So it's moving on and so are we.
Let's go. Okay, up next we do have quite a bit more
of a like for like.
We have on one hand a $5 Cabernet Sauvignon from the Lodi. I am certain
everyone will correct me in the compliments,
so thank you so much in advance for doing that. I
I really appreciate it.
And next.
We have another Bordeaux blend.
So this is a Cabernet Sauvignon driven wine,
so as if it was from the left bank of Bordeaux.
This is a just red blend, but it's primarily
Bordeaux grapes from Washington state though.
And it's Costco's signature series. This is actually,
oh, I didn't even mean to do this.
This is the most expensive wine of the tasting.
This is the cheapest. This one's $5.
So this is an interesting little matchup.
All right, and by the way,
if you've enjoyed nerding out with me so far about wine, then I
think that you'll probably like my free newsletter too.
Every few weeks, I send out an email with
valuable wine info, and I even do free wine giveaways.
So if you haven't yet, please consider
checking out WineGuyDustin.com to sign up.
That's WineGuyDustin.com to sign up. Completely free,
tons of value for you. I'll see you there. Okay.
Up next, we've got our $5 wine versus our $15 wine.
Let's see what we're dealing with.
I will just say I've been remarked.
It's remarkable so far how little
these wines have just been like flat out disappointing
or a bummer.
This wine is also not messaging as being a completely flawed.
It just doesn't smell like much,
but sometimes cheap wines smell like, oh my God, that's
so cheap smelling.
This just smells like air and like faintest little thing of red wine.
Let's give it a little taste.
Okay, boy, that wine is...
A little interesting, it is very cheap tasting
and it tastes like they added sugar to it but like
It's still pretty dense and it still has a through line of pepperiness.
It reminds me quite a bit of a wine that did exceptionally well
in our $5 USA grocery store wine showdown
where we tasted 52 grocery store $5 wines to see which was best.
And the Yellowtail Merlot was a pretty exceptional wine at the $5 mark.
And I feel like this reminds me of it, like there,
this isn't immediately a turnoff and boy,
if you were about to have a wedding, wow,
this is a great value for five bucks.
It is not great wine, but it is pretty good.
It's a little sweet, but it's got some complexity and
it's $5. So like, kind of like back off in a way.
All right. So this really needs to just
be a little more than just like cheap wine and it'll probably win, but
We have seen Costco fall flat
on its face before. Let's give it a snill.
Okay, it already smells a little bit more like peppery,
a little bit more like tobacco,
a little leathery. So it's exciting.
Yeah, that's pretty good. I mean, it's, you know,
I've tried this wine before
and I am certain that the last one that I had had more like
concentration. This is coming across as a little bit watery to me
and I have a clear memory.
of a clear taste memory of this one like i was excited
when i bought this one again i was like
oh i remember this one being pretty good
so wine is a living thing vintages change this is a massive
like this thing's pulling grapes from all over the columbia valley
who knows but the point is in this particular case
this wine is the winner
But I'm just a little heartbroken
because I do know that I've tasted better ones of it.
And this by no means is a bad wine.
It's just not the winner in this particular case. But hey,
pretty good. All right, let's move on.
All right, up next we have a wine that I just
I do have some bias against this particular producer.
I don't think it's the worst by any stretch.
And for sure, you know, in a pinch, I think it's totally good.
But it's just like so big and like not really in my mind.
Related to what I'm seeking in wine, which is like some sort
of expression of a place and like the story of a winemaker,
like a family and like drinking something.
You're like, wow, I feel really connected to this story in this place.
Like this is hard to feel that way.
This feels a little bit more like a vessel for drinking.
And then over here, I was really excited about this one.
It's just Columbia Winery.
So I think I think Columbia Valley in Washington.
I think that their wines are excellent values
and so I think that that makes this a really
interesting matchup.
Clearly both values and they're almost the same price but in different
ways. So yeah I'm just excited.
I think that these both cost almost the same amount if I recall
and my excitement level for one of them
is a lot higher than my excitement level for the other one.
So oh these are both 2021s.
When you're buying wine from Costco,
that is a place with a lot of turnover in their inventory.
Things do not sit on the shelves at a Costco for very long.
The wine completely changes the aisle
every couple of weeks, it seems,
maybe every couple of months at the most. So the fact that
these are 2021s on the shelves
is clearly some intentionality there. These must be
Just now becoming available or they got a screaming deal on them.
So either one.
I hope that the story is intentional.
Like this needed more time and they let it have time.
And this was like, Costco was like,
what palette of old wine do you have that we can get a killer deal on?
Let's give it a smell.
Wow, this is so biased.
I promise I'm gonna be fair.
Here we go.
This doesn't smell like anything, I promise.
These smell a little bit like sun-made raisins.
A little bit.
Yeah, see that wine? It's just like sweet.
It honestly really reminds me of the Menage a Trois,
both the one that we drank
and that cool one I talked about in college. I
just don't really get it. I just don't get it.
I mean, I do get it at some level. Like,
I don't think that winos are buying this wine.
So it is more approachable than most of the wines
we've had. It's a little sweet. It's easier to drink.
It has a little bit of complexity,
but for me, that's, it's not really the one. Let's give this one a go.
Not much to smell here. It's a little bit of like a mouthwash-y thing,
which sounds like a bad thing, but that often literally evaporates.
It's like an acetone type
of finish. My experience, when it's on the nose and that light,
that tends to just kind of waft
off. So this is a freshly opened bottle.
Let's just keep that in mind. Here we go. Okay.
Here is what we can learn about these two wines.
This wine is made from a factory process.
At some point they put sugar in it and they make it sweet.
And it really helps cover up any of the flaws.
This wine tastes a heck of a lot more
like a natural wine making.
I don't mean like natural,
I mean like a typical wine making process
or normal or artisan.
It has
Complexity, it has pepperiness, it has zestiness,
it has like a green bell pepper thing going on.
Like this is enjoyable drink.
It is not the best Merlot I've ever had, but it's $12.
And in this case, it tastes a lot more like wine to me.
And it is the one that is moving on.
And you, sir, good day to you, Josh.
One day, I hope we get a chance to connect.
Because honestly, you're accomplished.
Business man, wow, what an accomplishment
to create this incredible brand.
But boy, I feel like we could partner together
and we could make a couple unique expressions
of Josh Sellers that were a bit more of a place,
a little bit less of a process.
And I think that you might be able to create
something really special for your customers.
So moving on, here we go.
All right, up next we have another pretty like-for-like situation.
We have a new Cabernet Sauvignon from Costco.
I've never seen this one before. It's another
Sonoma County, but broader.
That other one was Alexander Valley, which would be a part of Sonoma
County. So this is a bigger appellation to pick from,
so likely of less quality. It was cheaper,
too. Versus this Cabernet Franc from Octopod,
a little tip that can sometimes lead
I think more often than not to you finding better wines
is when you're looking on the shelf and
let's say you've got a $10 budget. This one was 10 bucks.
This one was seven. This wine being 100%
Cabernet Franc. That's a non-typical grape.
That's a weird grape. Like they have an uphill battle to
market and sell that wine versus someone
who's making Cabernet Sauvignon. So
To me, there is a higher likelihood of quality in this bottle.
Like, they can't be holding back the margins.
Like, they have to put everything they can into this wine compared
to something in Cabernet Sauvignon where they're like,
all right, like, someone will buy it.
So these tend to be more passion projects.
These might even be loss leaders.
Like, they might be like, Jesus, we need to get rid of this wine.
We made too much of it.
No one wants to buy it.
So I think that that can sometimes be really helpful is when you're at
the store and you're like, you know what, I'm going to buy something.
A little less typical than normal at lower price points.
I don't I don't think that scales.
I don't think that you should be buying hundred dollar weird wines
for the sake of it. Buy whatever
hundred dollar wine you actually want.
Okay it is time to finally get to the sniffy sniffy part.
Yeah, this smells, I hate to say it,
but it just kind of smells like cheap wine.
Like, it just has a softness to the smell.
And, like, when you can smell textures,
like it's a fabric softener softness, it doesn't normally bode well.
But we've seen that be wrong before.
Let's give it a sip.
It's actually a lot better than it smelled.
Wow.
It's even, I think, better than the, like,
the other Cabernet Sauvignon from Alexander Valley.
That one had a...
A little bit too much of a sense of place, like,
and that place might have been a stall, like a
stall of a pigsty or something. I don't know.
It's just a little too, like, of a barn.
This is approachable. It's kind of what I imagine Josh should be.
Like, it's not sweet, but it's
approachable and soft and doesn't have that many big flaws.
It's nice. It's like an easy drinker.
So let's see if this Cabernet Franc lives up at all to that
little approach I talked about earlier
about it being a bit off the beaten path.
Okay, this has a bit more to smell,
like it has a bit more of a mossiness, has a bit more of a
to it. It almost smells like like morning fog
in a way. Here's the thing, this wine is
Really pretty good for the money, I have to say.
The $7 is, you're getting a lot of value for that money here.
And I'm a little alarmed to share
that this wine has a little bit more softness,
cheapness edges to it than I typically would like.
But it also has this really rich plum.
It reminds me literally of like a plum sauce,
like the Chinese condiment.
Like it's like a plum sauce sort of thing.
It's a little soy saucy.
It's like a little...
Sweet and umami and it has just more going on but it
also has like a through line of just being
like cheap and manufactured too.
But there's way more to talk about with this wine and so
with that being said this is clearly the one that should move on.
But also I have to say
before we totally move it on I have
a complete morbid curiosity to know about
The blend that we've been building back here.
Like, what is 16 pour outs of red wine
under $15 at Costco like?
And is it better than some of the other stuff
that we've been tasting?
So let's give it a little, let's give it a little taste.
It really doesn't smell like anything.
It's not really too much going on here.
It kind of reminds me of this one, to be honest.
So it's not, yeah, it just doesn't have much going on.
Let's give it a taste.
Pretty good.
It tastes a little cheap.
Like it tastes, it tastes a little cheap hookery.
If this was against some of the other wines
like the Ménage a Trois, this would beat it.
So I think what it shows you is how bad that wine is.
But yeah, this isn't so bad.
That all being said, this is not moving on.
The Octopod is.
So are we.
Here we go.
We're back! It's round two, match one!
Okay, up next we still have a rather improbable matchup.
A legendary historic producer, Louis Jadot,
following a millennia of tradition in producing
100% Gamay Beaujolais wine, and on the other hand,
like a really different approach, which is a
Red wine blended from grapes all over California
in likely a pretty like supply chain optimized
way. So not to say this isn't supply chain.
I mean, this is a huge company, but as far as which
one is just a little bit more rooted in tradition,
uh, it's going to be this one. So old world
versus new. Here we go. All right.
On the nose, this is like getting like plummy and jammy.
It's like approachable. It's really nice. This wine is like,
Soft, supple. I just,
I want to get to know it more and I'm excited to do so now.
It jumps out of the glass to me.
It has a lot of character.
It is lacking concentration,
which is a demerit,
but it makes up for it in being so unexpected, being so
playful being so like sweet and fun, but also earthy and
and like a sour
Cherry thing, like man, this is exciting to drink and fun
and I just keep wanting more of it.
That's a big accomplishment.
Bogle though, on the other hand,
is beloved by so many of you.
Let's see how it does.
Okay, on the nose, this has become more sophisticated.
It has way more oak coming through.
It has like so much more red fruit
bursting out of the top now.
Like it just, it's coming a bit more alive.
So this is way more of a match up now.
Let's give it a taste.
You Bogleheads, which is a thing.
Bogleheads are people who are into the guy
who invented the index fund
and started the Vanguard Corporation.
His name was like John Bogle.
People who follow him are called Bogleheads.
So the rest of you Bogleheads out there
are onto something.
I'm really like, this is really very, quite good.
The thing though.
Is that it has cracks in its armor, like it has some flaws
that are just creeping in that are just taking me out of it.
This being like a lack of concentration, man, I mean,
everyone's drinking La Croix's, spin drifts, Waterloo's.
Those are the definition of lacking concentration.
People made a consumer like category.
Out of a lack of concentration,
so it doesn't strike me as the worst crime.
The rest of it is so rich with fun. This on the other hand,
its crime is that it just has
this like manufactured slash kind of cleaning product-y
That thing in the middle, like it's like the opening
and the finisher sutured together
by some sort of artificial sweetener.
It doesn't go down smooth for me.
It's really good.
It has complexity.
It has the cool nose.
Like this is a good wine.
It just is matched up against something
that I think is living up to what fine wine
does really well a bit better.
And so with that being said, I'm so sorry, Bogleheads.
This one is moving on.
And so are we.
So again, we have a bit of a,
bit of a divide in terms of style of these wines
going against each other.
We have a loud, brash Malbec
versus a much more supple, reserved Rhone wine.
In fact, I'm gonna choose to try the Rhone wine first
cause I don't wanna like blow out my palate
doing the other one.
So I'm gonna start over here,
but let's get to the smelling part.
Yeah, not too much to smell on this one.
Just like a faint little hint of the word rock is what I would say.
Yeah, like a rock.
But maybe not even a rock.
It's just like the word rock.
So it
is elegant.
It's sophisticated.
It is a wine that has pencil shavings
and graphite and minerality and granite and like
Lum, cherry, like woof, that's a fun wine.
Really, really pretty good.
So, but I remember this being really surprising too.
So I'm excited to give this a go.
Here we go.
Way more to smell,
but I wouldn't say that what you get to smell
is like super interesting.
It just kind of smells like red wine.
This is a very, very close one.
This is gonna come down 100% to style.
If you are the sort of person who values
A traditional, big, new world style approach to winemaking.
You're going to really enjoy this wine for $12, $13, whatever it costs.
Wow!
There is a lot in this wine.
It packs a punch.
But I would still argue that it
is not exactly living up to a Malbec designation.
It's just not...
Totally concentrated. It's just not very chewy.
It's just a little soft. This Rhone wine, on the
other hand, is far more traditional.
It tastes like a fancy, expensive Rhone wine. And so even
though some of it's loud, it's more alluring.
It's more sexy. And so it's just, in my opinion,
the more successful wine.
They're both great, but in this case, this one is moving on.
And so are we.
Okay.
This is our first, like, I think full blown like for like,
uh, on so many levels, they
are both Costco brand wines.
They are both from Columbia Valley
and they are both Cabernet Sauvignon dominant.
Oh, the only thing they don't have in common is their price.
This one was like seven-ish bucks.
The real price was on the screen.
This one, I clearly remember, was 15.
So that is the difference.
I mean, there's probably more difference than that,
but at a high level, that is what we're dealing with.
So does double the money get you double the wine?
Here we go, Washington Valley Cabernet Sauvignon
dominant Costco wines that cost between $7 and $15 starting.
Okay, this one's starting to get a little more,
like, funky, funky wild.
It's getting a little more of, like, a living manure thing,
but in a pleasurable kind of good way.
Let's give it a taste.
Pretty good.
Like, that is great.
Wine for seven bucks.
I think it also would be an amazing candidate for,
if you happen to buy 30 bottles in a hurry
for a wedding or something,
you'd be getting a lot of value for your money.
So it's lacking a little bit of concentration.
It's got a little bit of sweetness and stuff,
but overall, like it's pretty convincing wine
for seven bucks or ish, seven ish.
Watch it be.
I'm like totally misremembering and it's actually 150.
No, it was like seven ish.
Here we go.
The expensive one.
The faintest little leathery tobacco thing,
but boy, it's faint. It's over there.
It's not really jumping out to me when you smell it.
This is just such a more grown up wine.
This wine is softer. It's more approachable. This wine
I went to the gym, got a little bit jacked.
Like it is harder to drink.
It's more tannic, it's more aggressive,
but it's so much more sophisticated.
It has so much more going on.
And it is the winner in this case, but boy, oh boy.
No need to sleep on this one.
It's still pretty good too.
It's just in this case,
it was outgunned by its bigger, more jacked brother.
All right, let's move on.
All right, we have got a...
Like a pretty reasonable like for like here,
a Columbia Valley Merlot, so a Bordeaux blend grape
with a California Cabernet Franc, another Bordeaux blend grape.
So these should be similar
in style. We're not having to compensate too much
for like wildly different.
Kind of expressions of wine,
we get to be just a lot more like which of these is the better one.
I am excited because air changes the game of wine
and these have all been open,
they've all been getting a little bit more alive
and so let's see what's happening.
Uh this one is just it's like a little it's just
a light little bit of plummy thingy
kind of charcuterie board accoutrements
um but not loud just like a light delicacy to it.
It's pretty good.
It's surprisingly approachable in a way that isn't flawed.
That is a hard thing to manage for wine makers.
You know, normally when you get into approachability,
you also like sacrifice complexity.
And this wine manages to really stay the path
and be like just pleasant.
It is not the most, it's not like a, you know,
a hundred dollar bottle of French Bordeaux that, you know,
will sit on your palate for an hour after you've had it.
But it's still, it's just really,
It's an approachable...
Drinkable Bordeaux blend and I like it.
Let's smell this one. This one's becoming more interesting.
That green bell pepper thing is like way more present
and so is like a raspberry thing. It's
just getting like, it's a little bit more like alive I feel
in a way than this this other wine.
Let's give it a taste. There is more going on in this wine.
It tastes to me, do you remember as a kid?
In your garden might have been some sort
of plant growing like sunflowers or maybe it was like a tomato plant
or something and then you like bit the the green part
of the plant like the the main plant part you were just like what
is okay like there's the pepper like what is the plant you just
like bite it you're like I want to try it and it's so vegetal
and it's also like spicy and it's also just like alive like it has
so much more of that in it but it also has so much more of this like
Manufactured softness, like it feels like had they just let
the wine be what it was gonna be and not intervene
in the winery, like not try to make it more approachable,
it would have probably been something really special.
Instead, it's like trying to
Fight through all that doctoring to express itself.
And so it just ends up being like a little bit of a mess.
This on the other hand tastes more honest to me
and it tastes like it's a happy accident
that it ended up approachable versus this
where someone wouldn't just let the grape be
what it wanted to be and instead forced it
to be something it wasn't.
So with that being said, this one is moving on.
Columbia Winery, let's move on to.
Okay, I am not gonna lie,
I am a little heartbroken about this one
because these two wines have been doing an excellent job
in this tasting so far,
and I kind of feel like it's now my job
to choose between two of my favorite children.
It is with a heavy heart that I pour these two wines
so that we can send one to the finals and one to slaughter.
Oh boy, oh boy.
I don't love the way that that sounds.
It's what needs to be done.
Let's begin with the 100% Gamay from Louis Jadot.
Wow, this is becoming even more interesting to smell.
It is so funky.
Like, it's like the inside of the barrel room of a winery.
Like, wow, this is really cool.
It's alive.
It just feels like it's been a great dance partner so far.
And so I'm very excited to try it.
This is really good Beaujolais of the Lodge.
I've had a lot of this in my life.
This is a particularly exceptional bottle.
Like it is really coming together in a way
that I think in my years has been hard
to come across with this.
Mostly I've been a little miffed by these bottles.
This is a really good one.
It's really showing well.
The only thing that isn't showing well
is it just has a bit of...
Sweetness in a way that is coming across
as a little bit of blood and it is not
super concentrated. It just tastes like they added
a bit too much water to it
therefore is maybe a little cheap tasting.
Here we go. Yeah this is finally
getting more like peppery.
a little plummy. Richard said it was jammy on the nose
and I think that that's true. I think it's
just like a sophisticated jam.
Like not one you'd necessarily pick off the shelf but one that if
someone was like oh this one is limestone jam you'd
be like okay I'm curious to like give that
a sniff at least. So yeah this is like rocks jam.
Oh man I have to choose one of my favorite
children to survive and the other to slaughter.
Here's the thing about these boys is that
Stylistically.
They are both dialed in. Like these are exactly what
these wines are supposed to taste like,
but this one really doesn't have any flaws.
Like it doesn't jump out to me like it's by no means
the best Rhone I've ever had, but ---- man it doesn't really have any
concentration issues, wateriness, like it's just good. This
It is really excellent,
but this is really very good and deserves to go to the finals.
And so for that, Costco, you should be proud of yourself.
Good job, Costco.
Really good job.
All right, let's move on.
So let's get into it.
Columbia Winery Merlot
and the Costco Signature Series.
Please.
Please.
Columbia Valley Wine.
This is becoming a bit more alive when you smell it.
A little more plummy, a little more exciting, a little more racy.
I'm excited to try it.
Man, this wine is approachable.
It is the most excellent beginner wine.
Wow, I cannot recommend this wine enough.
People who are new to wine, they're trying to learn about it
because you're going to get to try a big boy wine
without so much of the big boy wine baggage,
like high tannin, high acid.
That's really good, really approachable.
Here we go.
Okay, ma'am.
These two wines are
Different expressions of a similar thing.
One of them is showing up as a buddy, someone who just is down to hang.
The other one is a bit more of a recluse, a bit more on its own,
but you can tell has some complexity
and a little bit more kind of brooding going on.
But here's the thing, this wine also has some flaws,
like that loner ---- isn't really helping it all
that much in this case.
I think that this wine is a lot more agreeable.
It has a lot more stuff to offer you.
And I think that the more people you invite
to drink this with would like it too.
This wine is gonna shut too many people down.
And honestly, it's like kind of acetone-y flock.
It's gonna get in the way real quick.
So with that being said, finalist.
And so we're moving on.
Alright, the finals!
Oh my god, we have two very different expressions of wine here.
On one hand, we have a Columbia Valley Merlot,
so a Bordeaux-style expression,
and, which is from Washington State,
and a Rhone blend, Grenache Syrah Mouved,
from the southern Rhone region of France.
But the Costco brand, ooh, what a value king over here. Okay.
There's nothing left to do but to get into it.
Here we go.
The more that I drink this wine,
the more that I like it.
The more that I am so impressed
with how deeply approachable and tasty it is
without being off-putting, without pushing people away
who might not be as experienced with wine.
Wow, I cannot recommend this wine enough.
If you are new to wine, you should track this down.
I think you'd really enjoy it.
It has an exquisite balance of sweetness, tannin, acid.
Fruit, earthy minerality, all of that stuff.
It is here in spades.
It's really, really good.
So now, up against Costco's Grenache Syrah Mouvedre.
Here we go.
You gotta give these Frenchmen a raise.
Like, they just did such a good job for you.
This is a really, really great wine.
And what I love so much about it is how...
honest and true to the expression of southern wines it is.
Like it is those types of wines.
Often in this tasting,
the Costco versions of wines were just slightly cheaper versions of
those wines. Like I don't feel like that makes it a value.
Like I think the Kirkland Signature
brand should be about being the absolute best
for the best price. This wine...
Actually lives up to that promise.
This is a full blown Southern Rhone wine
that just happens to be at a Costco brand price.
And so with that being said,
there is one clear winner of this particular tasting
and it is this.
Costco Southern Rhone wine.
Woo!
Oh, Costco.
Wow, Costco, you won your own battle.
All right, that was so much fun.
Thank you so, so much for watching.
If you haven't subscribed yet to the channel,
now is a great time to do so.
The more subscribers we get,
the larger and more expensive these wine tournaments
will be for you in the future.
Think.
$500 wines instead of $10 and $15 wines.
And don't forget about the free newsletter,
which you can sign up for at WineGuyDustin.com.
Also, if you like this video, click like.
And one last thing,
I have a friend who started her own business.
It's called Tosi Tortilla Chips.
These chips are dope.
They are fantastic.
She's a great friend.
I'd love to do anything I can to help support her.
This is for sure not a sponsored ad.
This is just something I wanted to do to help her,
but truly she is Austin based.
These are
Without any question,
the best tortilla chips I have ever eaten in my entire life.
I don't really think about sitting on the couch
and like snacking on tortilla chips.
These are those.
Like I will sit and engulf a bag of these.
So I highly recommend you check them out.
They also are quasi healthy.
They have all these super food type things.
I wouldn't do it justice by explaining it.
She could, but for sure.
Check them out at toastyfoods.com or on Instagram at toastyfoods.
So I really, really hope you do.
These are immaculately good.
They would win in a blind tasting tournament
of tortilla chips without any doubt.
And if you found this video interesting,
then check out this one where I blind tasted every
Costco brand wine to find out which one is best.
I'll see you there.
