🔴 LIVE - FATHER FISH IN THE EVENING 12/27/20

Father Fish
51 followers
Oct 21, 2026
JOOIN THE SHOAL FOR FUN, FOR FRIENDSHIP, AND FOR FISHY CONVERSATION.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedFather Fish and guest Carrie discuss the technicalities of fish keeping, the philosophy of creating self-sustaining biotopes, and the challenges of growing a YouTube community. They emphasize the importance of deep substrates, the role of microorganisms in tank health, and the necessity of mutual support and hard work for aspiring content creators.
Guess it'd be good if we had volume.
what I hear. Do you hear what I hear?
A man, a man explaining a plan on how to keep your
fish healthy.
On how to keep your fish healthy.
People, do you know what I know?
Two and a half inches of sand, your substrate.
It will keep your fish healthy and great.
Merry Christmas, Father Fish.
Merry Christmas, Chattanooga, Ed.
And thank you so much.
That was absolutely wonderful.
Well, hi, Carrie.
Hi.
Hi, Carrie.
Nice to see you.
It's been so long since we chatted.
I know.
An age or two.
Thank you so much for coming over.
Well, thank you for inviting me.
It's going to be fun.
Yeah, I really enjoyed being with you.
Appreciate the invite, well anytime.
And Joey, you're welcome anytime too, oh well thank you that's very
sweet and it's nice to meet you
In person Carrie, I feel like I meet you all the time but yeah
Officially, officially we're meeting
But thank you that's so sweet and I didn't get to watch
Your stream because my family has been on a Zoom call visiting
So my daughter's out in the
The room now on the same Zoom call
So I missed the actual stream but I tried to look at it a
Little bit but I'll go back and re-watch, well
And this is, again, this is all thanks to Mary
Mary's put all this up, she did, she's awesome
Yeah, she's such a joy and I teased her too much
I should not do that because she takes it very personally
and that's that's not fair to her
Right, so we love you Mary very very much, you're
critical to us so since i wasn't able to be in
the stream what did you kids talk about a little bit
of everything i get too nervous if i like get
super prepared like i used to get quite like have questions
and now i just kind of treat it like
a phone call like catching up with friends
so we talked about substrate and a little bit of
everything oh nice i mean i love that approach terry i don't like
when you choose you know
planned and rigid now not me
so that's perfect yeah i wanted to live stream for a long time and
it took me like no joke a year to psych myself up
to do it yeah i had all the equipment it was
just sitting here and i was like i'll
do it eventually have a way of working out i think
you know oh it was it's so much fun like getting
to know everybody in this community you guys
really are my friendship circle i don't have
a social life except for the fish fam and you guys
are just like my best friends i take care of the family
and then i am involved in the community as
best i can and that's that's what i want no that's
so sweet but i agree with you you know you feel
you feel a closeness to people you know you listen
to them either either every day or you know once
in a week or whatever it is but you feel like you're getting
to know them absolutely yeah it's
true it's true yeah so that's really cool
and i'm not keeping up with chat i'm trying to say hi
everybody but i'm missing tons and so hello everybody
and welcome and it's it's really
nice to have you here karen well thank you i'm excited
to be here this is like this is my go-to
stream now yeah and right on the heels
of father fish's five thousand i know i i'm not gonna like
i was down here like jumping for joy yesterday adding
my sand to my tank so i'm like you guys
are going to do it.
And he did.
I was just so excited. I told him
I'm living through you because
it's well deserved.
It's well deserved.
Absolutely.
It's exciting. I don't even know what's your number now
Fatherfish.
It's
about almost
5,100.
You've got
your Fatherfish t-shirt on the shoulder.
I do. You like that?
say that yeah that's awesome keep it keep it dirted right
that's great so anyway i don't even know
if i can try to keep up with the hello
because i miss so many how many how many
do we have in here i don't know 51 20 28 thumbs up
Craig Broderick
is asking us to help
him get to 100 subs.
So those of you who have not, there's his link.
Well, I'm going to go look because I never know.
It's just the click of a button.
And you help people out, so it's great.
You bet.
76 needs 25 more.
We probably have them here
We can probably do it right here
I'll look here
In a minute for a question
And see if there's a question
But you two can carry on for a minute
While I do that
Lee Light
Subbed for you
Rubber room mode Joey
What?
Greg says rubber room mode
Oh
I see names like that
I know
She, Colleen, John, obviously Craig,
Gil, the Common Goldfish, Kenny's here.
Craig, the guppy side guy, says, thanks, Father Fish.
Well, thank you, guppy guy.
Yeah, awesome.
What fun.
Those first 100 subs were always, it was the hardest.
But it was when you hit that first 100,
I just felt like it was the sweetest moment
when i was like i got subs i know
and you know some of the the people that have a lot of subs
say that those those are really the milestones
the hundred yeah five hundred a thousand those
are the ones that they really remember yeah
that's what joey was saying the other day yeah
he said it took him three years to get to 25 subs
and his big thrill was a thousand
He cried at a thousand
Wow
There was somebody else
Who was asking us
To help him
Somebody else that was looking for subscribers
Yeah yeah
Mainly Bettis is getting close to a hundred
Post your links guys
Post your links
So we can click over
Yes anybody with a wrench
Can post their link
Or anybody else's
Fred, if you've got a wrench, you can post the link.
Right.
And I'm sorry I stopped the hello.
Craig says he'll cry at 100.
Let's get him up.
Let's get Craig up there.
Yeah.
William Pride Moore.
Hello, William.
William hasn't been here for a while.
Let's give William a wrench.
Hey, Craig, I have a hat I could put on.
He's asking me what hat I'm wearing today.
I have a hat I could put on.
Really?
It's not a Christmas hat.
Jessie is checking her cows.
She can't post right now.
She wrote a post to say she can't post.
I see the humor in that.
What did you, John wants to know, what did you do?
Go through the sub list and give all wrenches.
No, no.
You only get a wrench if you are a loyal
and faithful Shoal member.
A loyal and faithful Shoal member,
member of the Fatherfish Shoal.
Then you get a wrench
because you have earned our trust as a fellow Shoaler.
Exactly.
Like that.
Crystal, hello, Crystal.
You show up.
Right.
So, Keri, what are you keeping now that's exciting for fish?
I like my Ameca splendens right now and my Carrie Tetras.
But my guppies will always be at my center of my heart.
That's what I started out when I was a little bitty kiddo.
And I had guppies all around my room.
And they will always have my heart.
But my silver arowana upstairs in the dining room
is kind of like the centerpiece.
Everybody comes over to see the arowana.
sure and to watch him eat because he's he's quite
the eater i was just saying men and men especially
like arowanas yeah yeah i i'm really right now
like i'm just digging all this learning all about
the substrates trying different things honestly
because i was telling father fish in the last
chat i grew up and i just always had my one inch gravel
so now that i'm really kind of learning
more about the deeper substrates and why it helps
and layering and all of that it's kind of that's
been kind of fun just playing around with yeah absolutely
and i'm not an aquascaper so attempting
i said i have like five plants that i use
yeah i have i have a lot of jungle val
and it grows great right yeah it does yeah
um and i i played around with the substrates a little bit
too like you said just different combinations
of you know that um that that first layer with dirt
and whatever and then the same cat
so it is interesting and you know and i just want to
kind of keep mental notes and see
which ones i think are doing better yeah and some of the
tanks like they'll sit right next to each other they'll have the same
and one will take off and
look beautiful and then the other one i'm like okay now we
are gonna have to sit down yeah it's
like what is the difference right yeah sometimes
it's just like you feel like it's being set up
but it is very different you know
um so but that's what makes it fun and interesting
right now i'm just discovering all the ways
that you can grow algae successfully
i do that i'm really good at the hair algae
if you need help you know like growing some really
good mess and nasty hair algae i'm
your person i i don't need help trust me but i think she's
really pretty and it's beautiful shade of green
and i don't mind it yeah uh and i'm just a fan
of cleaning the front glass that's what i do everything just hang around
on the other three surfaces this
one right here you can't see it
but all that background it's growing up and i just kind of
trim it down but that has a bunch of yellow shrimp in it
and they go nuts so i just clean
the front glass and let it build up
and trim it if it gets too out of control i'll just kind of
trim it up but that's just kind of an algae wall
and those yellow shrimp love it so well and they
must look beautiful on the green, it does look
good, it does, it really does. So Father Fish, you're
you're just studying that chat, what do you got? Well I
was just, I just gave waterborne tropical
syringe and I've been clicking over on everybody
is posting their uh link to make sure I
that you're subscribed, yeah
and I, most of them I have. Did you find any questions while you're at
it? Father Fish, stop these people posting
their links, it's sad. It is good to put in some work
before getting your subs. Oh well, we we want
to get everybody to a hundred, that's
yeah, and you know you just do it differently than other channels but
that's the way you like
to do it right. Hi Jesse, well hey Jesse, we're we're all in this together
you know, and that's, I mean I can't go anywhere
with my channel without a whole lot of people
supporting me and helping me
so I'm just, I'm just passing it on, that's how I, that's how I feel I'm
like I don't want to ask people to be on my channel even just
to chit chat if I'm not willing
to do whatever I possibly can to pay it back
because this community is so awesome and I want
to do anything and everything I possibly can
to help anybody I can, even if it's just like a YouTube
question or a fish tank question, editing question, I'm not the best
but I can help if I can. Well and
that's the thing, you know, it's like especially
new people they have sometimes when people get
frustrated with the simple questions
but if you're new those are the questions well that's right
that's right you know
and the reality the reality is no one of us is going to get anybody
to a thousand you're going to do that by working
at it you've got a hundred people to help you
then you know that's going to help
but if you don't put the work in you don't make it
doesn't matter how many people help
and the reality is YouTube is on the lookout for that
they will see if all you're doing is trading subs
in order to get up they know it they say it for
what it is and and they'll shut you down
so you know we're not doing that we're not trying to
pump each other up we're trying to be supportive
and helpful to do something that is really quite
hard to do taking care of the fish is hard
to do and then adding YouTube onto it yeah really i had
no idea like i figured it was going to be a little difficult recording
because i never i i don't take
family pitch i'm not i'm not a one to be on camera person by any means
and so being on YouTube and
making videos at first I didn't I wasn't in the videos
and learning lighting and music and how to
even take out the background noise like how
do you take out the background noise
that I didn't know and just how much longer it took
to do a water change versus filming a water
change I didn't know going into it
and I'm glad I stuck with it to learn but sometimes it's like
it takes me a whole day to learn how to do something
and then i can go back to the video
because i i don't know and all that new stuff
when you first start a channel can get overwhelming
and make you not want to do it so if i can help i'll help
and that's great you know that you are
willing to help because you know not everybody
is not everybody has time to help exactly
it's not maybe that they don't want
to help they just don't have the time to help
um but you are right it is it
is consuming you know it it you know between making videos or
live streaming or whatever you're doing there's
a lot that goes into it it's not just the hour
that you're sitting up on the screen that's
the reason i haven't had any videos lately it's been
all live streams because with christmas
and the kids i'm like i i'll start in a minute
that's exactly what i did i did live streams i didn't
do a daily live stream for six months
and i finally figured some things out
and it's now paying off william pride more says i'm going
to start working on my channel bigger better
stronger hopefully you know if we can inspire
someone to do that
by simply being here.
I mean, that's what
we ought to be doing.
See who's calling me. Father Fish.
He's got to answer
some fish questions. I know. It's so cool
to be here. It's like, oh.
Well, then I'll answer the ones that are going through there.
Yes, Petro Man Chiefs. I don't know how
we pulled that game out, but we did.
There's your football. You get one football.
And whoever says they're getting
beard envy, thank you.
My beard is coming along nicely this year.
I've seen two of them earlier.
Tomorrow, 10 to 4.
I had him a beard straightener for Christmas last year.
I'm on Venice Avenue just before the bridge.
Father Fish Aquarium.
Yeah, it's not on the island.
On the way.
Sounds great.
Texas Fish, does anyone have any experience with
figure 8 puffers? There's one for Father Fish.
Figure 8 puffers. I've kept them.
I've never bred them.
I'm not a big puffer guy. I've had puffers that I've kept
for a few years. I've done a lot of pea puffers,
figure 8 spotted, all that stuff.
I have green spotted ones in the past.
They somehow don't really
interest me, so I never
do very much with them.
I'm not a good one to talk to about
puffers.
Not on my list.
Not your forte?
Well, maybe.
I'm sure there's somebody in the chat.
I am too.
Well, Stephen is here.
Stephen loves everything.
I'm sure there's somebody in here.
He's kept them.
He's kept a lot of puffers, I'm sure.
Yeah, I've just had the pea puffers
and the green-spotted puffers in the past.
That's all I've had.
I've never kept any, so I've got nothing.
I did not know that you needed to increase
the salt of the water as they grew.
So it's kind of brackish?
As they get older, and I did not know that.
And I bought them from Walmart back, I don't know, 20 years ago.
I got three of them from Walmart, and that's how I got them.
And I did not know that as they got older,
you're supposed to increase the salt.
And I, yeah, they didn't make it.
I had them for a little while.
I did have them for a while, but they didn't,
I didn't have them long-term.
BJ Palmer, is the long black stringy threads among
my plants a weird type of algae?
Should I pull it all out if I can?
Yes.
And again, yes.
If you can get it all,
go for it.
Really.
Waterbarn says, thanks, Father Fish.
My L33 Plecos are not showing any desire to breed.
Most of the Plecos are hiding in their caves.
Do I have six males?
Well, now, that's one possibility.
It's frankly not a likely possibility, but it is one.
If you want to breed plecos, feed them live food.
That's the key.
That gets the females egged up,
and it gets the males gonads going.
So feed them live food.
Worms, black worms are great.
Earthworms, you can chop up earthworms.
They'll scarf them down.
It will definitely put them in the mode for spawning.
That's what I would do before giving up
on maybe not having any females.
You probably do.
You probably have females.
They just need to egg up.
And getting them egged up is not easy.
You know, they may not do it.
They may not do it easily.
But live food will do more than anything
to get a female fish to egg up.
So try that, Water Barn.
See if that works.
And call me if it does.
I don't want to hear it if it doesn't.
I would like to get positive affirmation.
What's the time frame
when you start feeding live food?
I mean, does it take a week?
Does it take two weeks, three weeks?
Is there a general idea for that?
Well, yeah.
If they haven't spawned in the next six months,
then you probably have all males.
Okay.
you might you might try trading three of them
in you know sometimes they get some new stock just
trade half of them is there for an age that you have
to wait to introduce plecos together to
breed because i have i had five cheese creek plecos
and now i have two and every time i tried
to introduce them to each other one would kill the other
so now i just have two and they're
separated and i'm scared to death to put them together
but i got them when they were really
young and now they've gotten maybe an inch
and a half two inches and i'm scared to death to put
them together what kind are they cheese creek plecos
but i cannot remember the name the l number
i don't even know what they
are yeah i can't remember i got them from for those in the chat
i got them from jeff rose fish jeff rose fish keeping
and i cannot remember the l number for
the life of me but they're really pretty
and i had five i had them they came i put two and two
and one and now then i had one in each tank
and now i have two so i just have them separated and
i'm just growing them out as large
as i can until i would hope i like to breed them someday but i
don't know if i have a male or female i just have the two
but i was curious yeah there's a certain
age or something let me know let me know
because i don't breed them i've kept plecos my whole life
like i've always had one pleco
in my guppy tank you're supposed to put one pleco in each tank
that's a rule my dad taught me
and now i'm curious about trying to breed them but i've i've
never attempted i've just always kept them one
in each tank i've never well i stopped keeping
pretty much any kind of bottom feeders you know
when i started getting more serious about breeding
my fish because it just doesn't work
so i don't have any no i don't know but i have no experience
breeding them but i mean people do it a lot
so i mean it can't be super difficult i mean you can
do it and or have them get along i would think
you know yeah sam dan says i lost my favorite
female betta today i made stupid decisions i'm
to blame it makes me question my hobby
okay there's a there's a line of progression there
that goes off the rails did you see where that
happened where the train was going down the track
and he loves his fish and one of them dies and
then all of a sudden and he doesn't want to be on the rails anymore
and he's over here in the field
wondering how to get off track
so here's here's what you got to do you gotta you gotta get back
on the rails. It's called staying on the horse.
Going down there and when one of them dies,
you just stay on the horse. You question
if you can what happened, try to figure it out
and go get another one.
You will love it every bit as much as you love that one.
I promise you. Just go for it.
I'm with you on that.
We all make mistakes.
We all lose fish.
We're big in the middle.
Keep going.
Don't stop.
Yeah, I have killed more fish than anybody here has ever had, probably.
Oh, I think we all have.
And I don't feel a bit of guilt about it.
I really.
And it's not like I take joy in killing fish because I don't.
But the reality is fish don't live very long in the wild.
You can keep them in your tank.
The longer you keep them, the longer they are living in your tank,
then they would have lived in the wild.
I didn't say that right, but you got the idea.
I know what you mean.
You're giving them a better,
longer life by keeping activity than they would live in the wild.
It's absolutely true.
You know, most fish, why do you think,
why do you think fish have a thousand babies?
Exactly.
Why do you think?
Because about one or two live.
Because out of that thousand, not one will survive.
Not one.
They will do it again.
Not one of those will survive.
By the time they do it ten times in one breeding season,
one of them or two of them might survive.
The odds of a fish surviving in the wild approximates zero.
It never gets to zero because if it did,
there would be no fish in the wild.
It gets right up to the line.
in my ecology class they told me that if the more
babies they have the lower on the food chain they
are so they have that many babies for a reason
because they're really low and then as the animals
get larger they're they don't have as many
because they're a little higher and i was like that makes
totals i never thought about like
that but that is true yeah what do you think what do you think
that the most the most predated upon fish
is in the amazon river what fish is eaten more
more frequently more commonly
and in greater volume than any other fish see if you can figure
that one out i have the answer i don't i don't
know i would say some kind of tetra or something
that just i don't know something really small
and good good guess what kind of i'll give you
what kind of tetra absolutely yeah yeah neon
the neon is the most eaten it's red and it's like a
bullet point on the red little
quick fish
and just get nibbled up.
They spawn
by the billions.
Yeah.
I can't get them to spawn in my dad's table
for the life of me.
I'm going to apologize
for not saying hi to everybody
in the chat. I just stopped because
I'm talking and I apologize.
And Craig?
Rohan, John got it.
Emily got it.
Jonathan said piranha.
Ah, that's funny.
So Father said.
Waterborne got it, yes.
Sorry.
Craig says, I'm up to 90 subs.
Did I make 100 subs?
Well, I put on a hat, yes.
You get to 100 subs, I'll put on a hat.
So that's everybody in the chat getting to 100 subs.
Waterborne said, I would eat a neon if I was swimming in the Amazon.
They're so pretty.
maybe they taste better with that red and blue
is it like Skittles
Loving Dog says
hard to play Neons
but are they good tempera batter
they're brutal batter
yeah
yeah
yeah Waterborne says
yeah I would eat a Neon if I was playing a Neon
right absolutely
madness madness
madness
magic turtle
channel. I don't know, PJ.
It's a fillet in neon.
P&J. Hard to fillet
neons. Not if you
have the right knife for them.
Well, that's what I was thinking
when you were talking about you killed so many
fish. I was like, I've killed a
lot of fish. That's because I was eating them.
Really?
There's that.
Here's another one.
How many people here
have ever eaten a fish
that they've grown up in their tank.
No. I'm out.
I haven't done that one.
I have. I've done
two. My grandpa
made us take care of turtles and then he turned
them into turtle soup, but it was not a fish.
It was a
turtle.
I grew up
two fish,
got them big,
and then took them to a local
restaurant, a Thai restaurant
across the street.
had them prepared, and took them to a fish club meeting
where everyone at the meeting had a taste.
What kind of fish were they?
Two fish.
One was about a 10-pound pacu,
18 inches long,
and the other was a red-tailed shark about the same size.
Two things for me.
One is I don't like fish well enough to eat any of mine.
And what went into your decision-making
when you decided you needed to cook these fish?
I always started feeding them.
That's what I was thinking.
It was time for them to feed me.
Time for them to go.
Okay.
Well, I grew them up with that in mind
because I wanted to do a –
Isn't there a club in New York that has dinners of wild meat?
I don't know.
Possibly.
I can't remember how to put their name.
I'm sure.
I'm sure in New York there is, yeah.
Yeah.
Oh, you've got a question from, I don't even know.
Hold on.
3D Fox and 3D Fox.
640, 3D Fox and, yeah.
Hold on, I'm right here.
Scratch bumping itself against the plant.
midnight lobster wanted to know how they tasted
everybody really liked the pacu uh the catfish
was interesting because half of the body was
was the head it was solid bone there was no meat
so it really was very little very little actual
flesh so the pacu was wonderful it's
a very firm white meat kind of a sweet meat and it is a
popular food fish
throughout South America.
Well,
that was my question.
Like you said, what kind of fish was it? Was it oily?
So you answered it.
Yeah, 3D pox.
Yeah, get that question.
Okay, leaving out the white diarrhea
poop, scratching
and bumping against
the plants, that
points to ick.
Anytime you've got that kind of
flashing, it's called
flashing where they scrape themselves on the bottom
um raise the temperature to 85 degrees
put a teaspoon of salt
in the tank per gallon
and give it 24 hours 86 degree temperature
a teaspoon of salt per gallon give it 24 hours
you might use epsom salts rather than table salt
Epsom salts works a little better.
Steven is here.
He'd probably give you some advice, too, if he's still here.
Although he just hurt himself real bad,
so he may be in a recuperative mode.
So try that anyway.
Yeah, the diarrhea-along poop I don't know about.
It could be that you have parasites.
But the scraping says to me, it doesn't say parasites to me.
It says ick, and it's got white spots,
I think you said.
No, you didn't.
Does it have white spots is the question.
He doesn't say that.
Anyway, give that a shot.
Right.
It doesn't say white spots.
It just says the dye.
Yeah.
And the flashing, yeah.
Yeah.
If you do have, you might put some garlic in the tank.
See if they'll eat, if they will eat and eat garlic,
that could help straighten out the parasite problem.
If they have internal gut parasites,
the garlic can help clear that out.
And Brian has a question.
He says, how do I make sure that the mud I'm collecting from the lake
or pond is safe for my aquarium?
Well, that's an excellent question, Brian.
And I will let you get away with that question
Because he hasn't been around much
That's right, he's new
Yeah, he's new
And because you asked that question
I have now wrenched you
So you're now a member of the crew
So what you're going to learn is
That mud that you've collected is gold
It is gold
Let me explain something about bacteria
There is no such thing as good bacteria, this is in large,
there is no such thing as good bacteria and bad bacteria.
What makes bacteria bad
is when it explodes in your fish tank.
And what makes it explode?
Bacteria does not make itself explode.
It occurs when you put so much food in your tank
that it becomes foul, and the bacteria then explode to try
to take care of that excess food that you put in your tank.
And it can reach a proportion where they burn up all
the oxygen in the tank, and the fish die.
So, the reality is, if there are a thousand different kinds
of bacteria in that mud you have collected,
one of them might be a problem.
The other 999 will not be a problem.
So what you want to do is gather up that mud, bring it into your tank,
dump it in the bottom of the tank,
and put two inches of sand on top of it
and fill it up with water.
Put a couple of fish in it, a couple of plants in it.
You can do that day one.
And then keep an eye on it.
And you will,
with 99 to 99% certainty, be amazed
and delighted
if you're not
there are other people you can
talk to here who will be
happy to
denigrate the father fish
system and they will be thrilled
to do so
you'll have lots of friends
absolutely
I can attest to it
but it'll work
I promise you it'll work
it will absolutely work
You basically can't go wrong.
Holly said I don't recommend boiling it.
If you boil it, you may as well not bother.
Right, you've gotten rid of everything.
You know, I mean,
the whole idea is to bring live organisms into the tank.
And that's what you've got to get in your head.
What a balanced tank is all about is having a wide range
of living organisms, most of which are microscopic.
You will never see them unless you've got a microscope
and are putting them on strips and looking at them.
You'll never know they're there.
That's another reason why you need a deep sand bed
Because it helps to enrich that culture of life
That is the foundation of a living biotope
So that's what you're trying to create
It's a living biotope in your system
And if you will do it, it'll last the rest of your life
It'll be honest to God will
it will last for as long as you live
and your heirs will have to break it down and throw it
away because they won't know what
to do with that stinky mess i was just going to give them one
little warning though yeah the only reason it might
not work would be if you have you're putting
fishing there that dig in your substrate
to make sure you don't have you know you're keeping fish
that will leave that substrate alone
or at least only disturb the top
quarter of an inch or half an inch.
If you keep something like convicts that dig,
it'll be a mess.
That's true.
The two-legged
fish
are the worst culprits.
Well, there's that too.
They go
in there with their
sumps and their pumps
and their nets and their scrapers
and they start
They start fixing it.
And the more they fix it, the worse it gets.
Until they fix it to death.
That was my problem.
Never to vacuum.
Never vacuum the ground.
You're not fixing it to death.
Right.
Leave it alone.
Leave it alone.
If you start seeing dirt on the top, put a little more sand in.
Add in the sand.
So, Carrie, have you actually set up
I've set up this dirty tank yet?
are you in the process of it i have two you have two i have two i have
this 55 gallon behind me
has dirt in it and then my Minka splendens has dirt at the bottom of it
and it it was pretty
it was pretty barren for a while
but they i think they prefer it honestly the plants and the fish i
think they did better when it was all tanned
and up for a while honestly oh i agree i agree you
know what we like isn't necessarily what they like that's
when all the plants sprouted off like they
just took off and they slowed down as the water cleared up
but i slowly add to it i it's not the
thickest yet but i'm slowly adding to it
but the Meka splendens i did dirt and then i had two five
gallons that used to be my betta tanks since the betta has passed away
and it was kind of old and
nasty and i put that right on top of the dirt
and then i put sand on top of that so and then i'm
just slowly building it up this one behind me it doesn't have dirt
in it but it's got a lot of
fluval stratum mulm
and then i added sand to it last night to cover some more sand on top
John Cobb John Cobb says but pond river mud has
parasites made the mistake one time now i don't
know what you mean by parasites there
are big parasites that are like dragonfly larvae yeah
They will certainly, or mayfly larvae, well,
dragonfly larvae, they'll eat your fish.
We're talking about little parasites like ich,
parasites or some kind of worm that will attach itself to the fish.
Those are visible.
If it's an ich parasite, it's not coming in from the mud.
That's happening in your tank.
That's in your tank anyway.
If it is a leech that attaches like a gill fluke
that attaches itself to your fish, those are big enough to see.
They're visible and they're removable.
It doesn't matter how tiny the fish is.
You catch the fish, use a pair of tweezers,
and you can pull that little bugger off.
Those you can get rid of.
It's certainly possible to get one in.
i found one in a tank from i collected a bunch of woods
and rocks and i put them in the tubs
outside i was like what is that and i had two leeches that i dug out
because they'll get to
my guppies quick so i pulled them to it
but they came from some driftwood that we got at a creek
or a pond or somewhere out in the woods
and i just picked them out and got rid of them but they were
they were pretty good size they're about an inch
or so long right exactly you knew it yeah there's
nothing tiny, microscopic
that's going to attack your
fish. Anything that can attack
your fish will be big enough to see.
And if you, so
the caveat is
look at what you're doing.
Go ahead and put it in there and keep an eye on it.
The reality is
if you're putting two inches of
sand on top of that mud,
there ain't much that's going to get through
that sand. It's going to be
dead within hours
of being covered because the sand
cap creates an anaerobic layer and all of those
parasites have to have oxygen to be able
to survive. They can't live in an anaerobic environment
so it's going to kill them.
It will not be a problem. It will not have a problem
unless you're just dumping
if you've gone down to a foul, murky, messy, stinky
rotten creek
that's a sewer
and you're throwing that in your tank
and you deserve what you get
you've got to use
some common sense
I don't sell
common sense
I don't even recommend common sense
I assume
I assume
common sense
if you cannot apply common sense
to what we're talking about
and what I'm teaching
then there ain't a lot of hope for you you've got
to be able to think through what you're doing
it's yours it ain't mine when you put something
in your tank that's you putting that in your tank
if i told you to do it
and you did it you make the decision to do it it ain't me doing it so
be responsible for what you're doing don't just take
on faith what somebody says father fish ain't
You know, I am not, I am not,
what's the word I'm looking for?
There ain't any number that fit.
I'm wrong as often as I'm right.
I mean, I'm talking out of my own experience.
And I try to do exactly that.
I try to say things that are based on what I know to be true
because I've done it.
Because it's my experience.
but it's still simply and only my experience it's
not your experience the point i've tried to make
over and over about this hobby
is that this this is a hermit's hobby it's a hobby we each do
in private on our own in our secret little fish
room wherever we have it tucked away in our house
There may be a couple who do it together.
That's a blessing when it happens.
But usually it's not.
Usually it's one person doing this.
So you've got to be utterly and thoroughly
and totally dependent upon yourself.
Get as much education as you can.
Learn as much as you can.
Do trial and experiment as much as you can.
If you fail at something, try to figure out why you failed.
That's how you learn, by understanding why it went wrong.
You're never going to learn anything by being perfect,
because it's not duplicatable.
Perfection is not duplicatable.
Failure is duplicatable.
Got that one down.
Yeah, but I think you reassured some people just with the one statement
that you made that when you take your dirt source or your mud
or wherever you're taking it from and you layer it
and you put your two into the sand over, there should be comfort
in knowing that nothing can live, as you said, without oxygen.
So that should make people feel more
comfortable about trying, I would think.
yeah you know you might get a worm that'll work
its way up through the sand but if you do you'll
see it and you'll be able to dispose on it that's
the other thing you gotta you gotta look at the
tank you know i remember when lee first put sand
on his dirt he he did a little video and he said
i'm so angry with you
because now I don't have anything to do i used to go in there and mess
with it all the time and now i can't
do that and i said wrong now you get to watch it you get to
observe it and that's what he did
and for six months he didn't even feed those fish but he
watched them eat anyway he watched them find food
and he learned more about them and more about his
tank than he learned before that because he
was always mucking around in there you know making it
more complicated. Once he
got it to the place where it was stable
and he was able to really pay
attention to what was going
on, that's where you learn what these
fish are all about.
And plants. And everything else.
I agree.
How we do it time-wise.
We are down
to it.
We are.
Well, again, I apologize.
I stopped saying hello to everybody.
But I think we had
I'm excited
I was so excited to be here
I got caught up in
talking to you guys
wonderful to have you
Carrie
I always forget
to pay attention to the chat
because I get to talking and I get excited
and I can only do one thing
at a time
I agree
I was doing well
until you came on screen
then I started talking to you
right right well i want you guys to learn how
to do this youtube chat thing so keep up the good
work because you're showing me how to do it well we all try we try
but i'm not trying right now
and i admit it i'm not trying right now i'm busy yeah i'm supposed
to be at my dad that's my dad's
i'm gonna go work on his angelfish tank for him after
that so well that'll be fun yeah i'm gonna
go check in with that tank get it all fixed back up
do you overdo everything and gravel back too
much i have to really stop myself oh that's funny
bye bye y'all nice
to be with you
thank you for having me you bet wonderful
to have you here
Let's talk about the amazing things
Let's talk about all the good things
and the bad things
And baby, let's talk about
Let's talk about
fish,
fish,
baby
Let's talk about all the good things
and things
Where may we find
Let's talk about
Oh, I'm
dancing
now
