I Never Use Companion Planting (Here’s What I Do Instead)

Natural Relaxation
386 followers
Oct 11, 2026
In this video I cover why I don't follow companion planting as a gardening technique and share what I do instead. Get your copy of Edimentals:
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker distinguishes between traditional companion planting and their own approach, \"complementary planting.\" While companion planting relies on strict rules and charts to avoid or encourage specific pairings, complementary planting is a principles-led method focused on how plants fit together visually, spatially, and functionally to create a cohesive, productive, and beautiful garden.
Companion planting is probably one of the first ideas
that you come across when growing food.
It looks great.
It's, you know, grow your tomatoes with basil
and deal with your cucumbers
and grow nasturtiums as like a trap crop
to help take away cabbage white caterpillars from your cabbages.
And it is a great technique,
but I've realized that it's not a technique that I've ever followed.
and it's partly because of the fact that it's maybe
a little bit too rule-based and in fact
I follow something that I'd say is similar to companion planting
but I kind of call it
complementary planting and complementary planting isn't about worrying
that I am planting the wrong
two plants together because that's it as well
with companion planting you have the pairings that can
go together but you also have the pairings to avoid like beans
and alliums and then sometimes
it can be really confusing
because some of the charts sometimes contradict one another and then
you don't know which one to go for and note
that this is complementary with an e not an i i am not
complementing my plants saying hey radish you're looking uh lush today
no i am talking about
complementary with an e and what i mean
by the complementary with an e is about plants that
that can enhance or complete a pairing
because that's the other thing with companion planting
you're very much looking at plant A and plant B
but for me complementary is looking at very often
it starts with a core plant
and then I kind of look at that core plant and think what can I grow
around it to enhance it without worrying about whether I should
or shouldn't be planting those
things together because I don't have time
to worry about things like that and at the moment I have
yet to have a major failure
by pairing two slightly random plants together but they're not exactly
random because there's a reason behind these pairings.
So just think about it that companion
planting is asking about how two plants affect one another
or maybe one plant affecting a primary
plant but complementary planting is about how
a plant can fit alongside other plants and taking
your entire garden as a whole
so it's actually bringing more of the visuals in that may be
missing from companion planting.
And just to reiterate, I'm not saying that companion planting
is useless. It can be a great way to help reduce some pest pressure,
to help with designing
productive gardens, and as well for bringing in pollinators.
My style of gardening, for any of
you that know me, is far more principles-led.
And so I'm going to share with you some of the
principles that I use to pair plants together in my garden.
Because I think the danger of just
using companion planting charts is that gardening kind
of starts with the chart whereas for me
gardening I want to start with the plant.
Really what I'm after is what kind of plant combinations
can I follow that make the whole space work together be it a pot,
a container, a bed or my
entire garden. You could take globe artichoke
for example it is it is large it is upright and
I could have that in the garden now I could
be tempted to see what could I companion plant with
my globe artichoke but I rather just look at it in front of me
and say you know what it's actually
got some space underneath
so maybe I should grow some strawberries because strawberries are
perennial I can pair that with a globe artichoke they're going
to stay there for quite a few years
and maybe as well just to to contrast against
the very kind of large structural leaves I could
offer something like growing some chives underneath
that globe artichoke and then also I'm thinking
about color wise you've got almost the silveriness
of the globe artichoke leaves well if you if you
pair that with the purple flowers of the chives
that is a very beautiful aesthetic I don't need
didn't make a claim that the chives
or the strawberries then help the globe artichoke
grow better which is what a lot of kind
of companion planting is instead these plants
simply fit together and they contribute something different
to either the garden or myself as the
gardener and mainly because of space they're
not they're not really actually going to be fighting
against one another and this is a kind
of a little snippet into the the principles the four main
areas to look at when deciding how to plant plants together
and how to pair them. What I have to say
that's so important before you even think about what you want
to kind of pair together is just
remember why are you gardening
because these principles can be applied if you're just trying
to grow as much vegetables as possible.
You've got things like intercropping or underplanting
which is a type of complementary planting.
If you're growing something taller like kale you
could grow lettuce underneath it and enjoy that partial shade
so it's not just a case of visuals
but for me I love to use it to look
at how I can complement things that I'm growing for food
to then bring in some extra edible harvest
but also that layer of beauty because I believe that
there doesn't have to be a separation between like a kitchen garden
and an ornamental garden
you can have ornamental kitchen gardens you can
have edible ornamental gardens it is very much a
spectrum and we're all at different stages of those spectrums
but i just love adding that extra
layer of color around and texture to to the spaces that i'm growing
so for me instead of asking or
what is a companion plant for a said crop i look at the planting
and i just think what is missing
and that is based off my goals is it goals
in terms of what is missing visually or what is
missing in terms of height and layers
or what is maybe missing in terms of kind of joy pollinator
wildlife benefit so for example you could have
a bed that flowers all at the same time and so
something that is missing is a bit
of successional color maybe you have a bed that is very productive
but it's quite visually flat
so you think oh actually I want to put in a plant that just
adds a little bit of textural contrast
and a very simple way of doing that is just changing
up the leaf texture.
There are four kind of key principles to help with deciding what to
complementary plant with things and that is form,
space, time and function. So form is basically
about their texture their their structure
their the colors spaces about like the layers that they
occupy if they are a deep rooted plant you'd want
to complement that with something that is more
shallow rooted if it is a tall plant you want
something smaller growing underneath you can take
kind of take the principles from the seven layers
of a food forest and permaculture
and apply this to your garden only working
at a maximum of three layers at a time because
trying to put all of those layers together ends
up just causing too much shade and reducing
productivity. So a tall plant and a climbing plant
and a ground covering plant can occupy
the same space in different ways
and not really compete with one another. So you could have
runner beans, you could have sunflowers planted
at the base that are growing up and around the
runner beans and you could have nasturtiums being
a bit of a ground cover and starting to climb up
the runner beans and the sunflower time also matters
because gardens are constantly changing
it's about knowing what is kind of already
in the ground how long is that going to live for
when is it going to flower
and can you complement that in terms of either flowering alongside it
so to enhance its visual display
or is it a case of saying you know what that actually
is about to go over it this month
so I want to complement with a plant that then takes over
aesthetically to carry on that visual interest
and then you have function what is what is this
that the plant contributes in terms of in terms
of food what does it contribute in terms of
pollinator support those kind of things really gardening
is a bit like a jigsaw puzzle you've
got all of these different plants
and how can you fit them together so they're not competing but at
least they can all occupy
these different spaces you know you could have some like taller growing
cavolo nero and just grow a cash crop
of radish underneath it it doesn't just have to be about
ornamental it's about working with these layers
and the space and the timings and succession
planting so everything complements each other working towards
your set goal and it's this kind
of complementary pairing of certain plants
that I wanted to make really practical in my new book
Edimentals which is out today
and every single crop that I have includes plant pairings so like
for example nasturtiums here I've got runner bean squash
and sunflowers which links into the example
that I shared earlier so if you could go through
and pick an edimental that you want to grow
and then you can see some other pairings you can go to those pairings
and then actually often they
link to other plants and then you can put those all together
and create a really productive but
really beautiful looking planting scheme
and it really is just a starting point for creating
combinations it's not rules it's just kind
of a guide to get you started to then make your own
kind of creative choices the issue
though is with complementary planting you gain confidence as you
have more growing experience whereas companion planting
is something that any beginner or
gardener who's just starting off can use
so hopefully the the information within edimental
with the crop and plant pairings helps to kind
of bridge that gap of of taking that idea of hey
try these things but then also you have a little bit more freedom
and opportunity to plug and play
as long as you've got a core set of principles there
is almost no limit to the creativity
that that you get to use in your garden i'm all about growing plants
that can give you as much
as possible and if this style of gardening
is something that appeals to you then get your copy
of Edimentals. There's a link down below
and it's there just to fill you with so many ideas
to make an incredibly beautiful, productive and tasty garden.
