A German spy chief is arrested for treasonous espionage. What exactly is he accused of doing? Also, two tech billionaires are leading the Pentagon’s future of war project. Is that a problem?
NPR's Mary Louise Kelly speaks with Esme Nicholson in Berlin about the case against August Hanning, and with NPR's Tom Bowman about how bases housing U.S. troops around the world could be vulnerable to drones.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This episode of NPR's \"Sources and Methods\" examines a major espionage scandal within Germany's BND, security threats to U.S. bombers in the UK, and the evolving nature of asymmetric warfare. It further explores the Pentagon's \"Project Meridian\" and draws historical parallels between modern intelligence and espionage tactics used during the American Revolution.
This message comes from Dataiku Agent Management.
Most enterprises can count every device,
every login, and every contractor.
Almost none can count their AI agents.
Take control of your agentic workforce
with one view across every platform and tool,
showing what's driving revenue,
what's drifted, and who signed off on it.
Visit dataiku.com.
That's dataiku.com.
Sources I've spoken to describe Hanning
as quite a sort of flamboyant character
who perhaps was concerned about losing sway in retirement.
A German spy chief is arrested for treason.
What exactly is he accused of doing?
Also, two tech billionaires are leading
the Pentagon's future of war project.
Is that a problem?
This is Sources and Methods from NPR.
I'm Mary Louise Kelly.
Each week we dive into the week's biggest national security stories
with NPR reporters here in Washington and around the world.
This week, with a big old German espionage scandal unfolding,
we have Asma Nicholson making her Sources
and Methods debut from Berlin.
Hi there, Asma.
Hi, Mary Louise. Thank you for having me.
Welcome. And right next to me,
NPR Pentagon correspondent Tom Bowman making,
I don't even know what number.
I think it's 29.
29. At least it feels like it.
I'm just throwing that number out. It may be 30.
Go with it.
Good to be here once again.
Yes. Let's timestamp this. Today is Thursday.
It is October the 8th. It is a little past, half past 11.
Let's call it half past 11 in the morning Eastern here in Washington.
5.30 in the evening your time, Asma?
It is.
So let's start with genuine spy intrigue out of Germany.
August Hanning, the country's former spymaster, arrested.
Asma, how do you say treason in German?
Verrat.
Say it slowly.
Verrat. You've got a good German R there to test the microphone.
And did I just pronounce his name correctly? August Hanning?
August Hanning, that's right.
So who is he?
Well, he, as you say,
is the former chief of Germany's foreign intelligence agency.
He served between 1998 and 2005.
And when he retired in 2009, 2010, he set up a consultancy business,
which essentially drew on his expertise, his networks,
and, as federal prosecutors now allege, on classified documents.
Hanning, who is now 80, was arrested earlier this week
and is now facing charges of espionage and attempted treason.
Espionage and attempted treason.
Okay, so just to walk through his timeline, his tenure as head
of Germany's foreign intelligence branch, the BND, it ended in 2005.
He stayed in a different government position until he retired
from government a few years later.
But the access to the information he would have had
was much more recent.
In fact, from this year,
this is because of his chief of staff. Tell us about that.
That's right. His former chief of staff actually only retired this year
and went on to be chief of staff for three of Hanning's successors.
And in that time, for at least 12 years, allegedly,
he was providing Hanning with documents.
They think 2000 documents
and Hanning was paying for these documents that are all classified.
Right now, this man has also been arrested.
Prosecutors name him as Manfred D., and he is facing charges of aiding
and abetting attempted treason and espionage.
So Manfred D., and this is German law, they don't give him
his full last name in the documents, also under arrest.
Do we know what was in these documents?
We don't specifically know what was in the documents,
but what we know is that he will have been privy
to internal briefings meant for the intelligence chiefs
that meet every Tuesday,
so the chiefs of all of the intelligence agencies,
and he will have been privy to briefings meant
for the Chancellor's office.
And it's suspected, therefore,
that these documents were then passed on to Hanning.
So this is obviously a very high level.
Well, you couldn't get any higher.
Yeah. I mean, I do want to note, this is like the tabloid detail,
but my paging tabloid editors here, German law enforcement apparently
stumbled across this whole thing by accident while investigating
a totally separate case involving a steakhouse heiress.
That's right. This is an ongoing custody case about
an alleged abduction.
And Hanning allegedly was involved in it.
So when the police...
Not with the abduction, but with like consulting for a client.
With consulting and a firm that he was on the board of.
And of course, Hanning's lawyers deny any involvement.
And they've spoken since the arrest this week.
They've also denied all of the allegations,
although they have admitted that he was in possession of the documents.
And those documents, as you say,
were found when police searched his premises
on an entirely different case to do with this steakhouse heiress.
So, you know, it's quite a character.
And actually sources I've spoken to describe Hanning
as quite a sort of flamboyant character
who perhaps was concerned about losing sway in retirement.
Well, you've teed me up perfectly for my next question,
which, of course, is like what the motive would be.
I've been recalling an interview that we had
on All Things Considered earlier this year
with a man named John McLaughlin,
who was the former deputy director of the CIA,
and he was explaining an acronym
that the Central Intelligence Agency uses
when they are trying to determine motive.
It's MICE.
MICE, M-I-C-E, which stands for Money, Ideology, Compromise, and Ego.
Those four characteristics are things that we often look
at when we're trying to understand spying.
Money, Ideology, Compromise, and Ego.
Okay, John McLaughlin, we were interviewing him
on All Things Considered because arguably the most famous traitor
in CIA history, a man named Aldrich Ames, was in the news.
John McLaughlin's view was that
Aldrich Ames' motive was probably
money, or at least that was the biggest
thing. Have German prosecutors
laid out what they think
August Hanning's motive may have been?
No, prosecutors haven't,
but it's quite well known
and spoken about publicly that
Hanning had
some financial difficulties.
But as I said
earlier, this is based on conversations I've
had with a security source
that knew him better or certainly was reporting
at the time that he was in office, says that this
maybe has also something to do with ego,
with fear of a loss of influence in retirement.
One more to you, Esme, and then Tom Bowman,
I'm going to let you hop in here. But I'm thinking
about the timing of this.
And there's probably never a great time to have a big intelligence
scandal, but it is worth noting this one comes
at a particularly awkward moment in Germany.
The Chancellor, Chancellor Merkel,
is making a push to respond more aggressively to Russian
aggression toward Ukraine, maybe toward NATO members.
And part of that push, as I understand,
it was empowering the BND, the agency that Hanning once led.
That's going to be kind of tricky to
empower the BND if nobody wants
to share intelligence with them anymore, because
maybe it's not secure well that's right i mean
the timing is uh difficult because these are huge
reforms that are being debated right now
in in the lower house um that essentially are of the
bundestag of the bundestag that's right
that essentially are meant to empower germany's
intelligence agencies not just
its foreign intelligence agency but also its domestic
intelligence agency
and it's i think it's worth explaining that there's there's a clear
line between the powers that the police have
and the powers that the intelligence agencies have so
they have no operative powers here they're
to a certain extent little more than bookkeepers of
information which is why they are so reliant
on the CIA the NSA GCHQ etc MI6 absolutely and why
is this the case well of course it's German history
the history of the Gestapo the Gestapo
is short for Geheimer Staatspolizei, so secret state police.
It's also the history of former
East Germany's Stasi, Staatssicherheit, the secret police.
That is such a helpful
primer on German intelligence.
Also, this episode is going to be great for my German. I'm learning
so much. Tom, pick up with this thread
of the implications for countries that are allies of
Germany, that share intelligence with Germany,
who might hesitate to keep doing so under these
circumstances well i think particularly
the united states would want to know how did this happen what
was the intelligence shared clearly russia would
be of great concern to the united states right now
with the war in ukraine and and so and what russia
is doing uh in europe you know threats of drones
and and so forth so that would be i think number one
for the united states um you always think
about protecting you know if if intelligence gets
into the wrong hands it can reveal how you know
what you know. It can reveal, dare I say, sources and methods.
Sources and methods, particularly
things like, you know, intercepts of phone conversations,
radio communications, that's
always the most sensitive.
Or you could have a mole in a particular area and we don't want anyone
to know we have a mole.
So yeah, I'm sure this would cause some concern in the United States.
How did this happen? And especially what was the intelligence shared?
And also with what country?
I think a lot of people will say, aha, it has to be Russia.
But that's really not the case, is it, Esme?
They're not saying it's particularly Russia, right?
Yeah, is there any evidence that Russia has its fingerprints on this?
Again, the federal prosecutors are staying quiet right now,
which is fairly typical here.
They will take their time, and they tend not to speak until
their investigations are fairly developed.
But either way, this is, well,
possibly the biggest scandal in the history, the 70-year history
of the intelligence agency of the BND, the Bundesnachrichtendienst.
And we're yet to see what kind of damage it could potentially do.
Intrigue, intrigue, intrigue.
We're going to take a break.
When we come back,
why the U.S. military is so worried about five guys in vans.
That's ahead on Sources and Methods from NPR.
stay tuned for the following announcements
and messages from our sponsors this message comes
from wise the smart way to manage your money around
the world with Wise you can send, spend
and receive money in over 40 currencies
at the mid-market rate. Learn more at wise.com. T's and
C's apply. This message comes from Leesa
and their lineup of beautifully crafted mattresses tailored
to how you sleep. Go to leesa.com for up to 30% off mattresses,
plus get an extra $50 off with
promo code NPR. This message comes from the NBC News podcast,
Here's the Scoop. It's a daily look
at the top headlines with deeper conversations about
the stories shaping the world, from the
economy to AI to the midterms.
Listen to Here's the Scoop, a podcast from NBC News. Let's hop
from continental Europe to the UK,
where peculiar details keep trickling out about an alleged
terrorism plot. Now, this starts with a group
of young men in white vans near an Air Force base in
England, rural area, middle of the night,
a rural area that contains a base the U.S. has used to
carry out strikes on Iran as the U.S. has waged war against Iran.
Those men have all since been
released on bail. A couple of others have also been arrested.
The British Prime Minister, Andy
Burnham, and President Trump,
they are both saying this could be linked to Iran. Neither is providing
any evidence, and Iran denies they had anything to do with this.
Tom, what the heck? What's the
latest? Well, the latest is, again, there were seven people arrested.
All have been received
bail now, and no charges have been filed.
But you're right, it started with white vans,
and a rural woman saw this, it looks suspicious, she calls police
and then they show up surround
the vans and drag these guys out. No explosives in the vans
but canisters of gasoline and then
a couple of other guys were arrested
the first five apparently were all in their 20s, British
nationals. The two others were British Iranian nationals
so that's kind of where we are and
And you're right. They suspect it's Iran.
Intelligence reports basically say there
was a threat from drones from Iran.
And that's why they took the B-1 bombers, which were based
at RAF Fairford, and sent them back to the United States.
The U.S. has taken its bombers back.
That's right. And these bombers took part,
of course, in the attacks on Iran.
Do your sources have any thoughts in terms of what would prove a link
or what kind of questions they're asking?
Well, again, it's sensitive intelligence.
And if I had to guess, it would be, as we were talking earlier,
on intercepts of phone conversations.
That's usually pretty good stuff.
And again, it was a significant threat, enough of a threat,
that they decided to send these bombers back to the United States.
So to zero in on this point that U.S. bombers have
been based at this British base, that the U.S. has
been using this base in its ongoing operations against Iran.
I mean, I'm thinking, you know,
we've talked on this podcast about how America's allies
in the Middle East are paying a price for hosting U.S. troops.
This is not a country in the Middle East.
This is the United Kingdom.
It raises questions about whether other U.S. allies are going to pay a
price, are paying a price for hosting U.S. troops and helping the U.S.
I think that's quite possible.
And it shows the reach of Iran.
Now, the administration keeps saying, well, we destroyed their Navy.
We destroyed their Air Force.
while there's still a significant threat from drones.
We've talked about this many times.
Drones are the threat of the present.
It's a serious problem.
And I was talking to one guy,
I had coffee with a NATO military officer.
This is before all this came out.
He said, you know, I could buy a commercial
off-the-shelf drone, put a grenade on it
and fly it to Fairford and do some damage
to a B-1 bomber.
Those things cost like more than $300 million.
I could do this with a drone probably cost,
I don't know, $100 or less.
This is such a 2026 conversation about how drones
are just totally upending all of these calculations.
This guy also mentioned about, you know, some of the bases,
you know, in Europe and also the Middle East.
He said, you know, these planes are out in the open.
They're on the tarmac.
They're not in hardened shelters.
He said, you may have to harden all of these airports
with concrete shelters to prevent an attack by a drone like that.
cost, you know, God, hundreds of millions,
billions of dollars to do this. Or as you say,
some of these countries may say, you know what,
we don't want the U.S. military here anymore.
They're a threat to us. I think you're going
to see that more in the Middle East. Some of these
countries, you know, Bahrain,
that was hit very hard by Iranian drones and missiles. It was
basically destroyed the Fifth Fleet headquarters
of the U.S. They had to remove all the dependents
and almost all of the service members there back to the United States.
So, you know, Bahrain, some of these other countries may say,
you know what, it's too much of a threat to have the U.S. here.
And our infrastructure, our oil infrastructure is getting bombed.
We may just cut a deal with Iran and say,
you know what, that's our way forward.
Hello, asymmetric warfare.
Absolutely.
Esme, hop in here.
Is this story of the British base and the guys in white vans,
has this got traction in the German press?
worth noting Germany also hosts U.S. troops.
Yes, it has. And Germany really does host U.S.
troops, about 36,000 of them.
And in about almost two dozen different installations,
Ramstein is the U.S.,
the largest U.S. airbase outside of the U.S. And so I think this is a
great concern. And the concern until now has been,
of course, the security implications of the U.S.
pulling out and potentially going elsewhere.
But, you know, it's that double-edged sword of them
being here. So I think there are major concerns.
But I think also Germany's military has been
asked to step up constantly.
And I think we're starting to see that now because Mats, he is
spending. A lot of that spending is going into AI-driven drone tech.
Munich is becoming a hub
for it. Maatz was in Kiev at the weekend,
and he took the CEOs of these new drone startups like
Helsing and Quantum Systems.
So Germany, I think, is facing up to potentially being left alone
to threats. They also thwarted a drone attack
on Leipzig airport back in August, which they have
blamed on, Berlin has blamed on Russia.
And Leipzig airport is important because it's a major NATO hub.
let's take another quick break
when we come back we're going to talk through the pentagon effort
to reinvent itself to fight the wars of the future the wars of 2026
and beyond and we're
going to talk through whether elon musk ought
to be part of that effort keep listening to sources
and methods stay tuned for the following announcements
and messages from our sponsors
this message comes from lisa
and their lineup of beautifully crafted mattresses tailored to
how you sleep. Go to leesa.com for up to 30% off mattresses,
plus get an extra $50 off with
promo code NPR. We the people make a free press possible.
Together, we hold power to account with
reporting for the public, funded by the public.
It takes all of us to protect the future of public
media. Make your gift now at donate.npr.org.
This election season, you can streamline your news
intake with Up First. Our team of reporters
and editors works overnight so you can start every
morning with three stories you need to know in short episodes,
12-14 minutes long, to save you
time and your sanity.
Follow Up First on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Pentagon Chief Pete Hegseth announced at the State of the Force speech,
which we touched on last week,
that the military will be launching
an effort called Project Meridian. Tom.
What is Project Meridian?
It will look at the future of warfare.
And clearly drones will be involved, AI,
space-based weapons and satellites and so forth.
And what's interesting here is—
So this is like an expert panel that's going to weigh
in and give recommendations to Pentagon chiefs?
Right.
Okay.
And they'll report in 120 days.
And some of the people involved in this are household names.
One is Palmer Luckey, who runs Anduril,
which is a drone-making company.
Also, a guy you may have heard of, his name is Elon Musk,
who runs SpaceX, Tesla, and then finally, Twitter, a few other things.
Yeah, he's busy. And who's the third?
Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich, who was kind of a surprise there.
He never served in the military. He's been on the Defense Policy Board,
has taught at various military colleges and universities.
So he's a surprise.
Knows the ways of Washington.
Oh, there's no question.
He knows the ways of Washington.
So they're going to report in 120 days about
the future of the U.S. military.
How are we going to fight in the decades to come?
Now, the concern, of course, is...
Well, what I'm hearing is that, correct me if I'm wrong,
but two of those three, Palmer Luckey, Elon Musk,
would have a financial stake in the future of how the U.S. wages war.
Correct.
They have tens of billions of dollars
in government contracts as we speak.
So there's a great deal of concern about a conflict of interest here.
I talked to one guy who was a senior Pentagon official in Trump one.
And he said, Tom, of course, this is a conflict of interest.
These guys are going to shape the future of the U.S. military
and they have a stake in it.
Yeah. Right. Another guy I talk with said,
I'm not as concerned as others are.
Listen, it's a recommendation. It's going to go to Congress.
Congress obviously writes the checks,
they're going to have a huge say, right? Now, we know
the future of the U.S. military.
We could go to a college sophomore and say, what's the way ahead?
And that person's going to say, drones, AI,
space-based stuff, right? Hacking, right?
We should be running this commission, Tom.
Exactly, right. So it's not a shock
that this would happen. And he said, listen,
if they're writing the regs for a new weapon system
and then bidding on it,
That's a conflict of interest.
So, again, some are really worried about it.
Some are not.
The bottom line is this.
Congress is going to look at this.
And as you know, like any report in Washington,
they're going to either accept it, accept a little part of it,
or put it on a shelf and let it get, you know, crow dust.
So that's kind of the way.
But there are concerns about a conflict of interest.
There's absolutely no question.
All right.
Well, I look forward to, as you continue to ask questions
and nose around this one, what you learn.
and come back and tell us and keep us posted.
With that, we're going to jump to OSINT,
Open Source Intelligence,
valuable intelligence right out there
for anybody who should come want to look.
Esme, your debut OSINT, what do you have for us?
Bring it.
The talk this week of so many classified documents
made me think about Germany's former Stasi headquarters,
which I went past, I cycled past the other day
on my way to an interview.
In that building, there's a team of archivists.
They're called puzzle women
because they're mainly women still putting back together
the files that the Stasi shredded in a panic in 1989
when the wall fell.
And anyway, I was on my way past this building
to go and talk to somebody about the far right.
And I wanted to get some Vox as well.
Vox, just to explain,
is like random man or woman on the street.
Tell me what's on your mind to answer this question.
That's right.
Kind of, you know, the real standard.
Vox Populi.
Exactly. A real kind of basic in reporting, right? And I love doing it
because I like talking to people and I get people to talk to me.
But then I don't, you know, they often then won't give me their name.
And partly that's certainly a legacy. I think a general shows,
again, the general skepticism of anybody wanting their data,
of certainly the secret police on that legacy.
The irony and I think the paradox of my beat, though, is that just
a couple of days before the former intelligence chief was arrested,
there was news in a broadsheet about another high-ranking intelligence
official about the fact that his private cell phone number,
his private home address and his private email address are all readily
available and accessible online and have been for the past six years.
So you can't get the man on the street
or the woman on the street to give you their name,
but you can look up the cell phone number of the high-ranking official.
I'm picturing you now on your bike whizzing past Stasi headquarters
and trying to get people.
Did you get the Vox in the end?
I have my ways of making people talk.
There you go.
There you go.
I would not resist.
Tom Bowman.
We were talking about U.S. troops in Germany.
Right now, the Pentagon is looking at reducing the footprint in Europe,
maybe by tens of thousands of troops.
Likely, some of those will come from Germany
and either head back to the United States or head to Eastern Europe.
Now, I'm told that Poland is looking at building two bases
in the western part of the country, and they could
be accepting troops from elsewhere in Europe or possibly Germany.
We'll get a sense of that probably by the end of the year.
And you may remember, Mary Louise, in the first Trump administration,
there was talk of building a Fort Trump in Poland.
So I'm not sure if they're going to retain that name,
Fort Trump, maybe Fort Hegseth. But keep an eye on that.
You could see permanent U.S. troops in Poland.
Right now it's rotational troops. So we'll keep an eye on that.
And I'll keep you in touch on that as well.
I hope you will. It's funny. I've been asking,
nosing around on this as well, because I find it fascinating
that there might be a permanent U.S. footprint in Poland.
And I had the chance on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly
a few weeks ago in New York to ask Poland's foreign minister.
This is Radek Sikorski, who is also the deputy prime minister.
And I was asking him, how about it?
Permanent U.S. military footprint in Poland. Here's what he said.
So we want the kind of U.S. presence that would reassure us,
but not be threatening to Russia.
And we hope that President Trump keeps the promise
that he has made to this effect to our president.
What would that be, a presence that would
be reassuring but not threatening?
Well, we think two heavy brigades, so up to 10,000 troops,
which is what we've had recently, more or less, would be sufficient.
So there you have it.
And I could just say that also Poland would like
to get long-range fires on its soil from the United States.
That will definitely get Russia's attention.
Sounds like a reporting trip might
be in your not-too-distant future to Poland, Tom.
I'm in.
There you go.
Let's spend some money.
I will close us out.
I'm going to circle us back to old-school espionage.
In fact, very old school, a very old spy ring, older than
the United States, which worked to deliver intelligence to George
Washington as he was fighting the Brits in the Revolutionary War.
The reason this is on my mind is I spent this past weekend
in Oyster Bay, lovely little seaside town,
small city town, I think we can say, on Long Island.
I was with my college roommates for a weekend.
And among our activities, we went to tour a place called Raynham Hall.
Have either of you heard of this place?
Never heard of it.
It's this beautiful old house.
It was built in 1740, beautiful white wooden house.
And it is where a man named Robert Townsend grew up.
Townsend became a spy for General George Washington.
And you can go through the house
and see exhibits on the secret codes they used and ciphers
and couriers to try to make sure, you know, how do you get
a letter to George Washington on the front lines in the 1700s.
For added security, they used invisible ink.
And a particular invisible ink invented by James Jay,
brother of John Jay, by the way.
You can learn about how Benedict Arnold really mucked things up
when he switched sides, switched to the British team
and launched a campaign to arrest American spies.
We got a lovely tour from the museum director,
a woman named Harriet Gerard Clark, and she shared,
this is where I'll leave us, the story of one particular
invisible ink letter written by Robert Townsend in 1780.
They were warning that the Brits were planning
an attack on Rhode Island, Newport, Rhode Island,
and they were trying desperately to get that intelligence
to George Washington so he could figure out how do we bluff the Brits
and keep them from doing this attack. And they did it.
And I sat there listening and thought, you know, the role
of intelligence in shaping war plans and the role of misinformation
and disinformation and bluffing your enemy, plus ça change.
You know, there they were in 1780. And here we are.
And the technology looks a little bit different,
but the invisible ink was working for them then.
With that, I'm going to say a big thank you
to Esme Nicholson in Berlin.
Thanks for sharing your reporting with us this week. Come back soon.
Thank you for having me.
And NPR Pentagon correspondent Tom Bowman here in Washington.
Always a pleasure.
Yes, it is. Before we go, a thank you to our NPR Plus listeners,
who support the work of every journalist you hear on this show,
wherever they are in the world.
NPR Plus listeners also get every episode without sponsor messages,
and they can access our full archive of episodes.
Learn more at plus.npr.org. Thank you for listening.
I'm Mary Louise Kelly. We will be back next week
with another episode of Sources and Methods from NPR.
Stay tuned for the following announcements
and messages from our sponsors.
Midlife brings a lot of changes.
Your Turn with Alison Aubrey is a new podcast
to help you navigate the twists and turns.
From health and relationships to creativity and purpose,
we can help steer your next chapter.
With Your Turn with Alison Aubrey.
Find it on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
This week on Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, we talk
with David Byrne about the early fashion advice he got from Lou Reed.
I had really hairy arms at that point.
He said, you should never wear short sleeves.
Body shamed you.
Don't miss our full conversation and the rest of our games.
Listen to the Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me podcast on the NPR app
or wherever you get your podcasts.