WILD MPG: 2025 Honda Civic vs Elantra Hybrid Economy Battle!

Sedan Autos
6 followers
#GJWauto #reviewcars #sedan #sedanauto #reviewauto #drivingcars #popcars #cars #autos #review #reviewautos #reviewcar
AI Generated·May contain errors
This video is brought to you by Grandeur Warranty, your number one
online source for factory-backed extended warranties in the country.
Today, Jen, we're not drag racing
and we're not driving big trucks over rocks.
We're going to do some real-world testing
that will actually help people shopping for cars.
That's true. We have two great hybrids
that we're going to be taking on our Denver 100 loop,
which is a 111-mile route around the majority of Denver.
Let's see which one wins.
Check it out, Jen.
So what are we working with here, Case?
Under the hood of the Civic,
this car is motivated by a 2-liter naturally aspirated 4-cylinder
and a dual-motor hybrid system that Honda makes.
That's pretty interesting.
Sometimes this engine directly drives the wheels,
but a lot of the time it's just an electric motor
that's actually moving the car.
And this combination should,
according to the EPA, get me a combined 49 mpg.
49, okay, that's not bad.
200 horsepower, 232 pound-feet of torque.
Wow, well that is looking, I would say,
a little bit better than my setup. On the Elantra,
we're working with a 1.6 liter four-cylinder hybrid
with a six-speed dual clutch. However,
this is only coming in at 139 horsepower
and 195 pound-feet of torque. However,
under the right circumstances this is estimated
a combined 50 miles per gallon that's true and
today's video is about mpg
so while the civic is looking downright sporty by comparison
that's not what this video is about no
first before we go on our mpg loop we've got
to top up both cars and every time that we top up
we do our double click method we wait 30 seconds in between
and we're going to do obviously the
same thing for both cars this one was pretty near full
so now just wait 30 seconds and we'll top it
off neither of these cars specifies any particular grade
of gas on the fuel door so we're just
running mid-grade we're up here at altitude
so our mid-grade is actually 87 instead of 89 or what you
might find at lower altitudes all right this one
was a little bit lower this is only about a quarter
tank so we had to fill up 9.24 the trip odometer is zeroed out
and we are ready to go start our
loop we're merging on the highway now
and this Denver 100 that we do is pretty much all highway
driving so this is more like a real world road trip MPG test
and jen how is it merging onto
the highway in the Elantra. It is slow.
It is not as alarmingly slow as I kind of anticipated with
139 horsepower, but it is adequate at best.
We're also here at about a mile above sea level around
Denver, which granted isn't as impactful on a hybrid
as it would be on just a purely combustion
powered car, but it still has a bit of an impact.
The Civic here, I'd say the acceleration is
adequate. I don't think anyone is going to buy this car
so that they can win a bunch of drag
races, but it can hold its own.
How are some of the features on the inside of your Elantra? Because
my Civic is decently well-specced.
I got kind of a smaller center screen. I've got heated seats,
but no ventilation, don't appear to have
a heated steering wheel either, but I've got the basics.
Now, I'm actually fairly impressed with the interior
of this Elantra. You know, it's got
two 10.25-inch screens with Apple CarPlay, Android Auto.
It's got lane keep assist and
lane follow assist.
So far, it's been very nice, and I have heated and ventilated seats.
Now, both of these vehicles are economy cars,
and economy cars are all about saving money.
And if you want to save even more money in the long run
and protect your investment,
check out Ranger Warranties.
Ranger is our number one provider
of extended factory-backed warranties.
So if you ever have anything that needs repair on your vehicle,
you can get it fixed by factory-trained technicians using OEM parts,
and they cover everything from the powertrain
to the electronics and more.
so check out that link below for a Ranger warranty.
Now what the Elantra might be lacking
in acceleration, it definitely makes up for in some features
and a really pretty nice interior.
That being said, and I hate to say it,
I do think that the front end of the Elantra looks
a little catfish-like. It seems to be looking down at the ground.
You are a thousand and two
percent correct this I I think they designed it after
a catfish because the
looks are uncanny it is not great on the exterior
but I will hand it to him the
interior is actually pretty nice
and that being said I do like some of the
body lines on the exterior
of the Elantra especially the three lines that
go through the doors give it kind
of a distinct look the Civic doesn't have
of anything styling-wise on its exterior
that I think would offend anybody, and that's kind
of the point. Civic is meant to be a very mass-market car,
but it is a little plain
from the outside. Yeah, the Elantra leaves somewhat,
at least for me, a negative impression
for the exterior,
but the Civic just doesn't leave an impression at all. That being said,
Honda does a really good job on a lot
of their touch points on the interior, so I've got
a lot of physical buttons for my climate controls, which I like a lot.
I've got a few USB-C ports,
which is great. Steering wheel feels good in hand.
So this is still a very nice car to drive.
Now, one difference that I noticed is you've got 18-inch wheels
on your Civic, whereas I have 17-inch
wheels on the Elantra. Which ones do you think
are going to be a little bit better for, you know,
a better MPG loop yeah as much as a big 18 inch wheel looks good
the 17 should be more efficient
and it should also be a little bit more
comfortable since you'll have some extra sidewall
dampening some of these very bumpy uncomfortable
Colorado highways that we're driving
could not agree more i uh definitely
a big fan of smaller wheels bigger tires
now we've both got our cruise control set at 75
which is the speed limit here on the tollway
and i've even got my lane keep assist active
so it's doing a little bit of steering as well
we've got quite a bit of highway ahead of us
so it's time to crush the miles
so Jen we're about halfway
through our miniature MPG
trip and these are 75 mile
per hour highways so
these are not the best conditions for getting
the best possible fuel economy we're also not
hypermiling. We're driving these vehicles
as people normally would on a road trip. So we're
going the speed limit. We're not going way under
to get crazy fuel economy. We're cruising around
with the radio on. We've got our AC and our climate set to auto.
So nothing insane as far
as trying to get the most possible MPG.
Really just trying to drive these cars like a normal
person would to see what you would get every day.
Exactly. And I know the first half of the
correct me if I'm wrong,
is kind of climbing and now we should start a small descent. So
MPG should rise a little bit,
but what are you sitting at average right now?
So what my fuel economy is showing is anywhere
from right now around 44.5 to 45 MPG changes a
little bit as we get an uphill or a downhill stretch.
And like you said, yeah, we have done
the majority of our uphill driving, so that number should improve.
But of course, there's
also a little bit of variance in what
these trip computers tell you that you're getting
so everything that we get we have to confirm at the pump
but what's the Hyundai showing you now
well i've seen as high as almost 52 mpg
but right now it is sitting at 47.1 so still not
you know atrocious by any means
but i think we're going to see some improvement as we finish up this
loop and that could be interesting
because on paper these cars should be pretty close in their
fuel economy, but again,
once we get these to the pump and we actually confirm the fuel economy
numbers and really know, because sometimes
these trip computers can be a little optimistic
and we're not really sure exactly what fuel economy we're getting,
that Honda could make good
on its lack of horsepower by overcoming it
with some extra fuel economy, but we'll have to see.
Day for testing this though, there's pretty
low winds, we're almost 70 degrees, so as
far as the day is concerned,
this is about as good as it gets for doing a fuel economy
run.
That being said, we're cruising some pretty high speeds,
so this would be more relevant
to what kind of fuel economy you would get
if you're doing a road trip in one of these
cars versus day-to-day commuting, especially through the city.
Exactly.
We get a little bit of stop
and go towards the end of our loop as we enter through Golden,
for you know the majority of this entire loop it is all highway
and luckily not a lot of people on
the road today so we're not doing a whole lot of stop
and go pretty consistent with our speeds
should be a really good test, that's right, we've got quite
a few miles left so it's gonna be
exciting once we can get
these to the pump
and actually see what they
did so Jen, according to my
trip computer I got 50.3 miles per gallon
which I'm pretty impressed with because like we said
it was all highway at pretty high speeds
and that's actually a little better than what the
EPA estimate said I should be getting
which was 49 combined or 49 combined 47 highway so already
to go over 100 miles right now we're at just under two gallons
so once we top off it'll be
a little over that's already pretty impressive right
and our top off and there's our final
number 2.27 so we do the quick calculation
so my trip computer said 109.3 we'll do it exact
divided by 2.27, 48 so not quite as good
as what the trip computer was telling me but
still a really good number still a great number
the uh the car was a little optimistic
yeah a little bit optimistic which is not unusual at all
but the question is will the Elantra do
better and I kind of hope it does
because you got to justify the power deficit somehow right also
the catfish so yeah doing the same mid-grade 87
filler up buttercup kind of say nice thing about
both of these cars is they really don't use a lot
of gas no no I mean you used how many gallons to
go just over two gallons
that's nothing pretty good now Jen what did your trip computer say
53.6 mpg which is a lot better than what you know
the Monroney calls for yeah and if that's true
and my Civic got about 48
then this might actually be a worthwhile sacrifice to make yeah and we
still have to talk about price
if we're talking about worthwhile all right all right ready let's
do another top off good so 2.1 2.1 okay
so it didn't use less let's get
the exact number so
109.3, same mileage, divided by,
what is it exactly? 2.086.
Final result, 52.4. Wow! Yeah,
so that's pretty big.
So both computers were a little better, they're reading a little better
than what is actually shown, but still pretty fantastic.
Yeah. I don't know, I think this might
be the winner. It's a tough call
because the Civic is definitely noticeably quicker. Yes. But
4MPG over the lifetime of these vehicles
is going to average out to quite a bit of money.
And it's worth talking about money on both of these.
So that Civic starts around the mid $20,000
range. But if you want to get a hybrid,
you're going to be closer to $30,000. And the one that
they sent us is pretty spec'd out,
so it's in the mid $30,000 range, which is getting up there a
little bit in price. Okay, yeah, so same with the Elantra.
You can get these in the 20s, but this is
the limited hybrid, which is the big boy,
the biggest one you can get, and this is topped out
at about a little over $30,000. Okay.
So, better MPG, better on the pocketbook. I don't know.
Yeah, and arguably a nicer interior
but the Civic is certainly quite a bit quicker, yes, and depending
on your personal point of view maybe a little better looking
so let us know down in the comments
below which one of these two you would go
for Jen, I'd say we gave some pretty decent consumer
advice today, I think so, and I think we found a clear MPG king today
