YES, KAREN. PLANTS REALLY DO GROW IN SAND.

Father Fish
51 followers
Oct 8, 2026
Speaking truth to ignorance means tearing down fantasies. Our hobby is awash in fantasies. The best way to test a fantasy is to challenge it with proof. Prove sand cannot support plants. Put it to the test. Here are some plants with roots growing in sand. Proof!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedFather Fish debunks the common misconception that aquatic plants cannot grow in sand. Through a live demonstration of various plant species, he provides empirical evidence that roots thrive in sandy substrates, arguing that many hobbyist beliefs are based on assumptions rather than hands-on experimentation.
This is Father Fish.
Somebody asked me earlier today, they asked me,
why do you recommend sand in your tank?
I've been told plants cannot grow in sand.
And I thought about that for a minute.
And my immediate response was, well,
whoever said that has never done it.
And so they're basing their beliefs on their own
ideas, probably on their own self-interest
and not on factual trial and error proof.
I find that interesting because there's a lot of that kind
of knowledge going on in the tropical fish hobby.
A lot of people say things and insist upon them as true,
when in point of fact, what
they're really insisting upon is their own self-interest,
their own ideas, ideas that
grow out of their head, ideas that grow out of their beliefs,
that grow out of their understanding
of how things work that do not, however,
grow out of actual hands-on trial and error proof,
experimentation proof. So it's a simple matter.
Can plants grow in sand? Well, let's look at this.
Here's eight inches of sand. Eight inches of sand.
Those are plants. See all the plants?
let's let's pull one up
and see if there are any roots you're
okay just keep going let's see
i'm gonna do this gently
so i don't disturb much what
do you see beauty you seeing roots
i am i'm seeing roots that's a lot of roots look
at the roots it's funny they're growing in the
sand yeah what are those roots growing in uh
by god they're growing in sand aren't they it's a
Look at that. So this is what I call empirical evidence.
Do plants grow in sand? What's that? Is that a root?
Do those roots look like they're having trouble getting
into the sand? They don't look like it to me.
Now this is interesting. What is this?
This is dead root. That's the original root ball.
It separated itself out and all of this,
all of it, all of that, that's all new root growth
that has occurred since this plant
was put down in the sand.
Let's put them back. You got my
technique now
this is a big plant what about
a little plant tell you
what let's go over here
and find ourselves excuse me
a little plant a bunch of them
in here let's try there's a little
root just starting to grow on that look
at that going right down there in the sand let's pull
this guy up. See what's happening here.
Look at the new roots. This was just put in a few days
ago. Brand new roots going down in there.
Look at that. Imagine that. Roots of a very tiny plant
growing in, what's this? Sand. Is that a coarse sand?
That's a very fine sand. Look how fine that
sand is. Hmm, interesting, isn't it? Let's find another one.
Oh, here's one that's all chewed up,
and I'll bet we just put this down in here because it was chewed up.
Let's see what's on the end of
it. Oh, look at that. Look at all those roots.
All of those roots, and they're all new roots. When
roots are white like that, that means they're brand new.
Something else that's interesting,
I'm going to put these back down in here
But those roots will die
And it will send new roots up
Because the roots all have little tiny cilia
Little tiny hairs
Much thinner and much tinier than the hair on your head
And they grow into the substrate
And they actually create little anaerobic pockets
That break down waste
so that they can pull them up.
Look at this.
This is a red blood sword here.
Look at all the roots coming off of it.
All these, like, ear roots,
they're all reaching to the bottom.
Let's see what's down in here.
What's down in here?
My goodness, it's a big plant.
It's got lots going on.
Oh, my.
There it is, right there.
See that?
that's a root they came off of just like
these these tap roots there's one that went down in
the sand see all the little tiny cilia all
the little hairs like a chain that's what is feeding
this now not this not the end look
at that on the end nothing at all you can take that off
but look at the roots see where they're coming
from they're coming right out of the stem right
there. So we're going to try to plant that whole thing a little bit.
So what else? Oh, here's one.
This is interesting. This is a valisneria.
Now what do they do? It's a chain plant. Look at the
chain. There it goes. See it? Look at that.
And it's coming off of, look, it's coming off of this
right here look at that look at all those roots
so what do we know now that we did not know
five minutes ago we know from empirical evidence
absolute proof based on our own lying eyes
that plants grow in sand so the next time someone says
that to you that plants can't possibly grow
in sand you might suggest to them
that they check out what they're saying before they open their
mouth and say something really stupid
because plants obviously can grow in sand if you look
in a pond in a creek in a river in the ocean
in a bay what are all those plants growing in
They're growing in sand. Sand.
That sand has a lot of nutrients in it.
It's got a lot of mud down in it.
But it is at base sand. That's what plants grow in.
Every farmer who has ever planted seeds,
started seeds, started them in sand. Sand.
Isn't it wonderful? Look at that.
All of these plants, every one of them, growing in sand.
Look at all that. Even this Apogonogeton crispus.
Plants growing in sand. Who would have believed?
Only someone who bothered to look and to see
and to figure it out by experimentation.
There you go. Plants grow in sand.
I defy you to say again that plants cannot grow in sand
because we have just seen plants growing in sand.
They don't grow in gravel. They do grow in sand.
Father Fish, have a wonderful fishing day. Bye for now.
