What To Make Of Knicks Pausing Extension Talks With Karl-Anthony Towns, Josh Hart | NY Got Game

New York Post - Sports
11 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 9, 2026
Welcome back to another edition of New York Got Game.
Dexter Henry, Stefan Bondi,
our fantastic beat reporter covering the New York Knicks, is here.
Stefan, how you doing, man?
Yo, man. How's it going?
Going good. Going good.
Knicks fans might be a little bit worried today.
A little bit concerned because you talked about this back on Media Day
that a lot of the talk here in training camp and through the preseason
was going to be about these extensions
that are available for these players.
And today, the Knicks came out
with a statement in which they basically said
they will not be discussing extensions through the season
and they're tabling it uh going forward
what did you make of that statement
and what does this mean for the Knicks and the players involved
primarily Josh Hart and Karl-Anthony Towns well it means
a couple things one is the they were not close to
obviously not close to an agreement
um which every player has said that i think that's not
a surprise the other thing it felt like
and i've you know nobody's confirmed this but it felt like
a response to what Karl-Anthony Towns said to us on Monday
when i asked him you know give us some
details separate fact from fiction about what's going
on with your contract situation he said all
i wanted all i want is um something
that values me i'm willing to take a discount but obviously
he was not willing to take the type of discount
that the Knicks were offering which was as i
reported four years 200 million dollars uh KAT
is eligible for four years 277 million dollars so
he's looking for something in the middle
um and the Knicks never got there and when he took some
of these issues more publicly he
also had a line no ---- Sherlock um that probably rubbed people
the wrong way in with the Knicks uh
then this felt like this was the Knicks response all right
you know this is now public well we're gonna shut it down
and there's gonna be no negotiations
and there's gonna be no distractions
um so you know that's my read on the situation um
and you know i don't think it's a surprise at all
that they are not coming to an agreement i do think
that taking this so publicly
and playing this out now with statements um that part is a little
bit surprising to me i was a little bit surprised just want
to read the statement uh from the Knicks
for the people said as an organization this quote
from the Knicks as an organization our entire
focus is on preparing for the upcoming season
and delivering another year for our fans to be
proud of as a result we will
not be negotiating contract extensions until later in the season
and will remain solely focused on preparing for the starter season,
which is October 20th at the Garden against the Sixers.
When I think about this, Steph, and I agree with you,
I'm not surprised necessarily
at the Knicks responding in this way, but...
No, I am surprised in that.
Yeah, sorry, and I'm speaking myself.
I am surprised in responding in this way, right?
I thought there would be some response,
and I might be a little bit surprised,
to be clear, about the timing of this.
but does the way the Knicks responded here,
does it benefit them in any way?
That is the question I have.
You know,
it,
it benefits them as a,
just a shot at who,
who they're negotiating with agents,
players,
whatever,
because obviously it's not going to stop the distraction.
Like it does the opposite.
Right.
You know,
the player,
it doesn't stop the players from thinking,
I don't have a contract extension.
That's not going to stop.
It's not going to stop the media from asking,
how do you feel about not having a contract extension?
the Knicks cannot ban players from speaking
to the media they cannot ban players from speaking
about their own contracts so to say that this ends the distractions
and now we're going to focus on
winning a championship um no i i don't agree
with that and i don't think that was their true purpose
in releasing it in a statement like this publicly you know
if they wanted to do it where all right
let's just stop the distractions
and focus on the season they would have met with the um representatives
of these players uh they would have come
to an understanding of listen we're not close you know
there's nothing you know we're not budging
from this um you know we have this second apron mandate
from the owner we can't pay you what you want
but you know i would like for us to table this
privately and um you know please don't discuss it publicly through
the media that's not what
happened um the representatives
from these players found out about it didn't catch them by surprise
they knew that the statement was coming
um but it's still you know it still doesn't feel like
what it says the purpose is what it says
which is stopping distractions right it's not because
the questions are still going to be asked
the next time there's media availability Karl-Anthony Towns and
josh hart will be asked these questions i think it'll
be interesting to see how they respond to
those questions speaking of their response steph both
of them took to social media and had some
posts on Twitter X whatever we're calling it
these days Josh Hart put in New York with a couple blue
and orange hearts promptly towns had always loved blue
and orange hearts I don't know if you saw
this and a picture a picture of him hugging Patrick Ewing
do you make anything of those
social media posts that came I mean the way you describe him
is it feels like they're taking the
high road and be like oh I love New York right has nothing
to do with the the fans and you know
people like Patrick Ewing so that that's what
my read on it is just feels like they're taking the
high road when you look at yours my read
was similar to that it is I think they're trying to
show hey it's always love between us
and the fans we know the fans love us the fans don't hate
anybody on this team right now right nobody
in this team could do wrong at this point after ending
the 53 year drought it's I agree with you taking a high road
and saying we've got the love from the
fans but do you guys have love from the fans
with this because this is kind of where I was going to
go next Steph there's been a little bit of goodwill
with the way things have been run with this team
the last seven years or so right obviously them getting a championship
and you know this being
around basketball for a long time there hasn't always
been that goodwill with the Knicks and how
they've run business so I guess
a two-part question here does this what's happened today
in the statement coming out does this affect how
the fans are now looking at ownership in the front
office and could this also have an impact on how players down the road
and agents look at dealing
with business with the Knicks
because of this coming out uh i think players and agents know
what they're getting into with the Knicks ownership i don't think
that is going to change um but you
know how the fans feel we'll see um if they win everything
is fine i've always said that it's the
um what's the phrase it's the great eraser
of any problem um is right that's not the phrase but
whatever the phrase is that's what i meant to say um and um you know
but if they struggle this is
going to be the main thing that comes up at all times
and if they will it will be pinned as the
reason why this team is not living up
to expectations it'll be pinned as the reason
why this team wasn't able to uh get another championship
um you know they the ownership
has made a decision to run it
but put the onus on themselves James Dolan put an onus on himself
to say if this doesn't work out i'm gonna take
some blame i'm gonna take the lion's share of
the blame because um it's gonna be the same team
that came back minus Mitchell Robinson who was
sacrificed for the second apron
and the second apron is uh James Dolan's mandate and it's also
going to be with players who have this contract extension
on their minds and they have that
contract extension on their minds
because James Dolan doesn't want to go into the second apron
and doesn't want to pay these players
um you know what they're asking for so I think we have to wait
and see what the fans think because we have to wait
and see how the Knicks play we do have to
wait and see how they play
and how this all plays out going forward you said to me on media day we
talked about this just how interesting it would
be to watch all these contract extensions that
because of the way this team
and the leadership they have particularly led by Jalen Brunson that
this would not be a distraction now
with this coming out seeing the responses has your opinion
on that change do you think this can become
a distraction for this team i think it can become
a distraction well first of all for i think Josh
is fine i think with josh we gotta remove him from
the equation because he has a team option
so i know he wants to be rewarded i know he wants to
be paid i understand why the Knicks would
not even consider doing it right now it just doesn't make
sense um you know unless he's willing to meet
a certain price right the the cat situation um
we talked about this before he had he has struggled
with the idea that he's not stable
and not in a stable situation and we saw that last season
when he was on the trade block
and you know he was being mentioned about going
to Milwaukee for Giannis Antetokounmpo or Portland
or whatever and he was playing poorly
and it was weighing on his mind he also didn't you know he
was struggling with his role with Mike Brown all
that stuff this could weigh on him in a similar
fashion um for sure and you know this is a guy
who's made it clear he wants to stay in New York
he absolutely wants to stay in New York uh Miles McBride
his whole career you know is feels like
it's on the line right now
and when i career by career i mean you know his big payday he's been
on this poor contract for a while now he has
not gotten any you know he has he's still waiting for
his big payday so i think regardless you know unless he would get
an extension that this is
going to affect his play one way
or another now is he going to come out and play even better because
he's now playing for big money
or is it going to you know hinder his game he's going to go out
there and try to do too much i i don't know the answer
to that but that will be certainly weighing
on mcbride's mind uh and you know i feel like it's potential
that cat will also have something
going on his mind during this season if that with no extension yeah
and i think some fans are going
to hear that and say well i don't like having too many guys
on the team that i'm rooting for that
are worried about their money right wondering how
that can all impact things in the locker room and
then i think one interesting interesting thing
to note here is cat if he were to sign an in-season
contract extension with the Knicks he would have
to decline that 61 million dollar player option he
has for next season in order to do that and it makes you wonder
if you're in his position because
you're right his situation is very different
from josh hart because of that player option
do you think cat would decline that player option just
to get an extension done in season later in
the season as the knicks have said they would
be willing to discuss yeah i mean if the money's right
for sure like if they say yeah we'll give you
whatever you know 240 million dollars that you're
asking for he would absolutely decline it
but he does hold the that's his big leverage is he has
the 61 million dollar player option where it's
like all right you know i'll play out this season
and if i get hurt or i don't play as well
and then i won't hit free agency i'll just play next season
on the biggest contract the biggest salary
that i've ever had in my career so he has uh he has
considerable leverage leverage
because of that 61 million dollar player option and he's in a good
position with that said you know cat
is a personality that wants everybody to like him
he wants everybody to be happy
and kumbaya um i don't think he's he he's comfortable with the
as he said being uncomfortable you know i know he said
that that's that's something he you know
that has to happen but cat doesn't strike me
as somebody that's comfortable when it's uncomfortable
yeah i think the thing for me is i'm really intrigued to see how cat
and both josh hart
respond to this when you know the beat writers talk
to them that that's really the response of
social media is one thing to me steph the other thing will
be what what do they say are they going
to continue to say something in public you know we know
the knicks are probably not going to say
anything more on this but i'm just very intrigued to see what they say
and how they carry this
because the message we heard from Cat earlier this week
when you and I talked in Philly it was
you know it was a very strong tone I wonder
if the tone the tone is still strong here or it
softens a bit that is a good question I don't know
the answer to that uh Cat was not in the
was the only player that was not in the locker room after
the game yesterday so he was the only
player we didn't talk to so maybe he probably knew what
was coming he had to know what's coming
maybe he wanted to get his words right
but we'll see with the next availability our Stephen Body
he will be on top of that either way interesting times around
the Knicks we'll see if this becomes
a distraction one thing we can both tell you
questions aren't gonna stop coming wait let me
Look, I got to say one more thing about the second apron.
Yeah, sure.
And I've said this before to you.
The idea that the Knicks can't go
into the second apron for one year is just silly.
They can go into the second.
The idea of the second apron is it inhibits your,
it stops your ability to get other players and get them on your team.
Build out your roster by signing players.
You can't use the mid-level exception to sign players.
You can't aggregate players in trades.
You can't take that force.
Whatever.
it's about stopping your ability
to build your team from other players
outside of your roster, it does not
stop you from keeping players on your own team
the Knicks have an
intact championship roster
they proved it, they won the championship
with the players they have on the roster
they have every right, they have every
ability to pay their own players
and go into the second apron
if it doesn't work out
you can then make a trade
to get out of the second apron, the Boston
Celtics did it, just recently
The Cleveland Cavaliers were in the second
apron just recently and got out of it.
So it's not hard to get out of the second apron.
The only problem with going into the second apron
is you're paying a ---- ton of money.
And if that's the problem, then that's the problem.
But to me, I don't understand why there's this,
I can't touch the second apron, it's the third rail situation.
You've said this to me before,
and I guess what I'll say to this is, I don't disagree with you.
my thing is when are owners going to be shamed
into going into second apron as long as this
system exists right there's been no shame for it
and you're right you saw boston do it cleveland's
a great point they they had
the largest penalties last season i think denver right now yeah right
and denver has not really looked the same since winning in 23
but owners are not really been
willing to do this outside of outside of boston
and james dolan made the mandate clear hey this
is not what i want to do i think it's disappointing
for the fans i'm with you i think it's disappointing
for the fans of the championship team
but no owners have been willing phoenix did it like i
just reeled off four teams
and the second apron hasn't been around for that long it's been around
for three years, three years right
when i say that it's the owners willing to do it for multiple
seasons right, that that that's the thing
with a championship roster okay well i'm not saying
that's my point there's no reason why you can't
do it for one season i'm with you i'm with you
on this yeah i'm i'm with you
on this but the thing i guess what i'm saying is not disagreeing
with you where's the shame for James Dolan
the fans still show up to MSG they're still there
the seats are going
to be filled right like yeah i mean i know what you're saying but like
you know that's fine that's that's always
been the case like the team that was terrible for a
long time and they were still selling out every game
but um you know the only shame that's coming
is you know i turn on First Take and Stephen A. Smith
and Kendrick Perkins are killing James
Dolan on it so that that's all i can think
of i you can never tell the fan i can i'm not telling
fans not to buy tickets yeah like they love
the Knicks i you know i are you suggesting that the
fans boycott the Knicks i think
in sports fans have probably more power than they realize but
they do not use it some of the times is what i'll say
but i understand after a championship i'm not
expecting them to boycott them this year
that's unrealistic um that you know what that that's you
that's the English Premier League fan
and you're talking because that's what they do over there
yeah but but hey does it does it
not work yeah you know better than me i don't follow it that
closely and to be fair to give the nuance in it it's
a little bit of a different situation because
we're talking about a salary cap and a non-salary cap
so i don't want to talk about it like it's
exactly equal because it's not you know i'm with you
though if you have a championship team
particularly a team that won a championship i understand
the limitations of the second apron
do i think you should go into it yes i do because
of what you said you can get out of it you could
get it out i think this i think fans i think you
and i've talked to most fans and other people
around basketball that would have said they'd like
to see the Knicks go to it and well and we're not
even talking about going into the next season
or this right it's in two years that the threat is
there and that's why you're not giving Cat
an extension right it's it's a it's a lot and it's
it's a larger discussion supposedly
and it's a larger discussion about this you know CBA current
CBA is it good for the NBA is it's good
for teams i don't know i don't think well the NBA loves the
second apron they just sent out statements defending it
because Bruce Brown had the audacity
to say um it's not good for me
but it isn't it hasn't been it it has it's it's well the nba
called him a liar there's more i could say
on that i'll say for i'll say for another time i
don't i don't necessarily agree with that not you
i don't know i don't agree with their statement
on that but i don't think it works for the i would say the middle
and lower class player of
the nba i don't think it necessarily works
for them i think the numbers prove that i know it's
like you said three seasons we're talking about
but in a short time i think if you really look
at the middle and the lower class player
in the nba in terms of earnings i don't think it
necessarily works for them which is why i know you probably agree
with this too steph just covering
the sport this is why i don't fault a cat
or a josh hart for asking for their money especially
when they've won and certain things
that they've accomplished i can never fault those guys for
that at all whatsoever i think where we can
and i appreciate you saying it and then writing it
about this stuff too we can fault the owners for the penny pinching
and not being willing to pay
and invest in championship level teams hey
at least you're bringing some shame right you're
bringing some shame i'm i'm gonna get
the english premier league fan and me here with the i'm not
trying to shame i'm not but i want to be clear i'm
not trying to we're not i'm not trying to shame
anybody to making any decisions i'm just
this is my opinion i i you know i obviously done enough
research about the second apron
and the consequences about it you know bobby marks laid out an entire
way that everybody on the Knicks court everybody
on the Knicks court can get paid and you're not in the
second apron and so like this is doable
and so the fact that everybody's like oh you know we we're you
know we can't pay everybody we can't pay
this guy they can't pay this guy at some point yes you
eventually have to put a cap on it right
but the knicks are not at that point yet right to your
point you can't pay everybody forever this team
is not going to stay together forever that's never
been your point you're right um at some point all things
are going to end in in this salary cap
world in the second apron world
but could they run it back yeah they could they could have is
Is this all disappointing that they don't want to go over it?
Yeah.
I understand where the fans are coming from.
I understand your point on it.
So, it's all interesting.
We'll see how it plays out.
That is the great Stephen Bondi.
He does a fantastic job for us covering the Knicks, Steph.
I appreciate the time, man.
I will see you on Monday for Knicks Temple.
All right, man.
I'll see you there.
All right, everybody.
Stay tuned for more on New York Got Game.
And thanks for watching New York Got Game.
Boom shakalaka.
