The Tropical Fish industry is built on failure, the failure of new fish keepers to keep their fish alive and healthy, This is altogether irresponsible and needs to stop. Stop making money by making fish sick. Just stop it!!
Father Fish discusses the systemic failure of the aquarium industry, arguing that big-box and local fish stores intentionally sell suboptimal setups to ensure customer failure. He claims this creates a cycle of dependency where hobbyists spend more on replacements and medications, leading 90% of beginners to quit. He advocates for a natural approach using dirt and sand to ensure success.
Hello. Come right on in. You're at Father Fish. Nice to have you with us.
Uh, Chris Trapp wants to know, Father Fish, what percentage of new aquarists do I think quit
within the first few months? My guess is more than 90 percent because they are, I just, I just,
Naresh just posted a clip from an older stream in which I'm complaining about this very issue.
The problem is both the big box stores and many local fish stores do not help people
to start their tanks in ways that are going to be successful. They sell them product
that guarantees their failure and they do it with absolute regularity. It is systemic.
You put a five-pound bag or a 10-pound bag of gravel in a 10-gallon tank and you sell it to
somebody and you say, dump the gravel in, pour water in, dump this chlorine remover in,
hook up the filter, put your starter gunk in there, and then throw some fish in it.
And of course, two days later, the fish are all dead. And it happens. And so they go back and
they get more fish and they put them in and they die. And they go back and they get more fish
and they put them in and they die. And they give up. 90 percent of the people who start tanks
give up. And they give up because nobody has taught them how to set up their tank to be
able to keep fish alive. And it aggravates, excuse me, it aggravates the hell out of me
because it's wholly uncalled for and unnecessary. It is a very simple matter
to set up a healthy tank that will guarantee 100 percent of the time be successful.
You put one inch of dirt, two inches of sand, carefully fill it up with water,
get rid of the chlorine either by letting it dissipate off or by putting a chlorine remover in.
That's if you got chlorine. If you don't, if you have well water, you don't put anything else in
except lots of plants and fish. And you're going to have a healthy tank. It's going to
keep your fish alive. Why in the world is it so difficult for local fish stores and big box stores
to teach people how to do this? It is the easiest thing in the world.
And yet there is such resistance to do it. I honestly believe that the whole market
has become so thoroughly corrupted that they depend upon failure in order to be able to keep
the cash flowing. And that may sound harsh, but I think it's absolutely true. I think the big box
stores and most local fish stores depend on people failing in order to be able to keep them coming
back in the door, buying more stuff. Because every time they come in with a sick fish,
it's another 25 bucks in medication. And it goes on and on and on until they get fed up and quit.
And that's the nature of the industry. That's what it's come to. 90% of the sales coming into a local
fish store or fish sales coming into a big box store are people trying to save their tank from
the failure that has been caused by those same vendors. And they spend money until they're fed
up with spending money, fed up with trying to keep fish and give it up. And the tank winds up
on the curb and it happens 10,000 times a day. 10,000 times a day. Why? Why is it so critical
to do that? Why is it so important to make people fail?
I just think we really need, we really need to go after these guys. Those of us who understand
how to keep fish need to go after them and need to defy them and need to get up in their faces
and say, knock it off. You want to make money? Do it by keeping the fish alive.
You want to make money? Do it by selling people systems that will keep their fish alive,
not that are going to guarantee kill them. Done with it. Done with it. We don't need it anymore.
And Corey, that goes for you too. Get your head straight about what keeps fish alive because you
haven't got it. You're more concerned about how many bucks you can bring in than how many people
you can help keep their fish alive. Get straight, man. Get straight. I'm done with it. Ran over.
Never got that name before. Yeah, it is unethical where it's done like. It absolutely is.
And it needs to end. Why not Wyoming? Hello, hello. Rugal. Rugal says Discord is full of us.
The ray gave up the gravel way. Now our fish live. Tori Rohe. Absolutely right, Father Jake.
Same thing with our healthcare system. Don't make, don't get me going. Why do you think I'm
doing this? Why do you think I'm doing this? You think I'm doing this because I don't care
about anything but fish? You have been paying attention. Oh my. What we do with our fish
is what we do with the rest of the world. It is the model. This is the model. I'm trying to get
out of it to get into some other area of the hobby. And the closest I can get at this point is
biodiversity. So that's my next step. I can't get out of it because I can't make any headway
with the hard heads in the fish fam on YouTube who don't want to look at or think about putting
dirt in their tank. You know, and some of these guys have been around for 20 years
and they know what they're doing and they've got spectacular systems and they call them natural
tanks and it's a quarter of an inch of gravel. That is not a natural tank. I'm sorry. It ain't.
It's not a natural tank. It's a synthetic tank. There's nothing natural about it.
Build a natural tank. Then you can talk about having natural tanks. My God, what's wrong with
you? I don't want to know. I don't want to know. I don't want to know. I don't want to know. No,
don't tell me. I don't want to know. That's what it is. I don't want to know. Right, exactly.
You don't want to know and say you're stupid and you're going to stay stupid
because you don't want to know. Oy vey. I don't want to start naming names again.
I did that once and I'm sorry I did it. I'm not going to do it again. My apologies to Cory.
Why am I so irascible today? I thought I was feeling good. I think this is me feeling good.
Well, I hope you found something you've never seen before.
Have a great day. Thanks for sharing with us. Come on back.