Why do we include dirt in our substrate? How long does dirt provide nutrients to our plants? What is the role of leaves in the substrate? What can PROJECT PIABA teach us about the importance of creating a true natural tank? These and other questions are answered by Father Fish in this important video.
24/7 live on Discord: This is a wonderful way to meet and make new fishy friends as well as get the help you need. Join us at Father Fish Server on DISCORD - https://discord.gg/8DmmRE9Nq4
Father Fish explains the mechanics of dirted aquarium substrates and the importance of creating a natural bio-food web. He addresses common misconceptions about nutrient leaching and anaerobic layers, while highlighting how leaf litter and microfauna sustain a self-sufficient ecosystem, drawing parallels between home aquariums and the natural environments seen in Project Piaba.
I just received a big long message from James Handy over on Discord,
and he has asked some very deep and very serious questions. I also simultaneously received a video
from Brad about Project Piaba, P-I-A-B-A, however you say that, Piaba, I guess.
And it's all about the leaves in your tank. So I wanted to try to combine these two because
they're linked together. Let's start with James and what he has to say. He says,
Father Fish, maybe I've lost my mind. I'm not sure, but I've been thinking about the deep
dirt and substrate. All right, first two inches of sand has aerobic conditions because oxygenated
water can pass through. We know that's good for beneficial bacteria and plant roots.
Bottom one inch layer of dirt has no water movement, which creates anaerobic conditions.
When first set up is full of nutrients, which are good for our plants. Since there's no water
movement in the dirt layer, I assume the nutrients reach the plant roots due to a leaching effect.
Is that so? Well, not exactly, James. While there is some leaching, there's also quite a lot of
biological and chemical activity going on. Let's talk first about the chemical activity.
When we set up the dirted system, if we're using the Father Fish method, we've included a number
of products in that dirt that react with each other short term in a process called chelation.
Iron oxide is one such item, element. Over a short period of time, a matter of a few months,
these chemicals react with each other until they finally stabilize and the whole thing smooths
itself out. There are two things that are important here. Number one is that that dirt layer not be
more than one inch deep. If it is deeper than that, it's going to create so much chemical activity
that it could blow up the tank. I don't mean blow up in the sense of a bomb, I mean in the sense of
fouling the tank. So the two inches of sand is able to contain that immediate initial process,
allow it to continue, allow it to go on, allow it to complete itself.
And then there are animals and bacteria that go down into that anaerobic layer.
They're actually micro fauna that will dive into that feed, come back up to breathe, dive back down.
So they're two inches down in the sand and they're feeding in that. And as they do that,
they're working it up. If you look on the side of your tank, I don't know if I have a good example
here. I don't think I have a good example. Well, maybe here. See this? See the levels?
Now that's dirt that has been moved up into the sand. It's not actually risen up on its own.
It's not leached up. It's been drawn up by the roots of plants and by the biological activity
in the tank. So it begins to, in effect, merge. Okay. There's that much. He goes on.
We know that after approximately a year, the dirt is depleted of plant nutrients.
So we must add nutrients back to the layer. All right. Let me stop there because the whole purpose
of the supplements in the dirt is to continue that process for more than a year. The iron oxide
takes upwards of a year to become accessible to the plants as an iron supplement. The same with
other elements that are in there. They have to break down. They chelate. They take time.
Some of them a long time before they really become accessible and available as nutrients.
So this soil is lasting more than a year. In addition to which, the deep detritus that sits
down into the sand that gets into that dirt becomes nutrients as well. So that enriches
the soil, increasing its longevity. I have tanks. I have one tank here that's 20 years old.
This tank is 20 years old. There was a period of time where I was pulling so many plants out
that I depleted the nutritional level. I added more plants, some more fish,
and it has replenished itself to the point where it's now supporting more life. I have not
needed to add anything to that soil to bring it back. So we're going to jump down a little.
He says we know that plant roots create anaerobic conditions. So why is it important to get the
nutrients back down to the dirt? I would think they would start absorbing nutrients from the
sand layer if they're there. And the other issue is we don't want that dirt coming in contact with
the water because it will dramatically increase the organic, soluble organics in the water and
create huge algae blooms. Okay, so he says where are non-rooting feeding plants getting their
nutrients? Well, there is a certain amount of nutrition that is created by the fish,
by the fish that are in the tank. That's why you need to put fish in this tank right away
because the nutrients the fish are creating, the ammonia, the nitrates, the phosphates,
everything else provide nutrition for floating or for non-rooted plants like Anubias and Java Fern.
So he says why is it possible to have success with just a two to three inch sand only substrate?
Because in time the detritus that sifts down into that sand forms that dirt layer. It forms that
volume of anaerobic activity and anaerobic material that's able to process the waste
and into such a form as it'll be made available to the roots of plants.
So, I hope that answers. Let me see if there's anything else.
Yeah, I think that's pretty well it. The roots are able to take nutrition out of the sand layer,
but they can't do it if there's no nutrition there. So that's why we put the nutrition at
the bottom. Okay, so I want to jump over now to Project Pia because this demonstrates exactly
how these systems work in nature. This is leaf litter for leaf litter lovers. Now,
look at the leaf litter on here and just think about how this is not just laying there. It is
deteriorating. It's deteriorating by virtue of the mycelium, that is to say the fungus
and the bacteria that are breaking it down and precipitating it more deeply into the bottom.
So, what you wind up with here is a very deep layer of muck, of mold, of mud,
of dirt, of soil underneath all of this litter, much of which is filtered through sand
before it gets down into there. So, in many cases, there's a sand layer. This is Project Pia.
It would be good if you would sign up at Project Pia, P-I-A-B-A. Subscribe to this, please. There
are a number of videos on here that are well worth watching and join Project Pia. It is a
remarkable project. If you will go to their home channel, you'll find a video here that
explains in detail what PIAB is all about. This is a remarkable project and one that we all need
to be supportive of. So, again, I want to go back to the leaf litter. Let me see if I can get back
to it and remind you that it is what we put in our tanks that provides the nutrition for our fish.
And that's exactly what this is doing. These leaves are providing support for microfauna.
Microfauna is the food that all these little tiny fish eat. That's why they're there. And
their babies are able to find food as well. So, they breed in it. They go down in it.
They live in it. Their babies grow in it. There we go. And it's able to provide a food base,
a food web for the animal life, for the fish in there. This is what you can do in your aquarium.
You can build exactly this. It may look just as nasty as that. If you look at some of
Paul Paulson's aquariums over on Discord, you'll see a tank that looks pretty much just like that.
There are other people on Discord that have tanks that are a little prettier with a lot
more plants in them, but they have the same kind of leaf litter base. What this does is provide
the nutrition for the tank so that you do not need to be putting food in the tank. In fact,
by putting food in the tank, you're really overloading the biological system. It supports
itself. And this is what we're about. We want to teach people how to create their own
bio food web and have a genuine, payaba, actually, really, truly natural aquarium. So,
hang in there with us. Work with us. Get over to Discord. Learn from us. Participate in the
learning because we're all doing this together. We're kind of growing up in this together. Some
have been doing it for a very long time. Most of us have not. So, it's new and it's something we all
can share in and build and can create a whole new sense of what our aquarium is really all about.
Thanks for tuning in. Thanks for being part of this channel. We depend very much on your support
in order to be able to continue making videos and finding ways to reach out to a broader
range of people. We want to be able to reach the entire fish community with this message,
with this story, because it's so important to understand how you can have a genuinely
natural aquarium. Be sure to sign up. Be sure to click on that bell too so that you can get all
of the videos as they come out. Bye for now. See you around. I'm here all the time. Just plug in.
Bye for now.