Government error leads to auction of mother's unit containing son's ashes

Fox - 5 NY
46 followers
Oct 8, 2026
But first, a Fox 5 exclusive, a Brooklyn woman says she lost almost everything she owns in a
storage auction, including her son's ashes. Welcome back to the 5 o'clock news. I'm Natasha
Verma. The city had been helping a woman pay for her storage unit and says an error on their part
led to this mistake. Fox says Kelly Kennedy is here. And Kelly, this case is now inspiring a
push for change. Yeah, that's right, Natasha. And the timing here really is critical. Records show
that this woman asked the city for help just eight days before her storage unit was auctioned
off. And she was still waiting for a decision from that city agency when everything inside
was sold. And sadly, that included her son's ashes. It meant that he wasn't fully gone and
that I had some connection with him. For 27 years, Nina Davila kept her stillborn son Siobhan close
to her heart, storing his ashes in a marble urn. The main purpose of having his ashes was I was
going to be cremated with him and hopefully be in the ocean. And I lost that opportunity now.
In May of 2024, public storage auctioned off that urn and nearly everything else Davila owned at
their facility in the Bronx. Childhood pictures, pictures of pets, family members, childhood
blankets, his blankets. Davila was experiencing housing instability, relying on funds by the
Human Resources Administration to pay her bill. City records show Davila requested emergency
storage assistance May 15th. Eight days later, public storage auctioned her unit. A week after
that, HRA denied her claim, a decision the Department of Social Services now admits was a
mistake. I was like, this is not happening. This is kind of a gene state of panic. And I was crying
hysterically. The city tells Fox 5, quote, an administrative error resulted in an incorrect
denial of Miss Davila's application for storage fee assistance. We regret this mistake and extend
our deepest apologies to Miss Davila for this error and the deeply unfortunate set of circumstances.
You know, part of me just wants to scream and curse everyone out that made these mistakes and
didn't do their job properly. Davila discovered her stuff was gone after calling public storage
the day after the sale. She is now suing, alleging the company failed to provide notice before the
auction. A source familiar with the case claims public storage made repeated attempts to reach
her by phone, mail and email. However, when Fox 5 asked for documentation of those attempts,
none was provided. Shortly after the auction, Davila was diagnosed with functional neurological
disorder, a stress-induced condition causing seizures, muscle spasms and tremors. Her tragedy
exposes a legal loophole. Storage facilities can legally sell off belongings while city assistance
decisions are still pending. Proposed legislation named after Davila's son could change that.
Shavanza will not only temporarily pause auctions if there is a pending storage fee assistance
application in process with HRA, but it also requires the storage facilities to notify HRA
when an auction has been scheduled. DSS says it can issue emergency checks to stop imminent
auctions, but says it received no warning here. By the time Davila got a lawyer and tracked down
the buyer, two months had passed. Her pet's ashes were returned, but she says she was told
her son's ashes had been thrown away. I was just bawling my eyes out because it was so,
I got something back and it was one of the things that were important to me. Davila says now she's
hoping this law will pass. What would that mean to you? It's not to deal with the pain, but it
would validate the situation and say at least this won't happen to another parent. Now Shavanza
passed the Senate Judiciary Committee this year, but it did not pass the full legislature.
Supporters tell me they plan to reintroduce this in January. Natasha? Yeah, such a powerful story,
Kelly. We'll have stamped it on that. Thanks so much.
