NO, THE TIGER DOES NOT SUCK

Heritage Horizons
23 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 7, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Tiger Tank. Specifically here, the Tiger I. We're not talking about the Tiger II today.
It is the most famous tank from the Second World War. It genuinely just is. Yes, I know the Sherman
is important. I get the T-34 is incredible when it comes to visualizing tanks in the Second World
War. But let's all be real, it's the Tiger. And media has really helped with that. It's not really
a point that can even be argued. When you think of World War II German tank, you think of Tiger.
It's why at the end of Saving Private Ryan, they fought a Tiger and not a StuG III. In many ways,
it's the Mark Felton of tanks. The first one we all subscribe to. And then provided you don't
have the mental fortitude of a toddler, the first one you abandon when you start to grow up and
mature and touch grass and speak to women. For some people though, specifically the Werriboo,
they then move on to the Panther or if they are truly enlightened, the Panzer IV or the StuG.
I know the StuG is not a tank, go away. But what about the Tiger? Just because you move on,
does that mean it's actually overrated and kind of crappy and really bad? It's quite fashionable
to say so these days and many people commonly believe it now. But, and here's the big but,
I say no. Here is a crucial thing when I say that though, and it's an important caveat to maintain.
That doesn't make it God. Oh, and I keep forgetting to say this at the start, but apparently it makes
difference. So like, comment, subscribe and hype the video. Now, to be completely honest,
I am not going to go too far into the development of the Tiger tank here because it's been done to
death by people who know more than I do about these big metal box things called tanks. Like
my friends over at the Totally Tanked podcast who can drink more beer at one rugby game than an
entire Panzer division. Simply though, the Tiger began development in the late 1930s but accelerated
after Germany encountered Soviet T-34 and KV-1 tanks during Operation Barbarossa.
These Soviet tanks could and would beat back the Panzer IIIs and early IVs when able to face them
in decent numbers and in prepared positions. However, in those early stages of Barbarossa,
most of the tanks on the Eastern Front were the BTs and earlier models anyway. So needing a bigger
tank was a problem, yes, but not a horrific one. Not yet at least. But anyway, that brings us to
a big point. The majority of tanks destroyed in war aren't destroyed by tanks. This is a simple
fact. Most tanks in war are destroyed by something that people commonly forget about called infantry,
artillery and anti-tank weapons. Tank duels are quite often the exception rather than the rule.
And the same goes with ships. Quite often, Battleship A from a country A is built to
fight Battleship A from country B. Case in point, the Bayern class and the Queen Elizabeth class.
But the odds of them actually fighting is in many cases next to impossible. And even if they do,
it will never be even. We will come back to this later when I bring up the hordes of Shermans and
T-34s. But that kind of gives you an idea into the mentality of the design of Tiger. You either have
to make it mass-producible, like the Sherman and the T-34, and your industry has to match to keep
it up, or you have to make it better. In ship terms, you either make the hood or you make a
lot more smaller battlecruisers. You have to pick one of the two. But back to the Tiger though.
Two major German companies, Henschel and Porsche, competed to design a heavy tank and ultimately
Henschel's design was selected and the other one, well, less said the better. The result though was
the Panzerkampfwagen 6 Aus A. We simply call it today though the, well, Tiger I. The Tiger I was
simply put a heavy tank. It clocked it at approximately 57 tons and it lugged around an
derived from the 8.8 centimeter Flak 36. This gun gave the Tiger exceptionally good long-range
killing power, allowing it to fight at extreme ranges for the time. However, and again, this
should be contextualized with the fact that the maximum firing ranges and effective combat range,
well, they're two incredibly different things. An effective combat range of a Tiger is well within
Allied fire, and very much given the war's trajectory, within range of air power. Particularly
this angry looking thing called a Typhoon. This is before we even consider geography. You are
never getting a fair fight in a war, so you can make your tank better in every single way,
but you still have to consider the realities on the ground. The tank's armor was up to 100
millimeters thick and this provided ample defense against standard anti-tank weapons of the day.
But unlike how a lot of old documentaries claim, the tank was not invulnerable to Allied tanks.
Sure, she could plink off Stuarts all day, but the Shermans could knock the Tiger out if they
were close, or even if they were in effective combat range. Or if they were such tanks as,
for example, the Firefly, they could with relative ease penetrate the vehicle. There is also the fact
that you don't need to penetrate a vehicle to kill it. After all, mission killing is a very real
thing, and infantry could, if given the chance, overwhelm the vehicle, especially when you consider
the fact that the Tiger had fragile electrics. A common way to kill tanks as well is to simply
blind them, or just wallop them until their crew is in a state where they can't fight back.
A great example is the footage we have all seen of that Bradley lining up the T-90 in Ukraine,
right? In no way was that Bradley ever going to penetrate it, but it sure as hell did a number
on the crew, and because it did that, and because it knocked out the crew's ability to see and to
fight, it mission killed the T-90, which means it beat the T-90. Internally as well, the Tiger was
quite complex. It featured an advanced suspension system with interleaved road wheels, and the
Tiger's engine, a Maybach HL 230, produced around 700 horsepower, and occasionally would have a
panic attack and just break. The soft factors were brilliant though, and the inside was comfortable
for the crews. There was a big wheel to drive it, there was space, I can fit in the thing,
things are organized, labels existed. It's very German, I mean exceedingly German, like
violently German. Everything had a place, and it worked well. But, and here is the big but, there
are quite a few negatives that we need to consider. To start with, it was horrifically expensive, and
I mean horrifically, and Germany was in a really bad position to fund and build a horrifically
expensive tank, let alone more than one looking at you Panther. However, and this is something I
brought up with the Chieftain when I hung out with him at AusArmorFest, I asked him what he would
consider a better choice for Germany, and he brought up a point that I have argued quite a
bit as well, that even if they had made the decision to just build more Panzer IVs and to
build more StuGs, where are they getting the crew? At this time, the cream of the crop German tank
crews, they're dead. They're quite often dead, and they quite often died well before a lot of these big
cats started to really enter service. So, Germany is in a rock and a hard place here. Yes, sure, it can
make more Panzer IVs, it can make more StuGs, but who's going to crew them? So, they either make the
big tanks, and the really fancy tanks, and the ones that are really expensive to make, like the Tiger,
and they crew them, or they have no one to crew the others. But anyway, back to the Tiger. We have to
consider as well that the big 88mm gun, while effective and it could smack things like a truck,
sure, it did also suffer from a really high maintenance schedule. It had a slow turret
traverse due to its sheer size, and again, Germany was cooked at the time. So again, it struggled to
support that heavy maintenance schedule. There was a lack of defense at closer ranges too, just to how
big and slow the tank was, to get that gun moving. And while this isn't a problem on the steppe, where
you know, big flat open plain, and you can see your enemy approaching, but say in an urban setting in
West Germany against a horde of Shermans, or in the Bocage in France, well, it's less than ideal.
The oil tanks also leaked. Cold starting the tank would send the transmission into a tizzy at random,
sometimes just destroying it. And then we get to the overlapping wheels, which on the eastern front,
in particular, were a colossal maintenance nightmare. Mud would gather between the wheels
during the colder months, and it would freeze. Now, while removing ice is pretty simple, getting mud
out of wheels isn't the straightforward approach of simply set the ice on fire. Rather, it took
several hours of boiling water, and using big sticks to get the mud out, and oh look, the horde
of rattling Soviet armor is approaching the location really rapidly. So yeah, there are some
key problems here, particularly when you consider the fact that the mud season in the east is not
once a year, no, no, no, it's twice a year. It's before winter and after winter. And look, there are
many other problems, and some other key issues I could pick at, and pull strings on for a while,
and rip into how it was overrated, but the reality was it's only overrated because Allied and German
propaganda made it overrated. Now, according to propaganda, the Tiger tank was the dominant and
super-powered force on the battlefield. These sources, if you want to call them that, were
always based on a combination of firepower and protection. Allied tanks simply couldn't fight it.
It took five Shermans, for example, to destroy one. You've heard that all before. Now, this is partially
true, as is all good propaganda. To get the best propaganda, you have to put nuggets of truth in
it to obfuscate reality. See, in engagements where it could operate and fire at long range with
support, the Tiger was absolutely devastating. But here again is the but. Shermans operated together
in squad sizes of around five, which means that every Tiger that was killed by a Sherman generally
had to face a squad of five. So, yeah, where do you think that rumor came from? And then there is the
fact that it never really got to fight in the open at range in the West. So, again, sure, theoretically,
it's amazing, but war is not a spreadsheet of stats. It's rapid and changing. One of the most famous
deployments of the Tiger occurred, though, during the Battle of Kursk, which is one of the largest
tank battles in history. Although German forces ultimately failed to achieve a decisive victory
here, Tigers were able to inflict significant losses on Soviet Unions, and this is one of their
few chances to actually fight at range on the steppe, and their ability to knock out enemy
tanks at distances exceeding 1500 meters gave German crews a very, very significant tactical
advantage. But again, there were issues with numbers, breakdowns, and a lack of logistics to
support the tank in ways that would have made it actually change the outcome. Reminder again, from
the start of the video, when I said that in actual war, tanks don't just fight tanks. Other factors
came into play here, and genuinely, the Tiger performed well, but make no mistake, it was no god
of the battlefield. The Tiger did also see some service in North Africa, where it was used by units
under Rommel. You know, that guy that was totally whitewashed by history to convince Western
populations that the Germans weren't really in support of Hitler, and that they now were allies?
Yeah, that guy. The guy who definitely did not ever commit war crimes, never ever, we swear.
Yeah, him. In the open desert though, the Tiger's long-range gun was particularly effective, and it
worked well. Until the sand and dirt got into it, and then the fuel trucks ran out, and well, are you
beginning to notice a pattern here? I briefly mentioned the propaganda before, and it's also
kind of sad that it's become the legacy of the tank, given that it probably was the tank's most
significant contribution. Allied soldiers often feared encountering Tigers, overestimating their
numbers and capabilities. Reports of Tigers could cause hesitation or even panic amongst inexperienced
troops, even though by Normandy, dealing with a Tiger wasn't even remotely impossible for the Allied
forces. This psychological impact was amplified further by German propaganda, and leadership
rivalries within the Allied camps played it up, and portrayed that the Tiger was an unstoppable weapon.
This led to random tanks just getting called Tigers, and all sorts of issues. The Germans
loved it, and they peddled out rewards to Tiger commanders, labeling them heroes on the level of
fighter aces. There is some nuance to that. If you were in the ESS, for example, you would be lavishly
praised and given everything you wanted. But, if you're in the normal army, and not a red-hot flaming
Nazi, then you didn't matter as much. Just have a look at Michael Whitman if you need some evidence
of that. To this day, to this day, his grave is one of the most visited graves in Normandy, and he
was nothing more than a massive flaming Nazi, and mouthpiece of propaganda for the party. It is a
sad reality that that is true. But, fun fact, at no point in World War II did the German government or
That is a completely made-up post-war thing, largely by Western media. Despite its effectiveness,
though, the Tiger tank did suffer from a critical drawback. It was extremely expensive and time-consuming
to produce. Approximately 1,347 Tiger I tanks were built between 1942 and 1944, and this is an
extremely small number compared to the tens of thousands of Shermans and T-34s produced by the
Germany's industrial capacity, strained by the demands of total war and Allied bombing campaigns,
and, you know, entirely held up by literal slave labor, could not sustain large-scale Tiger
production. Hell, at a pinch, it couldn't even sustain large-scale tank production in general.
When taken alone, the Tiger tank required significant resources, skilled labor, and a lot
of maintenance support, because reliability was a major issue. Breakdowns were common, and recovering
a disabled Tiger was difficult due to its weight and the fact that the Allies were advancing,
meaning that tanks would be knocked out and then the Allies would be able to advance ahead of the
position and seize them. This meant that Tigers would be burned out by their own crews quite often
or by the Allies if they couldn't hold an area where one had been knocked out to prevent its
recapture and reintroduction into service by Germans. Fuel consumption further limited the
Tiger's operational effectiveness, too, and as Germany faced increasing fuel shortages later in
the war, deploying and sustaining heavy tanks became increasingly difficult, let alone the required
vehicles to support these heavy tanks. And in short, while the tank was pretty good, it was a resource sink,
like all major military equipment, and a dying country could not support it. But then again, it
couldn't really support any other tanks, either, because it simply didn't have the manpower, because
much of its Tiger crews and much of its Panzer crews, the cream of the crop of the Panzer crews,
were dead. When actually deployed, though, the Tiger was most effective when used in
concentrated units known as Schwerpanzerbataillons. In English, this largely translates to heavy tank
battalions. These units were often deployed to critical sectors of the front or on-counter
offensive operations like a Kursk. But as the war progressed and Germany was forced to defend, the
Tiger became far more effective as a defensive weapon. Now, I know the movie is flaming hot
garbage, but think of that scene in Fury, you know, where the Tiger was hiding and then fired, and then
due to plot armor, the crew didn't aim at the tank that could kill them. Then they tried to charge it
randomly, because Hollywood, even though the Tiger could have just stayed in its position and kept
plinking off Shermans without the Shermans ever really seeing where it was. I have issues with
that movie, yes. But that scene, before all the silly stuff happens, a Tiger could hold down a
support. And while, yes, an anti-tank gun could also do that as well, an anti-tank gun can't
generally just drive into that position and then take the shots back that a Tiger could. So, while
it is hard to quantify just how much it was worth it, it is hard to deny just how effective the
Tiger could be at holding a position, provided, you know, the horde of Allied air power didn't show up.
But hang on, isn't this supposed to be a defense of the Tiger? And yes, yes, I know this video is
called Defense of the Tiger, and I have just kind of spent 10 or so minutes ragging on it for being
useless, but this is all within the context of Germany during the Second World War, when the
Tiger tank was introduced. But if we just look at the vehicle for being a vehicle, it isn't bad at
all here. Right here is where I'm going to upset everyone, because the T-34 is in the exact same
boat. What Germany and the USSR actually produced, versus what it was supposed to produce, are two
completely different things. A well-made, well-maintained Tiger is a brilliant tank. It is.
It is a genuinely brilliant tank, just like a well-made, no-corners-cut T-34 is. History, though,
is reality. And it is here that the Tiger loses out, and is held together only by its propaganda
from both the Second World War and Cold War. Compared to its contemporaries, the Tiger does
stand out for firepower and armor, but it lacks mobility. It lacks ease of production. And Germany,
Germany was on fire. Its factories were exploding. The slave labor, shockingly, wasn't putting things
together with quality in mind. And on the other side, the Allies had the ability to field large
numbers of tanks of similar designs, such as the mass-produced Shermans. A hundred tanks will always
beat one tank. And no, do not say quantity has a quality all of its own. I am not saying that at all,
because one great, fantastic tank will still beat a hundred bob samples. There is a limit to that
phrase. You build things well enough, you build things fast enough, and you build things with ease
of maintenance in mind. And sure enough, it is going to win at the end of the day. So no, as
good as the Tiger is, it could not do everything by itself. But that doesn't mean it was bad. Just
because the thing can't fight a modern Abrams doesn't mean you should look at it and go,
ha ha, terrible tank, awful. But at the same time, just consider the context in which it was made.
It's a cool vehicle, yes, but consider the hands that helped put it together. And just to harp on
that, while I was up at AusArmorFest, I recruited a man who knows about as much about tanks as I do,
aka another boat person. You may recognize him, actually. I'm not going to say who it is, but you
may recognize him. He's a good friend of all of us, so I'll just put it that way. And we talked
about why the Octopus of Judgment is not a huge fan of the Tiger. Hi, I am a slightly sun-kissed
history of everything, and I'm standing in front of the... It's a half-track. We all know what the
And while initially you may think Beatrice would be happy, this is probably one of the most
disturbing, yet most important things in this entire museum. And it has left Beatrice absolutely
fuming. The SDK series of half-tracks were very important to the German war effort. Towards the
latter part of the war, the German military machine is doing everything it can to put
anti-aircraft weaponry in the field with the guys, because allied air support, close air support is
doing bad damage. On the back of this one, we've got a detachable Flak 38 2cm gun. What's really
interesting about this weapon is that it's stamped with the Gustloff-Welke manufacturer's plate.
Gustloff-Welke was a Nazi labor initiative that was basically founded based on the liquidated
assets of Jewish families that had been persecuted and removed by the Reich, and their valuables had
been sold. And it went into funding the factories that were set up by this organization. It was
named after the murdered Swiss Nazi party leader Wilhelm Gustloff. And Gustloff-Welke manufactured
things from the Gewehr 43 soft-loading rifle to 2cm guns like this. They had satellite camps
like Buchenwald concentration camp. And so it's really a subtle reminder of the realities of
Reich armaments procurement manufacturing that, you know, at this stage of the war, the cheap
source of labor, the easiest source of labor, is captured persons and supposed undesirables
of the Reich. And here we have a tangible reminder of this rather horrific bit of
Second World War history. I think it's important to point out, and we both agree here, that
the big cats are cool. The German equipment is cool. It looks great. It looks fantastic.
But just don't forget the cost of why it looks this way, and where it all came from.
Later in the war, Germany would introduce the Tiger II, also known as the Königstiger.
While even more powerful, it did suffer as well from many of the same issues as the Tiger I,
and it was compounded further by a greater weight and complexity. Maybe one day I will do a video on
it sometime, but in the meantime, there is a whole point to this video beyond the Tiger that
I think is worth highlighting, and that your favorite tank, your best tank, does not have
to be the best quite simply because there is no such thing as the best tank. The Tiger tank,
for example, you might like it because it's cool and it works great on the eastern steppe,
but transplant it to the pacific and it's going to quite literally sink in the mud,
or the engine will just detonate you to the salt water. Meanwhile, the little M1 Stuart will run
around the thing and bully the crap out of everyone. On the other hand, put a Stuart at
Kursk and make it fight a Tiger, and yeah, the crew will become a thin veneer on the muddy steppe.
It's kind of a similar concept to the modern Abrams tank, and I highlighted this in my
Armour Week video. The Abrams is a phenomenal vehicle. It is a great weapon of war. I say
great as in its level of power, not that war is great, of course. But you transplant it away from
the army it was built to fight with, and the army built to fight around it, and you see just how
quickly it suffers. The Tiger tank follows a similar process. It was a good tank. It wasn't
the best, but it was kind of crap for those who built it. It was never going to win the war. It
was never going to stop the allies, you know, provided you consider reality. But that doesn't
make it bad at all, and I think it's worth praising the fact that this is a phenomenal vehicle put
together by scientists and engineers in a very difficult situation. But never forget, never forget
the hands that helped build the weapons of the Third Reich. Thank you all for watching. Like,
comment, subscribe, and thank you to Mike for the brief cameo in this video. You will see more of
him probably in our AusArmour content, but that's going to most likely go on Rex's channel, so keep
an eye there.
