Why I No Longer Make Compost In Autumn (And What I Do Instead)

My Green Garden
1 follower
3 Video Views·Oct 7, 2026
This video explains why compost making is no longer something I do in autumn, at least not in the way you might be thinking. Find out more here: https://huwrichards.mysamcart.com/hea
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedInstead of relying solely on compost bins, the speaker advocates for the \"chop and drop\" method this autumn. By leaving plant biomass directly on garden beds, gardeners can mimic nature, enhance soil biodiversity, and reduce labor. Compost should be treated as a precision tool for high-demand plants rather than a universal blanket solution for all garden beds.
This autumn try not to put anything in your compost bins and let me explain why because
there's a better place to put all of that stuff. So this here behind me is my kitchen garden and
it's getting to the stage where it's producing an absolute abundance of biomass which is always
great because in so many years I would put that biomass on the compost bins to then break down
and then I'll put that compost out probably the next year as a nice layer over my beds but that
has changed now because that isn't how nature builds healthy soil. Nature builds healthy soil
with all of this material so like these beans and stuff just falling on the ground and breaking down
in place. So what I would say is instead of putting down any compost on your beds in autumn
use all of that material all of this amazing biomass that we have growing look at that
comfrey behind me chop it down chop it up because that's going to make it break down faster and just
put it on your beds because what happens is when you when you put it on your beds it's returning
a lot of the nutrients from the very beds kind of it grew from so that's one kind of key benefit.
The other benefit is there's actually a lot of effort of moving material from your raised bed
to your compost and then maybe turning your compost and then bringing that material back out.
Now I'm not telling you to stop composting compost is still great but I think we have a little bit
as a lot of gardeners we have or gardening as a whole a bit of an unhealthy relationship with
compost we see it as a be-all and end-all the one ingredient to make everything possible but it isn't.
The one ingredient to make everything possible is plant matter. Now this plant matter material
can turn into compost that we can then bring out and use but I think we forget that we can
put plant matter down on our beds it'll then break down and this will compost in place and
provide a huge amount of nutrients but what it's also doing is like in nature like a forest in
autumn all of the leaves falling down is this is bringing so much life to your garden beds
like it's it's almost instantaneous as soon as you put you chop down all the material you put
it down on your beds in autumn to leave over winter it creates a really effective insulative
layer that raises the temperature a bit of the soil keep it a bit more ambient and the amount
of earthworms and beetles and things that move in it is it's an incredible sight but if you took all
of this plant material and placed it all in your compost bin and just put compost over your beds
you're not going to really have much of that soil life at all because most of that is pretty much
broken down so yes you're going to help the bacteria and the fungi but a healthy soil is not
just made out of bacteria and fungi in the same way as you look at any kind of food chain if you
look in an ocean yes you've got algae and plankton but you've also got whales so that's what i'm
talking about when it comes to your soil your garden all of this material this material can
work hard for you to make it really healthy and active and and pull a lot of that material down
into the ground into the soil because if you're just laying over like normal say compost no dig
you're just adding compost in layers there is no like kind of major material bits to incentivize
earthworms to pull to to eat like leaf matter and stuff and pull it down deeper into the ground
which then creates more organic matter deeper in the soil that holds on to more moisture you don't
you don't get a lot of things and also compost is so precious why would you put the most precious
resource with like bacteria and fungi exposed on the surface during the coldest darkest wettest
time of the year at least for us probably four or five months worth of my most precious resource to
that to me is madness and i am a little frustrated that i it took me a while to realize that but then
as soon as i realized that and i've changed now this whole garden this autumn i'm not putting
down any compost unless if i do want to put down a bit of compost i'm still going to mulch on top
of it with grass clippings with plant debris all of this kind of stuff to protect it because it
is precious now if you are interested in how i am using the compost i usually use it as a precision
tool now so if i've got something kind of hungry i'll put a little handful of compost at the base
of the sowing or transplanting hole and that's that but for the most part in this garden i'm
gonna just be bringing in what is waste material for so many people waste material and local
resources that would otherwise be gone or on a compost bin so grass clippings and leaves
another plant matter even you know stuff from kitchens all of those kind of stuff
all of these beds are going to be chopped and dropped and then topped up to make sure that i
have maybe like two to three inches five to seven centimeters of of mulch and that is it that is the
recipe for creating these healthy beds i've been doing this for about three years now with a lot
of my beds and this is the year that i'm moving into the entirety of the garden doing it this way
because i have realized it has made me far less stressed as a gardener it's brought so much more
life back to my soil visible life rather than just hoping that there's life my plants are happier
where i have also done it is shown to make more resilient beds during the drought so it's an
no-brainer for me and if you were getting into either getting into gardening or you're trying to
look at how to use nature and all of this plant material and to mulch in a way to create healthy
soil by spring i do have a online course there's seven lessons there's a load of supplemental pdfs
that leads you step by step to give you the confidence and all of the reasons plus a bit
troubleshooting like what do you do about slugs that is linked down below it's only 19 pounds or
27 and it is just designed to give you the confidence to benefit from using plant material
to help you grow a healthy productive garden and to not be so reliant on compost so the compost that
you do have and you do make during the rest of the season can be used where it's going to be most
impactful we should stop seeing compost as like a blanket solution and instead see compost as a
precision tool for us gardeners to use to help where it matters like if we're growing our tomatoes
and things like that but for most of the plants that we grow particularly the things like our
legumes our leafy greens things like that they don't need that amount of fertility and the amount
of fertility that you put in from a nice mulch like that that has also been incorporated into
deeper layers within the soil you're going to get less nutrient leaching as well all of these
different things that is going to provide a very healthy baseline of the fertility that about 80%
of your garden needs you see these two beds i'll just finish off here and say these two beds behind
me i've got some nice zinnias this is a secondary crop i've got kale i've got more kale behind me
there these haven't had compost now for over two years in fact for these beds i haven't even added
a handful of compost at the base of the transplanting holes these are just off using the
the fertility from the mulch of all of these natural materials so it works very well and you
can see how vibrant these plants are even after such a dry start to the year so yeah check out
the course i think you're going to find it super useful and it is it is a very freeing
thing to break off that dependence from compost and i will see you again soon
