The Center Square YT: Supreme Court Mail-In Voting Ruling & Election Integrity

VideoNest - Topical News
2 followers
1 Video View·Oct 6, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedRepresentatives from the organization Keep Our Republic discuss the legal and operational aspects of mail-in voting in the U.S. They address Supreme Court rulings on the Postal Service, the security measures employed by local clerks to ensure election integrity, and the benefits of a decentralized election system in preventing systemic hacking.
Joining us now from the organization Keep Our Republic
is Cameron Hoadley and Ari Middleman.
Thanks for taking time with us here on The States.
Thank you.
Thank you for the opportunity, Greg.
Absolutely.
So we've got the U.S. Supreme Court
reopening their new term,
pretty consequential case coming up
that they're hearing this morning as you and I are talking.
But let's talk about some previous Supreme Court stuff
impacting the elections.
And what exactly did the Supreme Court rule
about the Postal Service's role in the elections?
Well, as we know, Greg,
about a third of votes that were cast
in the 2024 presidential election were cast by mail.
This was done by Republicans, by independents,
such as myself, by Democrats.
It was done in many states across the union.
So I know there's been a lot of interest in these themes.
This specifically originated out of
what's known as the elections clause in the Constitution.
Just to take a step back for your audience,
there's Article I, which deals with the legislature,
and Section IV of Article I of the Constitution,
not to get super dry,
talks about the time, place, and manner.
And it gives that running of elections,
the place, the manner in which we run elections,
the power to the states.
So this Supreme Court decision,
which ultimately originated up in Boston or Massachusetts,
really was a fundamental question of authority,
and what authority has Congress, given the president,
given the Postal Service
as an executive branch independent agency,
really dealt with the kind of balance of power
that we have of three independent branches,
and then also real questions of federalism.
So you have the president essentially trying to,
as he says, make the elections more secure
when it comes to mail-in balloting,
had issued an executive order that spelled out,
hey, we need a certain barcode on the ballots,
and the Postal Service has to follow this protocol
to ensure only people who are eligible to get mail-in ballots
are getting them, and they're being delivered properly.
But what did the Supreme Court ultimately rule
that impacted that order?
Well, I think the important thing to know
is as we speak, Americans in North Carolina, for example,
and elsewhere in our country, ballots have gone out.
I think in the 2026 midterm elections,
which have had record spending and are quite contentious,
mail balloting is occurring.
American voters should have confidence
in that mail balloting.
I do think that there's an open door for future litigation
and questions around these themes in future elections,
but for this fall, as your audience is preparing to vote,
if it's an opportunity that's afforded to them
in their states, it's the law of those states.
So what does this mean for voters?
Is it just a kind of status quo
as it was two years ago, four years ago?
As of right now, mail-in voting is running
as it has in the past.
In Michigan, we've already had
over 2 million absentee ballots requested.
People are able to vote them as usual,
either mailing them back in Dropbox
or bringing them to their local clerk's office.
So a lot of the status quo maintaining
as to what the states already had in place
when it comes to mail-in voting.
Yes, right now, clerks are working
as they have in the past with mail-in voting.
Ari, you were gonna say something.
Well, I was just gonna say,
I mean, in Cameron's home state of Michigan in 2024,
there were upward of 2.2 million votes cast by mail,
and we know that President Trump
won the state of Michigan in 2024.
And as I said, this is in counties
that often go to Republicans,
counties that often go to Democrats.
This is increasingly being used by both political parties.
I think it's understandable, right?
I mean, if you're a political operative
and polls are only open, let's say,
in your state from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.
or 7 a.m. to 9 p.m., that's pretty high stakes.
If you can, quote-unquote, bank votes,
is what political campaigns say beforehand,
I understand that.
So it's a false narrative that only one political party
is utilizing mail voting.
Of course, the president made his executive order
saying that he wants things to be more secure
and for voter integrity to be upheld.
But what kinds of things do local officials do
to ensure that we have integrity
when it comes to mail-in voting?
There are a lot of checks and balances in place
right now with mail-in voting.
Just the act of sending them out,
those voter rolls are regularly checked.
Well, clerks are ensuring that the ballots
are going to proper addresses,
that if someone has moved, the system has been updated,
and the proper area is sending out their ballot.
Beyond that, once the voter turns their ballot in,
if they're doing it via Dropbox,
those are monitored 24-7.
There's cameras on them,
so those are incredibly safe options.
And then inside of the clerk's office,
once the ballots are back,
there are signature verifications.
There's continued outreach to voters
if their signature doesn't match for some reason
or if their ballot was returned
because it was undeliverable.
And then the actual processing of the ballots
is done by those of both parties.
They are putting the ballots through the machines,
ensuring that all of the votes are being counted,
that the signatures were verified,
and everything of that nature.
Now, of course, we have a decentralized election system
in the United States.
County-level clerks all across the country,
they follow state rules, they follow federal rules.
But how do we balance those local entities
and whether or not they're doing it properly or not
with those questions of election integrity?
How do we balance those issues?
Well, the qualified voter file that is used by clerks
across the state of Michigan,
that is able to be accessed at the local level,
so your city, township, the county level,
and the Bureau of Elections.
So it's never just one entity's eyes on the voter rolls
on who has turned in ballots.
There are continuous people looking at this information,
ensuring that those who are voting should be voting
and have only voted once.
And Greg, I think that one of the narratives
that's out there and what's contributed
to a lot of the heated rhetoric and interest, frankly,
in this discussion is,
and I'm not just gonna single out Pennsylvania,
but a very large state like that,
that's arguably a 50-50 state.
The legislature has not modernized the election code,
literally for a century.
And what that means in this particular instance,
in addition to other things like they must have lanterns
at polling precincts, but in this particular instance,
that county election offices
cannot physically open up the envelopes
until 7 a.m. on election day.
Whereas we know in other states,
they can at least open up the envelopes,
lie them flat, not peek and say,
oh, look who's ahead in the horse race on October 25th,
but just the physical act of opening.
So if you are the city of Philadelphia
and you can expect half a million voters,
and of those somewhere in the low six figures
voting by mail, that's a very serious task to do
in addition to maintaining hundreds of polling precincts
and hundreds of thousands of voters
coming to those precincts on the same exact day.
Yeah, that's definitely a tall order for elections,
officials all across the country,
and then all the volunteers that are involved as well.
But you're talking about Pennsylvania
has one set of policies,
another state may have a different set of policies.
Is there a way to try to bring about some uniformity
with these types of things?
I know for instance, in Illinois,
they've got the drop boxes,
but nobody's checking at the drop box
if the person dropping off ballots for somebody
got that person's permission
to drop the ballots off for that person.
They do have to check that
whenever it's done physically in person,
but not at that drop box.
I don't know if a video surveillance
really is that check, right?
So is there a way to bring about
some consistent rules nationwide
to again, address some of those people
who have questions about loopholes in election law
and ensuring that we have just elections?
Because one vote really can make a difference.
You know, I'm fairly conservative
and I generally believe in local government
and that our elected representatives
closest to their constituents
have the broadest perspective.
And I think that this patchwork
reading between the lines of what you're suggesting
is actually what makes us incredibly strong
as a constitutional republic,
that no two jurisdictions are running elections
the same way so that a bad actor overseas, for example,
can't just hack our election system.
Because in the case of Michigan,
that would be 83 different systems
that are slightly nuanced.
Yeah, and the same in Illinois,
104 different election offices all across the state,
that decentralization being something
that is replicated all across the country.
But should there be some kind of uniform standard?
The Save America Act was pushed in the House,
didn't advance in the Senate.
The President, he really wants this thing in place.
Is something like that necessary?
Well, I would say we do have federal legislation
that has been enacted into law for some time.
For example, voters who are blind,
there's accommodations for them
and that needs to be uniform across all 50 states.
For military and their family
who might be stationed in Korea or Germany,
there's uniform standards
about the way in which they can vote.
So that particular piece of legislation,
our nonprofit Keep Our Republic
doesn't take a position on legislation,
but it's been offered up.
It's been offered up now for some time.
We have a legislature that, yes,
has the filibuster in the Senate,
for better or worse, and that's-
We'll definitely be watching this.
Again, as you guys both note,
you've got mail-in ballots
that are being sent out all across the country.
The election is already underway,
if you think about it in those terms,
with now less than a month away
before that general midterm election.
From Keep Our Republic,
Cameron Hoadley and Ari Middleman,
thank you both for taking time with us here on The States.
