American vs. English Cream Golden Retriever: Obedience Training Comparison

Dog Training
13 followers
1 Video View·Oct 6, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome back to Bluegrass. It's a beautiful September afternoon. Today we are comparing
two types of golden retrievers. We have Poppy, a seven and a half month old American style
golden retriever. And we have Dapper, a 10 month old English cream style golden retriever.
And in this video, I just kind of want you to watch and compare and contrast. And if you have
experience with golden retrievers, feel free to get in the comment section and just tell people
what you think they ought to know about the different styles of golden retrievers. Okay,
let's go over here on the small exam table and kind of get a look for how these guys are built
differently. Come on, Poppy. Can you get up here with us? First thing you'll notice really is the
fact that they're different colors. Okay, so actually let me redo that and see if I can get
Poppy in the front and we'll get Dapper in the back. Come on, Poppy. Poppy, come on, hop up.
Get up there in the front. Okay, Dapper, you get in the back.
There we go. Stay. First thing you'll notice is that they're different colors.
The American dogs are typically actually golden and that makes sense since they're supposed to
be golden retrievers, right? Dapper's what's called an English cream, but like to me just
looks white. But I guess if you think about cream in terms of what you put in your coffee, yeah,
he's the color of cream. But some of the big things you'll notice right off the bat is like,
look at their head shape. Let's see if I can get their heads up here. Look at this. See their head
shapes? Okay. You'll notice Dapper has kind of a bigger head, a much more pronounced stop.
He's wider through the body, seems to be more bigger boned, carries more weight. Whereas Poppy
looks a little bit more rangy and that shows up in their athleticism. I would say overall,
Poppy has a little bit of an athletic advantage over Dapper, which leads us to thinking about
what it's like to own them. Okay. So if you were going to get these two dogs, personality-wise,
I would say kind of the big thing that separates them, number one, if they're just their basic
personality, Dapper is a really gregarious, outgoing dog. Think about him kind of like a
frat bro. Likes to drink beer and eat pizza and watch a game all day. Whereas, come on Poppy.
Whereas Poppy is kind of more that nerdy kid, sits in front of the class, has her hands up,
wants to always be doing stuff. And energy profile-wise, Dapper, hey, when he comes out
of the building and there's new people here, new dogs, he seems to have the most energy of any dog
in the world. He runs around, gets excited, spins in circles, wants to go meet everybody. And then
he goes and lays down. And that's kind of what it's like to have him. And so I have to make my,
I have to adjust my training style to accommodate this kind of dog. But like he's got tons of
energy, it just doesn't last very long, right? So he's pretty easy to manage, right? So he's got
high energy output, but for short periods of time, because he has low endurance and he's got a
relatively slow recharge rate. So like if I take him on a hike, he's done for the rest of the day.
He comes in and just lays over in my office in the corner or something, doesn't bother anything.
Whereas Poppy, come on Poppy. Whereas Poppy, if I take her out and go to working with her,
like she goes on the hike, she comes in, I answer some emails, then more people get here and she's
ready to go again. Like she keeps up pretty well with my field style lab and I have a British style
lab. I know, I know there's a lot of all these different like descriptor terms for the dogs, but
like that's a big difference, right? This dog here, she's going to give you a good amount of energy
all day long. And then every little rest period that she has, she's going to get up ready to
expend more energy, right? Now the good thing about this is, come on nerd. She is good at doing
stuff, right? So like if you want to train a dog to do a bunch of stuff, then Poppy's, she's pretty
good for it. She's easy to motivate. She likes to eat. She likes to fetch. She likes other dogs to
a certain extent. She's quite a bit kind of more bossy and tougher than Dapper. Whereas Dapper will
get in a big group of dogs. Let's see if I can find Dapper. Come on Dapper. Dapper's already over
there laying in the shade because it's the middle of the day and it's kind of got hot. Come on nerd.
And here he comes. Now see he's pretty happy even though he was over there just kind of laying
around. When he comes back, he comes back with a pretty good attitude. Let's see if I can get him
back up here. Come on Dapper. Get up here so they can see you. Come on. Get up there nerd. Up, up.
Okay, well there you go. You want to see what his personality like? That's his personality. He
does everything but he does it a little bit on the haphazard side but with a good attitude.
Again, he's a total frat bro. He just likes to go around and be good looking and have people
pay attention to him on his schedule. That's pretty neat. Dapper on the other hand, a little
bit more steady worker. A little less gregarious. Probably a little less happy to see you.
I mean every time that I call Dapper or I walk in the door and he's sitting inside,
he's really happy to see me. Whereas Poppy, she just kind of looks at me like well,
we don't do anything that suits me. If we're not doing something that suits her,
she sometimes will just go off and do her own thing which can be an advantage depending on
what you need out of a dog. Now physically, let's do a few physical things just so we can see
how they approach physical problem solving. I'll go over here on the rubble pile. The rubble pile
is what we use to prepare dogs to go into our pre-adventure area which is where we prepare
dogs to actually go do off-leash hiking. What we try to do is get them into situations where
they have to learn to really make good decisions as it relates to their paw placement, how they
distribute their weight in low traction environments or off-camber situations.
So we just kind of get up here and do this stuff and walk around a little bit.
All right, so that's kind of how Poppy approaches that. Come here Dapper, Dapper do. Let's look at
Dapper, see how he's going to do it. Come on, can you do that stuff? Can you get up here too?
Come on nerd, you can do it. Come here. Now he might be a little bit more hesitant to do it
and part of that is because, you know, listen, sometimes when you're working with a dog and it
looks like they're refusing to do something or they don't want to do something, people
think about them like being stubborn or whatever but really it's just harder for some dogs. Like
getting up here and moving around, Dapper doesn't have the natural confidence that it takes to
successfully negotiate this and he hasn't had quite enough early life experience to build
confidence where it didn't exist naturally and so he's going to struggle a little bit. You can
notice that when I got him up here, his respiration rate started to increase and that's because he's
nervous. So he's not not coming up here because he's trying to be resistant or hard-headed or
something. He just doesn't know if he can do it, you know, and part of that is not much
experience. Part of it is the fact that he's not naturally super confident in terms of his
physicality and part of it is just because he's a little bit on the clumsy side, you know,
and sometimes that being aware that you're clumsy is a lifesaver, right? The worst thing in the
world is having a dog that doesn't know that they're clumsy or having a person that you go
hiking with that doesn't know that they're clumsy. Let's try to get him just to walk across this and
see. Come here, Depper, Depper. Come on. Now look, so see how I'm kind of getting these refusals?
I'm not going to end this portion of the session with a refusal, so what I'll do is I'll
just lower my criteria a little bit and I'll get up here where it's a little easier and I'll give
him some easy wins. So we'll just move up this way a little bit and then maybe move across this low
portion. Oh, you're a good dog. Come on, Depper. And this is how we build confidence, right?
We build confidence by building skill, because as the dog gains skill,
then the things that you ask them to do is a little easier, and the easier it seems to them,
the more confidence they will have when approaching that style of obstacle. All right, let's do
something else. Let's go over here and walk up these bleacher simulators. Come on. Come on,
Depper. What are you doing? Let's see how Depper negotiates these. Come here, buddy. You can do it.
Let's see what he does here. And that's pretty good. Very good. But see how he kind of got up
here and hunkered down? Again, we get back to confidence issues a little bit. All right. Okay.
All right, let's do something that you guys will probably be a little bit more familiar with. Let
me run over here and get my steps. We'll go out, kind of practice getting in the car.
And now as we walk by, might as well see if we can get a rep of getting on the kayak. Come on.
Come on, nurse. Get up here. Oh, look at these good dogs. You're a good dog.
And now see, look, Depper, he knows that I give treats over here in this area,
and I think he knows that I'd like for him to get up on that kayak. But what he's going to
try to do is come over here and see if he can put in the least work possible and still get the treat.
Again, it holds true across the type. Let's see if I can make it a little bit more clear to him.
Come on, dude. You got to get all the way up here. Okay. Now right here, this is where you
make a value judgment as a dog trainer, right? Do I just accept the fact that maybe right now
he thinks that's too hard given what the perceived value of the reward that I'm going to give him?
Or do I go ahead and put a leash on him and say, look, dude, I'm not going to let you fail to live
up to your potential. I know that you can get up here on this kayak. And I also know that you're
really going to enjoy being confident enough to get in the kayak because where he lives,
he's going to have a lot of opportunities to engage in water sports and boating activities.
Very nice. So when you have a dog that maybe has not got the natural confidence or natural
athleticism of a previous dog that you had or the dog that you were expecting to get when you bought
it, okay, that doesn't mean they can't be athletic. It means maybe you're going to have to put a
bit more work in during the early training stages. Okay. So we'll go over here. We've been
doing a little bit of camping training. So if we're going to go camping or some stuff that dogs
need to be able to do, need to be able to get on the side by side. And so for the most part,
what I like to do is point at the side by side and have the dogs just jump right up there.
But these suburban dogs, they don't ever come out here with that kind of experience. And so we got
to kind of back things up, give them a little bit of extra help with the steps. Very good. That's
very nice. That's kind of how Poppy looks trying to go up the steps. Come here, Smeller. Come here,
Smeller. Good boy. All right. Now let's see what Dapper does. Dapper, come on. Can you go up those
steps? You can do it. And I don't know if it'll come through on the video, but it's just everything
these two dogs do. Dapper is just a little bit more reserved when he goes to do it. Like if his
perception is that the activity is going to be hard, he's a little less likely to try to engage.
Poppy is better, but she's not a go-getter like my labs or like the herding dogs that are here
right now. But she's pretty good. Come on, there. All right. Let's see. You get down.
There we go. That's pretty decent. Not too bad. All right. Let's go compare and see how they
get in the car. All right. Let's go down here and see if you guys can get in the truck.
All right. So obviously, you don't want to be carrying steps around with you all the time when
you have a young dog, but we always train them to the steps and to the ramps when they're young
because they're going to need them one day. And we don't want to be teaching a dog to go up steps or
go up a ramp when they're old and they actually need steps or need a ramp. So we try to knock
that out early. So I should be able to tell the dogs we're going camping and just point in the car
and then jump up and get in there. So I go, hey, Dapper, you want to go on an adventure? Let's try
that again. Come here, Dapper. Come on. Let's go on an adventure. Come on. And that's kind of what
I get. All right. Let's make it a little easier. Come on, dogs. Come on. Oh, my gosh. Now we got
some steps. Get in the van now. Come on. Get up there. Get up there. You can do it. Very good.
Appreciate it. Now, I don't know where Poppy has got off to. Is Poppy underneath the truck?
Come here, Poppy. What are you doing? Very good dog. Okay. So let's see how... We'll do them both
on the leash so it's easier to compare. Come on, Poppy. Up, up, up. Very good. Come on. Come on,
Poppy. Now, see that where she jumped off that last step? That's not a big deal for a young dog,
but I like to go ahead and get them in the habit of taking every step again because I'm training
them for when they're going to be old dogs. Come on. There we go. So when we egress the vehicle,
we want to make sure that we hit every step. Good dog. Perfect. That's a very good dog.
Very good. Oh, you missed a step. You missed a step. Let's try that again.
There we go. Now, let's get every step. Okay. All right. Well, listen, that's just a kind of
a quick comparison of what it's like to have a quick session with a couple of Golden Retrievers.
So if you have any questions, I'm going to have Dapper with me for a few more weeks. So post them
in the comment section and tell me if there's something particular that you know about the
English Cream style Golden Retriever, or if there's something that you'd like to find out
about them, right? Because one way or another, we'll get that information to you. And I hope
this helps you move along your investigative path to figuring out whether or not a Golden
Retriever is right for you. And if so, what style of Golden Retriever is right for you?
All right. I'll see you guys next week. Very good dogs.
