#History#Food A senator who spent years defending butter… failed a blind taste test and picked margarine.
That bizarre moment is just the ending of a much bigger story: a century-long food war over butter, margarine, politics, smuggling, prison sentences, and laws so absurd they literally forced margarine to be dyed pink.
In this video from Crumb Lore, we trace the full history: 🧈 how butter may have been discovered by accident thousands of years ago 🏺 why ancient Greeks mocked “butter eaters” 🌍 how butter became a symbol of wealth, status, and identity in Europe ⚖️ how margarine triggered panic in the dairy industry 🎨 why governments outlawed the color yellow on food 🚔 how people were jailed for margarine smuggling 🇺🇸 why Wisconsin became the last great holdout 🇨🇦 and how parts of Canada were still fighting this battle shockingly recently
It is one of the strangest true stories in food history, and somehow it all comes back to toast.
If you enjoy weird history, forgotten laws, and the politics hiding behind everyday foods, subscribe to Crumb Lore for more.
What surprised you most — the pink margarine laws, the smuggling, or the senator who couldn’t tell the difference?
In 1965, a Wisconsin state senator named Gordon Roselipe sat down in front of his colleagues
and agreed to a blindfolded taste test.
Roselipe had spent years fighting to keep margarine illegal in his state.
He was the loudest voice in the room every time the topic came up,
and he was absolutely certain that real butter was so obviously superior
that nobody with working taste buds could ever confuse the two.
So when a younger senator challenged him to prove it, Roselipe said yes.
They put a blindfold on him, handed him samples, and asked him to pick the butter.
He picked the margarine, not once, repeatedly.
But the real twist came later, after his death,
when his family admitted something they had kept quiet for decades.
His wife had been buying margarine illegally across state lines in Iowa
and serving it to him at home,
telling him it was butter because she thought margarine was healthier.
The man who spent his career defending butter against margarine
had been eating margarine the whole time and never noticed.
That story sounds like something somebody made up to win an argument online,
but it actually happened.
And it sits at the tail end of one of the strangest food wars in history.
A fight that lasted nearly a hundred years sent people to federal prison
and at one point forced an entire product to be dyed bright pink by law.
All because somebody figured out how to make a cheap spread
that looked a little too much like butter.
But to understand how we got there, you have to go back a lot further.
About 10,000 years, actually.
The best guess historians have is that butter was an accident.
Somewhere around 8,000 BCE,
probably in the grasslands of Central Asia or the highlands of Africa,
a nomadic herder tied a pouch of milk to the back of a pack animal.
The pouch was made from animal skin and sealed tight for the journey.
Hours later, after miles of bumpy terrain,
the herder opened it, expecting a drink, and found something completely different.
The constant jostling had separated the fat from the liquid
and what was left were clumps of something rich, creamy,
and unlike anything the herder had tasted before.
That was butter.
Nobody invented it.
A road and a bag of milk did the work.
For a long time after that,
we do not know much about how butter spread across early civilizations.
But the oldest physical evidence we have comes from ancient Mesopotamia,
in what is now Iraq.
Archaeologists found a limestone tablet inside a small temple
dedicated to the fertility goddess Ninkursag.
The tablet is roughly 4,500 years old.
And it shows a scene of dairy production,
including what appears to be an early butter churn.
If the Sumerians thought butter was important enough to carve into stone inside a temple,
it was clearly already a well-established part of their world by that point.
And then there is the bog butter.
This one is hard to believe, but it keeps happening.
In Ireland, people digging up peat bogs for fuel
have been pulling out massive chunks of ancient butter for centuries.
In 2009, a 77-pound barrel of butter was found in County Kildare.
It was roughly 3,000 years old.
In 2013, a turf cutter in County Offaly dug up a 100-pound chunk
that dated back around 5,000 years.
Several hundred of these finds have been recorded across Ireland.
The peat bogs acted as natural refrigerators,
with cold temperatures and almost no oxygen,
which meant the butter never fully decomposed.
Some of it, according to researchers, is technically still edible.
People who have tried it describe the smell as a mix of strong cheese and rancid milk.
Nobody is putting it on toast.
But the fact that it survived at all,
buried underground since before the Roman Empire existed,
tells you something about how seriously ancient people took their butter.
Not everyone was a fan, though.
The ancient Greeks thought butter was disgusting.
They were sheep and goat people who made cheese and cooked with olive oil,
and they looked down on the northern tribes who kept cows and churned butter.
The Greeks actually used the phrase butter-eaters as an insult.
If you wanted to call someone uncivilized in ancient Greece,
you told them they ate butter.
The Romans took it even further.
They knew what butter was, but they refused to eat it.
The Roman writer Pliny the Elder mentioned butter in his Encyclopedia of the Natural World,
but only as a medicine and cosmetic.
Romans rubbed it on burns, slathered it on sore joints,
and used it to treat skin conditions.
Eating it was a different matter entirely.
Pliny wrote that butter was, and this is a direct quote,
the choicest food among barbarian tribes.
To a Roman, butter on bread was not breakfast.
It was proof that you had not been civilized yet.
But here is what makes that so interesting.
While the Romans were looking down on butter,
the people they called barbarians were building entire economies around it.
The Celts in northern Europe treated butter as a form of wealth.
Viking traders used it as currency.
In parts of Scandinavia, a family's status could be measured by how much butter they had stored.
And that Irish bog butter that keeps turning up is probably connected to this.
Some archaeologists think those hundred-pound buried stashes
were offerings to the gods or spirits.
Others think the bogs were simply the best refrigerators available,
keeping butter preserved at a steady four degrees Celsius year-round,
which is almost exactly the temperature of a modern fridge.
Either way, people were burying huge quantities of butter in the ground
3,000 years ago and fully expecting it to still be there when they came back.
That is not something you do with a food you consider optional.
Over the centuries, as the Roman Empire fell apart
and northern European cultures grew in influence,
butter made one of the more unlikely comebacks in food history.
It went from being the thing that marked you as uncivilized
to being the foundation of some of the most refined culinary traditions on the continent.
French pastry would not exist without it.
Scandinavian baking depends on it.
English cooking practically floats in it.
The barbarians, it turns out, were onto something all along.
By the Middle Ages, butter had become a staple across northern Europe.
Monasteries churned it. Markets traded it.
The Catholic Church even got involved,
because during Lent, butter was technically forbidden along with other animal products.
In parts of France, people paid the Church for special dispensations
that allowed them to keep eating butter during the fasting season.
There is a tower on the Rouen Cathedral in Normandy
that locals have called the Butter Tower for centuries,
because legend says it was partially funded by those dispensation fees.
Whether that story is completely accurate is debated,
but the fact that people told it at all
says something about how deeply butter had woven itself into the culture.
There was a culinary border running across the continent that you can still trace today,
with butter countries to the north and olive oil countries to the south.
Butter was not just food anymore, it was identity,
and it was about to become very big business.
Industrialization changed everything.
By the 1800s, butter production had scaled up from farm churns and wooden barrels
to mechanized factories and railroad distribution networks.
Dairy farming became a major economic engine, especially in the American Midwest.
Wisconsin built its entire state identity around milk, cheese and butter.
Minnesota, Iowa and the rest of the dairy belt followed.
By the second half of the 19th century,
millions of dollars, thousands of jobs and an enormous amount of political influence
all flowed from one product.
The dairy lobby had real power, and when a threat to that power appeared in 1869,
the response was fast and fierce.
The threat started with a contest.
France was dealing with food shortages,
and Emperor Napoleon III wanted a cheaper alternative to butter,
something he could feed to his armies and his poorer citizens,
without breaking the treasury.
He offered a prize to anyone who could create a satisfactory substitute.
A French chemist named Hippolyte Mégémaurice took up the challenge.
He had already been working with fats for years,
and by 1869 he had patented a process for churning beef tallow with milk
to create something he called oleomargarine.
The name came from the Greek word for pearl,
a reference to the lustrous look of the fat in his formula.
Mégémaurice won the prize, but his product never really caught on in France.
In 1871, he sold the patent to a Dutch company called Juergens,
which improved the formula, industrialized production
and started building an international market.
Juergens eventually merged with another company and became part of Unilever,
which is still the largest margarine manufacturer in the world today.
As for Mégémaurice himself, he barely saw a franc from any of it.
He sold his rights too early and too cheaply.
He died in 1880, largely forgotten and broke.
But the product he created was about to cause more trouble than he could have imagined,
because margarine had one big problem.
In its natural state, it was white.
Not a creamy, appetizing white, either.
More like the color of school paste.
Nobody wanted to spread that on their bread.
So manufacturers did the obvious thing.
They started dyeing it yellow to make it look like butter.
And that is when the dairy industry went to war.
The yellow dye worked too well.
Consumers could not easily tell the difference
between cheap colored margarine and real butter,
and margarine cost a fraction of the price.
Dairy farmers saw their profits evaporating.
Butter producers panicked.
And the lobbying machine kicked into gear.
The argument the dairy industry made was simple.
They told state legislatures and Congress that yellow margarine was fraud.
That coloring a cheap substitute to look like the real thing
was a deliberate attempt to deceive the public.
Never mind that butter itself was also frequently dyed yellow,
because the natural color of butter changes with the seasons,
depending on what the cows are eating.
Butter from summer grass is a rich golden color.
Butter from winter feed is pale and one.
Dairy producers had been adding yellow coloring to their own butter
for years to keep it looking consistent.
But when margarine did the same thing,
suddenly it was criminal deception.
The first major federal response came in 1886,
when Congress passed the Olio Margarine Act.
The dairy lobby had pushed hard for it.
And they got what they wanted.
The law imposed a two cent per pound tax on margarine,
which does not sound like much until you adjust for inflation.
And that figure was about 60 cents per pound in today's money.
On top of the tax,
the law required grocers to pay annual licensing fees
just to stock margarine on their shelves.
And distributors had to pay their own separate fees.
The entire supply chain got squeezed.
Federal rules also prevented manufacturers from adding yellow dye,
which meant margarine had to be sold in its natural white form
if companies wanted to avoid even steeper penalties.
But the federal law was just the opening move.
State governments piled on with legislation of their own.
And some of them went much further than Congress ever did.
By 1898, 32 out of the 45 states in the Union
had passed laws restricting the artificial coloring of margarine.
New York banned the substance entirely in 1884.
Pennsylvania did the same.
Other states did not ban it outright,
but taxed it so aggressively
that buying margarine cost nearly as much as buying butter,
which defeated the entire purpose.
And then some states took it to a place that honestly sounds like satire,
but it was completely real.
Vermont, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Minnesota, and West Virginia
all passed laws requiring margarine to be dyed pink.
Not a subtle hint of pink, either.
Bright, unmistakable cotton candy pink.
The idea was to make the product look so unappetizing
that nobody in their right mind would confuse it with butter.
If you were going to buy the cheap substitute,
you were going to know it.
And so was everyone sitting at your dinner table.
The Supreme Court eventually struck down the pink laws in 1898,
ruling that forcing the adulteration of food was unconstitutional.
But the bans on yellow margarine stayed in place.
And in 1902, Congress doubled down by amending the Oleo Margarine Act
to raise the tax on artificially colored yellow margarine to 10 cents per pound,
which made it nearly as expensive as butter.
The white, uncolored version stayed cheap.
The message was clear.
You could buy the substitute, but you could not make it look like the real thing.
So the margarine industry got creative.
If the law said manufacturers could not sell yellow margarine, then fine.
They would sell white margarine with a packet of yellow dye,
tucked inside the packaging.
Families could knead the dye into the margarine themselves at home,
in their own kitchens, beyond the reach of the law.
Different brands came up with their own systems for making this as easy as possible.
One company called theirs the EZ Color Pack,
which included a capsule of yellow dye sealed inside a plastic bag of margarine.
You pressed on the outside of the bag to burst the capsule,
then spent the next few minutes squeezing and kneading
until the color spread evenly through the spread.
Another brand, Parquet, had something called the Color Quick Bag.
A third company included yellow tablets you could dissolve and mix in with a fork.
It became a regular household chore across the country.
Right alongside washing dishes and peeling potatoes, kids apparently loved helping with it.
Some families called the process stomping the butter,
which gives you a sense of how much kneading was actually involved.
The whole thing had an absurdist quality to it.
A product that was perfectly legal in its white form
somehow became contraband the moment it turned yellow.
The chemistry was identical.
The taste was identical.
The only thing that changed was the color.
And the color was the crime.
And while the dye packet workaround was technically legal,
the broader margarine trade was not entirely operating within the lines.
Margarine smuggling became a genuine underground enterprise.
People snuck colored margarine across state lines into states where it was banned,
and they passed it off as butter to customers who either did not know
or did not care about the difference.
Federal authorities treated this the same way they treated other kinds of smuggling.
A man named Charles Will went to federal prison for illegal commerce in margarine.
So did John McMoneagle.
So did two brothers, Joseph and Tony Worth.
These were not drug traffickers or counterfeiters.
They were margarine bootleggers,
and the United States government put them behind bars
for moving the wrong color of spread across a state line.
But no matter how many laws the dairy lobby stacked up,
they could not win a war against economics forever.
And the thing that finally broke the dam was not a court ruling or a political campaign.
It was World War II.
During the war, butter was rationed.
The military needed enormous quantities of dairy products for the troops overseas,
and there simply was not enough butter for both the armed forces and the civilian population.
Prices spiked, supplies ran short,
and for millions of American families,
margarine was suddenly not the cheap knockoff they had been told to avoid.
It was the only option on the grocery store shelf.
By the end of the war, more than half the country was using margarine regularly.
It had moved from the tables of people who could not afford anything better
to the kitchens of middle-class families who had tried it,
found it perfectly acceptable,
and started wondering what all the fuss had been about.
Public opinion flipped fast after that,
and it got some high-profile help.
Eleanor Roosevelt publicly endorsed margarine while she was still in the public eye,
saying she ate it on her toast.
In 1959, she appeared in a television commercial for a margarine brand,
which was a remarkable moment.
The former First Lady of the United States, on national television,
cheerfully promoting the very product that dairy lobbyists had spent decades calling a fraud.
That kind of endorsement was hard to argue with.
The federal margarine tax was repealed on July 1, 1950.
That single change affected 33 states and Washington, D.C.
One by one, the anti-color laws started falling across the country.
But 15 states, including Pennsylvania,
still prohibited pre-colored margarine even after the federal tax was gone.
The walls were crumbling, but they had not come down everywhere.
And in one state, they were not coming down without a fight.
And then there was Wisconsin.
Wisconsin had banned yellow margarine in 1895.
And for the next 72 years, the state held the line harder than any other in the country.
This was America's dairy land.
Butter was not just a product here.
It was part of the state's identity, printed on license plates,
and woven into the culture at every level.
Yellow margarine was not just discouraged in Wisconsin.
It was illegal.
Technically, violators faced fines of up to $6,000,
though there is little evidence the law was ever seriously enforced against individual families.
What actually happened was something more interesting
and more widespread than the lawmakers probably anticipated.
Wisconsin families, especially the women who ran the household kitchens in those decades,
started making what became known as oleo runs.
They would drive across the state border into Illinois,
where yellow margarine was perfectly legal and sold at bargain prices,
load up the trunk of the car, and drive it back home.
Gas stations and small shops near the Illinois state line did a booming business,
selling as much as a ton of margarine per week to Wisconsin customers,
who were technically committing a crime by bringing it home.
Some of these customers, ironically enough, were dairy farmers themselves,
people who raised cows for a living but wanted a cheaper spread for their own kitchen table.
By the mid-1960s, when Wisconsin stood alone as the last state in the country
still banning yellow margarine, these cross-border oleo runs had become a routine,
almost casual part of life for thousands of families.
The fight to keep the ban alive had its champion in Senator Gordon Roselipe,
a Republican from Darlington in the southwestern corner of the state.
Roselipe was vocal, combative, and absolutely unshakable in his belief
that butter was superior and margarine was a threat to Wisconsin's dairy economy.
So when a younger senator named Marty Schreiber
proposed a blind taste test in the state legislature in 1965,
Roselipe agreed, confident he would prove his point once and for all.
He sat down. They blindfolded him. They gave him samples.
And he chose margarine as the better-tasting option.
The man who had spent his career defending butter
picked the other side and did not even realize it.
Two years later, in 1967, the state finally repealed the ban on yellow margarine.
Governor Warren Knowles signed the repeal into law,
reportedly using yellow ink. But even the repeal came with conditions.
Under the 1967 law, Wisconsin restaurants were forbidden from serving margarine
instead of butter unless the customer specifically asked for it.
That rule also applied to schools, hospitals, and prisons.
Margarine could not be served in state institutions
unless a doctor ordered it for health reasons.
Violating the law carried fines of $100 to $500
and up to three months in jail for a first offense.
A second offense could mean up to a year behind bars.
And here is the part that might surprise you.
That restaurant law still exists. An attempt to repeal it in 2011 failed.
As recently as the last few years, it remains on the books.
If a Wisconsin diner serves you margarine with your bread without you asking for it first,
they are technically breaking the law.
Meanwhile, just across the northern border,
Canada was fighting its own version of the same war.
And in some ways, it was even more extreme.
Canada banned margarine entirely from 1886 to 1948,
a stretch of 62 years during which the product was simply illegal coast to coast.
The only exception came during World War I,
when butter shortages forced the government to temporarily lift the ban from 1917 to 1923.
After that window closed, margarine went back to being contraband.
The Supreme Court of Canada finally lifted the national ban in 1948,
but the provinces immediately stepped in with their own rules.
And Quebec, backed by one of the strongest dairy lobbies in North America,
held out the longest and the hardest.
The province did not allow margarine at all until 1961.
And even after margarine was finally permitted, Quebec banned it from being colored yellow.
Enforcement was real too.
Provincial inspectors would show up at small grocery stores
and seize batches of margarine that were the wrong color.
In 1997, the consumer goods company Unilever tried to challenge the law
by importing 480 containers of colored margarine from the United States.
The province held firm.
Quebec did not repeal its ban on yellow margarine until 2008.
That is the same year the first iPhone had been on sale for a year.
Within completely living memory, a province in a modern western democracy
was still telling people they could not make margarine look like butter.
When you step back and look at the full arc of this story,
what happened with butter and margarine is one of the strangest chapters in food history.
A product that was probably discovered by accident on the back of a pack animal
somewhere in Central Asia 10,000 years ago.
Something the most powerful empire in the ancient world considered too barbaric to eat
became so economically and culturally important that governments spent over a century
deciding who was allowed to use the color yellow.
Real people went to real prisons.
Laws were written at every level of government, from town councils to the United States Congress.
An entire food product was forced to turn pink by law.
Families drove across state lines with trunks full of contraband spread.
And in the end, one of the most consequential moments in the whole saga
was not a Supreme Court ruling or a presidential signature.
It was a blindfolded senator in Wisconsin who picked the wrong sample,
while his own wife had been quietly proving his argument wrong at the dinner table for years.
Butter is still here, and it is more popular than it has been in decades.
Margarine is still here too, though it has lost some of its mid-century shine.
The war ended a long time ago, and you could argue that both sides lost more than they won.
But the laws that war produced are still sitting on the books,
in at least one American state, and in the living memory of a Canadian province.
As a reminder that when money and food and identity all crash into each other,
people will fight over just about anything, even the color yellow.
If you made it this far, hit subscribe and turn on notifications so you do not miss the next one.
Drop a like if you learned something new,
and let us know in the comments which part of this story surprised you the most.