The First Wars Were Absolutely Horrifying

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
13 Video Views·Oct 6, 2026
How War Began, Keith Otterbein
Warfare and Its Relationship to the Origins of Agriculture, Keith Otterbein
A massacre of early Neolithic farmers in the high Pyrenees at Els Trocs, Spain, Kurt Alt et al
Rock art from at least 67,800 years ago in Sulawesi, Adhi Oktaviana et al
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the archaeological evidence of human violence, debunking the \"noble savage\" myth. It argues that while interpersonal violence has existed for hundreds of thousands of years, organized warfare emerged later, driven primarily by population growth and the precarious nature of early agricultural dependence rather than farming alone.
Hello everybody. In this video I want to do something a bit different and explore a topic
which is unusual for the channel. The Neolithic period and the evidence that we have, which is
admittedly a bit limited, for an evolution of, and an increasing capacity in human societies for,
organized violence. Now this is not an explanation of why humans begin killing
each other in a manner which essentially comes to resemble war as we would understand it per se,
in part because there isn't really an overarching explanation for that which archaeologists agree
with, so much as what the earliest evidence for something that we would recognize as organized
warfare actually looks like. So this is going to be a bit of a long one with a lot of stuff
crammed into one video, so grab a coffee. It's primarily going to focus on Europe and North
Africa and a bit of the Near East, simply because that's where much of the archaeology for early
conflict has been conducted, although not entirely. And this capacity for increasing
violence seems to have become especially prevalent during and after the dawn of farming.
In other words, we're looking at where and when the evidence shifts for something that anybody
watching this might understand as a one-off thing, or perhaps a limited feud, or a limited conflict
between, say, hunting parties, to basically what we can call the First Wars. And as far as evidence
goes, it's pretty grim, and it shows that although something like sustained conflict did not exist
until relatively recently in the grand scheme of things, societies, and not just human societies,
have always featured a degree of violence. So, for example, we have Cranium 17. This is located
in the Atapuerca Mountains in Spain, in a place called the Pit of Bones, and Cranium 17 is thought
to possibly represent the first murder victim, dated to about 430,000 years ago. Fast forward a
bit, and we have a recent study of an individual called Kasva 25, discovered in Kasva Cave in
Israel, which shows that the individual in question took a stone blade to the face about
100,000 years ago. You also have to keep in mind here that there was no modern medicine or anything
like that when it comes to this sort of thing. Now, in Peshmerga, in France, the cave paintings
are at least 20,000 years old, and one of them depicts a human with up to eight lines coming out
of the body, which is interpreted as being eight spears sticking out of the person, or possibly
arrows. Now, granted, our evidence is limited, but at some point in the material record, what seems to
be limited violence like this changes, and we begin to see archaeological evidence of warfare as
we would understand it, such as, for example, a site in Spain called San Juan Antiportum Latinum,
which appears to be some kind of a massacre pit dating to about 5,400 years ago or thereabouts,
and in this massacre pit, bodies were seemingly just dumped. Because this is an unusual topic
for the channel, I want to make it very clear here that in this video, I'm going to try and
summarize a lot of different stuff, and part of the information that we have for warfare,
and the development of agriculture and that sort of thing, is drawn from ancient population
genetics and other aspects of the hard sciences, which have exploded since about 2010. These various
facets continue to change month by month, so you could absolutely come back to this in a year,
and sections of this video will be incorrect. With that said, the development of organized
warfare is not a pretty subject. It's interesting to explore how ancient civilizations sourced
stuff like copper or obsidian, or trained small unit tactics, but at the end of the day,
it is, to paraphrase Dan Carlin, much more nitty and gritty and horrifying than you can probably
fathom. It's one thing to read in the sources about a battle, it's a whole different level to
uncover a Neolithic massacre site, and actually see five or six thousand year old cut marks on
human bones inflicted with stone blades. And you might see that on an adult skeleton, and say,
well, okay, there was violence and this person lost, but it's pretty jarring to realize that
these massacre sites include skeletons as young as three, or even under. So, I had just finished
reading the invention of prehistory, empire violence and our obsession with human origins,
which is an intellectual history of the entire idea of prehistory and what our archaeological
evidence looks like for various eras of the past, including violence and organized warfare.
And then I picked up Pat Wyman's new book, Lost Worlds, How Humans Tried, Failed, Succeeded,
and Built Our World, which I would highly recommend to anybody watching this video.
And the book mentioned this 8 mile or 13 kilometer stretch of cliff in Colombia,
which has tons of rock art called Serenia de la Lindosa. It dates to about 12,000 years or so,
and it's controversial because it might depict extinct megafauna. And I said to myself, that's
neat, so I started doing more reading on rock art, and a lot of it includes violence, so here we are.
Now, cave painting, which comprises our earliest evidence for human violence, is incredibly old.
We have an example which dates back to something like 43,000 years ago at Sulawesi in Indonesia.
It's maybe a bit older, and it's one of the earliest examples of art as a medium of
storytelling that we are currently aware of. Now, to give just a quick example of how fast
these things change, if I am understanding this correctly, this particular piece of art
was dated in 2018 to about 43,900 years ago. And in 2024, so just 6 years later,
an even older piece of art was discovered, dating to about 51,200 years ago.
So, the state of our knowledge, especially of prehistory, is always in flux. Much of this cave
art, scattered throughout the world, depicts animals, although not all of it. And in all of
this cave art, there are figures which show up which are interpreted as having some kind of
religious or ritual significance, if we're interpreting that correctly, like the sorcerer,
located in one of the many caves in Western Europe, although that particular example has
been criticized in the past two decades or so. The tradition of cave and rock art was continuous
for tens of thousands of years, and although animals and hunting tend to be the major themes
for much of this time, with humans seemingly, well, you know, not really depicted, when there
are humans, it tends to be, as I've said before, pretty grim. So, if we go back to Peshmerga,
we come to a cave system located in modern France, which is dated to the Gravetian period,
or about 20 to 30,000 years ago, approximately. This cave is quite famous for depictions of
numerous animals, especially horses, but it also contains this depiction of a human,
who is seemingly lying flat, with several lines extending out of the body. Next to this figure is...
something. Archaeologists are not certain what this thing is, and they've argued about it for
literally decades. It has been interpreted as maybe just some kind of an abstract shape,
or maybe it represents a spirit, or something like that. Perhaps it's an animal. However,
the figure with the lines is thought to represent a dead individual.
This sort of thing appears to be relatively typical for humans and cave art during the upper
Paleolithic. When they are depicted, such as at Peshmerga, or anywhere, really, it tends to be one
or two, or maybe a small number of human figures. Now, on the one hand, we are talking about
something so far in the past, that organic materials, or really much evidence at all,
simply does not survive. But, we have enough lithic artifacts, cave paintings, and things of
that nature, that we are able to reconstruct a decent amount of Paleolithic life all over the
world, at least in a broad sense. And, over the past decade or so, perhaps a bit longer,
there has been an explosion in archaeogenetics, which enables us to track human migration patterns
and the interaction of population groups, among other things. What all of this tells us is that
even during the Upper Paleolithic, the population of a given region was probably relatively low,
and fairly dispersed, at least when compared with later periods. That being said, we should not
take a lesser amount of people overall, to mean that violence never occurred. There is a relatively
recent book, Violence and Warfare Among Hunter-Gatherers, which examines ethnographic
and archaeological evidence of, well, violence and warfare among hunter-gatherer populations,
including the archaeology of Mesolithic Europe. And, it backs up many other works of anthropology,
which basically argues that it's not that violence is or is not common among societies that are not
settled, or which don't practice long-term agriculture. It's that the causes of that
violence are different. And, this is really the key thing here for understanding early warfare.
These aren't necessarily fights over territory or something like that. Instead, it's violence over
personal feuds and disagreements, something which still happens today, as well as things like
resource hoarding or oath-breaking. So, something to keep in mind here is that in non-literate
societies, such as you would have found back during the Upper Paleolithic and the Mesolithic,
societies probably would have been what are called high-trust societies, because they
basically have to be. A lack of writing means that order and power and things of that nature,
even if the society in question is not hierarchical and is much more egalitarian,
those things are going to be enforced visually, and they're also going to be enforced verbally.
There is a very good reason why. Just as an example, one of the oldest aspects of Indo-European
myth and folklore that we can reconstruct has to do with swearing oaths before the gods. Breaking
one's word or threatening another individual is not something done lightly. If something like that
is done, violence usually ensues. And we do have evidence of broken bones and injuries inflicted
with weapons from Mesolithic Europe, so we know that violence occurred between people and groups,
it's just not organized warfare as we would understand it. And it's not just in Europe during
the Paleolithic or the Mesolithic. A paper which was published in 2023, Violence in Fishing,
Hunting and Gathering Societies in the Atacama Desert Coast, a long-term perspective 10,000
years before present to A.D. 1450, examined several hundred skeletons to look for evidence
of interpersonal violence in the Atacama Desert in South America. It drew on an earlier study
which examined violence in the same region between about 10,000 and about 3,000 years before present,
in other words about 8,000 to about 1,000 B.C., and it found that of the 136 skeletons examined,
25% had some sort of trauma which was associated with interpersonal violence, generally to the
skull or the upper body, but only 2% of the total sample indicated lethal trauma. The 2023 study
essentially expanded on that older set of data and it pushed the timeline up to 1450,
and it concluded that between about 1,000 B.C. and about A.D. 500, although the population expanded,
it wasn't a trigger for violence because violence had already been a feature of light in the
preceding millennia. What seems to have happened instead is that the nature of the wounds changed,
and the frequency of violence seems to increase. From about 1,000 B.C. until the end of the study
in about A.D. 1450, the trauma on the skeletons becomes increasingly lethal. So, the reason why
I bring up this particular study is because it calls attention to violence and potentially fatal
trauma increasing due to the overall size of the population going up over time. And this helps
segue the discussion into, you know, why warfare seems to eventually increase in the archaeological
record. As many of the more recent studies done on hunter-gatherers and Mesolithic period skeletons
tell us, violence always appears to have been part of human life. That is to say, humans don't appear
to have archaeologically just started killing each other at some point. We've always done this.
And although it doesn't appear to be super common, it does appear to become more prevalent after the
Neolithic. There is a long-standing idea of prehistoric people being some kind of a noble
savage. Food was plentiful, population density was low, and people could move about, so they didn't
really engage in violence too often. And at least to an extent, that idea probably is correct, but
not as a totalizing sort of viewpoint. A major pushback against this idea of a total peaceful
prehistory came in the 1990s when the archaeologist Lawrence Keeley published War Before Civilization,
The Myth of the Peaceful Savage, which really emphasized this sort of low-level endemic violence
in prehistoric man. And which makes a very strong point to emphasize that, due to the low or at
Essentially, any sort of intergroup conflict between bands of people is basically total war.
If you are in a group of, say, 50 people, and 10 of those people are killed fighting another group,
or they are wounded to the point where they cannot be saved, you effectively just lost about 20% of
your overall fighting force. And this goes back to the 2023 study of the Atacama Desert Skeleton
showing that potentially lethal violence increased as the total population rose,
because we have to discuss agriculture. So when it comes to prehistoric warfare,
there is one archaeological site which is often pointed at as being evidence for,
you know, total war, as Keeley would argue. And this is Jebel Sahaba, an archaeological site on
the border between modern Egypt and modern Sudan, which dates to about 14,000 years ago,
and which was discovered in 1964. It consists of 61 skeletons, almost all of whom show very
clear signs of trauma. So initially, this was thought to be the oldest battle yet found,
but much more recently, the trauma on the skeletons and the burial patterns have been
reinterpreted. What that re-examination tells us is that those skeletons were buried at different
times, and that many display evidence of healed trauma, like broken forearms, indicating that the
arm was used to ward off a blow. This is sort of the stereotypical defensive wound that you see in
bioarchaeology. But this was earlier in life, so rather than being a massacre site or a place of
burial for those fallen in battle or something along those lines, this is probably a burial
site for people of a given group who, over the course of their lives, came into conflict with
other similar groups of people. Now, many of those same skeletons had projectile points embedded in
them at the time of burial, so some of them definitely did die to intergroup violence,
and at least two show evidence of an execution type of blow. But this was not a battlefield.
The Jebel Sahaba site is associated with the Kadan archaeological culture,
and these people don't appear to have been agriculturalists. Instead, they appear to have
primarily hunted and foraged wild grains, although they probably did process them. So with that in
mind, one of the interpretations of Jebel Sahaba is perhaps a burial site for people who were maybe
defending hunting grounds or otherwise came into contact with some sort of a group which led to
interpersonal violence. It is after this period that we begin to see not only the dawn of
agriculture, but also shifts in the evidence for societal violence, and ultimately what becomes
organized warfare. So how do you go from limited, albeit increasing violence among hunter-gatherer
groups, to the earliest warfare, the evidence of which really starts showing up around 6 or 5000
BC? Well, there is something of a popular answer that basically goes like this. As humans
domesticated crops, they began to settle in villages and eventually cities, and they had to
defend the land, and from this they came into conflict over land use. This viewpoint is...
not necessarily incorrect, but it's a bit more nuanced than that. Ben Kiernan, a historian of
Southeast Asia and of modern genocide studies, wrote a highly influential book called Blood and
Soil, a world history of genocide and extermination from Sparta to Darfur. And as the title suggests,
it examines all of the horrible aspects of human history. And part of the overall argument is that
it is with the development of agriculture that we see in the earliest written sources from
Mesopotamia and China, the presence of people who do not adhere to agriculture. Now they might
not necessarily be hunters and gatherers, but they are often nomadic. To groups like these,
agricultural fields or property boundaries do not necessarily mean anything, because they still have
to move their horse herds and flocks of animals into whatever else they have. So, it's in the
earliest sources that we see the tendency among agriculturalists to refer to these people as
barbarian, other, non-human, that sort of language. And it comes with stereotypes which are culturally
bound. For example, agricultural societies in what is today China tended to refer to these nomadic
groups as raw meat-eating savages. Something similar shows up in Japanese sources as well.
And one of the ways of translating terms for this is uncooked, meaning of course that they are not
because they do not grow and cook their food. No matter how it's conceived of though, the sources
begin referring to two different ways of using the land, farming and herding. The two cannot coexist
and so there is conflict, oftentimes with the farmers wiping these people out. There was another
recent book on the origins of states in the ancient Near East called Against the Grain, written by
the anthropologist James Scott, who notes that, in addition to this sort of thing, when you're
looking at the archaeology of the Near East, when cities and towns and things of that nature begin
showing up, the archaeological record also shows a lot of smaller sites which are just abandoned.
Now this could absolutely be due to disease, like the population is just wiped out, but he also
argues that given that one of the early signs in cuneiform for slave is domesticated human,
or two-legged animal, agricultural societies were probably attacking and enslaving each other
to work the fields. So there's a lot to commend this sort of view, but much more recent work,
especially over the past decade or so, has really complicated the picture. It's not necessarily the
case that agriculture was required for sedentary village life and thus organized warfare. An
example of what this looks like without farming to any substantial degree is the site of Oenohara
in Japan. This site dates to about 11,500 years ago, and it contains the remains of 52 huts,
at least 16 storage pits lined with clay, and tens of thousands of pottery pieces. These people,
who belonged broadly to the Jōmon culture, did not farm. Instead, they engaged in what
anthropologists call broad-spectrum subsistence. What that basically means is that rather than
being tied to something particular like a plant or an animal, the environment was productive and
lush enough that the people of Oenohara could forage and hunt to such an extent that they were
pretty okay as far as food was concerned. The remains of the storage pits and the overall site,
which was preserved due to a nearby volcano erupting and burying the site like Pompeii,
tells us that they favored acorns and other nuts, but they also hunted.
My point with bringing this up is that sedentism does not necessarily have to lead to agriculture.
Now, the same sort of thing shows up in the archaeology of the epipaleolithic Near East
between about 18,000 and about 8,000 years ago. Broad-spectrum subsistence took place,
including what would eventually turn into full-fledged plant domestication, that is to say,
farming. But what's important here, and this is why I talked about the study of the skeletons in
the Atacama Desert earlier, is that among the archaeological culture that we call the Natufians,
the population was absolutely increasing during that time period.
Another one of the articles I read while writing the script for this video was
Warfare and its Relationship to Agriculture written by Keith Otterbeam, an anthropologist
who, prior to his passing in 2015, specifically worked on the subject of early warfare.
And in this paper, he points out that while the more common argument of agricultural societies
engaging in warfare and the development of the idea of the barbarian and that sort of thing,
which we've already talked about, definitely did occur, agriculture and sedentism were probably
secondary factors which led to warfare. The primary reason was the increase in population
among the people that would go on to, you know, become the first farmers of the ancient Near East.
Another way of putting that is that the population increase came first, and then people began
fighting over land and food supplies rather than the reverse, which is typically how we think of it.
And then between about 7000 and about 6500 BC, those early farmers began spreading into Europe
and they moved, generally speaking, in two directions. The first direction was up through
the Balkans in stops and starts until they reached the banks of the Danube, and the other direction
was along the Mediterranean Littoral. Now as they spread, and as farming spread with them,
they came into contact with the Mesolithic hunter-gatherers of Europe, and then one or
two thousand years after this, we begin to get archaeological evidence of what we would recognize
basically as massacre pits and organized warfare. So what happened? Did the two groups ever interact?
And if they did, did they fight each other? Well, sort of. Farming mostly spread through
the population expansion of the farmers, and in the process, we now know from genetic studies
that they did interact and they did reproduce with the hunter-gatherers, but not to the extent
that it was a full blending of the populations. There were still two distinct groups of people.
This is where we come to the earliest evidence of warfare and massacres, and particularly much of
our evidence is from the eastern portion of the Iberian Peninsula, and it is here that the artwork
really changes from what came previously, because it definitely begins to depict skirmishes and
what appear to be outright battles. These people are often armed with bows, and sometimes the art
looks like it's depicting executions. And then we see the massacres, and there are really two
archaeological sites which stand out. Eltrox and San Juan Antiportum Latinum. The Eltrox site is
located in a cave in Spain, and it is here that archaeologists found five adults and four children.
The adults show evidence of having been shot in the face at close range with bows. The archaeologists
who excavated the site have actually found the remains of arrowheads in the skulls, and the
children were, as the broken bones make very clear, basically beaten to death. So who were these people
that were killed and then dumped in this cave? Well, the answer is that they were probably farmers.
Archaeologists have tested the ancient DNA of one of the individuals, and it matches with the gene
flow out of Anatolia. And some of the grave goods indicate that they were farmers as well. So one of
the interpretations of this site is that this may have been a conflict over farming rights between
two groups of people practicing agriculture. The other interpretation is that it's hunter-gatherers
in the region who killed these farmers for intruding on hunting lands. The other site is even
bigger. It dates to about 3300 BC, give or take maybe a century, and it contains more than 300
different skeletons, and apparently just thousands of random bits of bone. Based on examinations of
craniums, archaeologists estimate that there are 338 individuals here, not counting the random bones.
And of those 338 individuals, 137 are adults and 201 are teenagers or younger.
Approximately one-third of all of these people have cranial trauma,
with just under half having trauma that had not healed at the time of death,
and of the just under half who have unhealed trauma, a significant portion of them definitely
died from it because the skulls are simply smashed in. That is to say, those individuals died of
direct trauma in the form of killing blows, rather than having half of their face caved in and then
surviving for some time. This has to do with the placement of blows and things of that nature. Like
I said at the start of the video, it's pretty grim. Of the 338 known individuals at the site,
27, including children, show evidence of unhealed broken bones. The site is unusual because the
overall amount of trauma which is visible on the bones is higher than average for other sites of
the European Neolithic. The reason for this is assumed to be that killing blows hit the organs
or the neck or something similar, whereas here, we have a higher concentration of smashed skulls
and broken limbs. Now on top of that, skeletons which do not have evidence of broken bones do
have evidence of being shot with so many arrows that they have a higher likelihood of the arrowhead
striking the bones and leaving wounds. And with the recovery of 59 stone arrowheads from the site,
on top of the cranial trauma, archaeologists have learned significantly more about this
particular place than other massacre locations of the same period. What is particularly interesting
here though is that the distribution of the wounds is different when compared to the Neolithic as a
whole. Massacre sites from across Western and Central Europe in this period tend to show a
somewhat even distribution across male and female skeletons, but here at San Juan, male skeletons
have a higher proportion in the evidence. But it doesn't just stop there. Of all of the male
skeletons which could be identified, something like 70% of them are adolescents. It is not
entirely certain why this is, but the proposed explanation is that this group may have faced
some kind of sustained conflict, that is to say, a war. And most of the adult males,
and probably the females as well, although we don't know that for certain, who formed the
initial fighting force had already been killed, and so the younger people had to replace them.
An osteological analysis of the bones also indicates that up to 37% of all the people at
almost double the rate found in other Neolithic sites in Europe from the period.
Now what that is taking to indicate is that this group had a chronic lack of food,
and suffered severe childhood stress to the point where the skeleton was literally deformed on a
microscopic level. There is a very famous archaeological culture called the Linear
Band Keramic, otherwise known as the LBK or Linear Pottery Culture, which stretched across
much of Central Europe, and it collapsed. And we see a series of massacre pits around the time of
its collapse, not unlike the ones discovered in Spain between about 5000 and about 4500 BC.
Now oftentimes those pits show a striking lack of female skeletons. The frequency with which
those sorts of things begin to show up indicates that there was a general period of warfare,
and there was a recent study done on an apparent bottleneck of male genetic data from that period,
which caught the internet by storm about two years ago.
What that probably indicates is that warfare was attached to agricultural society, and as that
society broke down, the higher level of population meant that people fought to the death over
resources and land. And as frightening as it is to think about, they also fought over, well,
let's call it the right to reproduce. It's a crass way of putting it, but you have to explain why
these massacre sites oftentimes don't feature female skeletons, or if they do, they are pretty
few in number. That's sort of a condensed simplification of the LBK collapse, because
that's a whole subject of its own, and in this video I was really more interested in the earliest
signs of mass organized violence from the Iberian Peninsula, especially the San Juan sites. But all
across Europe in the Neolithic, violence becomes widespread, and there appears to be the first signs
of fortified sites. The gradual increase in population, and then the tying of those populations
to agricultural methods for their survival, probably produced a nasty feedback loop where
older life ways, like hunting and gathering for the majority of a community's subsistence,
at some point became forgotten. And once those populations became big enough, and once they
were always on the edge of disaster, one crop failure or something like that could spell the
end of a community, the employment of violence for land and the right to use it probably took
off. In other words, it's not farming per se which created warfare so much as human societies
increased in number, and then they became dependent upon farming and only farming,
and that generates conflicts with other groups of either farmers or hunter-gatherers. Because they
have to do that, because those communities were living on a knife's edge in a manner which they
weren't previously, as the osteology of the San Juan skeletons seems to indicate.
Of course, that could also be incorrect, or at least partially incorrect. The archaeology of
early warfare is still heavily studied, and I would not be surprised if we found even more
sites like this, especially in Spain where they appear to be clustered. So, with all of that being
said, when it comes to early warfare and the rise of organized violence in the first armies,
what do you all think?
