Dolphins in Depth: Dolphins need to learn from 0-4 start
Oct 6, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe Miami Dolphins are struggling with an 0-4 start driven by self-inflicted errors, offensive inefficiency, and defensive vulnerabilities. While the team shows flashes of rookie brilliance and defensive resilience, systemic issues with third-down conversions and offensive line stability continue to hinder their progress during a difficult rebuilding phase.
The Miami Dolphins are 0-4. I'm pretty sure that was not a surprise to anybody looking at the talent
base on this team, looking at all the salary cap that they were spending on players that were not
here, and sort of assessing where the franchise is in this rebuild. Is it a little surprising that
they've lost two potentially winnable games? We'll discuss that on this episode of Dolphins
In Depth, a podcast provided to you by the Miami Herald. I'm Miami Herald columnist Omar Kelly.
Joining me is Isaiah Smalls. Isaiah, the Dolphins were close. The 4-0 Minnesota Vikings,
which I don't think was very good, to be honest with you. Not a very good team.
They have a great defensive play caller, and then the special teams were pretty solid.
I don't know if you saw that. There was a graphic that flashed that
their kicker is responsible for more points this year than the entire offense.
That makes sense. How they continue to keep winning 4-0, I don't know. The Dolphins had
their opportunities in that 15-10 loss. It was yet another 4th quarter game, and they should
be proud of themselves for that. But where I stand is that this team is beating themselves
on a consistent basis, and young teams are going to do that. Talent-starved teams are going to do
that. The problem is probably going to get worse when you're suffering a couple more injuries
during the season. However, what I don't like about what I'm seeing about this Dolphins team
is that we're having the same problems every single week. Issues stopping the tight ends.
I'm going to actually push back on that just a little bit, only because there's something
Perk and I talked about. How Kelsey and Kittle decimated the Dolphins was very different than
what TJ Hawkins did. With Kelsey and Kittle, it was a big play that led them to eventually
scoring, eventually later in the game. With Kelsey, I believe it was a little bit more direct.
They were attacking open zones with those same weapons.
Well, that's fair. That's fair. But with Hawkinson, I think it was a lot more of a
steady stream. That, to your point, is correct. He was finding the soft spot in the zone and just
consistently attacking that. Yes, problems stopping the tight end, or is that just more
of an issue with their zone coverage and the inability to play tight zone coverage,
leaving these wide open holes? That's the question that I think needs to be asked.
Every zone has holes in it. Of course. It's just a matter of, does your quarterback have
time to wait for that player? Does the player have chemistry to read the right reads and options?
TJ Hawkinson is clearly a veteran quarterback. Obviously, he's developed some chemistry with
Kyle Murray, but it was too easy from my standpoint for this reason. They would go
in motion, get an indicator where those manners zone. After they got that indicator, Hawkinson
would just drop into the zone and Kyle Murray wasn't throwing nowhere else. 13 for 13. At some
point, as the team, and here's the thing, I understand why they're playing so much zone.
They don't really have the trust and confidence in their quarterbacks or don't want to expose
their quarterbacks or their safeties to get beat deep. But there are times when I'm pretty sure
that they can handle it. Yes, I watched every single one of those receptions and Hawkinson
played a very masterful game, but they made it too easy for Kyle Murray, Murphy and Murray,
and he ain't that good of a quarterback. He's not, they didn't even try to disguise anything
for him. Like, mind you, I'm complaining about the strength of the team at this moment. So I'm
being a little nitpicky. But you are in position to win that game. You're in position to at least
make it a closer game. And realistically, I don't even think the 1510 score is a great indicator
because TJ Hawkins stopped himself at the two yard line. He could easily score a touchdown.
So let's not even blow. I'm sure I already know the better.
Because they didn't cover the spread. I don't know. But that's what I yeah. Yeah. Listen,
and I think that was a little bit of, you know, let me hook up my neighbor. Because I'm sorry.
Yeah, I don't know what the analytics would say on that one. But I'm pretty sure
it would say go up two scores and two scores in a minute and 40 something seconds left.
You know, the quarterback hadn't even thrown for 100 yards yet. Like I don't think anything
massive was gonna happen just with all due respect to that off to the Dolphins. And
but I just don't think they were. Yeah. Now, is it fair to say that the defense ran out of gas?
Yes, they played like 78 snaps. Yeah. But then we get into the other problem that I have,
which is the offense of the third downs. And yes, you had a resurgent day or a decent day
on third downs against the Chiefs. But this has been a consistent issue all season.
The third downs have just been disastrous. What were they two of nine on third down?
Do you think you could survive all season converting 22% of third downs?
It's the same issue. They can't convert on third down. To be honest, I it was I saw that I didn't
watch the game because I ran for this game. But the box scores of Jalen Hurts and Malik Willis
both throwing for under 100 yards. It kind of made me scratch my head. It's very concerning.
But I'll say this about about the passing. And this is maybe a better question for you. I feel
like a lot of the stuff that they were able to do, the big plays that they're able to hit on
against the Chiefs, like maybe and this is something that we've noticed about Malik,
like he needs to take the easier option. There was the play, I believe, on third down at the
end of the game where yeah, where he again, kind of forced it to Chris Bell. But as I'm watching
film first quarter, it was a similar situation. They had bunch to one side, Chris Bell on the
other. Like they motion, I believe it was Malik to the to the outside. Right. Obviously, that's
bunch formations to me like your design. Those are designed for communication. Right. So once
that motion hits right and you snap that ball, you need to be looking at the one side first before
you make your read over to the to Chris Bell. And the thing that I didn't like about that
is that like he he like glanced over and then went right to Chris Bell.
Great. These are split second decisions. Blitzes are coming at you. I think I think
I'm not playing particularly where I sent six, but he had Malik Washington wide open
in the in the flat that could have at least gone. I think it was 38 again.
That could have at least gotten you to fourth and short, if not the first down. And to me,
it's these little simple plays that are just very, very difficult
for me to just comprehend. Like you have to take the easy play.
And like, who am I? Right. I'm a guy sitting at his home with my chips. You know what I'm saying?
Yeah. Yeah. It's easy. It's easy to watch these and replay when they slow it down.
And these are finger snap decisions. I am generally not a play call
criticizer. So I'm not going to criticize the play call. But I'm now on week four being like,
is there certain things that get called at certain times? And yes, I agree with you, Malik.
Probably, if there are two things I would, I would encourage Malik to do to improve his game.
And obviously, I'm not a quarterback coach. I just stayed at a Holiday Inn.
Wait, what?
You know that thing where they say, you know, I'm not a doctor. I just stayed at a Holiday Inn.
I've never heard that before. That must be some old man saying that I'm not hip too. Yeah. I mean,
it's all good. It's all good. Hey, it's not old. It's vintage. Okay. I shouldn't have called you
old. I apologize. Thank you. I appreciate that. Yeah. He does have to take the check down more
often. Everybody wants him to run more. I don't. I'm good. And something that Jermon Bushrod,
who was a former Dolphins offensive lineman, now turned a color commentator for FAU and is trying
to get into color commentating. Former player for the Dolphins. He shouldn't be throwing off his
back foot. And truthfully speaking, we all generally know a quarterback throwing off his
back foot is problems. Now with Malik, I make exceptions because he's got such a stellar arm.
He could still throw a velocity even off his back foot arm angles. His arm is
top shelf. But we also need to work on our accuracy. And maybe we need to work on our
foot placement to kind of enhance our accuracy. And I'm not saying that he's not an accurate
quarterback. I'm not saying he's making bad decisions. I'm not saying that his receivers
are running the right routes. What I am saying is, and this is the same thing I said last week,
especially when I wrote the column about it, a 73 quarterback, 73 quarterback rating,
that ain't going to cut it, my dudes, at all, under any circumstances. Like,
if you're not in the 85s, I can't mess with you. And that's, that's my, that's like my bottom
basement stuff. Like, and we're not even close to there. And I don't want to hear,
and I wrote this column coming out of the Washington joint practices. The one thing that
I don't want to hear excuses for this season is I wrote it, wrote it probably twice. I don't want
to hear the excuse of we can't evaluate Malik properly because he didn't have the necessary
weapons and players around him. I don't want to hear it. I don't want to hear it at all under
any circumstance, any condition. I don't care. You chose this route and sitting here and saying,
oh yes, does Austin Jackson need to be new to improve? Absolutely. I'm at the point now,
Austin, this might be your last week is my start of my dude. It, it just, I'm sorry,
I'm a bottom line kind of person. You either get the job done or you're not getting the job done.
And I understand that you at first were facing league players. And I know
this Dallas Turner, he, he, that I was going to say, he turned it up this year, man.
But come on, man. I was like, I haven't seen Austin get beat like this since he was playing
but we're talking about 38 plays. How many of them, what percentage of them would you
say the doubt that, that Austin Jackson was a problem? I have to, I have to go back and look
at my notes. I don't want to even get that. I don't even want to say that because I take notes
on literally every single play. So I won't, I don't even want to. I'll have a number for you
by the next podcast. Okay. In my estimation, it's generously 30%. Like if you're a problem for 30%
with the sheer number, it was like 38 plays. If I remember right, 30, 37.
Yeah. That's a, that's an even bigger issue. Cause you don't have a lot of plays.
Yeah. If you have 10 bad plays in the game, you, if you got 10 minuses in the game
and yeah, yeah. I don't have any, I don't have many options, but what I do have as a team that's
a lot of players that are thirsty and Caden Wallace deserves an opportunity if you're not
getting the job done and or whoever you would like, uh, what, what, what do the name? Uh,
should we God or Jared Kingston? What do you want? I'm sorry. I'm like, and I have respect
and appreciation for Austin Jackson. I think he's a better player than he has shown,
but you either getting the job done or you're not getting the job done.
And right now, like my Willie Willis is gun shy, not head gun shot, but he's,
he's impacted by your performance on a snap per snap basis. And yes, other people are screwing
up as well. But if I can count on Caden Wallace and Caden Proctor to do his job, I should damn
sure count on you to do your job. And if, if you can't do your job, then I'm probably have Caden
Proctor do your job. And then Jack Kingston do Caden Proctor's job. Uh, I, I, I'm not gonna,
I'm not buying into that. I don't think I'm, I'm with somebody. I don't think that they're
going to switch their young who's showing promise at home. I don't think they're switching them to
the tech. I don't think that I understand that, but what's a more important position.
Do you want to, you're completely correct, but are you, are you willing to hinder his
development right now at a position that you know that he's playing well at my choices are
hindered the offense or hinder his development? Which one do you think I'm gonna choose?
I would say hinder the office because the, cause the offense is only going to be here for 22.
Well, we have four, 13 more games with it, right? If you're going to hinder his development,
that could impact the next year, year after next.
Like, okay. Are we keeping Caden Proctor guard full-time for his whole career or are we moving
him out to tackle? Because I, I generally know if God make God make good money, but you know,
they do, they do, but you're going to do whatever is right for the Miami dolphins right now.
And I think one of the things that is right for them right now is keeping their first overall
pick of this new regime in a comfortable position because at the very, at the very least, right.
And we saw this with Chris Johnson, who had a great game on Sunday. We're seeing this with Jacob
who's had great games. He kind of struggled in coverage on Sunday, but at the very least,
yeah. Cause Jordan Brooks, certainly at the very least though, this regime can point to those
workers and say, look, look how well they're playing. As if like the guys that are hurting us
aren't, aren't our guys. Trust us because we know what's going to go. Am I wrong?
But maybe a lot of the things that they're calling are favoring to the rookies. And
because sometimes in the first two games, I'm sorry, you had Austin Jackson out there,
but naked was less. It was that really the best approach? Like, um, um, we'll cast Merrick.
I'm sorry. I would be, I, you know how you got to walk like in the buddy system in elementary
school. We'd be on a buddy system right now. We'll cast Merrick. Like we'd be me and you,
we together, like we got to hold hands. We together, like I'm sorry. And I have an
appreciation for Austin Jackson. I believe in Austin Jackson. I can't tell you that he had a
good camp. It was okay. I can tell you he's a starter cause he was your best option. We are
now a month into the program where you've got three decent prospects at tackle and nobody knows
what they, yeah, three, I'll give you, uh, my, my, what my face is because the operative word,
they're decent. I don't know if you can, I don't know if you, from what you saw,
granted it was a small sample. So what did you see with Kate and Wallace and training?
What did it give you faith? Okay. Okay. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. But that was also
somebody who just got here was just learning the system. Um, this guy's a former third round pick.
Yeah. Yeah. He flamed out in new England. Okay. No problem. But things happen. Guys flame out.
I'm not saying that this is the right answer. Hell we could go Jared Kingston.
The issue that I have right now is we can't keep having, I evaluate coaches based on how they
address and fix problems. We can't keep having the problem in week five that we had week one
and two, two issues that have need to be fixed. In my opinion, your coverage of tight ends,
you better figure something out because every team is going to put their game plan together
on Monday and Tuesday, and it's going to be carved you up with whatever tight end we got
every single week because you ain't stopping it yet. And, and the other game plan is going to be
attack Austin Jackson because he's been the weak link right now. And what are you going to do
about that? Jeff? How, how are we going to fix this? Like it's a problem and it's not going
anywhere. So either you find a replacement or you come up with a new strategy to give them some help.
Um, what would you say? Yeah, I'm just, I'm just like, it's like between a rock and a hard place.
Last week you weren't between a rock and a hard place figuring out what you did
a tailback with dog Devon H and that's the job. That's why you get paid millions and millions of
dollars. Um, speaking of Devon H and Ollie Gordon,
hundred yards. Uh, I would honestly tell you that surprised both of us. Let's be honest.
Uh, I'm not necessarily sitting here telling you that this was all Ollie's doing because I think
the offensive line created better holes for him in the second half. I think Ollie is a,
is a kind of back that he can, he takes a minute to get up to speed. And when he does get up to
speed, it's good. Um, but are you surprised that you didn't get much from Jalen? Right?
Not necessarily. Like I, I'm not, uh, I think sometimes with Jalen, right. I personally don't
know if any of these guys are as much as they keep saying, like, these are zone, uh, guys that
don't really see that, but it's okay. So I'm not surprised that Jalen didn't have a good game
because I feel like sometimes with, with, with, with the zone to me, it's like, once you see the
hole, you got to hit it, but you got to go with, with, with like gap schemes. It's like, okay,
we're going to create this hole. And then he runs through it. This one is like, you know,
you see it, then go. I don't know. That's like, yeah, it's more on reading and it's like,
I don't know if he's necessarily that type of player. Um, so I'm not surprised that he didn't
play well. No, that doesn't surprise me. I think there, there will be games that he plays better.
I think what did surprise me, he was the first running back on that field. Like he technically
was the starting running back. That kind of surprised me a little bit. I mean, not, not
not really. I told you if you're going to, yeah, but I mean, her down back, I guess.
So, I mean, if he's not the third down bag, what else I'm going to do with him? That's true. I
guess I'll be making the third down back and use Jalen right. As the platoon back, like not,
not to say that that's probably what it's going to be this week. Cause you know, I'm, I'm a big
believer in you keep, you keep what you kill. This is a, um, I forget what movie it is. Uh,
pitch black. Uh, um, um, I have no clue. It's a series of movies. It's, it was two movies. I
forget what you keep, what you kill. If you kill it, the X triple X. No, no, not triple X. Ah,
I'll get it to you in a minute.
Give me a second. Um, but Ali has earned a starting spot. Let's be real. I agree. Um,
now the question is, can Jalen right. Find a role for himself. I think he should be able to,
I don't know. You know what? I think a lot of times with certain players, it's about mental.
Right. And I think chronicles of Riddick. Okay. If you haven't seen it and pitch black was the
first one, by the way. Um, but the chronicles of Riddick and you keep what you kill. So
you kill, kill that game. Molly, you keep, I agree. And I, I think, you know, with Jalen,
at some point it becomes mental. Right. Um, and I thought that he had kind of exercised
some of those demons heading into training camp because he was on a, you know, he said he found
God. He said, I mean, yeah, I mean, I had hoped he did because I don't, I don't like getting blamed
for it. Cause he's a guy that's very much. So like all the media hates me and it's like, all
right. Like, I don't, I don't think we hate you. I think like, you know, we're expecting more of
you and we don't deliver on that. It's our job to say like, yeah, we expect more of him, but he
doesn't deliver. And so look, like I look, I think each week's a new week. Right. And the thing
about not having to bond HN anymore is I think every game you have an opportunity to prove
yourself. So I hope and pray that against the Bengals that, you know, of course they have a
Dexter Lawrence. I'm on that, on that defensive line. Yeah. I'm not going to say his next,
his nickname. I ain't going to call another. Dexy, Dexy. I ain't going to call another
grown man. You do what you want, but I just, I mean like, look, it's another opportunity for
you to go out and do what you have to do. And if it doesn't happen that, that,
if it doesn't happen this week, then you have a bye week and then come out.
And you gotta be, you gotta be ready. You gotta be ready. You gotta be ready. Like,
I don't, I think like it, I think it would do more harm than good if he's so focused,
hyper-focused on this game. And what is it? Five carries seven yards. Of course,
that's not a good game. No one, he was, he was, he was upset. He was visibly upset. Yeah. I felt
bad for him. Yeah. I, you know, you know, I've been doing this for 19 years. I, I, I know when
the mental part of the game is just as important as the physical part. And when a guy starts to
get down on themselves or starts to feel like they lost their opportunity and getting the dumps,
it's not easy. It's not easy. And it's not easy to pick yourself back up. Now I will say this,
it's on the coaching staff to pick him up. And I don't think that's going to be an issue with Jeff
Halfley. That's the one thing that I think I have realized he's very good at is communicating and
lifting guys up and being honest with them. Okay. You missed your opportunity this time.
Bengals right here. We're going to give you, we're going to give you, we're going to give
you plenty of opportunity. Prove every doubter that you have wrong. And, and I'm at the point
where I'm rooting for him, but you know, but at just like Austin Jackson, Tom's a click ticking
my brother and we need to get the job done and we move on. And that's this, that's the part of the
NFL game. I say this too. How many times have I said to you, the NFL is about when opportunity
presents itself, you seizing on it, you doing what it takes to, to separate yourself. And
that didn't happen. Um, since I'm so negative and everybody always loves calling me negative,
I want to go over Isaiah, some of the positives of, of this game.
Oh, I don't have any. I was, I was asking you, Oh, you want me? Oh, Oh, easy. Well,
at least just wrote a story about this. Uh, Jacob Rodriguez set the rookie record for tackles with 18
eclipsed the mark set by a fellow, uh, you know, red Raider in Zach Thomas in 1996,
18 times. And that's insane. Like that. And one of the things that Jeff, I mean,
TJ Hawkinson had 13 receptions. So somebody had to get them down. But anyway, let me get,
I'm going to be more respectful. He ball, he ball, he ball, he ball. I mean,
with the acceptance, I didn't cover she ball. Okay. I mean, yeah, but not all of those were
on him. There's another guy, Jordan Brooks, that isn't the best in coverage either. Like
people act like people acting like his extension was because of his past coverage.
Come on now. That's not, that's not why you got extended. That's not at all. Why you got
extended. And one of the things that I think happily was really proud of him in that regard
was because look, like you were there, like that Viking, um, stadium is loud. It's loud. It's,
it's, it's hectic. And for a rookie to go in there and call the defense and the defense played
probably their best game of the year. They didn't allow a touchdown.
Like they got four sacks, right? You got to give some credit to the rookie for calling that defense.
So that's one positive. Second one, Chris Johnson, man, coverage pretty much locked down. Like
didn't really, you know, a lot of the, the, the big plays that were, that weren't his band.
Right. So got to give credit where credit's due for him. And he's taken a big step. I thought
he played well against chiefs as well. So that's back-to-back weeks where, you know, he played
well. Another positive, finally the sacks, right. I think that's something that, um, you know,
can't be overlooked, right. Because they do come in bunches. I asked Josh about that today. Like,
look, what gives you confidence that, you know, you guys will be able to have that sustained success
for next week and week after. And it's like, one of the things you told me was look, man,
they do come in bunches, but now that that's like monkeys lifted off their back for a lack of a
better term, right. Like they don't have to worry about that anymore. And oh my God, we don't have
to get, we don't have a sack yet. Oh my God, we don't have a sack yet. Like they can go out there
and actually play. Right. And I think that was the very positive sign about the sack that happened
in first play. I asked him, like, what does that do for a defense? And it's like, look,
there's blood in the water. We're all sharks. We've got to go eat now. So I thought was a
great quote. I need to find a place to use that because that's, that was special, right?
So I'm at three positives right now. What, you want me to keep going? Oh, we said Ali, right?
That Ali, I think five, I'll go with, I think Chris Bell starting to come into like the guy
that we thought he was in, in, you know, when they drafted him. And here's why, right? Of course,
everyone's going to harp on him stepping out of bounds, right? Like, let's, let's, let's get
right. But he ran away from that dude, but he ran away. People forget what happened afterwards.
That's two weeks where he's finding where it seems like he's finding that he's finding that,
that second, third, I wonder what his miles per hour speed was on that play. I gotta ask Marcel.
Yeah. Like, I think that's, that's something that we can't gloss over again. Like, don't get me
wrong. Like we both agreed that like, okay, maybe he came back too early. Right. But if he's doing
what he's doing on Sunday, like what, what can we say? We can't really say much. Right. And when
I, that was one of the things I asked him about today, I was like, look, like, do you like, but
I don't care about, I mean, yes, I care about the end result on Sunday. Right. Like you did step out
of bounds. Like it was like your pick. So, you know what I immediately thought of though, now
that I'm like saying it in real time, I don't know if you remember this a couple of years ago
when KD was on the nets and they played the Bucs and Giannis and he had like a three either at the
end of regulation or, or overtime that like they had called and would have won them the game or
tied the game and gone into overtime. But he's like pinky toe or big toe was like on the line
and they caught it back. That's immediately what I thought. I was like, dang, like that's,
but that, but stuff like that, it, it, it happens. It can happen to the, to the,
the best players. It happens to the least played. So I think just for Chris Bell,
if I could give him one piece of advice, well, shake it off next play, whatever you want to get
yours. Right. So, like I said, like, and I, and so going back to what I said earlier,
I asked him point blank, do you feel like yourself? And he said, yes, he's starting to feel
like, I think another positive, Kenneth Grant is coming back. Kenneth Grant will practice this
is probably going to practice this week. I know Haffley didn't say that certain,
but I watched him warm up before the game. He looked, he ready. He looked ready.
Okay. So, and I think it's something that I'll probably write about and touch on this week.
Like, look, like everyone wants Caleb Douglas to play. He showed us a lot in that first game
that I think, you know, we are, we want to see more of, but I think if there's one benefit of
him not being there, it's that now Malik has to develop chemistry with the Chris Bell, with the
Kevin Coleman, with the Malik Washington. Right. And that scramble drill that we saw between Chris
Bell and Malik, like, of course it didn't end the way that you want it to, but it was a big tug.
Like, let's not act like he was, I don't even think it was as egregious as remember when
something similar happened in the preseason with, with Caleb Douglas, where he like stepped out of
balance and caught the ball. It wasn't even that egregious. Like Caleb had like a whole foot.
This man had his toe. So like, again, I think that there's, that we have something to build on.
Again, four sacks, two, two sacks either. I can keep going. Like I'm, I'm not, look, I'm not as,
as hardened mentally as, as you are. Oh, because you've seen, you know, this, the, what do you
call it? The mediocrity merry-go-round. You've been on it for way too long. Right. I'm, you know,
I just don't want to see the same mistakes. And that's going to happen. Like, I don't think like
I've in a perfect world. Yes. Like I wouldn't want to see the same mistakes either, but at the same
time, right? Like this is a, a, a younger team. What, what the biggest problem I had was why is
Parchett Park getting called for three holes? It's it's, but that's the thing. It's the veterans
making mistakes. It's the veterans. It's like, I'm sorry if I'm going to name the,
the worst starter on the team, it's Austin Jackson. Like why would Austin, why should
Austin Jackson be the worst star on the team? Not, there's probably a wide receiver starter,
like, but, but you get the point that I'm making. Like, yeah. It'll be interesting to see what
on Wednesday. We got the Caleb Douglas watch. Kenneth Grant is coming back. They're definitely
going to need him as a rotational player. And then we've got some other injuries that we need
to worry about, but dolphins in depth, the podcast provided to you by the Miami Herald
and the Miami Herald coverage will cover you on everything covering the dolphins.
They make sure you like subscribe. I hate when people say like, subscribe, whatever, whatever,
just it's important to like, it's important to share and it's important that you come back
because you know who feeds you well. All right. On that note, we are out. We will see you Wednesday.
All right. Don't don't exit yet.

