What Happens To A Forest After 25 Years Without Deer?

The Beauty Of Nature
21 followers
23 Video Views·Oct 6, 2026
After 25 years without deer, the forest has changed significantly. Young trees and vegetation have flourished, free from grazing. Populations of various shrubs, wildflowers, and birds have increased, creating a more diverse environment. However, the absence of deer has also disrupted the natural balance and affected the food chain.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAdam Harriton examines how white-tailed deer browsing in western Pennsylvania hinders forest regeneration. By comparing open forests with fenced exclosures, he illustrates how high deer populations strip the understory, preventing new tree growth and altering ecosystem composition, while emphasizing that recovery requires a holistic ecological approach.
Greetings everyone, I'm Adam Harriton. Welcome to the beautiful woods of western Pennsylvania.
Today I want to talk about something that I'm noticing more and more in places that look like
this, and I'm realizing a lot of people aren't paying attention to it. And I can understand why,
because if you don't spend your days wondering why things look the way that they do,
or what things used to look like, or how things might look a hundred years from now,
a lot of what I'm going to be talking about in this video could easily be overlooked,
even if you spend a lot of time in the woods. What I'm talking about involves that most
familiar wild animal in this corner of the world, the white-tailed deer. And specifically,
it involves a question that you commonly hear being debated among different groups of people,
farmers, hunters, non-hunters, gardeners, land managers, insurance agents, golf course
superintendents. The question is, are there too many deer today? And what this question actually
implies is that if there are too many, they're causing some kind of problem. Now to be clear,
I'm not going to speak on behalf of all these groups, but I do want to say something based on
what I'm seeing today in ecosystems that look like this. When I look at them, even if I don't
see a lot of deer, I still ask myself, am I seeing evidence that deer browsing pressure
is high enough that the habitat itself seems to be challenged in some way? And this is an
important distinction. When I say pressure, I'm not strictly talking about how many deer are on
the landscape, but the kinds of impacts a given number of deer can have in a particular place.
And I might be biased, but what I'm about to show you in this video is, I think, some pretty
fascinating stuff. So let's begin our discussion here in a place that's very close to my home.
Now, it's not like I grew up coming to these woods. I actually grew up not spending much
time in the woods at all. I played a lot of piano inside instead. Chopin, Bach, Beethoven, Mozart,
even the occasional Schubert. But I would say I started coming here maybe 16 years ago,
and I always knew there were deer here because I would see them, but it took me a while,
many years, to understand the kinds of effects they were having on the larger ecosystem. And
you can see it all around me if you know what you're looking at, or maybe what you're not
looking at. So these woods are what I would consider mature. The dominant trees are oaks,
and the oldest are typically in the 75 to 100 year age class. Now, when we look below that upper
canopy and bring our eyes to ground level, we see something vastly different. Open space. So much
that you can see right through the woods in some areas. And if you look closely, you'll see that
very little vegetation is growing below a certain height. And this line can actually be seen from
the outside looking in. Now, in some areas inside these woods, you do see an understory, mostly of
Japanese stilt grass, Japanese barberry, and multi-flora rose. You occasionally see plants
like white snake root and some native grasses and sedges. But in many parts, you don't really see
an understory at all. When I first started coming to these woods more than a decade ago, I actually
really appreciated all this open space because I could see mushrooms much more easily. Chanterelles,
a boatload of boletes, you name it. And if you hunt mushrooms, you know how easy it can be to
find mushrooms when there's so much open space. But I had no idea why I was seeing all this openness
and I didn't even really care at the time either. But when I started asking more questions and
thinking about it more deeply, I realized that what I was seeing was pretty incredible, especially
when I considered what a particular man-made structure inside these woods was telling me.
Here is that structure. Keep in mind I'm in the same woods. I never left. I just moved over to
the spot. So what the heck is this thing and what's it doing here? Well this is a deer exclosure fence
meant to keep deer out. I actually met the man who put this in. I met him at a mushroom foray many
years ago and he said that he installed this in the year 2000. So more than 25 years later, look
what's happening inside. We see all kinds of herbaceous plants, woody plants, and seedlings
and saplings of trees, which means tree regeneration is happening. There's red maple,
black cherry, sassafras, eastern white pine, white ash, dogwood, hickory, and at least three species
of young oaks. Now I want you to stop and think about what this means. Obviously you and I both
know that deer eat a lot of plants, but I want you to think about what kind of story the plants
inside this fence are telling us. Not just about what's going on with these woods today, but the
future of these woods. There are oaks outside this fence. I showed you a bunch of them, but the vast
majority are mature trees. Sometimes you see mid-story oaks, but you hardly see any oak seedlings
or saplings. In fact, in many places within these woods, you don't see seedlings or saplings of any
tree species. I remember a few years ago I was on a botanical walk with a group of people in these
woods, but a little bit over there, and an older man on the walk said that he would give anyone,
I think it was five dollars, if they could find an oak sapling, any oak sapling in these woods,
and he was lamenting the fact that oaks weren't regenerating, in his words, because of deer.
Well, sir, you owe me five dollars because I found a bunch of oak saplings, but maybe these don't
count because they're all locked up inside this fence. Now, you might be saying to yourself, well,
okay, I get the deer part. That makes sense. They eat a lot of plants, but couldn't there be other
factors at play, like light? I mean, these woods are pretty shaded. There's not a whole lot of
Doesn't this prevent an understory from developing? Well, yeah, light matters for sure,
but keep in mind the area within this exclosure is pretty shaded too, yet there's obvious growth
showing us that at least some seedlings can get started in these woods if deer don't eat them
first. But what about clearings in these woods? Let's say where a big oak has died and sunlight
is reaching the forest floor. Wouldn't we expect to see more seedlings and saplings there?
Well, yes, you would think, but even where light is getting through. In some areas of these woods,
you don't really see much of an understory at all, not even an understory of seedlings that
tolerate shade. And where you do see smaller trees ready to take advantage of newly created openings,
they're almost all above deer browsing height, and the majority of them are not oaks. So with
few exceptions, decent regeneration isn't really happening much outside this fence,
but it's happening here. And although it is easy to get excited and hopeful that all these young
trees will eventually all grow up and reach the canopy, that's not necessarily what will happen
because each tree growing within this fence is growing at a different rate and has different
light requirements. Some will thrive, some will be shaded out and die. Trees like red maple are
pretty tolerant of shade and can grow relatively quickly. Others like white oak are less tolerant
of shade and they don't grow as quickly as red maple. Think about what this means, especially
in the context of the so-called oak regeneration problem we're seeing in many eastern ecosystems
today. Deer may have something to do with this, but based on what we're seeing inside this fence,
deer exclusion alone might not automatically recreate the conditions that once allowed
oaks to dominate. Even if we manually thinned out some of the big oaks outside this fence so that
more sunlight could get in, it's still not guaranteed that oaks will populate the under
and mid-story levels and eventually replace the larger oaks. And this brings us to our next really
important question. How the heck did all these oaks come to dominate the canopy in the first
place? I mean conditions must have been ideal for them at some point to sprout, grow, and eventually
mature. Well a few things help to explain this. First, many of these oaks started their lives
during a time when deer browsing pressure was probably lower than it is today. Second, trees
like red maple and black cherry were less abundant and their seeds were less abundant in many of these
forests than they are today. And third, and this is a really important piece of the whole puzzle,
fire used to be much more common in certain North American ecosystems than it is today.
And where it did occur with some regularity, it had the effect of benefiting fire-adapted trees
while suppressing fire-sensitive trees. Well guess what happened as fire suppression became
increasingly widespread in the U.S. during the 20th century. Forests changed, fire-sensitive trees
like maples and cherries became increasingly more common, and fire-adapted trees like oaks found it
increasingly more difficult to regenerate. So when we look inside this fence today and see a few
younger oaks growing and seemingly thriving, it's easy to get excited and feel really hopeful. But we
shouldn't assume that they will become future dominant members of the canopy when they're
growing next to trees that grow more quickly and tolerate more shade. Now before we move on, I want
to clarify something about this idea of openness. When ecologists talk about a different kind of
ecosystem, oak woodlands and savannas that were historically maintained with fire, they're often
talking about landscapes that were open but in a different sense. Dominant trees were often spaced
farther apart and the ground layer could support rich biodiverse understories. So they were open
in that way. Here in these woods, the dominant trees are somewhat closer together and in some
places there's almost no understory at all. And yet a lot of people would also say these woods are
open. So both kinds of landscapes can be described like this, but they're open in different ways and
for very different reasons. I want to end the video today by showing you one more place because
I think it also has a lot to tell us about deer pressure. So this is another deer exclosure fence,
about the same age as that other one that I showed you. But we're in a very different kind
of forest right now. Still in Pennsylvania, this is a mature hemlock white pine forest and it's
pretty dark in here. So we shouldn't expect the same kind of understory here as we would in those
more open oak woods that I showed you. But take a look at what's growing inside this fence. Now it's
easy to think, wow, the understory is recovering inside this fence. And yeah, that's one way to
think about it. But there's a difference between the recovery here and the recovery in those oak
woods I showed you. There's a lot of rhododendron inside this fence. Dense thickets in some areas,
there's a lot of black birch, there's some decent eastern hemlock regeneration, and a few white
pines growing. Now of course deer exclusion is part of the reason we're seeing all this, but I
would say light has a lot to do with it as well. Now generally a hemlock forest is typically much
darker than an oak forest. So any understory in a closed canopy hemlock forest has to be able to
tolerate deep shade as well as the particular soil conditions under all these hemlocks. But what's
interesting is that outside this fence in this immediate area, even in the spots where there's
gap in the canopy and sunlight can come through, I'm still not seeing a whole lot of woody plant
growth. There are a couple rhododendrons scattered here and there, but nothing like what we're seeing
inside the fence. The same is true with black birch. There's not much eastern hemlock regeneration
happening, but I am seeing some decent white pine regeneration outside the fence. When we look inside
the fence, there's not much eastern white pine at all, but there's a lot of black birch. And there
are some gaps in the canopy, so this probably explains why we're seeing a lot of black birch,
but even in the shadier spots within this fence, for example where there's a big tree,
underneath all that there's still some decent plant growth. Now rhododendron adds another layer
of complexity because when it does become this dense, it can make it more difficult for plants
and seedlings to establish and grow, even those that tolerate shade like eastern hemlock. And this
brings up another important question. When deer pressure is removed, or at least reduced, will you
eventually get the kind of forest you might envision? Well, as we've seen today, the answer is
maybe, but not necessarily. It depends on many factors, which is why I keep coming back to context.
I don't think many people would argue that deer can have tremendous impacts on certain ecosystems,
but what happens when that pressure is reduced depends on the plant community, the habitats,
the disturbance history, the amount of time that has elapsed, and a lot of other things. This is
why when I walk through the woods, I don't really start by wondering how many deer are here, and is
that number good or bad? I usually start to wonder what's the larger story here, and why does any of
this matter at all? We only really talked about deer in the context of forest regeneration today,
but this is something that I really pay attention to because it tells me so much about what's going
on. And if any of this stuff interests you, and look, if you've made it this far in the video,
I'm sure at least some of this stuff means something to you, then I encourage you to develop
this kind of ecological literacy. It's like a big old book out here, it really is. This place is full
of all kinds of stories. The question is, do you care enough to learn how to read them? Thank you
so much for watching this video, I truly appreciate it. I hope you enjoyed it, I hope you learned
something. If you'd like to support this channel, please subscribe to the Learn Your Land YouTube
channel, head on over to learnyourland.com, sign up for the email newsletter so that we can stay
in touch, and check out my online courses on ecology, tree identification, and mushroom foraging.
Thanks again for watching, I will see you on the next video.
