This MLB Insider is SUPER High on The Mets...
1 Video View·Oct 5, 2026
This MLB insider is stoked about the Mets future. Despite a disappointing season,
MLB Network's Joel Sherman has officially named the Mets the number one rookie class
in the 2026 season, highlighted by Nolan McClain, probable rookie of the year Carson Benj, A.J.
Ewing, and yes, Zach Thornton as well. What's going on guys? I'm Josh Byrne. You're tuned
into Mets Digest. Guys, thank you for all the support this season. It does mean a lot if you've
been enjoying the daily updates and you are not subscribed. Please do consider doing so as it
helps out the channel a ton. Now, Joel Sherman's the guy we've all heard about as baseball followers,
baseball fans. Some of us really like him. Some of us don't, and that's totally okay because all
of these writers have their own definitive voice, their own flavor about how they go about writing
and covering the game, and they're all going to have their critics. But the fact is, is that Joel
Sherman is one of those names that's synonymous with the writers of baseball and one of the most
influential, prominent, articulate people speaking about the game today. And what he says is going to
be heard, it's going to be seen by a lot of the people covering the game. And that includes people
within the major league baseball industry, people within organizations, and what the media is saying,
media members such as Joel Sherman are saying, is going to impact how teams are viewed, how rosters
are perceived, and everything in between. And so MLB Network last week officially tweeted
an insight from Joel Sherman that he thinks the Mets had the best rookie class this season. They
asked, do you agree? I do agree. I think I've made my opinion on this abundantly clear, but it cannot
be undersold in the slightest. The Mets had the best rookie class in the season, which is really
unbelievable when you consider the fact that this was a Mets team with an over-under coming into the
season around 90 games, and they finished 16 games below that mark, yet there is so much reason to be
optimistic about the future, starting with Carson Bench, who in my view is the clear front-runner
for National League Rookie of the Year. Why? Well, we've covered it on the channel, but
in summation, the guy does everything you want well. He can steal bases, he can hit for power,
he can play terrific defense, boasting the best arm of any right fielder in major league baseball,
and oh yeah, he's 23 years old, he'll be 24 next season. This all comes after he was basically
invisible in his first month with the New York Mets at the major league level, and outside of
that month, his OPS was well above 800 for the remainder of the season. You see, the reason why
the Mets fell short this year was because they couldn't rely on veteran players making a lot of
money, whether that be Juan Soto, Francisco Lundor due to injuries, and due to both of them by the
playing below their career averages, or you look towards David Peterson, not the highest paid
player by any means, but a veteran guy who came in with higher expectations, was extremely
disappointing for the Mets. Freddie Peralta brought in, extremely disappointing, but this
rookie class was absolutely one of, if not the best classes in major league baseball this year.
And then you look at AJ Ewing, and AJ Ewing, similarly to Carson Bench, had a moment this
season where he was in the doldrums, okay? And I was extremely high on him, because unlike
Carson Bench, right out of the gate, that's when AJ Ewing looked really impressive. But Bench,
he struggled early on, then he got going, and it was in high gear the rest of the way.
Ewing, he got it going immediately, then he hit a big rough patch, and then got it going again at
the end of the year. You look at the numbers he finished with, the OPS right at 700, right around
league average, but if you factor in his well above average defense, and his electric base running,
there's a lot to like. And it's been a while since we have seen the Mets with such a young,
exciting core of playmakers who can cause havoc both in the field, making sparkling plays,
and on the base paths. This is easily going to be, next season, the most athletic Mets team
in quite some time, if it was not already this year, but hopefully with some more complementary
pieces built around that. And then you move on to the pitching, and Zach Thornton, and unlike AJ
Ewing and Carson Bench, I don't believe Zach Thornton was on anybody's radar coming into this
season. He certainly wasn't on my radar. When he was initially called up in June to start for the
Mets, I thought it was just another ho-hum, band-aid, spot start. Nothing wrong with that.
Every year you see young guys making their major league debut as a spot starter, and a lot of times
they are not, you know, high-profile prospects. And that was the case for Thornton. He was not a
high-profile prospect. He wasn't on Baseball America's Top 100. Heck, he probably wasn't on
the Top 200. But he certainly played like it. And what's fascinating about Zach Thornton is that
he's a lefty pitcher who pitches to contact, which reminds you a lot of David Peterson.
What's even more fascinating is that David Peterson was traded to the Cubs, the first
domino to fall about a month or maybe a little bit more than a month before the official trade
deadline. It would ultimately be a sellout for the Mets. And around the time he was traded,
Thornton was brought up and he would not surrender his role at the big league level. And he was
splendid. Provided a huge upgrade for the Mets versus what they were working with with David
Peterson, a guy who has the same pitching style but put up very different results than the veteran
Peterson. And this isn't to knock Peterson. Peterson, in my view, will go down as a very
good Met. You think about what he did, especially in 2024, I thought was extremely impressive.
And even in 2022, he had some pretty good moments as well. But nonetheless, he's not here anymore,
and Zach Thornton is. And Thornton, I believe, has the potential to be better than David Peterson
ever was. Now, do I see him as a frontline starter? Well, when you look at these numbers of
3.42 ERA, 84 innings pitched across 15 starts, you would take that out of your number three.
The advanced metrics do not back up the extent of success that Thornton have. However, I will
provide a disclaimer on that in that the hard-hit metrics and the underlying savant pages are not
ever going to fare perfectly well with pitchers such as that Zach Thornton. Why? Well, because
he is a contact pitcher, because he pounds the strike zone, he is relying on contact,
and therefore, his contact rate will be higher, as will his hard-hit rate. Now, there are things
he can do to short-circuit that, and Zach Thornton has talked about improving his velocity. And I
don't want him to hyperfixate on improving the velocity, but the reality is, if he can get his
fastball average from about 92, where it is now, to maybe 94 or 95, like he's talking about,
that would firmly put him, in my view, as one of the frontline starters for the Mets going forward.
Do I expect that? No. But as a back-of-the-line rotation piece, which is of the utmost importance
these days, given the lack of depth that starting rotations generally don't have, that is huge.
That is huge. And of course, Nolan McClain, who barely kept his rookie status after making about
eight starts in 2025, and came into 2026 with about as much hype as a pitcher can have. Did
he live up to it? Look, I don't think it's fair to say whether he did or did not, because frankly,
there was so much hype about Nolan McClain coming into this past season, that he probably never was,
and frankly, he probably didn't live up to it. That being said, he had a darn good season.
He stayed healthy, he made 31 starts, an ERA just above 3.1, and just below 200 strikeouts,
and he really got better after the month of May. Because he started off a little wobbly,
a little up and down, especially in the month of May. And after that, he was the pitcher that we
have come to expect after what he did in 2025. And now we fully expect him to be a frontline starter.
There's a lot of talk and a lot of smoke about the Mets potentially making a splash move this
offseason for an ace. And I think it's going to be hard for them to find a pitcher better,
more talented than Nolan McClain, to lead this staff unless they do get Tarek Scuba, which they
may in fact do. But if they do not become successful in their pursuit of him, then Nolan McClain is
your ace, and I'm comfortable with him being so. And don't forget, Jonah Tong was also a rookie
this season. Him coming up in September made him lose his rookie status for next year,
but Jonah Tong was a guy who went through a lot of adversity this year.
Quite a bit of it. And his September was huge for me. It was just as, if not more important
than a guy like A.G. Ewing getting his swagger back and getting hot at the right time, or at
least at the end of the season to get his numbers on track. Because Jonah Tong was really struggling
in AAA for the majority of the season. And there were a lot of skeptics and people who were
changing their view of what he could be and what his potential is after he had such a wildly
dominant 2025 campaign in the minors. But, slowly but surely, in July, he got things together.
And in August, he was even better. And for the most part, it did carry over to the big leagues.
These numbers encompass both relief appearances and starting appearances for Jonah Tong. But a
3A2 ERA finishing the season with his last start being five innings, one run, and nine strikeouts
gives you immense hope. And all of a sudden, McLean, Thornton, and Tong are three rookie
pitchers from this season with at least a significant amount of optimism provided by
what they did in this prior campaign. Not to mention the most likely National League rookie,
the Aaron Carson bench, and what should be the Mets' everyday center fielder moving forward
in AJ Ewing. And with that, it makes total sense why an MLB insider like Joel Sherman,
amongst many others, are very high on the New York Mets and their rookie class.
If David Stearns can build off of this and build a fundamentally sound roster with the highest
payroll in baseball, with the most resources, it's something that doesn't sound like it should
be too difficult, but he's made it look that way. And there has never been more pressure on him
than right now. David Stearns, get it done. We have the foundation and he needs to tie it all
together. Let me know what you guys think about Joel Sherman's analysis here, as well as what
you're thinking overall about this rookie class of the Mets and how far they can take them and
what the Mets need to do in order to improve the roster around them. Comment below, let me know,
and as always, guys, let's go Mets.

