Dennis Prager joins PragerU CEO Marissa Streit to discuss Prime Minister Netanyahu’s address to the United Nations and what the walkout during his speech reveals about the UN and the moral state of the West. Dennis examines what he calls an “age of moral confusion,” asking what happens when compassion comes at the expense of justice and why morality must come before politics or economics.
Why we live in the age of moral confusion Compassion versus justice, from a New York subway attack to the Lindsay Clancy case Gender surgeries on minors, and biological men in women's sports Why morality comes before everything, including the debate over Iran The midterms, gas prices, and the war with Iran The walkout during Prime Minister Netanyahu's speech at the United Nations Hostility toward Israel in Spain and Ireland, and what Islamists and the left agree on Why Dennis remains in love with America, and what disappoints him Viewer question from Utah — How does Dennis stay happy through hardship? Viewer question — How has music played a role in his recovery? Viewer question from Sweden — How should a student push back against leftist ideas in school? Viewer question from Portugal — How should anyone answer the so-called deaths of capitalism? Viewer question from Buena Park — Should a woman without brothers keep her maiden name? George Washington's meeting with a Jewish financier named Prager
Join PragerUnited today and submit your question for Dennis to answer during an upcoming episode ⏩ https://l.prageru.com/4g56Ph9
Hi, Dennis.
It's hard to believe that it's already October, and we'd love to hear your thoughts.
I don't know if you know this story.
It happened in May.
Two women, two young women on the New York subway were attacked by a guy.
And luckily for them, and happily, the New York City Police Department showed up in time
to save them.
When it came time to prosecute the guy, one of the women who spoke for both of them said,
we're not cooperating with the prosecution because we don't want to send another black
man to prison.
The guy was sent to a hospital, a mental hospital, let out an hour later, and a few hours later
threw an old man down steps at a New York subway station and murdered him.
That's one story.
Here's a story from a few years ago that I think about a lot.
It's, I guess, if it's possible, it's even more dramatic.
And that is a young German woman was sexually assaulted by an illegal immigrant from a Muslim
country.
And she refused to testify against him because she didn't want Germans to have a bad impression
of immigrants from Muslim countries.
She was the daughter of a major German official at the EU, the European Union.
There is so much to unpack in these stories.
And I could give example after example.
You know, all the women who have been demonstrating on behalf of Lindsay Clancy, for example.
The fact is that women's inclination is toward compassion and nurturing.
Men's is towards justice.
That's a very big difference.
Justice is a masculine value and nurturing is a feminine value.
We need both.
But when it's tipped over, way over in one direction, look the other example is all the
children's hospitals that have done terrible surgeries on minors or young adults who say
that they're a member of the opposite sex.
It's mind blowing.
It's just mind blowing.
And it's almost all women in these children's hospitals and in the whole movement, the whole
transgender movement, even when it hurts women.
Now why would women support men, biological men playing in women's sports?
It hurts women because it's not just.
And justice is a masculine value, as I just said.
So women are in the forefront of hurting women, let alone an old man in the New York subway.
So those are signs of our times.
The bigger point is that we live in the age of moral confusion.
And it's getting really, really frightening.
And I don't get scared easily, but it is frightening.
But I'll tell you, and this will not win me popularity points, but that's, I'll have to
live with that.
19% of Americans, according to polls, 19.
That's a drop less than one out of five supports our efforts, our military efforts against Iran.
It's not like we're talking about Iraq.
This is not thousands of troops, innumerable casualties, Iraqis dying.
Do you know the vast majority, virtually every Iranian that has died by violence in the last
half year was murdered by their regime.
45,000 were machine gunned to death.
Some were put in burial packets without even dying and then buried alive.
It's a monstrous regime.
And then I read constantly and I got to say, it's disappointing.
The price of gas has gone up, not even dramatically, and it's mostly due to states like California
where they've gone up because of taxes, but they've gone up somewhat.
And because of that, four fifths of Americans really believe that depriving Iran of nuclear
weapons and ballistic missiles and the ability to attack America, Europe, and first of all,
Israel, because that's what it really wants to do, destroy Israel.
What kind of moral weighing is that?
Nobody's talking about the moral issue.
All we hear about is, you know, Bill Clinton's old line, it's the economy stupid, but it's
not just the economy stupid.
I said weeks ago, I believe I said it to you, my first is not America first.
My first is morality first, and you would think that every religious Christian would
share that with me, not to mention religious Jews.
Morality comes before everything.
That's number one, but it's not number one anymore, and I got to tell you, it's painful.
I love this country so much, and it is so painful to see what has happened because of
education and the internet and social media.
This is really stuff for people to worry about, the age of moral confusion in which we live.
Dennis, as we speak about morality, you may have watched Bibi Netanyahu's speech at the
United Nations, where 77 countries, or at least members of those countries, walked out
in the middle of his speech.
Yeah, what does that tell you about the United Nations and about the nations who make up
the membership of the United Nations?
They walked out.
In other words, we don't recognize him as the head of a country.
It's a regime, but it's not a country.
That's the UN.
The United Nations has condemned Israel more than it has condemned all other countries
combined in its history.
That's because of the staggering number of Muslim-majority countries.
They walk out.
He's not worth listening to.
He doesn't represent a real country.
What's interesting is actually some of the Muslim countries that have stayed during Bibi
Netanyahu's speech are the UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, even China, which isn't Muslim.
They stayed.
Yet, you saw countries like Brazil, Chile, Turkey, Cuba, Spain, Bolivia, I mean, countries
that I don't know that you would have expected Spain to walk out of Bibi Netanyahu's speech.
Oh, I would expect Spain to do that.
Spain and Ireland are the two most Israel-hating countries in Europe.
The Irish team just played last week between Ireland and Israel.
They would not shake the hands of the Israeli players.
That's the amount of Jew-hatred or Israel-hatred that is fostered in Ireland today.
And the same holds true for Spain.
There are really only two things that Muslim, or if you will, Islamist and leftist countries
agree on.
Israel is evil and America is imperialist.
That's it.
They have nothing else in common.
If Ireland played the Iranian team, would the Irish players shake their hands?
Would they shake the hands of the Chinese team?
Of course, but not Israel.
What do you think the impact of the war in Iran or the situation in Israel is going to
be on America's midterms?
Most of us who live here are very focused on the future of our country.
People are claiming that one of the reasons why Republicans might lose the midterms is
because of the war in Iran.
You mentioned the economy.
How should we address these midterms?
Some people are even saying that the way to hold Republicans accountable because they're
not doing what's best for America is to stay out and not even vote during the midterms
right now.
This is some faction of the extreme right wing that we're seeing all over the internet,
sadly.
Yeah.
It's real.
Well, that's what I was talking about now.
That 20% of Americans support the military actions.
It's almost silly to say war, but the military actions against Iran, what can one say?
It's a depressing statistic that Americans would vote for the party of Mandani and all
these democratic socialists who are really Marxist-Leninists.
They would vote for them because of the price of gas or because they don't want to bother
shaking up the Iranian regime.
I'm telling you, it's a very difficult thing.
I'm really bearing my emotions here.
It's a very difficult thing to be in love and then disappointed.
I've been in love with America.
I've written about it constantly.
I've talked about it.
I remain in love with the founders of America.
I remain in love with middle America.
I remain in love with America's values, the American trinity, as I've dubbed it, but it's
very disappointing that New York City voted for a communist Islamist.
People as recently as 10 years ago would not have imagined that possible.
And now in Michigan, this El-Sayed is favored to win a Senate seat.
The man who goes around campaigning with Hassan Piker, who hates this country, hates the West,
wants Israel destroyed.
What's happened?
Well, I would say that if the Prager United membership is any sign of the fact that some
people are willing to wake up and do something, then there is something positive to share.
You'd be amazed that we have Prager United members from all over the world.
The number of questions that we have coming in is outstanding, but also where they're
coming from, Sweden and Portugal.
I regret that I'm not going to be able to read all of them today, but I'm going to read
some of them to you and also acknowledge how grateful we are to the Prager United members
who are sustaining this program.
Dennis, this first one is from Henry.
He is 14 years old from Utah.
And he is asking, I was just wondering, how do you stay so happy through your hardship?
You're one of my biggest role models.
Thank you, Dennis.
From the very beginning, right after my accident, as soon as I could think clearly, I knew I
had three choices, and they were death, depression, or perseverance.
I don't want to be depressed.
That frightens me, the thought about being depressed.
And I love life, including now.
I love it.
I love living.
I love life.
I love what I do.
I love my friends.
I love my wife and my children and my grandchildren.
And I love my music.
I mean, my God, my love cup runneth over.
So what's my choice?
That's a very important attitude everybody should have.
What is your choice?
To lie in bed with self-pity, is that your choice?
I mean, that is truly the road to depression.
I don't feel sorry for myself.
Almost ever.
And believe me, I do not deny what a crappy condition it is to be paralyzed on all four limbs.
At the same time, I also believe there is rational, not irrational, rational reason for hope.
There is a drug that's being tested by the FDA.
The problem is, which by the way, has been almost 100% successful with paralyzed patients,
but they need a third test.
And that means another two years.
And that bothers me.
But be that as it may, everybody should ask,
what is my choice?
And I gave the three choices.
It makes it pretty clear.
I only have one choice.
I want to thank Henry for his question.
And Henry, the fact that you wrote in and asked that is a very good sign
that you're a young, deep man.
Dennis, there's so many questions in here that ask us about your love of music.
And specifically, given that you love music so much,
how has music played a role in your recovery during this time?
This may surprise people.
I don't listen to music to make me happy.
I, if I'm not happy, which is relatively rare, but it's certainly been a chunk of time.
Since my accident, I did not listen to music.
This will almost be two years.
Since the accident, the first year, I didn't listen to any music.
I have to be in a basically positive, my normal positive state of being
in order to enjoy music.
I don't rely on it to make me happy.
Oddly enough, it's not an antidepressant.
Once I feel okay, I'm crazy about it.
Then it brings me immense joy.
This question is from Jasper 22 from Sweden.
Hello, Mr. Prager.
How should I stand against our school system trying so hard to hammer leftist ideas
into our head?
I don't know what you can do in Sweden.
A mass re-education of all Western societies has to take place.
The left has conquered the West.
Whether it will survive it or not, I have no idea, but it has definitely conquered it.
The almost universal disdain for Israel and the acceptance of one of the biggest lies in my
lifetime, that Israel is committing genocide, this is living proof about the effects that the left
now compounded by most of the Muslim immigrants and their children in these countries.
It's an uphill battle.
Jasper, marry a woman who shares your values and homeschool your children.
Okay, so this one is from Dino 17 from Lisbon, Portugal.
Hi, Dennis.
Many times when I confront left-wing people with the deaths of communism, 100 million and counting,
they're quick to throw out an argument.
Oh, this is nothing in comparison to the deaths of capitalism.
And then they start to count every death and attribute them to capitalism.
What's the best way to answer so-called deaths of capitalism?
I got to admit, that's a new one to me.
So, I'm curious, where were the capitalist gulags?
Did I miss them?
Where were the capitalist killing fields like in Cambodia?
Where were the deliberate capitalist-induced famines like in Ukraine and China?
What are they talking about?
And who murdered anybody in the name of capitalism?
Capitalism is responsible for lifting the majority of humanity out of abject poverty
for the first time in human history.
What has communism done other than enslave and murder?
Oh my God, I was so curious what he was going to say their answer to that is.
All right.
So, this one is from James, 23-year-old from Buena Park, California.
Hi, Dennis.
How would you respond to a woman who doesn't want to change her last name after marriage
because all her siblings are female and she doesn't want her maiden name to die?
All of her siblings are female.
So, all the siblings, presumably, are changing their last names.
So, it's fallen upon her to keep up that last name.
That's very noble, but it sounds a bit odd.
What I would do, I've long believed in this.
Do you know why JFK is John Fitzgerald Kennedy?
Fitzgerald was his mother's maiden name.
He was given it as a child.
So, the mother perpetuated the last name by giving it as the middle name to her child,
to her son.
That seems to be a perfect response to me.
But I could tell you this.
If I have two sons, but if I had two daughters, I would want them to take the names of their
husbands, even if that ended Prager for whatever time it is.
By the way, talking about Prager, my brother, Professor of Medicine at Columbia,
called me right before I went on with you.
A fellow doctor at Cornell, my brother's at Columbia, a physician at Cornell,
sent my brother an email noting that he's reading this very long biography of George Washington.
And on page 593, it says that Washington had a meeting with a prominent Jewish
financier named Mark Prager.
So, how do you like that?
George Washington met with a Jewish guy named Prager, because Prager is both non-Jew and Jew.
And there you go.
I got a big kick out of that.
How fun.
History is full of treasures of fun.
Yeah.
Well, Dennis, thank you again for this great segment.
We absolutely cannot wait to see you on October 15th in Miami.
Many people have already got their tickets and their tables, and we just keep praying
that this is going to be a wonderful evening where we can actually see you in person.
And for those of you who haven't had a chance to get your tickets, make sure that you do so
quickly because we're going to run out of seats very soon.
And so, until then, Dennis, thank you so much.
Be well and healthy, and God bless you all.
Well, thank you, Marissa.
I'm looking forward to next week.