The BRUTAL Truth About The German Shepherd Breed

Dog Training
13 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 5, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA professional dog trainer explains why German Shepherds often become \"reactive\" and difficult to manage. He emphasizes that the breed's history as a high-drive working dog, combined with poor breeding practices and a lack of proper mental stimulation, often leads to behavioral issues in domestic settings.
Every single week, I get messages from families saying that my German Shepherd is the most
reactive dog ever, and I am seriously ready to give up on this dog. But what they didn't know
is maybe they didn't do anything wrong. Now, as a pro dog trainer, the German Shepherd is easily
the most popular breed that we train at my facility. And here's the thing you should know
before we move on. The German Shepherd sitting in your living room right now might be a completely
different animal than the one that was bred, let's say, 100 years ago. Now, a lot of people
just think a German Shepherd is a German Shepherd, and a lab is a lab, and a retriever is a retriever.
That's not how it works. And if you're thinking about getting a German Shepherd, what I'm about
to show you could save you thousands of dollars, months of even years of stress, and honestly,
could save a dog's life. Now, the German Shepherd wasn't invented to sit on your couch and cuddle.
Of course, they are fluffy and they are cute, but that's not what they're supposed to be doing.
You see, back in the late 1800s, a man named Max von Stefanitz out to create the ultimate
working dog, one that could herd, guard, and problem solve without constant instruction,
without somebody saying, hey, go here, do this, don't do this, don't do that. These dogs needed
to go out and work and think on their own. And that's why these dogs became the backbone of
police canine units, military working dog programs, and search and rescue teams. Now, of course,
we're talking about an animal engineered for high drive, high intelligence, and most importantly,
high endurance. They could literally work all day. And that's the good news. It's also exactly
why this breed causes so many problems in the average home. So let's break this down to the
three biggest reasons why I tell people to think twice. Now, this isn't a hit piece out on German
Shepherds. We see a lot of them and I love working with them only under certain circumstances,
but let's dive into number one. Plain and simple, guys, overbreeding. Because German Shepherds are
so freaking popular, they've become a cash grab for certain backyard breeders and commercial
breeding operations, including a lot of large scale breeding out of the Amish country.
Guys, anytime something gets popular, there's people that just want to make money, money,
money, money. So they go, oh, I'm going to try to recreate that over and over again. And I want to
be clear with you guys and honest. This isn't about bashing the breed. I can't say that enough.
It's about supply and demand when it comes to breeds. And when a breed is in this demand,
corners get cut. These operations aren't breeding for temperament or working drive or even health.
They're breeding for volume and for money. And that lack of careful breeding, you guys,
it shows up later on. Not right now when you bring that little cute fluff ball home. And that's what
surprises so many people. They bring this dog home. They go, oh, this is great. This is awesome.
This was something I've always wanted. I found it on Craigslist for an affordable price. This is
amazing. The dog at that point is not going to likely be showing signs of any of the issues
that are about to happen. Which brings us to the reason number two is training requirements. Now,
again, if you don't know, I've been training dogs for over a decade. So this is something I'm
deeply passionate about, but also am an expert at. Remember what I said earlier about the breed
being engineered for that high drive? That doesn't just disappear because your German Shepherd lives
in a suburban backyard. And this is where a lot of people start to lose control with really any dog,
specifically the German Shepherd. Because a tired, structured German Shepherd is a joy
to live with. A bored, under-stimulated one, now that's a completely different story.
These dogs need real training, real structure, and real mental stimulation. Not just, guys,
we're not talking about, let's just bring the dog for a walk when we get home from work. Let's walk
my dog in the morning before we go to work. Guys, they need more than that. And without it,
that intelligence and that energy gets redirected into things that you don't want. Destructive
behavior like chewing, excessive barking, jumping fences, or even worse, becoming aggressive,
starting to take all that frustration, snapping back at you, going after other dogs. These dogs
are absolutely no joke, but most people just get them and they don't think of these things.
Now, the last and final risk of getting a German Shepherd is simple, the reactivity risk. If you
Because most people don't realize that the German Shepherd are naturally super vocal dogs. They are
alert breeds. They were literally bred to sound the alarm and to be suspicious of strangers and
to react to things in their environment to get people and get other animals' attention. Now,
that's a feature in the dog, not necessarily a problem or a bug. And when it's in a stable,
well-bred dog with proper training, they go, hey, somebody's here. You go, hey, don't worry
about it. They go, okay, fine. That does not happen with the dogs that are getting backyard
bred. But combine that natural wariness with that unstable genetics we were just talking about,
you get a dog with a predisposition to be reactivity before it even leads the breeder.
Add that in with an inexperienced owner who doesn't know how to manage that temperament,
and you've got a recipe for a dog that lunges, barks, and reacts to everything from joggers,
other dogs, the mailman, the Amazon driver, to other people, et cetera. You can't have people
over. The dog is a nightmare to walk. That's why I get these messages every single week. It's
rarely one single thing that causes it. It's genetics, it's lack of outlet, it's a lack of
structure, all kind of coming into one. So does this mean you should never get a German Shepherd,
Tom? No, not at all. Like I said before, I love German Shepherds, and a lot of people have really
well-bred, nice-tempered, trained German Shepherd. But most people, you need to go into getting a
and know exactly what you're signing up for, and be ready to put in the work from day one.
And guys, that's exactly why I've built all my dog training courses, to give people the tools
and understanding and the knowledge to know what to do if their dog is reactive or their dog is
pulling them or whatever. If you guys have a dog that is reactive on the leash, drags you down the
road, you guys can find all my information on my dog training courses in the link below.
But back to the German Shepherd. Now, again, guys, I do like the German Shepherd. I don't
you guys to think like, oh, well, Tom doesn't like German Shepherds. I do videos all the time
about different breeds. And the reality is, is I'm literally the person who people bring these dogs
to, to go, hey, something's not right. Okay. And now what am I seeing? I'm collecting all that
data. I have all this evidence to go, hmm. Now, granted, I'm not getting the perfect well-bred
German Shepherds or the perfect well-bred Rottweilers or the Corsos, et cetera. I don't
see a lot of those in my training facility because well, they're perfect, right? So I just
want to be fair, but however, we do see so many German Shepherds coming in with all different
issues. And from the bottom of my heart, please make sure that you guys do your research on the
breeder and on the breed of dog that you're getting, because that matters so much. If you
get a German Shepherd and their temperament is great, and they just love people and they're
chill and they're just beautiful dogs that like to go for walks and like to run around and play
Frisbee and do all the dog things, you guys don't have to put in as much work as somebody who gets
a poorly bred German Shepherd with ill temperament. That dog is nervy and reactive and fearful and
insecure and constantly jumping and barking at everything, just making life like walking through
a freaking haunted hayride or a haunted house. It is very, very, very stressful. I've seen it
over and over again. It's literally been my career for the last decade. But anyway, guys,
I do love the German Shepherd. They can be an awesome breed, but most people don't understand
what I just said in this entire video. That's why we made it.
If you guys don't follow me on Instagram, make sure you do right now. My handle is right here.
And of course, if you guys need any help with your dog, we have hundreds of free dog training
videos in here on my YouTube channel. And of course, we have my courses that you guys can
find in the link below if you want to take it a step further and take it more seriously.
Thank you guys so much for watching. I will talk to you on the next one. Peace.
