Affordable No Dig: More Food from the Same Compost

GARDENING TECHNIQUES
6 followers
Oct 5, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker demonstrates that no-dig gardening is more affordable and efficient than traditional digging. Through a 14-year comparison using the same amount of compost, the no-dig method yielded 12% more food, retained more carbon in the soil, and showed superior moisture retention and plant resilience during dry periods.
Is no-dig gardening affordable? Many people ask me that because they say oh you need so much
compost. So I'm just showing you here two beds side by side where one bed we dig every year
and put the compost in the trench which is traditional way of digging in the UK at least
you incorporate the compost and the same amount of compost we put on the no-dig bed which is behind
me and that is not dug it's simply the compost sitting on top. So they both have the same amount
of compost and then I'm comparing the results and this is the 14th year of doing this there's
a lot of data it's on my website actually you can find all the results but what I'm noticing over
13 years so far the no-dig bed gives 12 percent more food than the dig bed for the same amount
of compost and that's saying to me that no-dig uses the compost much more efficiently because
it's not being disturbed or exposed to air and turning into carbon dioxide and actually the
carbon content of this bed last measured two years ago 14 percent carbon content of that bed
18 showing how the carbon is retained in the soil so you're getting better value from your compost
it's such a genius way of making the most of application of compost and plants love it because
you can see here with the uh actually no you can't see quite as well with the cucumbers you
see pretty much everything else cucumbers are the exception in that they're looking a bit stronger
on the dig bed but there's a reason for that which is I planted two cucumber on each bed in late May
and it was warm at the time and then it turned really cool in early June this year and two
cucumbers there died and these two survived you know already showing how plants take much better
in no-dig but because they died for me that's no good I want to see a trial difference between growth
and I had two spare plants in the greenhouse I put them in but they were good strong plants at
the weather then warmed up and actually it would have been better if I put all four in at the same
time but I left those two and they've just always been a little bit weaker uh they're still giving
nice cucumbers and then something else I'm doing is interplanting so both beds are cropping really
heavily with close planting I'm not doing any rotation that's another feature of no-dig because
you've got such strong soil biology it works really well you can put anything in anywhere
and also quite close quite close spacing or interplanting so you can see the fennel there
they don't really show up at first but 10 days ago we put little fennel transplants between the
cucumbers while the cucumbers are still cropping had to cut some leaves off popped in the fennel
and in about three weeks time sometime mid-September we'll cut the cucumber stems at the base lift them
off to the compost heap and then get a crop of fennel in October here we sowed parsnips between
the lettuce 29th of May lettuce was still cropping for five weeks and look at the difference between
the dig bed parsnips sown at the same time watered the same and the no-dig the absorption
of moisture into plant roots is much stronger with no-dig because you've got all the biology
helping plant roots to find the nutrients and moisture same difference with leeks dig bed leeks
looking a little bit not strong to me and also the leaf color is a little bit metallic I notice that
when plants are dry they don't look lush green so much as blue green and those are definitely
thriving more looking a bit greener I did sow a row of carrots here on each bed and because we've
had no rain effectively for five weeks since they were sown four did germinate there and none there
but sadly I haven't got a trial of carrots we had one in the spring this is all second plantings
the kale followed peas and slightly stronger on the dig bed but both lots and plants are
massacred by flea beetle which has been the theme of brassica growth this summer the sticky traps
there we put in only two days ago so that's how many flea beetles have been caught in two days
and there's still a lot there that's a bit of an ongoing story and you can find more on my
instagram feed actually I'll talk about it quite a bit there chicory these followed onions so these
are chicory for radicchio to harvest in October and look how strong they are there 12 plants put
in around three weeks ago compared to there 12 plants put in at the same time watered the same
and half of them have disappeared it's moisture I think in this dry weather it's more
apparent every year it looks a bit along these lines but this year the difference is even
stronger celeriac struggling a bit there the dig bed thriving there on the no dig
the one that's not so different at this end is beetroot and the french beans right on the end
which followed kohlrabi in early June I harvested some kohlrabi right on the end where the french
beans are and this bed gave just under four kilos and this bed gave six and a half kilos a huge
difference but the french beans are struggling a little bit and that's because of the sunflowers
it's not the sunflowers are allelopathic as some people claim not in my understanding anyway it's
more that they're very greedy for moisture and because they're quite strong now and they can
easily root under the pathway they see the effect on the nearby bed so that's a bit of a handicap
for the dig bed french beans but overall I would say no dig is certainly affordable practical
it saves you watering you don't need to water quite so much so we do water here the same
have to be careful watering the dug soil because the water tends to run off so
it's actually quite a faff because we have to water this a bit let the soil get a bit wet while
we're piling it on there and then finish with the same amount of water going on here but it
takes a while to soak in so you're saving time you're saving effort saving water getting more
it's affordable
