My first proper ride of the Colnago Y1RS, this year's Tour de France winning bike. Is it as fast as it looks? How does it compare to a Canyon Aeroad, Trek Madone and Specialized Tarmac SL9? I joined my local chaingang to find out
Join the channel to get access to perks: / @davidarthur
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The reviewer tests the Colnago V4Rs (referred to as Y1 RS in the transcript) during a high-intensity \"chain gang\" ride in the Cotswolds. While acknowledging the bike's speed and striking aesthetics, the reviewer finds it comparable to other top-tier aero bikes rather than revolutionary, noting some drawbacks regarding weight and crosswind stability.
Behind me is a Carnago Y1 RS.
Quite the looker, isn't it?
Now, nearly two years ago,
I was one of the first people outside
of both the company and the race team
to actually ride a bike for the first time.
The only issue was, it was outside a team hotel
in a car park, and I'm wearing jeans and trainers.
Not ideal at all, but that video went on to be viewed
by nearly two million people,
both here on YouTube and over on Instagram.
And ever since, I've been keen to see how the bike
actually rides on my local roads,
and nearly two years later, I finally get the chance.
But instead of going for a gentle ride
on my local roads and talk about the handling
and performance and all that sort of stuff,
I give a proper intro to the Cotswolds,
because a race bike like this should be raced, right?
Unfortunately, there aren't any road races
happening this week, but I do have the next best thing,
my local chain gang.
Oh yes, it's fast, it's fairly fearsome,
and it's a good place for me to find out
whether the Y1RS is actually as fast as it looks.
So today, no spec sheet review, no lab testing,
no wind tunnel results.
I'm simply gonna ride the heck out of the bike
and tell you what I think, and try and answer
five questions by the end of today's video,
such as, does it actually feel as fast as it looks?
Can you really feel the difference
versus a normal race bike?
What's the price you pay for all this speed?
Does a bike this expensive actually make you faster?
And lastly, would I actually buy one?
So, let's dive in.
Honoring facts.
Yes, there's a certain pressure, responsibility.
I took a photo of that bike, but I put it in a bargain.
No, no, no, it's been out for two years, isn't it?
Yeah, yeah.
No, go for it, yeah.
So, I waited nearly two years to ride the bike.
Was it worth the wait?
Well, some immediate observation are that it's quick.
It's clearly a very fast bike.
It's also pleasantly smooth for the most part as well,
and pretty stable handling,
but there are some things I'm not convinced about,
largely around the weight, a bit on the heavy side.
Now, last night's chaingang was a good, fun blast.
I've been riding a chaingang all summer,
and it's a great midweek session,
and last night was a good workout
and a good test of the bike.
The route is just over 40 kilometers long,
and it's a good route in terms of fast, flat sections,
some punchy, long climbs, rough and smooth road surfaces,
and look at my Strava data.
My normalized power was 263 watts,
where max power was just over 900 watts.
We averaged 38 kilometers per hour,
and my average heart rate was 145 and a max at 170,
and I'll answer the five questions
from my intro on this bike,
and I made some notes.
I had time to digest my thoughts
of riding the bike last night,
and we'll start with the most obvious one.
Is it as fast as it looks?
Because, I mean, look at the thing.
It looks rapid, just standing there in my studio,
and yes, it's a very, very quick bike indeed,
one of the fastest bikes I've ever ridden,
but it doesn't feel least quicker
than other very quick bikes.
I'm thinking the Canyon Aero, CFR,
the Trek Madone SLR, the Giant Propel,
the BMC Team Shoe R, a very rapid bike indeed,
and of course, the Specialized Tarmac,
so I can't sit here and say it's quicker than those bikes,
because on that first ride, it didn't feel any quicker,
and that leads me on to my second question.
Can you feel a difference
compared to other very quick bikes?
Well, not really.
That's the bit that really surprised me.
I thought, I had high expectations for the bike.
I thought it would feel amazing
and just blow all our bikes out of the water,
but really, it didn't,
and that really surprised me the most.
So yes, it's quick,
but it doesn't feel alarmingly quicker than other bikes,
so yeah, that's something I'll really dive into
with more testing, do some more back-to-back testing
on the same circuit, in the same condition,
on the same day, to really get a better handle
on how fast it actually is
and what the margin might be compared to other bikes.
On to my third question,
and what's the price you pay for all that speed?
Well, not much, but there were a few occasions
when we had a sort of crosswind
and it's pushing quite hard,
and you're in that line trying to hold the wheel in front
and not overlap the wheel,
where I felt the bike being moved around,
a bit of buffeting,
really trying to manage the handlebar
to not get blown around the road
and maintain that position in the group,
in those stronger crosswinds compared to other bikes,
combination of the frame design, I guess,
and the deep suspension wheels.
I've had the wheels on my own Carnago C68,
and that is less affected by crosswinds than the Y1 RS.
It does seem to be affected by crosswinds more
than a tarmac or a canyon aero,
so that was definitely a downside.
And while generally the ride quality is pretty smooth,
that crazy seat tube junction is doing a good job
of giving a fairly smooth ride
through your saddle and through your butt.
On some of the rougher sections,
with the 28mm wide tyres,
the ride was fairly hard and firm,
and definitely there was a lot of feedback
through the contact points,
through the handlebar especially.
So yeah, you are reminded you are on a very stiff race bike
and it's not buttery smooth on all the roads you can ride.
But where are they?
The bike actually arrived with the Vision wheels
with 32mm tyre, which I took off
for the chain gang last night.
For the purposes of using a tyre
and wheelset I'm more familiar with,
compared to other bikes.
But I've put the wheels and tyres back on the bike
for my long-term testing,
and maybe the extra width, the extra volume
will lead to a smooth ride on the crappy roads
here in the Cotswolds.
Next up, does an expensive bike like this
make you ride faster?
Well, yes, of course it doesn't and does.
What this bike last night gave me
was the ultimate expression of all the gear and no idea.
Riding a bike like this,
I felt, for the first time ever actually,
really conscious of how I had to justify a bike like this,
and really put in some serious power
every time I was on the front,
to justify having the World Champs colours on the frame
and Taddy Bogacar's own bike,
and a flash white bike.
I felt a certain amount of pressure
to really do it justice and just go like the clappers
every time I was on the front of the group.
So that maybe spurred me on to ride harder and faster
than I would on a regular run-of-the-mill bike
that isn't as flashy and that ranges
looking at this one here.
So yeah, maybe there's something in that.
I wanna have a question that came to me this morning
having breakfast.
Is the Carnago Y1 RS actually a good bike
or just a crazy aero experiment by Carnago?
Because it's so different, so radical
compared to any other bike out there
this size of a factor one.
Well, yes, when you are riding along,
you're not looking down at the handlebar,
everything feels normal.
The three contact points, your shoes, your hands,
and the saddle, your bum, feel fairly normal.
The reach, the geometry, all feels fairly standard.
And you're not looking down at the handlebar,
it feels like a regular bike
and ride in a regular manner.
It's only when you look down at the handlebar,
you get a glance of the white frame beneath you,
are you reminded you are on a aero experiment.
So yes, in one way it is an aero experiment,
but one that does seem to work pretty well
in the real world.
And lastly, would I actually race one?
Would I buy one?
Well, it's way too early for that.
But sometimes when I ride new test bikes,
I come away thinking I have to own that bike,
I have a strong, immediate desire to own that bike.
And some bikes just leave me feeling a bit mixed,
a bit cold perhaps.
This one had to grab me by the balls, shall we say,
and force me to rush out and buy it.
Dig deep into my savings to find a way to own a bike.
I don't desire it, I don't crave it yet.
But that may change,
because this isn't a full in-depth review,
just literally a first ride.
Well, a second ride for my first proper ride on the bike
and give me some real honest, unbiased,
unpaid thoughts and views on the bike
compared to all other bikes I've been riding
over the last few years of running this YouTube channel.
So yes, early days yet,
but stay tuned for much more testing on the bike.
I'll do some proper comparison with other race bikes
around a controlled test track
and do some long rides
and really get an understanding
of what the bike is all about.
From my point of view,
based on all the bikes I'm riding
and that collective knowledge of testing
to see how it really stacks up
and see whether there's substance to the crazy shape.
But yeah, for now, just a first ride.
Hope you enjoyed today's video,
my first ride on my local chain gang.
Let me know your thoughts on the bike
and what I said about the bike.
Like, drop me a comment down below.
And if you want to know more about the bike
and why it looks the way it does,
then watch this video right up here.