The Dark Truth Behind the World's Most Important Invention

Dr Brian Keating
330 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 4, 2026
Fritz Haber won the 1918 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for pulling ammonia out of thin air. That one reaction still feeds about half the people on Earth. He also ran Germany's poison gas program in World War I and earned the name "father of chemical warfare."
I call it the worst Nobel Prize ever. Here is the chemistry, the history, and the hard lesson about knowledge versus wisdom.
Original video: https://youtu.be/AotqljjfXwo
0:00 The controversial prize
1:04 Nobel committee blunders
2:22 Introduction to Fritz Haber
3:48 The Haber-Bosch process
5:29 Nitrogen and life cycles
7:15 Feeding the global population
9:14 Chemistry of ammonia synthesis
12:58 Knowledge vs. wisdom
AI Generated·May contain errors
I'm kind of a big deal when it comes to the Nobel Prize, at least in my own house. I've
written two books with the words Nobel Prize in the title. The first one, Losing the Nobel Prize,
was about my memoir as a young scientist trying to aspire to greatest accolade in the scientific
world. The second comes from my interviews on this very channel with nine Nobel laureates about
their wisdom, not just their knowledge. It's useful to us in getting into sync with the world
in understanding it and harmonizing with it and being able to cope with it. And today we're
talking about a scientist who had tons and tons of knowledge, but relatively little wisdom,
and I call it the worst Nobel Prize ever. There have been several controversial Nobel Prizes.
Some say the worst Nobel Prize ever was actually the one given for the lobotomy. They kept being
wrong sometimes. We're not going to talk about that on this channel. We like to preserve our
brains here. True as that may be, there have been actual blunder Nobel Prizes. Real bloopers
when you think about Gustave Delen, shown here, who won the Nobel Prize in 1912 for his invention
of gas accumulators for use in lighthouses and buoys. Now, who among us doesn't use a lighthouse
to get around and navigate their way through life? I know I sure do. Forget that newfangled
GPS system, as silly as that Nobel Prize was. And actually, it maybe was of interest back in
1912 or so. However, I remind you, that was just seven years after Albert Einstein invented the
special theory of relativity, photoelectric effect, Brownian motion, and many other things,
for which he wouldn't win a Nobel Prize for another 17 years. He won the 1921 Nobel Prize.
But Gustave Delen got his Nobel Prize a decade before good old Albert. Why is that? Well,
for one reason, there was some antisemitism with the Nobel Prize selection committee,
and that's plagued the Nobel Prize for over 100 years. It's gotten better, and there have been a
lot of Jewish Nobel Prize winners to date. But there's still possible discrimination and issues
with the Nobel Prize that almost every one of the Nobel Prize winners that I've interviewed
has admitted to. That the Nobel Prize needs reform, some of which was included in my first
book, Losing the Nobel Prize. Now, let's turn to Haber's Nobel Prize. Who was Fritz Haber? What
did he do? He's been called the man that killed millions, but saved billions. What's a few million
people when you save a few billion people? Is that really true? Would the world have actually
played out differently if Fritz didn't invent the process that we're about to explore? Who knows.
It's called counterfactual history. It's not really that interesting to speculate on.
But I assume, like most scientific discoveries, it would have been discovered eventually,
and perhaps without his immoral and anti-wisdom type behavior. Now, I've done a video on this
channel called Knowledge is Not Equal to Wisdom. And I've also done a video at Prager University
called Follow the Science, where I get into some of these same issues. Science has to be first and
always about pursuing knowledge. We have a tendency to conflate knowledge with wisdom.
When someone's incredibly smart, we think that they're also quite wise. There's almost no
correlation between them. Fritz Haber was a chemist. And he was a German-Jewish chemist.
And that's important for reasons you'll see soon. He was the co-inventor, along with Bosch,
of the so-called Haber-Bosch process. And it's that same Bosch that later went on to create
things in the German industrial complex, operating from the early to the middle of the 20th century.
What is the Haber-Bosch process? Well, you benefited from it earlier today, when you had
breakfast. You see, their discovery led to the process of fertilizer production that we enjoy
in almost all of the food that we eat. It's one of the most important inventions or discoveries
in modern history and fits well with what Alfred Nobel wanted when he created the Nobel Prize
via his death in 1896. His will, written in 1895, mental note, make your will out at least a day
before you die. His will said that the prize should go to a scientist who discovers or invents
something that has the greatest benefit to mankind and that was discovered in the preceding year by
a single person. Again, these are rules that the modern Nobel Prize committee ignores routinely,
but yet again, see my book, Losing the Nobel Prize, for more details.
This fertilizer production method is responsible for almost half of the food that we eat on Earth.
And so it led to the 1918 Nobel Prizes. And it's controversial, but not for the scientific reasons
that say the Bohr atomic hypothesis shown here is responsible for controversy. Because that model is
actually wrong. The atom isn't like a little tiny solar system. So although it makes predictions
that are correct, the actual model on which it's based is completely wrong, as we now know.
So it's different than that type of a blunder or mistake by the Nobel Prize committee.
Just a quick pause to ask you for a small favor while my thumb is occupied with old Albert on it.
Yours is presumably freed up to leave a thumbs up on this video. Really helps me a lot with a good
old fashioned YouTube algorithm. Thanks a lot. Now back to the video. Let's take a step back.
We're used to talking about physics on this channel. So botany is not my strongest suit.
In fact, when I would do biological experiments in high school, I would say be given a frog.
I would do the dissection, but I was so bad at it, the frog would live.
Plants are the backbone of all life on Earth because everything traces its energy source to
a plant at some level or another. And of course the plants trace their energy source to the sun,
which we've talked about. So there is a connection between what I do as an astronomer and some of
these botanical delights that we're going to talk about. Plants need more than just water and
carbon dioxide. They need nitrogen. Now the air is full of it. So you might think, well,
let's just grab it from the air. That's not so easy to do. The nitrogen in turn forms part of
the DNA structure that is so crucial to all living systems. DNA in turn is built from amino acids,
which require nitrogen. So without nitrogen, there's no plants, no plants, there's no animal
life. And we are not here to be discussing the importance of nitrogen. The role of nitrogen in
chemical processes that affect botanical life is described by sources of nitrogen and sinks
of nitrogen. Things that replenish nitrogen and things that take away nitrogen. Denitrification
shown here is leaching phenomena, which then produces nitrogen dioxide or nitrous oxide,
or dinitrogen oxide rather, or molecular nitrogen N2, and that then goes into the atmosphere.
And the plants also suck up the nitrogen and use that to build their amino acids, which then
produce the organic material that life forms like you and I will eat. Everyone out there is eating
a plant at some level, even if you're not a vegetarian. You've given me the food that my
food eats. Fertilizers can replace the nitrogen in the soil that gets sucked up by the plants,
and you want to keep this process in balance. The carbon, I should say, in the amino acids
comes from usually decomposing plant material that's already there. The green matter that
then decays is responsible for replenishing the carbon, but it doesn't as effectively
re-establish the amount of nitrogen needed for those same amino acids.
So if you're growing a lot of plant life, you need a lot of nitrogen. And farming is a battle
between denitrification and nitrification, so getting sources and sinks of nitrogen.
Can you farm? Yes.
They have to be in a delicate balance. Too much nitrogen can cause problems as well as
too little nitrogen will prevent the accumulation of the amino acids necessary for plant life.
So this can be done in many ways. The ancient agrarian societies knew that you had to rotate
crops. You couldn't keep planting the same crops in the same place and expect to get the same
bountiful cornucopia harvest. Crop rotation isn't fully as efficient as actually fertilizing is,
but you do have to do both of them. And of course, you can have composting where you take manure
from animals, which has some nitrogen, but mostly it's carbon. It's the unprocessed food from the
ruminants that don't get converted to beef or milk or whatever they're producing. And so that
goes back to the soil. But again, it doesn't have as much nitrogen. It might have phosphine,
phosphorus, and carbon, but it doesn't have nitrogen. Nitrogen is the key for sustaining
a planet with 8 billion people on it. Population's been growing exponentially from just about a
billion or so in Haber's time to the 8 billion number that we have today. So where are we going
to get this nitrogen from? There are sources of natural fertilizers. Fun fact, bat guano,
bat droppings, can still be used by each and every red-blooded American citizen as a source to
harvest for fertilization purposes. Look into that on your own. I don't want to be accused of even
being more bat crazy than I already am. Now, air is 20% nitrogen. Let's just use that, right? No,
no! Nitrogen triple bonds, as illustrated in this chemical equation here, is incredibly stable
and very difficult to break into just single nitrogen atoms, atomic nitrogen.
What about making ammonia? Well, making ammonia is very simple. You just take two nitrogen atoms
bound together as molecular nitrogen, N2. You add three atomic hydrogen molecules,
H2, and you get out two molecules of ammonia, NH3. The formula to make ammonia could be extremely
simple, but the problem is it's very slow. And that's because, also, ammonia is somewhat stable
as well as molecular nitrogen. So this is where good old Fritz enters the story. He was a German
Jewish chemist working in the 19th century and the 20th century, fixated, you might say,
on producing ammonia. And for his work, eventually, and what was known as the Haber-Bosch process,
he did win the 1918 Nobel Prize. What is it? How does it work? Let's do some chemistry, shall we?
Haber's idea was to take the exothermic nature of making ammonia and use it to an advantage,
to effectively recycle it and use the heat. The exothermic nature means it gives off heat,
which you can use energy, and you have to only work on speeding it up. Once you have the right
ingredients, all you must do is optimize it. At least that's what he figured.
How can you get gases to react faster? It's actually a form of molecular physics.
You can give them more energy, heat them up to higher temperatures. You can add in more molecules,
increase the pressure. You can force the molecules to mix using shock waves to compress the gas
together. And the result is that you get ammonia out of the reaction chamber. You have a certain
number of these cyclical chambers, and each one processes and amplifies, if you will,
the processed material from the previous step. And when you have unreacted gas, as I said,
it's not 100% efficient and it's also slow, you send that ammonia back into the system and start
it over again. This is a self-sustaining exothermic reaction with compression at its
core at high temperatures. This is the Haber-Bosch process. But not quite. What was really the key
enabling catalytic ingredient was a catalyst. A catalyst is a type of material that doesn't get
consumed in the reaction. You may be familiar with catalysts from your catalytic converter,
which uses platinum. The main bottleneck in the reaction is separating the two nitrogen atoms in
the nitrogen 2 molecule from one another so that you can make them, recycle them into NH3. Remember,
you get out two NH3 ammonia molecules for every one molecule of molecular nitrogen. So it turns
out that by experimenting with different types of catalysts, mostly different types of metals,
from iron to nickel, manganese and calcium were tried, but the most effective one was a rare one
called osmium. That osmium allowed him to dramatically enhance and amplify the production.
And it didn't require that he use uranium, which would have probably killed him before
he finished this process. The Haber-Bosch process shown here is used to make literally
200 million tons of ammonia every single year. Ammonia has wide ranging uses from fertilizers,
where it uses mostly 80% of the ammonia, to explosives, to refrigerant gases, and many,
many uses. The commercialization and efficient production has led to the feeding of billions
of humans. Now, why is this the worst Nobel Prize in history, according to yours truly?
Well, for one thing, Haber wasn't only interested in fertilization and preserving human lives.
He used the fame and money that he got from this process to bolster his factories, his chemical
factories, and what he was later recruited by the Axis armies during World War I. When the Axis
powers were fighting the Allied powers, his chemical knowledge was used and his chemical
technology was used to create the very first chemical weapons, earning him the moniker the
Father of Chemical Warfare. Now, this chemical warfare, you might say, well, maybe that was just
how they used to fight things back at the time. And did the US use an atomic bomb? Well, this was
actually outlawed prior to World War I and signed by Germany. So Germany was party to a treaty that
banned the use of chemical weapons. They were so gruesome. And by some estimates,
tens of thousands of Americans and British were killed, overseen by not only Fritz Haber,
but also five other German chemical shock troops, as they were called,
all of whom had won Nobel Prizes or would go on to win Nobel Prizes. For his work,
he did win the Nobel Prize. But unfortunately, the fame and financial success that he obtained
was used to further sustain his chemical ambitions. And later, in World War II,
Haber's family was actually killed in Nazi concentration camps that used a chemical
called Zyklon B, which had been produced in factories utilizing some of Haber's own mechanisms.
So his party, being a party to the Axis powers in World War I, eventually led not only to create
tragedy in his family life, but to eventually devastation and destruction of his own family
at the hands of the Nazi monsters in World War II. So never conflate knowledge with wisdom.
As the saying goes, knowledge is knowing a tomato is a fruit, but wisdom is knowing not
to put it in a fruit salad. And sometimes the consequences are far, far more grave,
literally, for humanity. So never conflate knowledge with wisdom. If you'd like to learn
about the Nobel Prize and conflation of knowledge and wisdom,
click here for this playlist that I made just for you.
