These sectors of the economy will be CRUSHED, expert says
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe discussion explores the confusing state of the current economy, where positive data like lower core PCE inflation fails to drive markets upward. Experts analyze the tension between robust nominal growth and persistent inflation, debating whether Federal Reserve rate hikes are disproportionately harming weak sectors while failing to cool the strongest parts of the economy.
So in 1973 Billy Paul had a huge hit right it was titled will it go around in circles, right?
You guys remember the song i'm going to song I sing with my friends will it go around in circles?
And the reason I thought about this song that ain't got no melody
Is that I feel like that song almost every day when it comes to the economy the federal reserve buying yields
I don't understand what's going on
This morning core pce came in lighter than expected. So you think maybe wow
This is going to be a green light for a monster day to the upside
What's up, but not monster day
on top of that inflation adjusted spending posted its biggest monthly gain since march of
2023
And yet the atlanta fed updated their gdp. Now, you can see it's plunged. It was at five percent
It was at five percent now. It's three point seven percent
Let's bring in rennmack head of economic research neal dutta and neal
I mean, you're the man to help us figure this kind of stuff up help me understand. Let's bring up the pce stuff here
Uh, it looks like you know, you get core prices
year over year
Third quarter a month over month. I mean just it just looks like it should have done really well and yet we haven't
I mean, it's just you know
Yield to back up
Well, that makes sense to me charles. I mean, so the way I would think about it is
Look at your slide, right? You have inflation at three and a half percent ish and you have real gdp a little over two
So you put that together you're talking about, you know close to six percent
Nominal growth. So if that's the growth backdrop that we have
That's uh pretty robust which is why interest rates are backing up so
you know, I I think the way i'm thinking about it right now is
Uh growth isn't a problem, right? The economy's fine. Inflation is still a problem, right?
And if you think that and you agree, um
Then it's really hard to get along the uh, the bond market
Okay, so core pce as 0.2 but like maybe a third month in a row isn't that the fed's target?
Okay, so
That annualizes to three percent core inflation, okay
So if you were to run this number month after month for 12 months, it would be three percent
That's still let me get out of this
Let's bring up let's bring up the title
You had a great report. All your reports are great on monday though
This report you you've talked about uh, you said the higher rates will be biting where it shouldn't bite essentially. I mean
Residential investment and transportation equipment. So this is I guess a bigger question
The federal reserve keying off these day off these data points and taking action hiking
It seems like the hikes hurt people who need the most help in my opinion
and it doesn't necessarily
Stop where all the action is coming from and do we really want it to do we do we want to slow down an economy?
That's been desperate for growth
Well, you know, it's a tough question
um
I would just say
My job is not to make like a judgment on whether what they're doing is right or wrong
but really trying to figure out what they'll do right and so
What i'm trying to say with this is they're going to crush the sectors of the economy that are already quite depressed
Right the housing market's been right
You know flat on its back for years home building stocks have been very very sluggish
And higher interest rates are going to do what just make those already very weak sectors worse
And that'll bleed into things like household durables and so forth
But to your point like what's driving growth right now? Why is the equity market strong?
I mean you were talking about micron before right? I mean, so
That's information processing equipment like business investment's been really strong, but rate hikes won't do as much to slow that down. So
Really what's going to happen is they're going to make the things that are already really bad worse
Uh while doing very little to affect the things that are quite strong. So yesterday, um
Williams came out
In the middle of the day says he's no urgency
Of course, he didn't really I don't think he saw urgency going into the you know
And the odds flipped I think there was like 60 70 percent chance of a rate hike in october that flipped to less than 50
There's a tug of war going on inside there and it seems to be more than academic what's happening?
And and who do you think is going to ultimately prevail in terms of where we go with the next series of meetings?
Well when I was on your program last time I checked I was back in july and I was making the point that the committee
Would lead warsh to hike but now it feels like warsh is
Taking the reins and hiking himself. So I think he's actually somewhat more hawkish than a lot of his colleagues and
You know the williams bit is interesting because I think there was a lot of inconsistency
Is in what he said like he's talking about how growth is above trend
But he thinks inflation is going to be fine
Like I don't really know how that makes sense after supporting a hike in september if there was no urgency
Why do you go for that in september? Right? So uh on on the bond market there was an interesting article
Yesterday could there be a run on the bond market sort of you know
Could the action in the bond market trigger something some form of panic?
You know a lot of I think what I like in the last couple of weeks in terms of
What i've seen out there a lot of people trying to put this in perspective particularly yields, right?
That uh, you know if you go back to a long far enough
The average is about five over five almost closer to six percent
So we should not necessarily be panicking
But I think the velocity of the move and the persistence of the move could that in of itself trigger some kind of a panic
I mean, it's possible. Uh, but to me, I mean the tell is the stock market, right?
I mean yields will keep going up until something bad happens in the equity market and that hasn't happened yet. So, you know
If nominal growth is six and a half seven percent. Um,
Why wouldn't interest rates be higher now? I to your point?
I definitely think there are not so good reasons for why rates are up. It's not all sort of roses
I mean inflation is firmer central banks are tightening not only here overseas rates are up everywhere, right?
I mean there's deficit concerns in europe, for example, so
It's not all good reasons. There are bad reasons for um,
The increase in rates and it's starting to have some effects on the economy running the economy
Just a little bit hotter than normal. Is that ever going to be possible with the current group bank at the federal reserve?
No
They have a two percent target. I think they mean what they say
and ultimately as I say
Like you have to start thinking about whether you think they'll actively try to slow the economy down to bring inflation towards their target
Neil great stuff, my man. Good to see you. Great seeing you. Thanks a lot

