"Our chance for an evolutionary leap is to consciously train as many people as possible to be constantly in the flow of higher cognitive processes." Kristina Kallas tells what AI still can't do, and shares how Ministry of Education and Research of the Republic of Estonia is preparing students to use AI wisely while sharpening the skills and thinking only humans can grow. Kristina Kallas, PhD, is an Estonian politician, political scientist and educator. As of April 2023, Kristina Kallas is a prominent member of the Estonian government, serving as the Minister of Education and Research. She is the founder and the current head of the political party Eesti200. Prior to her career in politics, Kristina Kallas was a researcher at the University of Tartu. Simultaneously, in 2015-2019 she was the Director of the Narva College of the University of Tartu. As an expert consultant for several organisations and projects such as OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities, Kristina Kallas has advised many governments in integration policy, including Kyrgyzstan, Ukraine, Moldova, and Georgia. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community.
The speaker discusses the necessity of evolving human cognition in the age of AI. Rather than focusing on the technology itself, the emphasis is placed on shifting education from lower-order thinking (memorization and application) to higher-order cognitive skills (analysis, evaluation, and creation) to prevent cognitive decline and ensure human relevance.
Thank you for giving me this opportunity. Actually, I'm not going to talk about AI.
I'm not. I'm going to talk about humans, because when I became a minister now,
more than three years ago, unbelievable, that's a very long time ago,
JATCP have been out for five months. It was in November 2022, and I became a minister in April
2023. And my advisor came to me and said, dear minister, I think we need to do something about
AI. And I said, OK, what should we do? And he says, I'm not sure. So another two months,
we started working on different policies that we had to develop. This was our agenda. But AI was
not on the agenda when I became a minister. This is something that I didn't think about,
but it was there. So two months later, my advisor comes back to me and says,
I think still that we need to do something about AI because students are already using it in
schools. And I said, fine, what do we do about it? And he says, I still don't know.
So what we did was that we went to the smarter people, people who actually knew something about
AI. And we had a lot of rounds of meetings and discussions with neuroscientists, with cognitive
scientists, with tech companies, with IT people to just to figure out how is AI going to affect
the education and learning and what should we as policymakers do about it. And what we came up with
was that it's not about technology. We don't have to care about the technology because the
technology is part of the other discipline. Me, as a minister of education, I have to care about
the learning, what happens to the learning, to the human brain and the human capacity to learn
if the technology advances to the stage where it was already back then. So my question was then
when AI is here and when AI is so magnificent, then what is something that we have to do in
education system for the humans of next generation? But it's not a new question because
back in 2017 already, OSCD, which is an international organization on economic cooperation,
did a survey of skills, labour skills, the workers in the workforce. And they found out that two
thirds of the workforce already at that time had a literacy and numeracy and digital skills lower
than the computers at that time. So human capacity to think, to analyze, to calculate,
to functionally read and understand the text was already lower compared to the computers at that
time. So that was a very big question to the education system. So what about the humans?
Should we actually give up learning altogether? Why would we need to develop our brains and our
capacity to think, to analyze and many other things if there are computers that can do this?
What is exactly the education then for? And that's a very big question. So we were struggling
with this question for almost a year in the ministry when we were discussing with the
experts about this. And we came to the realization that it's not the first time in human history
when the technology puts humans under the cognitive pressure, under the true evolutionary
pressure. One time when it was happening was when the printed press was invented, when humans,
the literacy, the reading skills were not universal. But then the printing press was
invented and what happened to humankind was that every human learned to read. So all the humans
actually evolved in a capacity to learn reading. So what we realized was that after a very long
period of time, humankind is again in a very significant evolutionary lead pressure. So we
have to evolve. We have to evolve as humans and the main evolving pressure is our brains. It's not
the ability to stand up and run fast. It's not a physical evolutionary pressure, but it's a mental
cognitive evolutionary pressure. So what we have to do is that we have to think faster,
more systematically and much more creatively. Our capacity, our brain capacity has to change
and that's an evolution, human evolution. Now the question is like where do we find the space
for development needed for this? Some of you, I don't know if you have neuroscientists or cognitive
psychologists in the audience, but you know that our human brain works in two modes. One of them
is lower cognitive modes and the other one is higher cognitive modes. Lower cognitive modes
is mostly related to the memory, to the understanding and memorization. So and something
that we have automated skills, something that we have learned once and we keep repeating it and
it's on autopilot all the time. So we don't relearn it. We just learn like we learn to cycle
the bicycle or we learn to skate or we learn to ski and this is something that we learn and we
don't relearn every time we sit on a bicycle again because our brain has just absorbed this skill
and this is something that we apply all the time. This is a mode that our brain prefers to be on
all the time. So it prefers to be on this lower cognitive mode that we learn once and then we
keep repeating. Our stereotypes for example come from that lower cognitive mode. We learn that
Italians are loud and then we expect every Italian to be loud every time we meet them because that's
how our brain operates. We just don't relearn every time we meet an Italian. We have to relearn
the person. We had lots of talks before here how we have to learn actually out of box but most of
the time our brain prefers to be on a lower cognitive mode. Higher order thinking or higher
cognitive mode is when we have to constantly be in the learning mode. Like we have to relearn all
the time. The thing that we learned yesterday is not something that we use today in the situation.
In a situation where we are today we have to learn again. We have to relearn again. Use our
base knowledge to learn a new situation. Why do our brain prefers to be on a lower cognitive mode
is because it takes less energy for brain to operate in a lower cognitive mode. Brain is our
biggest organ that takes the biggest share of our body energy. So it's the biggest energy consumer
of our bodies. So we prefer to be on a lower mode all the time because it's the least energy
consuming. If we have to relearn all the time then it takes a lot of energy. So if you
study for a very complicated exam you will be dead next day physically because your brain was for 24
hours in a very high cognitive mode and it took all your energy from your body. So you need to
really sleep. You really need to rest because the energy was taken out. It's much more difficult
than running a marathon which is a physical exercise in a lower cognitive mode. So human
brain is more all the time in the lower cognitive mode. In an AI era that we are living in that's
not an option any longer to be constantly on a lower cognitive mode. That's not an option. We
have to train our brain to be much more often, much more awake hours in a higher order thinking
skills. And here is this cognitive tree that you see. The lower cognitive thinking skills
is remembering. Just the memory. Just memorizing something. Understanding what you have just
memorized and applying it. As I said, like bicycle. You learn to ride a bicycle or you learn
that second world war started 1939 and then you understand it and then every time somebody asks
you just automatically say it. You don't think anymore about this. So this is like lower
cognitive thinking skills. The higher order thinking skills is analyzing all the time.
Why did it start 1939? What were the reasons? Who are the actors? Why did they do that? You have to
put the different actors together. Think about their relationships. Think about the actions,
the motives behind it. So this is much more complex process. Also evaluating, giving assessment,
having ethical evaluation on certain things. This is higher order cognitive thinking. And creation.
Being constantly in a new situation, in a new environment, in a new situation. That's also
something that makes your brain very tired because it takes a lot of energy. Now, education systems
throughout 200 years have mostly focused on lower order thinking skills. Learn something, remember,
understand, apply. And then you do the test. The teacher was going to check whether you have
actually understood it, whether you have understood it or not. Whether you are not
analyzing it, how you use it in a new situation, how you create something new out of this.
Education systems are not really going that far. They are most of the time going to this
remembering, understanding, applying. Only when you get to the PhD and research, that's when you
get to this higher order cognitive thinking skills. Now, with an AI, AI is capable of doing
all this that is here, with the few exception that they are not very good at doing evaluation
and creation. Ethical evaluation of the things or creating new realities, they are capable of
doing creating new realities only out of statistical probability cases. But the human creation is
completely something else. Human brain is in this sense still unique. And what we understood is that
in education system, it's no longer enough to stop education when the applying aspect of knowledge
is. So it's not enough anymore to just memorize something, understand something and then apply it
and then that's it. Education systems have to evolve into higher order cognitive skills,
so the result is that we have to consciously train humans and as many people as possible
to be constantly in the flow of this higher cognitive thinking processes. And this is a
human brain training. You just train human brains into this. Of course, the training starts in
education system. So training of higher cognitive processes starts in school and it's not no longer
just in PhD. You have to do it already in the lower secondary, higher upper secondary, BA when
you do the BA studies and so on. So you come to the lower secondary. In case of Estonia, that's
seventh graders, that's 12, 13 year old kids. That's when you really have to start already in
the curriculum and in the teaching, applying analysis, evaluation and creation. But we realized
that we have to do it with AI as a tutor and assistant in it because the AI is the one that
pushes us to do those things. Without AI, we kind of leap back to the usual lower cognitive thinking
of memory, understanding, applying. So we decided to introduce AI into the schools to
give licenses to the students and train the teachers how do you integrate AI into the
learning process so that it pushes you to do more analytical thinking, more systematic thinking and
more creative thinking and critical thinking. So the wise people around me that I talked to a lot,
they created AI strategy for Estonian schools in 2024, by the end of 2024 and we started an AI
LEAP program in February 2025. So we are in the first pilot year. We started only with the upper
secondary schools. The program is private-public partnership because half of the budget comes from
the private sector companies that are investing in this and half of the budget from the ministry.
It's outsourced as a task to the foundation. It's not run by the ministry. There are various
reasons why ministry is not the best place to do such innovative initiatives and we launched it,
as I said, on 10th and 11th grade students and in 2026, September, we will be extending it to
the vocational education students. The absolute focus is on teacher competencies to understand
teachers that how they use AI to bring students to do more analytical thinking and systematic
thinking in their assignments and exercises. So teachers are absolutely focused on this. We use
Socratic style tutoring AI tool. This is something that we developed together with OpenAI. I have to
say OpenAI has been an extremely good partner for us to do an R&D work on the tool that we want to
use at school. It's not the general purpose JET-GTP. It's actually a Socratic version of JET-GTP
for schools. We do scientific monitoring but we also don't know much what is going on. We are
really observing and learning as we go along because there are no clear answers or fixed
answers yet. There is very little science that we know about it. So Estonia is first and so far the
only country that has given this kind of Socratic tool to students to study with and everybody of
course is watching us but we are asking everybody to come along and learn with us because we were
most afraid that if we don't do anything then there will be a brain rot and cognitive offloading
and all these kind of things because education system will go based on inertia only on those
lower processes. So as our president said when we launched this initiative it's not
about using AI the most. It doesn't have to be the hours we use. It's about how we use it
and why we are using it for. So let's use it the wisest way and I think we are producing
scientific knowledge out of this project as well that I think world is waiting and wants to
know how the AI is affecting the human learning process itself. So thank you very much for your attention.