What's actually holding your generation back — and it's not what you think. Princeton philosopher Robert P. George says the answer is simple to state and brutally hard to do: live an examined life. In this conversation, Professor George — a leading voice in political philosophy and natural law — explains why ideological conformity made independent thought harder than ever, and why what's replaced it, a "ferocious absolutism," may be even more dangerous. He argues authenticity and integrity can't be inherited or assumed — they have to be earned through self-examination — and uses his decades-long intellectual engagement with philosopher Peter Singer to show why taking your fiercest critics seriously deepens your own understanding, even when it never changes your mind.
We discuss: • Why every generation faces the same core challenge — and why yours may have it harder • The difference between "peak woke" conformity and today's "ferocious absolutism" • Why authenticity and integrity must be earned, not assumed • What Robert George learned from decades of intellectual engagement with Peter Singer • Why engaging your fiercest critics deepens your understanding, even when it doesn't change your mind
If you only get one life, it's worth examining it.
Topics: Robert George, Examined Life, Critical Thinking, Gen Z, Intellectual Humility, Peter Singer, Philosophy, Self Improvement
The speaker argues that the greatest challenge for the current generation is the struggle to lead an \"examined life.\" He discusses the dangers of ideological conformity and \"ferocious absolutism,\" emphasizing that true authenticity and integrity are only achieved through the courageous pursuit of truth and a willingness to engage with opposing viewpoints.
What do you see as the biggest challenge facing my generation, and why is it holding us back
from thriving?
Well, the biggest challenge facing your generation is the same challenge that faces all generations,
and that's the challenge of leading an examined life.
You know, Socrates is famous for having said, the unexamined life is not worth living.
And there's some truth in that.
We're made to lead examined lives.
We're fulfilled by leading examined lives.
Now, leading an examined life can be difficult and unsettling and challenging.
So it's not going to make us happy in the psychological sense all the time.
Sometimes it can make us very unhappy, because reality can be very tough and very tragic.
And yet, we're better off leading examined lives.
I see my vocation, Daniel, especially as a teacher, to be forming the young men and
women entrusted by their families to my charge, to charge my fellow professors, to be determined
truth seekers and courageous truth speakers.
And the challenge for the student is to form himself to be a determined truth seeker and
a courageous truth speaker.
And that's not easy.
It's not easy for any generation.
I think it may be true to say that it's particularly difficult for your generation.
Well, you're coming up at a time when there's an enormous amount of pressure for especially
ideological conformity.
We saw it at its worst in the period that some people call peak woke, you know, roughly
1920...
Sorry, 1920.
2020 to 2024.
Right.
When people felt that they had to at least pay lip service to woke, secular, progressive
values, whether they actually shared them or not.
And because of the natural human rational pressure to be consistent, people would try
to talk themselves into believing things, or at least talk themselves out of questioning
the prevailing dogmas in the culture, especially the intellectual culture.
But what begins in the intellectual culture, of course...
Seeps down.
Seeps down, yeah.
So it's in the broader culture.
And so it was very difficult for young men and women.
It remains to this day, we're still living in its wake, remains very difficult for young
men and women to think for themselves, genuinely for themselves, to lead examined lives, to
do what you have to do if you're to form yourself to be determined truth seekers and courageous
truth speakers.
What's the risk if you don't live an examined life?
What are the negative consequences of that?
You waste your life.
You're inauthentic.
Authenticity is not something merely instrumentally valuable.
It's intrinsically valuable.
It's central to who we are.
And if you lose it, there's no getting it back.
You only get one chance in life.
And you can waste your life.
You want to waste your life worried about titillation and pleasure and social advancement,
focused on the things that matter, but not at the end of the day, really, all that much.
Wealth, status, power, influence, prestige.
Those things aren't bad, necessarily.
Because you can do good things with them.
If you make a lot of money, you can build businesses, you can employ people, you can
provide people with goods and services that they need and want.
If you make a lot of money, you can give generously to causes that you believe in.
But although they are not necessarily bad, they're also not good in themselves.
They're good only as means to other ends.
The things that really matter are the things that are worthwhile, not simply as means to
other ends, but for their own sake.
Faith, family, friendship, knowledge, beauty, integrity, decency, honor.
And those kinds of things are the fruit of an examined life.
They're the substance, really, of an examined life.
Even when it comes to something like faith, a faith that is not earned by thinking, by
self-examination, is not genuine faith.
And certainly the same is true with integrity.
The only way you have integrity is to earn it, to work on it, to meet the challenges
that have to be met if we're to be people of integrity.
What would be the first step toward living an examined life?
It seems to me at least one thing is you have to believe that there is some sort of truth
out there that's worth pursuing, that's worth seeking, that's worth standing up for.
And it does feel to me like there's a lot of my generation, they'll say things like
what is truth or Pontius Pilate said that 2,000 years ago, what is truth?
So for someone who says, Professor George, what does it mean to seek truth?
There's no such thing, it's just your opinion, my opinion.
What would you say to that person?
Well, you know, I heard that more commonly with earlier generations, a kind of polite
skepticism or relativism, well, there's really no such thing as truth now, is there?
There's just opinions and you have your opinions and I have my opinions.
And then people would try to draw the inference from that, an inference that was entirely
not warranted, by the way, that we should therefore be nice to each other, be tolerant
to each other, not violate each other's rights.
Now, how there can be rights if there's no truth, that's another question.
So this polite skepticism or subjectivism or relativism was at the end of the day incoherent,
but it was polite and it aspired to a kind of tolerance or toleration.
What I find in your generation is not that, it's rather in some ways the opposite.
It's a ferocious absolutism, not a relativism.
Oh yes, there's truth and I've got it.
And if you don't fall into line with it, if you don't affirm it, if you question it, you're
a bad person.
Wrong think marks you as an enemy of humanity.
So it makes me in some ways, Daniel, look back fondly on the good old days when my job
was really to question and provoke people to think about, more critically about, this
polite kind of innocent relativism.
It has some advantages over the ferocious absolutism that you get today.
I'm going to say one thing, though, to rescue my generation, which is there is something
that is at least almost admirable, that they believe in something.
Do you know what I mean?
There's something about...
I don't think so.
Satan believes in some things.
One of the things Satan believes in is God.
Fair point.
Okay, that's fair.
That's fair.
Nobody believes in God more fervently than Satan does.
That's fair.
And Hitler had beliefs, so there are some beliefs that are really wicked.
I just meant, if you can redirect that enthusiasm and energy and kind of emotional desire to
really spread the gospel, that is something that could be redirected towards the good.
Actually, I wouldn't want people to be as fiercely authoritarian as woke people tend
to be these days, even if you replace the substance of their beliefs with my beliefs.
We need to be willing to question even our own beliefs.
We need to be self-critical.
I sometimes put it to my students this way, Daniel.
We human beings, quite naturally, and there's nothing wrong with it really, but it can get
out of hand.
We human beings quite naturally tend to wrap our emotions more or less tightly around our
convictions.
Now, I say that's not necessarily a bad thing because we need some emotional investment
in our convictions if we're to get anything done.
For example, it's one thing to believe, well, as a bare belief, it's one thing to have just
the bare belief that it would be nice to get my kids up in the morning, get them washed
and dressed, get them fed breakfast and sent off to school.
But if it's just a bare belief and you have no emotional investment in it, believe me,
you're not going to get it done because it's hard and you have to get up and you have to
wash them up and you have to feed them and you have to get them off to school.
So we need some emotional investment, but the problem is, and for sure, you need that
emotional investment if you're to do hard things that require sacrifice.
It's jet fuel, emotion is jet fuel.
It's jet fuel.
Exactly right.
And so we need some emotional investment in our beliefs when it comes to the good causes
we believe in.
If we're to actually go out there and take risks and make sacrifices because we believe
justice and right, virtue, morality, require these things, require this action on our part.
But having said all that, if we wrap our emotions too tightly around our convictions, it doesn't
matter what the substance of those convictions is, we become dogmatists, we become ideologues,
we're not leading the examined life.
So we need some distance, a little bit of distance at least, between our beliefs and
our emotions.
We need to distance ourself a little bit at least from our beliefs in order to be self-critical,
in order to be willing to entertain criticism.
If you don't have that at least little bit of distance, you'll perceive anybody, no matter
how good their wills, you'll perceive anybody who challenges you, challenges your belief,
questions them in any way, as engaging in a personal assault on you.
You see them as an enemy.
Because you've so deeply identified yourself with your beliefs.
So you need a little, now, this is not to say, Daniel, that I don't want people to be
people of conviction.
Yeah, we should be people, I mean, as you know, I put whatever resources I have intellectually
and otherwise to the service of certain causes I believe in, the pro-life cause, the pros
of marriage and the family, the cause of religious freedom, and the rights of conscience.
I mean, much of my life's been devoted to serving these causes, and as deeply as I believe
in them, I still don't want to adopt a kind of authoritarian attitude.
You don't want to shut out the debate on those things.
Exactly right.
And I want to be open to any arguments that people, because even if it turns out I'm right
about these things, being challenged by intelligent critics who see it differently is a good
thing.
It's a good thing for this reason.
Even if it doesn't change your mind, even if it shouldn't change your mind, it will
deepen your understanding of the truth.
Yeah.
Now, being a Princeton alum, you, of course, are familiar with the most famous philosopher
in the world, Peter Singer.
I am.
Now, as you know.
I took your class and his class.
That's what I want students to do.
And to his credit, that's what he wants students to do.
You know, I encourage students to take his classes.
My conservative friends are scandalized by that.
He encourages students to take my classes.
That's very good.
We both actually believe that students are made better off by hearing the best arguments
on the competing sides.
We both have our views.
Now, our views couldn't be further apart.
Right.
You know, he believes not only in abortion, but even in infanticide.
Infanticide.
Yeah.
I remember that.
At least the moral.
I remember that very uncomfortable moment in a precept in his class, where the class
was kind of discussing the readings and the lectures, and then we just kind of realized
where it led.
And everyone was like, oh.
Well, exactly right.
Which is, I know that's something you think about a lot of.
One way that you judge certain arguments is seeing where those arguments take you.
Exactly right.
Yeah, that's right.
You've probably heard me say, because you were my student, that look, anybody who's
got a proposition on offer to you, be very careful.
Think.
Consider before accepting it, because when you buy a proposition, when you affirm a proposition,
you are, whether you like it or not, affirming everything that proposition presupposes and
everything that proposition entails.
You know, logic matters.
Right.
The logical presuppositions and the logical implications of a proposition come as a package.
Now, I bring up Peter Singer for this reason.
He and I couldn't disagree more, especially about issues in bioethics and about the sanctity
of human life.
And yet, in our engagement with each other, intellectual engagement with each other, in
our discussions and debates, in person sometimes, but more often in print, my understanding
of those issues, which are very central to my concerns, my understanding has always been
deepened by engaging with him.
It hasn't changed my mind.
Quite the contrary.
It's actually strengthened my understanding.
But the more important thing for the moment is not that he's strengthened them.
He's deepened them.
I understand my own argument better.
I understand the things I actually do believe are true better because I've listened to him,
I've entertained his challenges, I've engaged with him.
So that's part of what it means to try to lead an examined life, to allow your views
to be examined, to engage a critic, to become your own self-critic.
So you, in your own mind, are considering the best that can be thought and can be said
on competing sides of whatever issue it is you're thinking about.