A clean tank can not support life. A balanced tank allows waste to be used to feed microscopic life. Without microscopic life everything in the tank will die. Father Fish explains the distinction between Natural and Hi-Tech sterile aquarium setups. Natural setups use dirted substrates and aquarium plants for a balanced ecosystem. Hi-Tech aquariums involve technology like CO2 injection, high-intensity lighting, and nutrient dosing for optimal plant growth. Father Fish emphasizes the importance of choosing aquarium systems that mirror Nature.
Who is Father Fish?
Louis Foxwell, known on YouTube as Father Fish, is a seasoned fish keeper with 70 years of experience. His simple, easy, and guaranteed methods ensure healthy, happy tropical fish in your aquarium.
Louis adopted the role of Father Fish many years ago when he opened a tropical fish store as a retirement business. Prior to this, he served as a missionary for 25 years, following in his father's footsteps by ministering to a congregation of deaf worshipers. Louis fondly recalls his grandmother in Berlin, Germany, who inspired his love for fish keeping as a child.
As a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, Louis played a significant role in its development, serving as chair of the Community Relations Committee and participating in the Search Committees. With extensive experience across nearly every level of the fish industry, Father Fish offers a wealth of knowledge and products, including plants, soil supplements, and more, to enhance your aquarium experience.
The primary goal of fish keeping is to keep fish alive and healthy. There are two radically
different approaches to achieving this goal. There are tools that are common to both of these
approaches. Filters, lighting, heaters, food, aquariums, other tools, and some chemicals
are typically used by some of these groups of fish teams. The practices
involved in maintaining the systems, however, are diametrically opposed.
There are, as I describe it, two fundamental approaches to keeping fish in an aquarium.
The one is to keep them in the most technologically sophisticated manner possible.
The other is to keep them in the most natural environment possible. Both of these approaches
have very serious advocates. Both of them have the investment of countless hobbyists
deeply committed to each of these two different approaches. For my part, I'm on one side and
not on the other. I'm on the side of maintaining a natural system and I oppose, sometimes very
vehemently, a purely technologically approach to keeping fish alive. Why is that? Why am I
so strongly opposed to the use of technology in an aquarium? Well, the truth is I'm not.
I use heaters. I use lights. I use filters. I use aquariums. I use many of the tools,
many of the devices, many of the systems that have been developed as technology over the last
50 to 75 years, nearly as long as I have been in the hobby. It is the attempt to
remove all natural activity or primary and major activity from an aquarium that I oppose.
What do I mean by this? Well, if you look in a pond or a creek or any body of water out in nature,
you will find elements in that environment that are not permitted to exist in a high-tech
environment. For example, the substrate. The substrate, for me, is the absolute foundation
of a healthy aquarium. The purpose of the foundation is to increase the biodiversity
in the aquarium. Those who do not agree to this either have no substrate or a substrate that is
very shallow and frequently one that is composed of gravel or perhaps small rock, marbles,
occasionally sand, but typically not sand, and it may be no more than half an inch deep,
an inch at the most. Now, here's an interesting characteristic. The so-called under-gravel
filter. The under-gravel filter is, in fact, an attempt to create a natural system. Now,
it's one that is, I believe, fundamentally flawed, but it nevertheless is based on the idea
that waste brought into the substrate will create an environment in which that waste will break down
into its components and be able to feed plants. It breaks down by virtue of biological activity.
So, the under-gravel filter is dependent upon biological activity. It is not, strictly speaking,
a high-tech system at all. In point of fact, it is quite the reverse. The under-gravel filter was
very popular for many years. It came out in the 60s, the 1960s, as a way to be able to maintain
an aquarium long-term without having to do substantial cleaning. Now, typically,
those tanks were cleaned once a year, once every six months, but on an occasional basis,
and they were cleaned because they literally filled up with waste product, which became soil.
Here's an interesting feature of that system. It is at the point where the substrate, the gravel,
sitting on top of the plate that was pulling water through, the point at which that gravel became
completely clogged with detritus, it was at that point that the filter was functioning at its most
effective level. It was functioning as a genuine deep substrate. I have long recommended
to folks who have under-gravel filter systems to simply add an inch of sand to the top of it
and pull out the lift tube and let that act as a plenum so that detritus will continue to
precipitate down into the sand, into that gravel, forming a soil layer. And it is enormously
effective. There are countless hobbyists who have done this over the past few years and are very,
very happy with the results. So let's put the under-gravel filter system on my side of the
equation. On the other side is the half inch of gravel. The half inch of gravel is essentially
there for show. It serves little other function because it needs to be cleaned routinely.
And in point of fact, the hobbyist with a system that has little or no hardscape,
little or no live plants, and a thin layer of substrate with filtration, typically
hang on the back filtration, canister filtration, rarely if ever sponge filter filtration.
What happens to that water after about a week of regular feeding is that the water becomes thick,
heavy with organics. There is nothing in the system to remove the organics. Now,
organics are not solid matter. I'm not talking about detritus. I'm talking about elements that
are dissolved in the water that causes the water to become heavy with an organic composition,
things that dissolve, things like calcium, things like sugars, things like protein,
things that are more elemental, perhaps more microscopic, perhaps things that become a part
of the water column. As the fish are fed and they create waste, urine, for example,
begins to fill up that water system. Some of it is removed. It's removed by the bacteria
that grows in the filter and in whatever little substrate there is that breaks down the ammonia
into nitrites and nitrites then into nitrates. There is, however, nothing in that system to
remove nitrates and so they build up. The perfect example of an organic that is building up to
proportions that are essentially unhealthy. So that tank requires routine maintenance.
The maintenance is primarily of two sorts. It's changing out a substantial amount of the water
and cleaning the substrate, so-called siphon pumping the substrate. That will be done on a
regular weekly basis. It becomes possible to replace the water in the tank with new water
that does not have the organics in it, thereby reducing the percentage of organics. Now,
rarely is that a hundred percent water change. Typically, it's 25 percent, 50 percent,
75 percent. So it's reducing the dissolved organics by up to 75 percent. That increases
over the following week. That same amount of water is taken out, but now the organics are even
richer than they were before because you have that initial 25 percent. You have the additional
organics that have dissolved in the water over the last week, raising the level incrementally.
Eventually, in a year or so, that water becomes so heavy with organics that the whole tank needs
to be broken down. If it is not, the high levels of organics in the water will begin to stress the
fish. It will not be as active, not be feeding as well, and will lose its vigor, becoming
more susceptible to disease and parasites. So long term, that approach to fish keeping
requires considerable and substantial intervention. On the other hand,
with a deep substrate system and lots of plants growing in the water, in the substrate
and in the water column, Anubias, for example, which are taking nutrients directly out of the
water column and not out of the substrate at all. Rooted plants such as Swords and Valisneria
are taking nutrients out of the substrate. In addition to perhaps some floating plants
that are absorbing nutrients directly from the water, the combination of those plants
reduces the dissolved organics in the water and converts the waste that is precipitating
into the substrate into nutrients that the plants are then able to convert into stems, leaves,
flowers, the plant. That system, which is a natural system that goes on all over the earth
as a function of the ecosphere, the living organisms on the earth, is a completely natural
one, which is very simply and very easily duplicated in a fish tank. Now, I say that
knowing there are those who are absolutely convinced that an aquarium cannot be maintained
as a biotope. In other words, you can't have nature in an aquarium because, well,
it's a little glass box, and it's too small, and it doesn't get rain in it, and it doesn't get
wind blowing across it. It doesn't get leaves falling in it. It doesn't get sunlight,
and all of that is true. However, there are bodies of water that also don't get rain,
don't get wind blowing across them, don't get any kind of effective water change,
don't even get much in the way of sunlight on them. So, it's not different in that respect.
There are ways, however, to accommodate those conditions, and that's where I take advantage of
the technology that is available to be able to replicate sunlight, an impossible task.
We cannot create a light as bright as the sun, but we can create lighting, and I believe LEDs
have given us a wonderful way to be able to get directed light comparable to sunlight
into an aquarium. We can also leave it on for long periods of time in order to be able to come
closer to reaching the lumen level that the sun provides to plants. Water evaporates out of
aquariums. As it is replaced, that is rain accommodating the evaporation. That's a natural
process that occurs. Now, it's not raining in our house, but as the water level evaporates,
we do want to top it off. We do want to replace it. I replace that water with my regular tap water,
and the reason I do that is because all of the plants and all of the other life,
including the microfauna and macrofauna and the fish for that matter, that are in the tank are
absorbing nutrients, and not just nutrients, but absorbing the hardness, absorbing the dissolved
minerals that are in the water, causing the water to become softer. So, I add tap water.
My tap water is very hard. There's some who have very soft tap water. That's a completely
different issue, and really not one I have ever encountered. Everywhere I've ever lived has had
very hard water. So, I frankly would not know what to do if I were confronted with very soft water.
I probably would find myself adding minerals or adding some kind of substrate containing minerals
in order to be able to beef that water up. On the other hand, I might decide to keep fish
and whatever kind of plants I could that would survive well in soft acid water. It's not an
issue I'm dealing with, but one that certainly can be dealt with in a natural environment very well.
So, the fish tank set up as a biocode with a substrate capable of allowing detritus, allowing
waste to precipitate into it, to break down, and to nurture, to feed not only the plants,
but all of the microscopic life, all of the microfauna, the bacteria, the fungus, everything
else that's living in that environment that feeds on those precipitated materials. All of that is
fed on, and it breaks down more and more and more until finally the bacteria breaks down what is
left into its final constituent components, which are taken up by the roots of plants, thereby
creating a cycle. It takes a long time for that cycle to occur. It may take as long as five years
for the cycle to become a stable one. So, I create a substrate that has a very substantial amount
of minerals and other components in it, such that it will last for a few years at least
to give that system a chance to be able to become a cycled system. I also add leaf mulch,
and not just any leaves, but leaves out of a body of water that contain living on them,
all of the organisms that cause that wild environment to be able to thrive, that actually
break down the waste and consume it and create tinier amounts, also create macrofauna that feed
many of the fish and other smaller life forms in the body of water. So, it really does become
possible to maintain a very balanced, a very natural, a very living and thriving environment
in the aquarium, as opposed to trying to kill everything in order to prevent that from happening.
I think that approach, the approach of using chemicals to kill algae, for example, an
algaecide, to kill bacteria, for example, a bactericide, those things create a toxic
environment in the tank that eventually attacks the fish that the fish keeper is trying to keep
healthy. And it breaks down that fish's ability to withstand any kind of attack by parasites,
by viruses, by any sort of infective agent or disease-creating agent. So, the approach of
heavy chemicals, constant cleaning, constantly trying to maintain a sterile environment,
I believe is dangerous. It is counterintuitive. Ultimately, it is counterproductive
and eventually will lead to the fish that are being kept in that way dying before they otherwise
would have died. They will become stressed by an environment that is so synthetic
that it does not give the fish the benefit of all of the bacterial, the biological activity
that that fish needs in order to maintain its slime coat, in order to maintain its vibrancy,
in order to maintain its ability to withstand the impact of agents that might otherwise cause it
to become sick. So, I'll leave you with this. There is, I believe, an approach to fish keeping
that is being practiced. It is being taught in virtually every store. It is being taught
by virtually all of the manufacturing agents who promulgate all of these products. It is being
taught by an industry that has put the dollar sign before the health of the fish and before
the ability of the hobbyist to be able to maintain that aquarium long-term as a healthy environment.
I challenge you to set up a natural aquarium. Overcome your fear and anxiety of the natural
world and realize that we are here not because of technological advances but because of our ability
to farm and to nurture the natural environment in a way that improves our health. Whenever some
foreign agent is introduced to us that is of a purely technological nature, it inevitably causes
us stress, distress, illness, and death. When we can develop our technological skills to make use of
the natural processes in nature and be able to bring them into our lives, into our aquarium,
we achieve a higher degree of health, our aquariums thrive, and we are happier.
This principle is one that will determine our survival as a species. We will either learn to
live in harmony with nature by farming, by being husbandry men and women of nature in such a way as
to allow ourselves and the natural system to thrive, reducing our population, killing off
substantial numbers of people in the process, separating ourselves from the natural world,
reducing our ability to farm our land. All of those are destructive of our very existence
here on this earth. And I for one firmly believe that we are here by design. We are here to be
the keepers of this earth. That is our charge, that is our burden, that is our most fundamental
responsibility. We are not foreigners to the earth. We are not interlopers. We are not here by
accident, but by design to do what is best, what is healthiest for ourselves and for all of the
other creatures with whom we live, beginning with those little fish and that little aquarium.
Let that be the lesson for you, the life lesson, to learn to allow those animals to thrive in the
they best can thrive by allowing yourself to encourage natural dynamics, natural parts of
the environment, the natural world, to live in that little aquarium and for you to live
in the natural world. Love you all. Bless you all. Bye for now.