If you owe more on your car than it’s worth, trading it in may not solve the problem. It can roll thousands of dollars of old debt straight into your next loan. In this episode, Anthony breaks down how car debt keeps people trapped, the three numbers you need to know before your next move, and four practical steps to decide whether to keep the car, sell it, close the gap, and eventually break the car-payment cycle for good. He also shares how he went from making six figures with nothing left before the end of the month to building a life where his cars no longer control his financial future. ⏱️ IN THIS EPISODE 00:00 – Introduction: Why trading in a car you can’t afford can move the debt 06:00 – The two real options when you owe more on your car than it’s worth 07:36 – Why 72- and 84-month loans can outlive the car you’re financing 09:26 – How rolling $7,000 of negative equity into another loan keeps the old debt alive 10:42 – The hidden car expense many buyers forget to price before signing: insurance 18:09 – Anthony’s six-figure wake-up call: looking successful with nothing saved or invested 20:30 – The three numbers you need: payoff quote, private-party value, and your remaining gap 23:11 – How to compare the cost of keeping the car versus selling it and closing the gap 27:18 – The cash-car ladder and Anthony’s four-step plan for ending the car-payment cycle
I was making six figures, getting paid on the 15th,
and I've got nothing left by the 26th of the month.
11 days of paycheck, 19 days of the month,
and a whole lot of reasons.
Nice cars, living with our parents,
and barely covering our bills.
Nothing saved, nothing invested.
All of us are performing.
Most people believe the way out of a car
you cannot afford is to trade it in
and to get something cheaper, a.k.a. a new car.
But the truth of the fact is,
you didn't pay off that $7,000.
You moved it.
It's still yours.
It's just wearing a different car now.
Nobody out there was foolish.
We were all optimizing for how it looked in the driveway
instead of what it left us in our account.
If you owe more on your car than it's worth,
you have two specific doors.
The very first door you can walk through
is you can keep it and pay it off.
Now, door number two is you can sell it and close the gap.
You drive that car past the payoff
while everybody around you is signing for their third one.
You keep the margin, you keep the peace,
you keep some options, and you keep building your future.
Depreciation is guaranteed, but interest is optional.
And most of you have walked that hallway already,
and nobody ever told you what it costs.
Stewardship is the foundation of wealth building.
It's not just about having a lot of money and being wealthy,
but it's about having and experiencing freedom.
My name is Anthony O'Neal,
and you're watching The Table with your boy A.R.
If we were sitting across from each other
at a coffee shop this morning,
here's the very first thing I would ask you.
Do you know exactly where your money is going
each and every single month?
Because most people in today's day and time
do not have a money problem.
They have a clarity problem,
and you cannot change what you refuse to measure.
That's why I wrote my brand new book,
Stop Living Paycheck to Paycheck.
I wanted to hand you and your loved ones
the same step-by-step plan I would give you
if we were sitting at the table together.
Listen, if you are ready for the plan and clarity,
go to anthonyoneal.com forward slash book
and order your copy today.
Again, that's anthonyoneal.com forward slash book.
And I promise you, if you read it and apply it,
your finances are gonna look totally different
in the next 12 to 18 months.
The first car I ever bought by myself, no co-signer,
was a brand new Nissan Maxima,
and I was right around 24, 25 years old.
I remember the car like it was yesterday
because I used to see that on all the latest TV shows
and hip hop shows.
But check this out, a few years before that,
I was sleeping in the back of the Nissan Maxima,
specifically in 1987, parked on a street
in Southern California,
specifically in a Walmart parking lot
because I didn't have anywhere else to go.
You see, I had the same badge,
roughly about six to seven years apart,
and I was stuck both times.
You see, now most people believe the way out of a car
you cannot afford is to trade it in
and to get something cheaper, aka a new car.
But coming from a former car salesman,
that's exactly what the dealership is counting on
because right now,
almost three out of every 10 people trading in a car,
they owe more than what the cars actually worth.
I'm gonna give you a specific number upfront
in today's episode because that average gap
is roughly $6,884, so we're gonna round that up to 7,000.
And that 7,000 doesn't disappear when you trade it in.
You should know that because I promise you,
as a matter of fact, if you're watching this on YouTube,
let me know in the comment section below
if you traded in the car and you were upside down
because we all know that that extra $7,000
gets bolted onto the next auto loan, onto the next car.
So you're not financing, quote unquote, a new car.
You're financing the last three cars you had.
Three numbers, two doors.
That's the whole show today.
And I'm not making you wait for it.
Let me be clear before we get started on today's episode.
I do not believe in financing a car.
To be exact, I have not financed a car
in the last 12, 13 years.
And since I haven't done it in the last 12 or 13 years,
huh, I have financed a car.
The very first car I had a co-signer
by my California father.
And then the next one, I did finance that one.
That was the Nissan Maxima.
So today's episode is not gonna be any shame.
I'm not trying to throw any guilt on anyone.
I just wanna be honest.
I don't believe in financing a car.
That's a liability.
So listen, there's a second number attached
to buying a car and almost nobody prices it
before they sign.
It's the one that gets people.
You see, I built a free tool that fixes it.
And I'm gonna be coming back to it here in a few minutes.
So don't go anywhere.
So we got three numbers, two doors,
and I wanna get straight to it.
I'm gonna give you the answer upfront today.
Then I'll spend the rest of today's episode proving it.
Because if I make you wait, let's be honest,
some of y'all are gonna leave and I need y'all to stay.
As a matter of fact, while you're here,
go ahead and hit that subscribe button
and hit the thumbs up and share today's episode
because I promise you it's gonna save some of you all
a lot of money and a lot of headache.
But if you owe more on your car than it's worth,
you have two specific doors.
The very first door you can walk through
is you can keep it and pay it off.
Now, door number two is you can sell it and close the gap.
Those are the two main doors.
And we're gonna go through all these doors
throughout today's episode.
Now, here's the door that isn't a door.
And it's the only one.
It is the one that when you walk through the dealership,
this is what they want you to do.
They want you to trade it in,
roll what you owe onto the next one,
drive off with a longer term
and a easy, affordable monthly payment.
And to me, for my community, that is not a door.
That is a hallway that walks you back into the same room
with more furniture in it.
Think about that.
It's not a door.
It's a hallway.
And when you walk back to it, it's just more furniture,
more bills, more issues.
And most of you have walked that hallway already
and nobody ever told you what it costs.
I want that to sit in just for a little bit.
I did some research.
And as I am, you all know, as I'm getting my doctorate
at one of the best schools, Regent University,
here in the DMV area,
I found that the average new car loan in America today
is $43,925 at around 6.5% interest rate,
if you have actually good credit.
And a term, this is part of the thing that I do not like,
72 months, Lord Jesus, six years.
Now, plenty of dealers will stretch this to about 84 months
if you flinch at the payment over 72 years.
Now, how long do you actually keep the car?
For most people, it's two to three years on average.
So I want you to sit with that just for a little minute.
You signed for 72 months.
You're leaving at 30 months.
Pause.
I signed a loan for 72 months, but I'm leaving at 30 months.
Family, that's the whole problem right there.
Your loan outlives the car every single time.
Being upside down isn't bad luck.
It's the whole thing they want you to be in.
That's exactly where they want you to be
because that car starts losing value
the day you drive it home,
the day you drive it off the lot,
but your loan doesn't even care.
In the first years of the 72-month note,
a big piece of every single payment goes to the interest,
not the balance.
So the car is falling.
The loan is barely moving.
And somewhere around year two or three,
those two lines, they cross.
That's the moment you go underwater.
And most people have no idea because nobody's checking.
Then you walk into the dealership.
Uh-oh, we're going back to that hallway.
And when that man runs your trade in
and sees you owe $6,884 more than the car is worth,
he doesn't say, sir, you're upside down.
Let's fix this first.
He says, we can take care of you.
I got you.
You see, what they're gonna be saying is,
how much money do you wanna pay a month?
They're not gonna tell you
how much total you're gonna be paying.
And here's the truth.
He can fix it.
He'll roll that almost $7,000 right into the new loan
and keep the payment friendly
because he stretched it now from 72 months to 84 months.
And you drove off the lot feeling like
you did something amazing.
You got this brand new car.
It smells fresh.
It looks good.
It has brand new paint on it.
But the truth of the fact is
you didn't pay off that $7,000.
You moved it.
It's still yours.
It's just wearing a different car now.
Mm, do that twice.
And people are doing it.
And now you're making a payment every month
on a vehicle somebody else is driving right now.
I want that to sit in.
You traded it in and you're still making a payment
on the car that you have now
and on two other cars that someone else is driving.
And they're saying thank you for depreciating the car
and I paid cash for it.
Think about that.
But before we move on,
so the payment I would say was never the real number.
There's a second number nobody runs before they even sign.
The one that I promised you at the top
that I will come back to.
You see, insurance isn't priced on you.
It's priced on the actual vehicle.
Same driver, same car, same clean driving record.
Put that person in a, let's say a Ford F-150
and it's $100 a month.
Put that exact same person in a Tesla Model Y
that's driving itself and it's $241 a month,
more than double.
Nothing changed but the vehicle.
So you shop the car, you negotiate the car and you sign.
And two weeks later, the insurance bill,
it shows up and the car you agreed to
costs $200 more a month than the number you agreed.
You priced one number and never priced the other one.
Family, let's talk about one of the biggest money leaks
in your budget and that's car insurance.
You see, most folks are overpaying by hundreds
every single year just because
they haven't checked their rate.
If you haven't shopped your policy lately,
you're probably giving away money for nothing,
for no reason.
Here's the truth that I recently found.
The average driver is paying over $2,000 a year
for car insurance.
I said that right.
And rates have jumped up more than 30%
in just the last couple of years.
But three out of four drivers never shop around.
So they stuck paying more for the exact same coverage.
Listen, you work hard for your money.
Why give more of it away than you have to?
You see, with my trusted tool,
you can compare real quotes from top companies
in just minutes.
No spam, no pressure,
and it won't impact your credit score, I promise.
Most people save hundreds a year just by checking it,
specifically just from within our community.
Do not let another dollar slip away.
Visit anthonyoneal.com forward slash car insurance,
enter your zip code and see how much you could save today.
It's quick, it's free, and it's your money.
Keep more of it inside of your pocket.
Listen, family, let's stop overpaying for car insurance.
Go to anthonyoneal.com forward slash car insurance
right now and start saving today.
All right, let's get back to the show.
You see, nationally, that's $2,237 a year.
And listen, I live in Maryland.
We pay the most in the country.
Oh my gosh, the average person pays close to $4,100 a year
on average, right?
I'm paying almost seven.
Now, if you already have the car,
you can still cut that number today.
And every dollar you cut goes straight at the payoff.
That's door number one.
And this is how you fund it.
You see, go to anthonyoneal.com forward slash car insurance,
put in your zip code and compare
what you're paying against what's out there.
Listen, it will take you not even two minutes
on this particular form that I created.
It won't touch your credit.
It's 100% free.
You're not gonna get any spam emails.
That's my tool.
So when you use it, listen,
I promise you it's going to be effective,
but I wouldn't put my name on it
if I wouldn't tell my own mother to do it.
As a matter of fact, this tool saved me
close to about two to $3,000.
And if you do not have a car yet,
price the insurance before you pick the car.
That's the order.
Go to anthonyoneal.com forward slash car insurance today.
Give yourself two minutes,
put money back into your pocket.
Let's get back to it.
So what does I would say that hallway cost us?
And I'm saying us because I have done this before.
I will not do this again, but I have done it before.
I'm saying every one of these out loud
for those of you who are listening in the car.
So you don't have to worry about anything else.
If you're driving and watching this on YouTube,
just listen and pay attention.
Now let's talk about this hallway.
Somebody who rolls negative equity forward,
let's just say the second quarter of the year,
their payment lands, let's say right around $944.
The industry average is right around $777.
That's $167 a month every month
for moving the problem instead of for solving it.
So let me break it down like this.
That's an extra $167 a month
that you rolled over to your new car payment
for the old car somebody else is driving.
But the payment is the small part.
The person rolling over equity into a new loan
is projected to pay $16,000 in interest
over the life of the loan.
The average new car buyer pays roughly $9,811.
So that one decision, rolling over old cars into new cars
is close to $6,500 in interest payment alone.
Now I gotta say that one more time
because I need this one to land.
Remember, this is about financial freedom.
Every dollar we could save from paying out interest,
we can position that money to now make us interest.
$6,500 gone to interest
just for rolling over your car.
Y'all, that's an emergency fund
for a family that has never had one and it's gone.
It didn't buy you a better car.
It didn't provide you peace.
It didn't set you up to have options.
And it didn't buy you one day of freedom.
What did it buy you?
12 more months of pain.
What did it buy you?
Less freedom.
And this is not a handful of individuals.
Almost three out of every 10 trade-ins
in this country are underwater.
And more than one in four of those people
owe over $10,000 or more than what the cars were.
That's a third of the car market carrying debt on vehicles
they do not even own anymore.
And nobody is even telling them.
I was telling this to my class just the other day
at Virginia Union University
that the system isn't designed to make you wealthy.
I'm gonna say this respectfully
and I do not want to disrespect anyone outside
of the African-American minority community,
but the system is especially not designed
for black people, people of color.
It is designed to keep you paying
to keep us in debt, period, period.
So now I gotta tell you how I ended up in it.
I gotta be transparent and honest.
You see the brand new Maximal I told you about,
I was about 24 to 25 years old.
And I'm gonna be honest with you, I was proud of it.
That was the secret ingredient.
That was proof that the kid who used to sleep
in a Maximal had made it out.
I was pulling up.
I was looking good.
That was the brand new body style of that Maximal boy.
It was sweet.
It was black on black, black wheels, black leather.
It was the first car I had with leather.
You couldn't tell me nothing.
I thought I was the man.
But the truth of the fact is I wasn't.
Truth of the fact is I wasn't.
I was making six figures, getting paid on the 15th.
And I've got nothing left by the 26th of the month.
11 days of paycheck, 19 days of the month.
And a whole lot of reasons.
I was sitting in my driveway, looking beautiful.
Pulling up to church, looking like he got it made together.
But if I go back and I remember the past,
every Friday me and my crew went out to Oceanside,
California, play volleyball on the beach.
We'll have our shirt off and put on oil
and look good for the ladies.
Every car in that parking lot was clean.
Everybody looked like they arrived.
And on one of those nights,
one of my boys walks up to me and asked me for $5
so he could go to McDonald's.
And this man is driving a Range Rover,
sitting on 24s and living with his mother.
Now I want to be careful here
because there's a version of this story
where I'm the smart one
and that lot shaking my head at everyone else.
But that's not what happened
because every one of us was doing the exact same thing.
Nice cars, living with our parents
and barely covering our bills.
Nothing saved, nothing invested.
All of us are performing.
And I was doing it in a slightly cheaper package.
That's the only difference between me and that Range Rover.
That's the night I said, I have to change my life.
So when I tell you I don't finance cars,
I'm not saying it from a pedestal.
I'm saying it from the parking lot.
Nobody out there was foolish.
We were all optimizing for how it looked in the driveway
instead of what it left us in our account.
And you cannot budget your way out of a car
you should have never signed for.
Is this making sense?
So I want to get to some real numbers
because I know some of you are saying,
man, this is feeling overwhelming.
Overwhelming specifically for one reason.
You've never written them down.
It's two simple phone calls.
Number one, what you owe.
Not what the app says.
You call your lender and use these exact words.
I need my payoff quote.
That's gonna be exactly, well, apply this.
That's what it actually takes to make the car,
to make that car yours today.
Including the interest built up since your last payment.
It's almost always higher
than the balance you've been staring at.
And people get emotional when they hear it.
Which is exactly why you need to hear this.
Then number two, what is your car worth?
And I want the private party value, not the trade-in value.
Not the trade-in value.
Because coming from a car salesman,
the dealership only is gonna give you
the lowest value of your trade-in.
Because trade-in value is what the dealership hands you
so they can resell it to make a profit.
Which is totally expected.
No one's in business to not make any money.
But private party value is what a real person pays you
on Saturday if you'd sell the car directly yourself.
The spread is often, I would say, thousands of dollars
and it belongs to you.
I think last time I did a research,
you can probably get about three to five more thousand
dollars for your car if you privately sell it.
Now number three, the gap takes number one
and subtracts number two.
You see, I don't wanna say this.
If the car is worth more than you owe,
you've got equity and options.
But if you owe more, that difference is your gap.
That's what you will still owe on a car
you don't even have anymore if you sold it tomorrow.
I want you to write it down and put it where you'll see it.
Because the day that number stops being a mystery
is the day you start doing something about it.
So right now, what I wanna do is pick the door.
I want you to listen to this episode
and pick which door is best for me
if you're in this situation.
And let's just say you're not in this situation,
I want you to share today's episode
with someone who is in this situation
so we can help them get out of this situation.
So how do you know which door is yours?
Let me say this up front.
It's not a feeling, it's a comparison.
Cost, I'm gonna say it like this.
The cost to keep it is gonna vary every time.
What's your remaining payment on a loan?
All the way to the end.
And the cost to leave it is your gap
plus whatever reliable used car cost you in cash.
Hopefully that makes sense.
Hopefully I'm saying it correctly so you can understand it.
The smaller one is your door.
That's the whole test.
Door number one, keep it and pay it off
using the debt snowball method.
If it's cheaper to keep that car, I want you to keep it.
And I don't mean drift along on minimum payments.
No, I mean you put it in your debt snowball
and you go after it.
Every extra dollar, the insurance money you just saved,
the raise that you just got, the tax refund you just got,
all of it until that note is dead,
until that note is gone, until that car payment is zero.
And here's the part that changes your entire family.
You see, when it's paid off,
you keep making that payment to yourself
into an account you do not touch.
That $750 was already gone and you were surviving.
Now let's take that same $750
or whatever your car payment is and let's start building.
Let's get you into a season of thriving.
And you drive that car past the payoff
while everybody around you is signing for their third one.
You keep the margin.
You keep the peace.
You keep some options and you keep building your future.
That's the whole thing.
Because what's gonna happen is when you pay that off,
you're gonna feel like, oh, I need a new car.
I need new insurance.
I need to go get a brand new.
I need something with leather.
I need something with the Apple TV.
I need something that I can step up in.
Door number two, sell it and close the gap.
I need you to pay attention on this one
because this is gonna be a little different.
You see, if the number says get out, I need you to get out.
I need you to sell it privately, not trade it in
because that's where the higher number lives.
And you take that money straight to the lender
and whatever's left, let's say it's $4,000.
Yes, listen to me clearly.
You take a loan out for that $4,000
and you attack it like your life depends on it.
Now I know some of you, some of you just flinch.
Wait a minute.
Anthony just said loan.
Anthony said debt.
Hear me clearly.
There is no car attached to that money.
The car is gone.
You're taking a $43,000 problem
and turning it into a $4,000 problem.
So you can kill it in a year
instead of for dragging it six years.
Don't, don't, don't, don't clip this
into the Anthony's contradicting himself.
He said, go borrow money.
No, no, no.
That's not financing your car.
That's closing out a mistake.
My liability would just went down.
I went from $43,000, sold the car.
I'm down to $4,000.
It saves me on time and it saves me on interest going out.
And there are two rules on it and they're not negotiable.
The number has to go down and the car has to be gone.
Period.
So I know the question is now.
So Anthony, what do I drive?
Anthony, okay.
Let's say if I got to go to door number two
and I have no, no, no, no car.
What do I drive?
You start where you are.
Maybe you buy a $3,000, $4,000 car.
Cash is not the car you want.
And I won't pretend it is, but it's yours.
And it doesn't send you a bill.
You drive it a few years while your income goes up
and your expenses stay flat.
And you're saving the whole time
because you don't have a car note.
Then you trade up to a $10,000 car cash.
And then what happens is you do it again.
You see, you keep climbing the ladder
and one day you'll pay cash
for something you never believe you could own.
I know because I did it.
I did it.
I went from an old school.
I traded my Maxima.
I paid the gap.
Downgraded to a Acura TL used older version.
Then I upgraded to a brand new Acura TL.
Sold that to my former boss.
Went and bought a BMW 7 Series.
Traded that in.
Got into the Porsche.
Traded the Porsche in.
Went into the Bentley.
Pay cash.
I've never signed again for any of my cars.
So first, get your three numbers.
Second, run the comparison.
Third, pick your door.
Fourth, start the ladder.
Because a $4,000 car that you own
beats a $44,000 car that owns you.
Every single day of the week.
You see, I'm reminded as we close
in Proverbs chapter 22, verse seven.
The rich rule over the poor
and the borrower is the slave of the lender.
The borrower is the slave of the lender.
That's not me being dramatic, family.
That is actually scripture.
God designed you specifically for freedom, for abundance.
And every dollar you keep out of a car payment
is a dollar you cannot use to build, to give,
and to leave something that outlives you.
So here's what I want you to do.
Go get my brand new book,
Stop Living Paycheck to Paycheck.
That car payment is the single biggest reason
so many of you are 11 days into a 30-day month
and you're broke.
Today's episode is just a tool
to maybe bring this awareness.
That book is the plan and the strategy.
To be honest with you, a lot of you all do not know this,
but it was my doctoral final project at Regent University.
The research and the book are the same body of work.
It's the one I had
and I'm having still to this day to defend.
And listen, this was never really about a car.
It was about every single payment you agreed to
before the month, I would say the month ran out.
Depreciation is guaranteed,
but interest is optional.
Y'all, it's your boy, Anthony O'Neal.
If you made it all the way to the end,
give me a thumbs up.
Please hit that subscribe button
and I'll see you in the next episode.
Peace out.