I ranked watch complications

Talking Watches.
92 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 4, 2026
This Watch, That Watch evaluates various mechanical watch complications, ranging from standard date windows and power reserves to tourbillons and chiming mechanisms. The analysis explores the intersection of aesthetic design, engineering complexity, and daily utility to determine how these features enhance or detract from the overall function and appeal of a timepiece
AI Generated·May contain errors
Complication, that's the word you use
when talking about the things your mechanical watch can do.
Date, that's a complication.
Moon phase, complication.
Chiming mechanism, complication.
Let's rank them and figure out which are good,
which are S-tier, and which are absolute trash.
Let's dive in.
Let's just start with probably the most common
and ubiquitous complication, the date function.
Usually you have that little nine o'clock window
with the current date showing.
In the world of iPhones, iPads, smartwatches,
and digital information everywhere,
nobody really needs the date function.
And yet, it's hugely convenient.
It happens more often than I care to admit
that I need to sign something
and I need to note down the date.
And instead of opening up the phone,
I just glance down at my watch.
Ask anyone who has a watch.
The majority will swear to the date function
as absolutely essential, but it's not without its problems.
Because what it has in terms of usefulness,
it does sometimes lose in terms of implementation.
Because just below elected officials
comes complaining about date complications.
Is the date wheel color matched?
That's a paddling.
Is the date window cutting out part of the six o'clock
or three o'clock numeral?
That's a paddling.
Does the date window lack some sort of frame?
That's a paddling.
Does the date switch exactly at 12 o'clock?
If not, that's a paddling.
4.30 date window?
That's also a paddling.
Something so simple is so easy to screw up completely,
but you can't get away from the fact that it is essential.
This is an A-tier complication.
Not quite S-tier, but so very close.
One thing that also I think should deserve a paddling
is people who are returned viewers to the channel
and have not yet subscribed.
What's the problem?
Can't you see the click button?
It's right there.
Please subscribe.
Thanks a ton.
Power reserve.
This is a function that shows how unwound
the mainspring barrel is,
and gives you an estimate of how much reserve you have left.
Just like the date window,
you've got all sorts of implementations.
There's the power reserve approach
on watches like the Glashütte Panel Reserve,
which is simply beautiful.
And then there's the Grand Seiko approach,
which is let's take our beautiful dial
and shove a power reserve in somewhere around at 7.30
and hope it kind of looks okay.
The biggest problem with power reserve,
apart from it being ugly often, or sometimes,
is that it's pointless, at least on an automatic watch.
On an automatic watch, it's downright silly,
but even on manual wind, it's a little bit stupid
because most watch users will either wind their watch
at night or in the morning before they put it on.
We know how long our watch will last,
and even the most basic of movements these days,
having a minimum of 41 hours of power reserve,
it's just not really that useful.
Sure, it's a complication, but you don't need it.
You turn the crown until you meet resistance,
and then you stop.
You repeat in 24 hours time, if it's a manual wind,
and then you move on with your life.
Seat here.
The Tourbillon, Tourbillon, sorry.
The ultimate complication.
A Tourbillon is an intricate mechanical watch complication
that houses the escapement and balance wheel
in a rotating cage,
generally completing one rotation per minute.
It was patented in 1801 by Abraham Louis Breguet,
and it was designed to counteract the effects of gravity
on pocket watches, theoretically improving accuracy.
I might as well get you all riled up
before I explain my reasoning.
The Tourbillon is trash tier, D tier, bottom of the barrel.
It is the watch world equivalent of the machine
that goes, bing, what does it do?
It goes, bing, and the Tourbillon does nothing.
It doesn't make the watch better.
It doesn't actually counteract gravity.
It is an utterly functionally pointless complication.
Technically, that actually means it's not a complication
because it doesn't do anything.
So it's complicated, but it's not really a complication.
Is it difficult to do?
Absolutely, but not as difficult as it used to be.
You can get Tourbillons in fairly affordable brands.
You can get them from Seeger for $4,000,
Yammer for 10, 12,000, you know, thereabouts,
Horage, 10,000.
With access to modern production equipment,
it's honestly not this feat of engineering
it once used to be.
I know, I'm even in disagreement with ChatGPT,
who I asked this about.
ChatGPT and Claude both believe it's super hard to do,
but I just don't agree.
This is just like making a nuclear weapon.
It's not hard.
It's hard to get hold of the materials.
It's expensive, and it's very easy to spot
when someone is trying to enrich in uranium.
But technically, it's just not that difficult anymore
if you have access to the right people
and the right equipment.
And lastly, it's just not always particularly pretty.
It ruins the dial, it makes the watch thicker,
and it just doesn't do anything.
If only it just went, bing!
You are telling me you really need to know
where we are in the moon's phases.
Why?
Are you a werewolf?
Do you need to chain yourself to a desk in the basement?
You can't just look up at the night sky?
When do you need this information?
Seriously, unless you're a nurse
working the emergency room
and wanting to avoid the wildest nights,
then the moon phase really has no usefulness to anybody.
But it is pretty.
When done right,
it's one of the prettiest complications out there.
More often than not, it elevates the dial,
it adds visual interest, it adds intricacy,
and it communicates class and sophistication.
Usefulness be damned.
I want that stone dial background
with that silver hand-stamped moon
to slowly appear day by day
until I have a full moon dead center on my dial.
It's A tier for sure for me.
Beauty over function.
Tide.
The little sister to the moon phase.
The moon and tide phase.
You do not see this complication often.
The tide, to a large extent, follows the moon phases,
but it also has a daily cycle
that is related to the rotation of the Earth.
Much like the 300 meter dive watch,
there's always someone in the comments
that's a saturation diver.
There is someone out there
that lives permanently underwater,
and therefore can't do without a watch
that can remain submerged at a depth of 11 kilometers.
And there must be some North Shore surfer
who just can't do without a tide complication
so they know when the gnarliest sets are coming in.
But for the rest of us, it's useless.
It's a pain to set
because you have to search both moon phases
and tides to set it,
and it's not like you're going to tell your kids,
wake up kids, it's 2.30 in the morning,
the tide's coming in and it's safe to go swimming now.
It's not trash, it's beautiful,
but the moon phase trumps it.
B tier.
Having a seconds hand is a complication.
And this is boring on S tier.
Why?
Because the seconds hands is what tells you
that your watch is working.
Sure, a dress watch with no seconds hands
can be elegant and refined,
but I guarantee you at some point,
every person with a watch without a seconds hands
has at some point or another held the watch up to their ear
to check if it was ticking.
Also, without the seconds hands,
how are you going to satisfy
the obsessive compulsive among us
that need a way of gauging by eye
whether or not your movement
actually is plus minus two seconds per day accurate?
You know who you are.
Without a hacking seconds hand,
your life would devolve into chaos.
You would not be able to function
because where the rest of us just show up to meetings at work
with a leeway of plus minus 11 minutes,
mostly plus 11 in my case,
you need to be bang on schedule to the second.
You know what?
Screw it.
S tier for the seconds hand.
The jump hour.
It's the one where the hour jumps.
It's the Swiss watch industry's answer
to the digital G-Shock display.
It gets oohs and ahs from every one
that sees it for the first time.
It's undeniably cool to see,
especially when you have that instantaneous switch
at the top of the hour.
Some of my favorite Grail watches
are variations on the jump hour theme
with the Lange Zeitwerk to this day
being my absolute favorite.
The jump hour does have two fatal flaws though.
On a simple aguchet style,
it often ruins the look of the dial.
Admittedly, this is because we're so used to seeing a dial
with at least two hands,
one short, one fat, one long, one thin,
that seeing just a single long thin hand
comes across as odd to our brains.
What you're often left with is a largely empty dial,
a minute and possibly a second's hands
that feels like an abandoned mother and child
where dad went out for cigarettes one night
and never came back.
And the jump hour in itself
has a similar challenge to the date window.
Is it color matched?
Where does it go on the dial?
It's no coincidence that the good implementations
like a Tank Aguchet from Cartier are rare.
And the best implementations are not just jump hours,
but fully digital complications,
just like my Grail, the Zeitwerk,
which keeps my bank manager up at night.
C-tier.
Not a lot of regular humans with lives, family,
and healthy interests know this,
but watch nerds know that there is such a thing
as a mechanical alarm wristwatch.
The Memovox from JLC comes to mind,
as does the Vulcan cricket.
The concept is simple.
You set the alarm function to a specific time,
and when the actual time catches up to that time,
a mechanism vibrates within the case.
Unlike a chiming mechanism,
the alarm is typically just a shrill
or metallic buzzing sound.
The name Vulcan cricket has a very fitting name
in that it does have that distinct buzzing
that you get from Japanese rainforests
filled with cicadas making the most infernal noise.
Usefulness is top-notch.
It works exactly as advertised.
The downside, more often than not, it sounds awful.
I suppose it's fine for timing an egg
or something in the oven,
but as an alarm clock,
I can't think of a worse way to be woken up in the morning.
Odds are I would be sending that watch flying
on morning one just to get it to stop.
This is not Apple iPhone gentle wake-up melody
or a wrist sensor's soft vibration on the wrist.
It's just a cacophony of metal against metal
guaranteeing that at least I will be in a bad mood
for the rest of the day.
I'd also put money on you getting fired
pretty quickly if you use that to time
when a meeting needs to end.
The idea is brilliant,
but the implementation is more often than not substandard.
C-tier.
The chiming repeaters on the other hand
are a whole different kettle of fish.
There's no longer just an alarm buzzer,
but a set of gongs that differentiate
between the hour, the minutes and the seconds
with varying tones for each.
With the push of a button,
you can chime off the time whenever you need it
and it plays a cute little time melody.
The best of the bunch are acoustically brilliant
with a clear and bright tone that you would never expect
from something as small as a wristwatch.
It's a stunning complication,
but also one of the pricier ones.
Usefulness is again in the category of,
I suppose it has its place.
It's more of a party piece,
but it's one that never ceases to put a smile on your face.
You pay through the nose, but for me, A-tier.
There are different variants of calendars
from the simplest ones that show the day, date and month,
but fail to compensate for 30 and 31 days
and are completely baffled by the concept of February
to the slightly brighter pupil in the room
which knows we usually alternate between 30 and 30 days,
but still has no clue when it comes to February.
And then of course, they are the true perpetual calendars
that for 400 years, at least give or take,
know exactly which month it is,
how many days there are in a month and whether or not
it's a leap year.
Some brands even throw in a year disc for you
and some brands even supply an additional disc
should you live long enough to need it
for the next 400 years.
The simplest version, the day and date,
is what differentiates the date just from the day date.
Well, that and a lot of gold
and an additional $30,000, $35,000 to the price tag.
But you don't really have to pay that much
because there are numerous ETA, Solita
and various off-the-shelf movements that offer the same.
It's fine, but it doesn't get me excited.
On its own, that's a decent B-tier.
The annual calendar has the usual benefit
over perpetual of being cheaper.
Often you have really similar implementations on the dial
getting you the perpetual feel
and you only need to adjust it when you hit February.
But it's B-tier to me simply because it's a compromise.
There's an appeal to the engineering complexity
that goes into a true perpetual calendar.
It's got extra gears and cans and due dates.
Yes, that's a technical term by the way,
but there's just something about the long-term precision
to it that enthusiasts find hugely compelling.
It's also a complication that lends itself to beautiful
but not overstuffed dials.
The different elements can be relegated
to different sub-dials.
I'm partial to those kinds of models
over the ones that have different date windows.
Having a day sub-dial, a date sub-dial
and a month sub-dial plus some sort of leap year indicator
can be incredibly beautiful.
It is A-tier though and not S-tier.
Why?
Price and usefulness.
There just aren't enough affordable options
and brands have a tendency to paywall this complication
behind precious metal, further pushing up the price.
And honestly, the date is convenient
but the rest, kind of pointless.
The comment I get most often
when talking about the usefulness of chronographs
is some version of, I use it to boil my eggs.
And from now on, I might have to call
the chronograph mechanism, the egg timer complication.
The chronograph complication is S-tier, simple as.
It's a relatively affordable complication.
It's not exclusive to the precious metal paywall
and chronograph implementations add visual interest
to the dial and case.
The movement, if visible, often has enough going on
to be worth gushing over.
Whether that's a Lange chronograph
or something seemingly as simple
as a 321 or 3861 movement, they are good looking.
It's practical, even though I do contend
that most people don't use it at all.
What's not to love about the chronograph?
It's the complication that I think every watch enthusiast
should have in their collection.
The GMT, a complication that adds a second hour hand
which rotates around the dial once every 24 hours.
It points usually to a 24 hour rotating bezel
that allows you to track an extra time zone.
It's usually not the most aesthetically
interesting complication, but what you lose
in terms of intricacy, you gain in practicality.
The chronograph's usefulness is theoretical for most,
but GMTs actually have a use case
and most people do travel at some point in time.
I always have a GMT of some sort with me
when traveling out of country.
I love having my home time easily available.
Could I just subtract seven hours from the country
I was in over summer to figure it out?
Sure, but you forget.
You inevitably ask your travel companion,
is the difference six or seven hours?
I think it's seven.
Is it seven?
Are you sure?
Let's check.
You don't have to do that.
You just look down.
From an aesthetic perspective,
you rarely have bad implementations.
It adds detail without throwing off balance,
aesthetic or simplicity.
And if you really want to go all in,
upgrade to the world timer,
which is the GMT with a globe on it.
Fabulous implementation.
It's a phenomenal yet simple complication.
For me, it's not just S tier, but God tier.
So that was my ranking
of some of the most widespread complications out there.
Which ones I think are best and why?
What's your ranking and why?
Share in the comments, like, subscribe.
Cheers.
