President Donald Trump has responded to an Iranian official calling him the "worst president in American history." Trump spoke at an event, where he said, "they lost one set of leaders. Then they lost another set of leaders. Then they lost half of a third set, and they had a little runoff for who wants to be president and there were no participants."
A top Iranian official also claims the Iranian officials who negotiated with U.S. officials in New York City during last month's United Nations General Assembly did so against the orders of Iran Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This analysis examines the low-intensity conflict between the U.S. and Iran, highlighting the Iranian regime's internal instability, the impact of a stringent U.S. naval blockade on oil exports, and the strategic deployment of U.S. military assets to deter aggression as Iran shifts toward a more preemptive and global military posture.
Jonathan, thank you so much for taking the time to be here with us.
Thank you so much for having me. Always my pleasure.
And I wanted to start by talking to you a little bit about these remarks because it seems as though
we continue to have kind of this back and forth where there's questions over who is in control,
who has maybe the lead here, so to speak, in this war between the U.S. and Iran still ongoing.
So what do you make of that kind of back and forth as it continues?
Yeah, so I think that's the proper framing is the war is still going on in some phase,
although it's clearly lower intensity than what we saw earlier this year.
So I think partly what you're seeing from that Iranian official who was quoted, who has been
promoted to this, as Trump said, third or fourth set of leaders since the war started,
a lot of that is Iran wants to do. Well, first of all, they want to convey both to the world,
to America and to the Iranian people that the regime in Iran did not lose this war. Now,
they probably genuinely believe that, but they also want for the purposes of deterrence,
both internal and external, to keep hitting those notes. He's also competing with other
people in Iran for leadership. And this is a good way to to brandish your bona fides
is to come out and be as anti-American as possible. And also on the other side,
what you're seeing from President Trump is a belief that he still controls the initiative
against the Iranians. As you said, we're not in the high intensity war right now,
but there's clearly very much a competition and risk taking both to set the terms for any future
round of conflict, but also on both sides to try to deter the other side from ramping up.
And I want to read those again. This is, again, coming from that representative there from Iran's
National Security Council, as he said, quote, after one failure after another,
the worst president in American history just keeps talking and talking. And now his words
have even outrun his own fantasies. You can win every day in your own imagination, but
reality is shaped by Iran, by its people, its soldiers and its missiles. And that right there,
just part of President Trump's response, as he said, in part, quote, they lost one set of leaders,
then they lost another set of leaders. Then they lost half of the third set and they had a little
runoff for who wants to be president. And there were no participants. Everyone said, quote, I
don't, I don't want to be. So again, that is just a portion of what President Trump had to say.
Now, I also want to go to this right here, because this has been a topic of discussion.
We did have the prayer leader who said on Friday that Iranian officials who held negotiations
during a recent visit to New York City had acted against Supreme Leader Mashtaba Khamenei's
instructions. And that quote, the Supreme Leader did not authorize negotiations. He only instructed
them to convey these seven conditions to the United States. And he went on to say his instruction was
to announce the conditions not to negotiate. Those who negotiated there acted against the
leader's orders. What do you make of that? Because that's a pretty strong comment to make,
essentially saying that any negotiations there really didn't happen lawfully, so to speak.
Yeah. So that's a great quote in the context of what we've just been talking about. And it
goes back to the quote from the first Iranian official we saw, which is intended to convey a
message that Iran is not going to negotiate under pressure with the United States. We've seen,
there's been talks on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly about potentially getting back
into negotiations. We saw Iranian officials float a so-called seven-day plan to go back to the deal
that was agreed in June, which is very favorable to the Iranians. It's one of the reasons it fell
apart. But right now, what you're seeing is competition among the hardliners in the Iranian
regime who want no negotiations with the United States. They'll take a deal if it involves one
sided capitulation by the United States, but they don't want to get back into negotiations.
They think they hold an upper hand and they think diplomacy would lose that advantage,
lose that leverage for them. In comparison, the officials who were the target of that quote we
just saw are Iranian. People often call them moderates. That's incorrect. They're in no way
moderate, but they are more pragmatic in the sense that they are willing to try to negotiate
for U.S. sanctions relief, get some relief for the burdened Iranian economy and regime,
and then use that as a position of leverage. It's really a question, a difference of means
rather than goals. But because the previous Supreme Leader was killed at the outset of the
war and there's a question about how much authority his successor, his son, currently
holds and practices, you have this sort of vacuum where everyone's competing to sound more extreme
and defiant than everyone else. And Jonathan, you and I haven't really discussed this in any
of our previous conversations, but I know that at this point, we still really don't have an idea of
where Majtaba Khamenei is. He's, of course, the one who was named Supreme Leader after the death
of his father. You have that post that I read that essentially says that those representatives
from Iran that were there in New York City defied his orders. So why is it that we necessarily
haven't seen him over the last, I would say, seven months or so? Yeah, it's a great question.
And I think the answer is clearer now than maybe if we had this discussion four or five
months ago. The general consensus is he is alive, although badly injured, and he is trying to keep
as low profile as possible, given very real fears that if he surfaces, he would quickly be the
target for U.S. or Israeli airstrikes. He certainly internalized that lesson. So the net result of
that is, while he keeps a very low profile and communicates indirectly and surreptitiously with
various officials, while he is generally agreed to be the new Supreme Leader, his ability to exercise
that authority is limited for the reasons we just discussed in everyday practice. And therefore,
you get a lot of these other hardline officials, particularly in the military, who are close to
Mojtaba, basically carrying out the day-to-day functions and trying to set the everyday tone
for the regime while the Supreme Leader himself remains in hiding. And you are taking a live look.
We've shown this quite a bit. It's from Marine Traffic and essentially shows the movement or
lack thereof that's taking place in the Strait of Hormuz. Now, essentially,
only those vessels there that actually have their transponders are actually being able to
be visualized there. So even though it looks like there's not a lot of activity there,
there could still be, but it's those folks who are not turning on their transponders.
And that brings me to my next point here from Iran International English, the type very small,
but essentially U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Besson saying that Iran would have no oil
shipments at sea at all this week and no associated revenue as Washington intensifies what
he described as an unprecedented campaign to isolate Iran economically, saying, quote,
for the first time in history, since they started pumping oil, they will have no oil on the water
this week. Besson saying that in an interview with the Axios show that was published earlier
on today, adding, quote, they will have no revenues. Now, he said the economic pressure
followed what he described as a deliberate sequence of military and economic measures
against Iran, adding, quote, we had kinetic action. We destroyed their Navy, their Air Force,
substantially depleted their drone and missile capability, destroyed their chances of rebuilding
that. Then we went with what the president calls the iron wall and the blockade, which we've never
done before, adding, quote, and now we have Operation Economic Outcast and we are isolating
them economically like it's never happened before. So how exactly does that kind of work? Because
we're not talking about missiles being fired over at Iran. We're talking about hitting them where it
hurts with the economy. Yeah. So what we saw in that quote from the treasury secretary is Iran is
unable, by and large, to send oil out by ship from any of its ports. That's the U.S. naval blockade
just outside the Strait of Hormuz that's doing that work. And Iran exports the vast majority,
I mean, more than 90 percent of its oil on the water out through those outlets. Iran's been
trying to get some out through overland routes, but it's a drop in the bucket compared to what
we're talking about here. And then before this Operation Economic Outcast was declared,
before the naval blockade was put in place, Iran had lots of oil sitting in tankers.
It's a so-called ghost fleet or shadow fleet that was sitting out in waters around the Indian Ocean
in Asia, which then it was selling sort of under the table to the Chinese. Iran is now running
out of that oil in the water, as the treasury secretary put it. And so what that's really
focusing now on is rather than who can get more oil out through the Strait of Hormuz, ultimately,
this is about who can stop the other side from exporting oil. The U.S. naval blockade is proving
very effective. Iran is trying to keep up by targeting ships coming out on the other side
of the Strait of Hormuz. And that gets back to that graphic you just showed where all those
transponders are off very conspicuously right around the Strait of Hormuz. Looking at the
western side, that's where the U.S. Navy and the U.S. military more broadly is helping escort
oil ships, oil vessels out through that side. Iran is still trying to hit those with drones,
with some regularity, even missiles occasionally. But given the military degradation we've heard
about in the previous clip, Iran's having a harder time doing that. So they're losing
that competition in the Strait. And it's also important to note that we've heard
from the U.S. military here, this is being reported by several different sources, including AP,
Reuters, all of that. And the U.S. military appearing to be deploying roughly 9,000 troops
aboard a group of ships there to the Middle East as the conflict unfolds here. And the Associated
Press reporting via those U.S. officials that the troop movement includes a third aircraft carrier.
Does that tell us in any way that we could potentially see military action escalating
there? Or could it essentially just be kind of a threat to say, look what we have,
we could hit you if we wanted to? So it certainly is the latter. It's certainly a threat. President
Trump, as part of this larger competition and risk-taking with Iran that we've been discussing
this whole time, sending a third U.S. carrier strike group to the region can certainly focus
Iran's minds. It can also send a signal to the rest of the world that the U.S. naval blockade
will not slacken and that we're ready for escalation if Iran wants to retaliate for
the naval blockade by again firing missiles and drones around the region at our bases,
things like that. And this syncs up with statements we've seen from the president recently
that he is genuinely contemplating renewed military action sometime this fall. It will
take that carrier strike group a little time to get to the Middle East. The key X factor,
which we don't know yet, is whether it's going to replace one of the carrier strike groups that's
already in the region or whether it will join the two that are already there. That'll take
a few weeks to play out. And of course, we're going to be watching it all play out here
in real time. And Jonathan, before I let you go here, what are you going to be watching for as
we see all of this kind of play out here? We wait to see whether or not there's more economic
action, whether or not there's more military action. We see things kind of heating up,
so to speak, and the rhetoric maybe even getting more heated. What are you going to be watching
for? So I'm watching for two things. One is it's very immediate, which is how Iran responds to this
losing battle. It's fighting in Hormuz about the competition of who can blockade
the other side's oil exports more effectively. If Iran really feels like it's losing there,
it may once again try to escalate either going across other targets in the region or targeting
U.S. Navy ships, pulling that blockade more aggressively. It's recently started to do that.
And I'll just close by also noting in the backdrop of all this, there have been reports about this
potential terrorist attack on a Royal Air Force base in Britain that hosted U.S. bombers during
Operation Epic Fury. While we're still waiting for the details of that to shake out, it certainly
fits with a lot of trends that follow Iran's aggression. They like to attack soft targets.
Unfortunately, bases like that are soft targets. Iran also has shown as this war has gone on,
they're willing to try to strike farther and farther away from the Middle East,
trying to hit U.S. bases in the Indian Ocean, in the East Med. This may also fit that pattern.
And then finally, it would fit with another pattern we're seeing, which is as this war has
gone on, and also these hardliners we've talked about increasingly set the tone, they're willing
to strike first. They're no longer content to wait to absorb an overpowering first blow from
the United States. So that's how I view events that are happening more broadly. I would say
Hormuz is important, but this is increasingly a much wider scope of competition. Jonathan Ruhi
over at JINSA, thank you so much for taking the time to join us. As always, a lot of developments
and we'd have to spend about 10 hours here just kind of breaking them all down. Anything we missed,
anything that you want to make sure that we mention or cover here before I let you go?
I would just say one thing. We've been talking about the U.S.-Iran dynamic and all this,
and I think one thing that's conspicuous because it's been so quiet
is the Israeli front here. While Iran is clearly trying to compete with us,
they as of yet have shown no real interest in reigniting the war to the extent that it
brings Israel back in. And that's not because Iran doesn't have the tools to target Israel,
they still do. But for now, I think Iran wants to focus this directly on the United States,
and partly that's because the United States is the real pressure point that's being put
on Iran's most sensitive spots. So I think that was one more thing to look at is how long that
Israel dynamic stays quiet, and partly because I think Israel was so successful in its first
40 days of war. All right. Jonathan Maruhi, thank you so much for being here with us as always. We
definitely appreciate it. Always my pleasure. Thank you. And we mentioned this during the
interview here, but I want to pop this up coming in from Iran International English because it
gives us a look at exactly what to expect as the week here in the upcoming days kind of progress
as it comes to the U.S. and Iran. U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Besant saying that Iran would
have no oil shipments at sea this week and no associated revenues as Washington intensifies
what he described as an unprecedented campaign to isolate Tehran economically, saying, quote,
for the first time in history since they started pumping oil, they will have no oil on the water
this week. Besant saying that in an interview earlier on today with the Axios show, adding,
quote, they will have no revenues. Now, he said the economic pressure followed what he described
as a deliberate sequence of military and economic measures against Iran, adding, quote, we had
kinetic action. We destroyed their Navy, their air force substantially depleted their drone and
missile capability, destroyed their chances of rebuilding that. Then we went to what the
president calls the iron wall and the blockade, which we've done before.