My Mum's Meeting My Dad for the First Time’ | BBC News 🧬❤️
Julia always knew that her mums had used a sperm donor, but she never expected to discover that she had 19 siblings. This BBC News story follows her journey as she explores her biological family and meets relatives she never knew she had.
A fascinating story about family, identity, genetics, and the unexpected connections that modern DNA discoveries can reveal.
Julia, conceived via a donor, embarks on a journey to discover her biological roots. By connecting with her father and 20 half-siblings, she navigates the emotional complexities of donor conception and the lack of industry regulation. Ultimately, she finds a biological community that complements her upbringing by two mothers, redefining her understanding of family and identity.
My mom is about to meet my dad for the first time.
I grew up with two moms, Kathleen and Betsy.
I really don't miss having a dad because they both completed a different area of me.
This is the family.
My sister Sarah and I have always just had each other.
And I love Sarah to pieces.
I always knew that I was donor conceived.
We were imagining you 18 years from now meeting this guy.
And we wanted you to like him.
I don't think I ever imagined that there could be so many siblings.
I thought maybe if I'm lucky I'll find one or two.
I think we're still trying to feel around and figure out how we're family.
It's completely uncharted territory.
We're going to go visit Carolyn, my half-sister.
Carolyn was the first sibling that I made contact with.
So I guess she's just the introduction, my introduction to the donor sibling world.
Carolyn!
What up?
Anticipation.
Your haircut, when did that happen?
That happened like a month ago.
I love it.
Thank you.
That's adorable.
I was like, growing up I thought that maybe I have donor siblings.
But then your mom was the first person to contact me.
So that was like the first time I was like, oh, I have a donor sibling.
And it's you.
So I thought it was just 19 of us.
And then Sam popped up and we were like, oh, Sam is another one that we didn't know about.
There's definitely 20 of us and my mom has like an Excel spreadsheet.
She does?
Yeah, she has like with I think everybody that we have to date and like their parents and contact info.
This is the sperm pipette.
Is that the word?
That my mother used.
And here you can see that it says 1317.
I guess she got this on June 6th of 95.
So she used a little vial and syringe to self-inseminate.
And it came in the mail.
It was frozen.
She said that she warmed it up like so.
I found out that my mom was actually in contact my entire childhood.
And even before I was born with other moms.
So now that I'm 18, the rest of us are also adults.
We have established our own relationships with each other.
She had these probably in her freezer for four to five months before she decided,
today's the day that I'm going to get pregnant.
Donor 1317 was originally approved for donation in November 1993.
Since the release of his semen, we have achieved six confirmed pregnancies.
The donor continues to be healthy.
That is so medical and scientific.
This necklace, it says 1317.
And my moms gave it to me for my 18th birthday.
And I think the number represents less of the donor 1317.
And more of my moms and my half-siblings.
And that just my family.
It's all different parts of my family.
When we were starting this process, first of all,
there were two sperm banks we were aware of, both in California,
that had a known donor program.
So this is the questionnaire we got from the sperm bank about your donor.
Why do you want to be a sperm donor?
Besides the money, which was definitely an incentive since I'm strapped for cash,
I think that it would be a very rewarding experience.
If I never have kids, then I would want to know
that I've given that opportunity to another couple.
Which option did you choose?
Identity release.
And explain why you chose this option.
It may be interesting to meet my unknown child
to see what effects environmental and genetic have played a role
in his or her development.
If we could pass a message to the recipients of your semen,
what would that message be?
Hold your head high and be considerate of others.
He just seems like a really nice guy.
So that's why we chose him.
We were imagining you, 18 years from now, meeting this guy,
and we wanted you to like him and think he was a good guy.
So that was kind of our process.
Are you glad we picked him?
I mean, yeah.
Kathleen and I got together when we were 23 years old,
so we were quite young at the time.
She was the kind of person that would walk in the room
and light it up.
Oh my gosh, Mom, you're so young.
Thank you, I think.
Not like you're old now, but just like...
That's very funny.
For the 3 months that she lived after her diagnosis,
she did more living than most people do in a decade, if not more.
Julia, this is when we were on vacation
the week before your mommy died.
And she played this song she had learned.
She taught herself to play the ukulele in the last 2 months of her life
and played this song for her whole family.
Don't worry about a thing
Cause every little thing is going to be all right
Don't worry about a thing
Cause every little thing is going to be all right
Love you girls.
You okay?
Kathleen was very insistent on making sure
that we used the Sperm Bank of California
because we were allowed to have a known donor program from that.
We didn't have any rights to the donor,
and he didn't have any rights to us either.
Julia was the only person that could make contact.
Julia was born in 1999 in January,
and she was conceived 5 months before Google was founded.
So there was no chance in our minds
that any of the siblings would ever be part of the picture.
It wasn't that we didn't want them.
It just never crossed our mind.
Well, thank you so much.
Have a great trip,
and I want to hear all about it when you get home.
On the road to Syracuse, New York,
where I'm going to meet up with 3 of my siblings,
George, Mari, and Samantha.
And I've met George before,
and I haven't met Mari or Samantha.
What's up?
Andrew knows.
You guys want to sit down?
I have huge hands.
I'm ginormous.
Yeah, you do.
I have bigger hands than my brother.
I never really wondered about the fact
that I might have these half-siblings, siblings.
I like more calling them sisters and brothers
because I'm trying to get more used to the fact
that they are, like, my sisters and brothers.
Now it's really become a much bigger part
of this whole sperm donor story to me
than the father aspect of it.
It's so grody that, like,
other people's parents had to have sex.
I know, right?
Exactly.
I know, right?
Like, I'm trying to, like...
Science joke.
Well, it was a double donor conception,
which means that a donor egg
and then a donor sperm was used.
I felt very alien.
I felt very, like...
In a whole...
And 50 years ago,
I wouldn't have been able to exist at all.
I felt like I was kind of forced onto the earth a little bit.
You know, it wasn't natural at all.
And there was a period that I was just...
I wished that I hadn't been born in this way,
really, at all.
And I almost kind of blamed her
because I knew that she wanted a child so bad.
People don't report when the pregnancies are successful.
So the sperm mates don't get a lot of information
in return from the families.
So apparently there's some problem with, like,
a lack of regulation around that or something.
Yeah.
But, I mean, I don't know.
Should they have 20-something kids?
Like, sperm donation's around to stay.
Mm-hmm.
So for, you know, I don't know,
like, someday it might only be this.
I don't know.
I mean, like, we don't know the future of, like,
of, like, any of that.
I want you guys, too.
There's a lot, you know?
Yeah.
Welcome to the family.
Yeah, we're not brothers and sisters in name only.
Like, I kind of want to make it more than that.
I think it's definitely possible to have a few people
or a lot of people, maybe,
even if I'm good with time management,
who I can have really deep relationships with
who feel like my brother and sister.
I think it's important to do something
every once in a while with these people
to grow these connections.
I don't think it necessarily has to be something
where it's talking to all of them all the time
or even having one person that you talk to all the time
because, I mean, we're not accustomed to that in our lives,
but I think, I think that this can be a family,
and I'm actually really excited about that.
Again?
What would you say?
I thought you said, what are you doing?
Yes.
My half-sister came up to me and gave me a hug today,
and I was the first blood relative she's ever touched.
And it's a Thursday, just a random Thursday,
and the whole experience is always just shocking
and bewildering, but, like, in a really beautiful way
and, like, a really touching way.
Hugging George, it was like, I don't know,
a strange sort of homecoming, you know?
Just, it was like someone that I should have been hugging
throughout my childhood but never did.
I wish I could have told younger me about this day,
and I just wish I could go back and tell her
that you'll find them.
You'll find that, find those people that understand.
It'll definitely, like, keep me warm
for a very long time, you know?
We're still figuring out how family works
and how our family works.
I don't really know, I don't know where we are in that,
but I like where it is.
Wherever it is, I like it.
Really only about three to five percent of all
potential donors actually become donors.
It's kind of an exclusive club.
So these are the samples, and they're attached to canes
like this, and we just lay them here
in these nitrogen baths.
We limit the number of vials that we allow a donor to produce.
If we allow a donor to collect 500 vials,
you know, if you do some calculations,
that would be approximately between 10 and 15 pregnancies.
It's not what I expected.
I expected it to be some, like, crazy, like, scientific,
all these people, like, with masks on running everywhere
and kind of scary, but it's very normal.
If we go down the hallway, this way is our collection room.
So it's basically just a sink, a chair,
a proverbial stack of magazines.
I don't know if I want to imagine this part.
I'm at a restaurant in Cleveland,
and I'm here to meet with Wendy Kramer,
who's the founder of the Donor Sibling Registry.
I'm excited to hear the other sides of the conversation.
There are donors who email me and go,
wait a minute, my sperm bank promised
I would have no more than 10 kids, 20 kids.
I'm looking on your website, and I see 67 kids.
What the heck?
You know, and this happens all the time.
Sperm banks need to be held accountable.
The reproductive medicine industry
has worked really hard to stay unregulated
and in the UK, they say donors can't be paid
and a limit of 10 kids.
But the problem is, all those laws are meaningless
when the majority of all people that use donor sperm
are importing from U.S. sperm banks.
What do you feel like you learned about yourself when you do this?
I learned that I love all my siblings,
and they're so smart.
And they just bring up so many thought-provoking questions.
Where do you see that going with everybody?
I feel so comfortable calling them all brother or sister,
but also we haven't had that connection
for the first 18 years of our lives.
So I really don't know.
I don't know, like, how much to connect with them
and how much I want out of their relationship with me.
And I feel like the best way to just do it
is to see what happens.
It's such an interesting, deep connection
that is...
I mean, it's love, you know?
I don't think I would have expected that, you know?
I thought I would have...
I don't know that I saw that coming.
It's really sweet.
I mean, I feel connected, so I can't even imagine.
Well, I do. I mean, I see you connected,
but it's just amazing.
It's really cool.
Yeah.
It's really cool.
I'm glad you have it.
It's great.
Me too.
We're going to meet Darren tomorrow.
Yeah.
Whoo!
It'll be great.
I'm about to meet my dad for the first time.
It's about 11.20,
and he's going to be here in 10 minutes.
From when you were like 10 years old, 9 years old,
you called him Don.
Don was my nickname for him,
because we didn't know.
Right, we didn't know who he was.
We didn't have a name,
so you called him Don,
and I thought that was the cutest name.
It's really cute.
Don the donor.
I'm a bit anxious, I have to admit,
but I'm channeling your mummy
to be grounded and clear
and thinking of what she might want to ask him.
You've never met a parent before.
You're the first born I've met.
And you're the first donor I've met,
so that's fair.
First of all, I want to say thank you,
because I have this amazing kid.
She's amazing.
She's really been a joy to raise and watch,
and I really appreciate it.
I don't know if you consider it generosity,
but I think it's like the biggest gift
you could have ever given anyone,
so I really appreciate that.
What a great human you are, and thanks.
Thanks for picking me.
Thanks for giving me life.
I'm Darren, I'm 44,
I'm from Southern California,
and I work in computer science, software development.
Did you ever worry about the parents, I guess,
like whether there was going to be a bad parent out there,
and did you feel responsible for that?
When I first donated, I think I was about 19.
I remember thinking that,
oh, it's so far in the future.
I didn't really think about consequences at the point.
When you're that young,
you're literally just thinking about your midterm
and about how to make ends meet.
About once a year, maybe, I just think,
huh, I guess that's about 13 years off.
What will happen?
You're just musons.
I think, like many things in life,
that anticipatory anxiety
is much worse than the actual situation.
He was disarming.
He was a gentle soul that was easy to be with.
Did you know how many children there were?
I had no idea.
I don't know how much information they gave you.
Did you know there were any?
Well, I knew there were some.
I guess I'm curious how you think about these kids.
I don't obviously have a strong connection to them socially.
Family is such a broad term.
People, you pretty much have to qualify.
My life is really full of taking care of my kids,
so I don't really think about all the donor offspring a whole lot,
because I'm busy.
When I do think about it, yeah, it's a little odd.
Not that odd, but just different.
If anything, it's good.
It helped give life.
I still feel a strange sort of
spiritual cosmic connection to them,
just in knowing that they share part of my DNA.
In that sense, I do feel a sort of connection,
a familial connection to the siblings.
From who I've met so far, and from what I've heard about them,
they are all very smart, talented, friendly, good-looking people.
I think Julia's kind of blown away right now.
I'm just, like, looking between you two talking to each other,
and you're my biological mom, and you're my biological dad.
I don't know why.
It's just very strange to hear you guys talk to each other.
For the first time.
Yeah.
And I'm, like, sitting in the middle.
Yeah, I keep just going, like, as you're talking to each other.
In a very strange way, maybe it's instinctual.
I feel kind of proud of her.
I guess donor seems like the anonymous guy,
but he's a real person now, and that makes it,
there's got to be a better word for it.
Take care, and I hope you feel better soon.
It was good to see you.
Wow.
How was that for you?
I don't know.
She left me this note.
I was at college my sophomore year, in the middle of my midterms,
and I got a call from Betsy.
She said, Julia, you have to come home.
After my mom died, I found this note that she'd left for me.
So I kind of just keep it there.
It hasn't moved.
It makes me happy.
Every connection that I've made in the last two years, even,
has shaped my idea of what family is.
I have gained a lot of family,
and that was, like, so much more than I would have ever thought it could be.
But I also never thought I could lose such a big part of my family.
And Kathleen's not replaceable at all.
But people help.
I think I'm learning how to live still,
and my family's definitely helping with that.
My very extended family.