The Rockefeller Heiress Who Wore the Romanov Emeralds — and Couldn t Keep Them

Ancient Art & Jewelry
19 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 3, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
On an evening during the Chicago opera season,
the most prominent woman in the city always arrived last.
Edith Rockefeller McCormick came by Rolls-Royce
wrapped in ermine to the private box
that was hers for the season.
She had hosted a dinner first
in a house where the guests ate from solid gold plates
and no wine was ever poured.
And around her neck on many of those nights
hung a rope of emeralds that had begun its life
as a wedding gift inside the Russian imperial family.
She was the daughter of the richest man in America
and the wife of one of its great industrialists.
She owned jewels a fallen empire had let slip.
She founded an opera company, gave away a fortune
and believed in complete seriousness
that she had once been the wife of an Egyptian pharaoh.
And when she died in debt in a hotel room,
the child who had stayed most loyal to her
was left a single 12th of what remained.
This is the story of those emeralds,
where they came from, where they went
and what happened to the family
that could not hold onto them.
Edith was the youngest daughter of John D. Rockefeller,
the founder of Standard Oil
and for a time, the wealthiest man on earth.
She grew up in a household of deliberate restraint,
frugal, teetotal and devoutly Baptist
in which her instinct for spending
was treated as a fault to be corrected.
Her father handed the stewardship of the family money
to her brother, John Jr.
Edith, he never quite trusted with it.
She spent anyway and she spent on a scale
that would have alarmed him.
In 1895, she married Harold Fowler McCormick.
His grandfather had invented the mechanical reaper.
His family's company would become International Harvester.
The wedding joined two
of the great American industrial fortunes
and placed Edith at the head of Chicago society,
a position she held without serious challenge
for the better part of 20 years.
She furnished that position with care.
There were the gold plates and the menus printed in French.
There was the mansion at 1000 Lakeshore Drive
where it was said no guest was ever quite her equal
and there were the jewels,
which she treated not as ornament,
but as the visible register of who she was.
The greatest of them had come a very long way
to reach her throat.
The emeralds had belonged to the Grand Duchess Vladimir,
the aunt by marriage of the last Russian Tsar
and one of the most determined jewel collectors
of the Imperial Court.
She had kept what amounted to a rival court of her own
and was said to show her guests
her collection laid out in glass cases after dinner.
When revolution broke over Russia in 1917,
the Grand Duchess fled St. Petersburg for the South,
leaving her collection behind in a hidden safe
in her bedroom at the Vladimir Palace,
a house of some 360 rooms on the bank of the Neva.
What happened next reads like fiction,
but it is well-documented.
Her son, the Grand Duke Boris
and a British friend named Bertie Stopford,
an art dealer with diplomatic connections,
disguised themselves as workmen,
talked their way into the shuttered palace
with the help of a caretaker and opened the safe.
They took the jewels apart,
wrapped the loose stones in old newspaper,
packed them into a pair of ordinary Gladstone bags
and carried them out past the guards.
Stopford smuggled the bags to London
and locked them in a bank vault.
The Grand Duchess herself
was the last of the Romanovs to escape Russia.
She reached Europe in 1919 and was dead within a year.
She had left her jewels to her children, divided by stone,
the sapphires to one son, the rubies to another,
the pearls and diamonds to her daughter
and the emeralds to Boris.
Boris, living in exile and short of money,
sold them to the jeweler Cartier.
Cartier reset them into a sautoir,
a long rope of a necklace,
and sold it to Edith Rockefeller McCormick.
It was described as holding 10 large emeralds
strung along more than 1,600 diamonds.
Some accounts trace the stones back further still
to Catherine the Great herself.
That was the centerpiece.
Around it, Edith wore a rope of pearls
valued at $2 million
and a diamond necklace so long
it could be taken apart into separate bracelets and brooches.
She owned, in effect, a piece of the Russian crown jewels
and she wore it to the opera
in a city built on stockyards and steel.
Under the house lights,
that contrast was the entire point.
It would be easy to mistake Edith
for a woman who only spent.
She also built, and some of what she built
outlived her by a century.
She and Harold were among the founders
of Chicago's first grand opera company.
She underwrote composers and small theaters.
When a young and entirely unknown Swiss doctor
named Carl Jung needed a patron,
she became his most important one,
a role we'll return to
because it changed her life as much as his.
For nearly two years, beginning in 1918,
she paid a monthly allowance to another unknown,
an Irish writer named James Joyce,
while he struggled to finish a novel called Ulysses.
And then, in the autumn of 1919,
without public explanation, she stopped.
In 1919, she gave away 83 acres of land,
a wedding present from her father
to the County Forest Preserve.
She said she did it out of a fascination
with animal psychology.
That land became the Brookfield Zoo.
In the years that followed,
she helped organize a series
of Women's World's Fairs in Chicago,
exhibitions built entirely around what women had achieved.
Over three decades, her biographers reckon,
she gave away well over $10 million.
There was one building she made from grief.
In 1901, her son John died of scarlet fever at four years old.
In his memory, she and Harold endowed a Chicago Institute
for the Study of Infectious Disease,
a working laboratory raised over a child's death.
A second child, a daughter named Editha,
had already died in infancy.
Two of her five children were gone before she turned 40.
And then, there was the house.
On a bluff above Lake Michigan, she built Villa Tarecum.
She had first approached Frank Lloyd Wright,
rejected his design, and turned instead
to the architect Charles Platt,
a decision Wright is said to have resented,
sneering that Platt does the wrong thing so well.
What Platt did was raise a 44-room Italian palazzo
with formal gardens, terraces, and a private tea house
at a cost that ran into the millions.
It was one of the grandest country houses in America.
Edith is said to have spent as little
as a single night in it.
In 1913, Edith went to Switzerland
to be treated for depression by Carl Jung.
She meant to stay a few months.
She stayed the better part of a decade.
The decision scandalized her family and her class.
A Rockefeller heiress had left her husband
and her children to be analyzed for years
and with no end in sight by a foreign doctor
almost no one had heard of.
There was an irony in it that the newspapers missed.
For all her wealth, Edith had never been trusted
to manage it.
Her father, doubting her judgment,
had handed her brother control
over her own share of the family fortune.
In Zurich, past 40, she was building for the first time
something that was unmistakably hers.
Zurich remade her.
She became not just Jung's patient,
but his student, training in his methods
and in time, practicing analysis herself.
Her money helped turn an obscure clinician
into a household name.
She had crossed the ocean as a rich man's wife
and was becoming something her family did not recognize
and could not manage from Chicago.
The marriage did not survive it.
Edith and Harold divorced in 1921.
What Harold did next was, if anything,
stranger than anything happening in Zurich.
On a transatlantic crossing,
he had noticed a Polish opera singer named Ganna Walska
and by the account that ran at the time,
wagered a friend that he would reach her first.
He lost.
The friend married her instead.
When that marriage ended,
Harold, now free himself, pursued her in earnest.
To do it, he underwent a gland operation,
one of the rejuvenation surgeries
then fashionable among wealthy older men,
performed by a Chicago physician named Victor Lespinas.
In 1922, he married Walska
and set about making her an opera star,
bankrolling productions for a voice
the critics never warmed to.
Her career, paid for by rich husbands,
is often named among the inspirations
for the opera singer wife in Citizen Kane.
Between the two of them,
a mother disappearing into analysis abroad,
a father rebuilding himself into a younger man,
the three surviving children were left to raise themselves.
Edith came home to Chicago in 1921
and the woman who returned was not the hostess who had left.
In February 1923, with the world transfixed
by the newly opened tomb of Tutankhamun,
she told the press that she was the reincarnation
of Anka Senamun, the boy king's wife.
She had married the pharaoh, she said, when she was 16.
She described leafing through an illustrated magazine,
seeing a photograph of a chair taken from his burial chamber
and recognizing it at once
as one she had sat in 3,000 years before.
Her interest in reincarnation, she added,
was of longstanding.
She studied astrology.
She celebrated Christmas on the 15th of December.
For a family that had built its name on Baptist sobriety,
each headline landed like a small disaster
and she stopped going out.
By the accounts of the time,
after she returned to the Lakeshore Drive mansion,
she did not spend a single night away from it
until illness finally forced her into a hospital in 1930.
No guest ever stayed overnight under her roof.
The Grand Dam, who had once ruled
a whole city's social life,
now ruled a smaller and smaller territory
until the territory was one house
and she was the only permanent resident of it.
It was against this background
that her three surviving children married.
Each choice became a public spectacle
and each one wounded her.
The first was the youngest.
In early 1922, the papers announced
that Matilda McCormick, 16 years old,
intended to marry Max Oser,
a Swiss riding master she had met
during her mother's Zurich years
when he rented horses to the family.
He was more than twice her age.
The newspapers could not even agree by how much,
printing everything from 47 to 57.
Her grandfather, John D. Rockefeller,
who had boasted in public that no European fortune hunter
would ever marry into his family, was firmly against it.
Her father consented on a single condition,
reportedly to satisfy the old man.
That Oser give up his stable and settle in America.
Oser gave cheerful interviews to reporters,
a bow-legged man in lavender spats, stroking his mustache,
insisting Matilda was no ordinary society girl,
but a real outdoor girl who loved horses and open country.
Edith did not attend the family council
that approved the match.
She stayed in her mansion and let it proceed without her.
In the divorce, custody of Matilda had gone to her father,
which in practice is what cleared the way
for the marriage at all.
Matilda married Oser in 1923.
The second marriage reached back
into one of the loudest scandals of the decade.
Edith's son, Fowler, had fallen in love with Anne Stillman,
known everywhere as Fifi,
the wife of the New York banker, James Stillman,
and a woman some 20 years older than he was.
The Stillmans had spent years tearing each other apart
in the newspapers.
The banker accused Fifi of an affair with a wilderness guide
and denied that their young son was his.
Fifi accused her husband of fathering a child
with another woman.
The court sided with Fifi, ruled the boy legitimate,
and refused the banker his divorce.
John D. Rockefeller himself was said to have advised Stillman
to step down from his bank over the affair.
When Fifi finally secured a quiet divorce in 1931,
she married Fowler within hours.
He was, by then, an executive
who would go on to run International Harvester,
the steadiest of Edith's children.
It made no difference.
Asked to comment on her own son's wedding,
Edith sent word through her secretary
that she had nothing to say.
The third was the strangest of all.
Muriel, the middle daughter, announced in 1926
that she considered herself bound to a man
who was already dead,
a young officer killed in the war in France
to whose memory she declared a kind of spiritual marriage.
Five years later, she married a living man,
Elisha Dyer Hubbard, 24 years her senior,
and was a widow within five years of that.
In her later life, she adopted a series of children.
Among them, it was reported, a grown man
who inherited what she left.
Three children, three matches to people decades older
or already dead or fresh from a courtroom,
and a mother who read every one of them as a betrayal.
While her children married,
Edith was quietly ruining herself.
She had poured her energy and enormous sums of money
into a grand Chicago real estate venture run
with two men she had met in Zurich,
the firm of Krenn and Dato.
Edwin Krenn became her constant companion,
a man she pushed into a society that had not asked for him.
The schemes were vast and largely unsound.
When the Depression came,
she sold some $18 million in securities
to keep the enterprise from collapsing
on the ordinary buyers who had trusted it.
It was not enough.
Villa Turicum stood empty and fully staffed,
its servants keeping the great house ready
for a mistress who never came.
She was, by the end, deep in debt.
She was also dying.
A growth taken from her breast two years earlier
had returned in her liver,
and by the summer of 1932,
there was nothing more her doctors could do.
She left the Lakeshore Mansion
for a suite at the Drake Hotel.
For two weeks, she lingered there,
rallying again and again in a way
that astonished the people around her.
In those final weeks,
the family she had spent years holding at arm's length
gathered around her, her former husband, Harold,
her three living children, her brother, John.
An estrangement, one account of the day noted plainly,
that had been more of her making than theirs.
She died on the 25th of August, 1932,
five days short of her 60th birthday.
Then the will was read.
She had set down her verdict on her children
in the plainest terms,
and accounts of the time tied the shares directly
to her disapproval of whom they had married.
Muriel was left four twelfths of the estate,
Matilda, two twelfths.
Fowler, the son who had stayed closest
and whom one account of the day called Faithful Fowler,
was left a single twelfth.
The largest share of what remained
went to none of her children.
It went to Edwin Crenn.
In the end, there was very little to divide.
Once the debts were paid, Edith's possessions were sold,
much of it for less than it was worth,
and her heirs were left with almost nothing.
Follow the two things she had cared about most,
and you can see the whole story in them.
The house lost.
No buyer could be found for Villa Turicum.
It stood dark on its bluff for years,
broken into and stripped by trespassers,
its gardens running wild,
until it was finally torn down in the 1950s,
a 44-room palace reduced to a set of ruined terraces
above the lake,
which is roughly all that survives of it today.
The emeralds won.
Edith's jewels went back to Cartier,
and from there, the Grand Duchess Vladimir's emeralds
found their way to another American heiress,
Barbara Hutton, granddaughter of the founder of Woolworths,
the girl the newspapers had christened
the poor little rich girl.
Hutton inherited one of the great American fortunes
and, like Edith, could not keep it.
She married seven times, spent without limit,
and died in 1979 with almost none of it left.
The emeralds had simply moved
from one vanishing fortune to the next.
She grew tired of them in the 1960s and sold them on again.
Some accounts follow the stones one step further
into a necklace worn years later by Elizabeth Taylor,
though that last step was never confirmed
by the jewelers involved
and is best treated as a rumor.
What is certain is that the Romanov emeralds
outlasted the palace, the fortune, and the family.
They had passed from a Grand Duchess
to a Rockefeller to a Woolworth
and kept no trace of any of them.
Edith Rockefeller McCormick spent her life
among objects that were built
to outlast the people who owned them.
The house could not manage it.
It fell down.
The emeralds could.
They survived the empire that first owned them,
the fortune that bought them,
and the family that could not keep them,
and they moved on to the next set of hands
as though none of it had happened.
That is the truth about jewels like these.
No one keeps them.
They only ever pass through.
