Midterms 2026: Will farmers still vote red? | This Is America

Aljazeera
59 followers
44 Video Views·Oct 3, 2026
This is America, and this is a country where, for generations, farmers have tended to vote
Republican. But there are signs of that support eroding. Tariffs and the war with Iran have been
squeezing farmers and ranchers, and patience is wearing thin in places that delivered Donald
Trump some of his biggest margins in 2024. Today we look at whether farm country still
believes the GOP has its back, or if this is the year that rural America begins asking for
something different. Here's Anna Byrnes-Francis in Washington to get us started. With just over
a month until Republicans face the ballot box, the U.S. President Donald Trump is crisscrossing
middle America, holding rallies in rural states where his base has traditionally turned out in
numbers. But that is no longer guaranteed. Take Iowa, which hasn't elected a Democratic senator
since 2008. This year it's been called a toss-up state. Now farmers across the country say they're
feeling the pinch from rising costs for diesel, fertilizer, and animal feed. And higher costs
at the farm gate means higher prices on the consumer plate. It's led to some farmers questioning
their loyalty to the GOP these midterms, as Heidi Jo Castro reports from Minnesota.
As farmers we have to be natural optimists. We plant a seed in the spring, we hope to get a
harvest in the fall. And if you start looking at all the trouble going around the world,
it's pretty hard to stay optimistic. Corn and soybean farmer Carson Duncanson isn't just
worried about the rain and sun this year. He's also worried about the cost of diesel to run
farm machinery and fertilizer to nourish the fields. Both have seen their prices surge since
the war with Iran began in February. I don't think the war is good for any of us. President
Trump's policy right now in the war is he's scared to do anything, because if he does anything and the
oil price goes up, it hurts him, it beats him up in the midterms. It makes him look bad. Hasn't
already happened? It has. Nearly 70 percent of rural America voted for Trump two years ago.
Now his approval is negative in nine out of ten of the country's biggest farm states,
including Minnesota, where Sam Ziegler's family has been farming since 1918. I voted for Trump
in 2024. Do you feel less inclined to vote for his party now? It makes me ask the questions,
the hard questions of of that party or him. He needs to not just talk, but I need to be seen
some things. And if he is truly going to support rural America. Farmers we spoke to say they want
an end to Iran's chokehold on fuel and open trade instead of Trump's tariff war that's decimated
the sale of American agricultural products to China. All of that has led to more American farms
going bankrupt, with the state of Minnesota leading the nation in the number of farm
bankruptcies, tripling in number from 2024 to 2025 and 2026 on track to surpass even those numbers.
Trump's agriculture secretary visited Minnesota in August to tout the administration's efforts
to help farmers, including securing twelve billion dollars in aid and passing tax cuts
that benefit small businesses. She also criticized media coverage of the farm bankruptcies,
calling it clickbait. I think people need to step back and really look at the facts and not
say flash in the pan responses. Ziegler says he's undecided how he'll vote in November,
while a few fields over his neighbor, Duncanson, says both political parties have disappointed him.
Are Republicans super small business friendly? Not really. They're all kind of crappy,
but the Republicans are better than the Democrats. Some Republicans fear the seeds of doubt will grow
among rural supporters and that the lack of enthusiasm will keep them on the fields rather
than voting on election day. Heidi Jo Castro, Al Jazeera, Good Thunder, Minnesota. All right,
so what has happened between rural and Republican here to discuss is Chris Lapitina. He's a
Democratic strategist and political consultant, and Mark Feifley, a Republican strategist and
former White House communications official. Gentlemen, thank you to you both. Mark,
I will start with you because that was a farmer who's voted red. Are you surprised to hear a
traditional thick and thin Republican talking about his party like that? It doesn't surprise
me. A lot of this is just the results of the most important place on the planet right now when it
comes to the U.S. election. It's not anywhere in the U.S. It's the Strait of Hormuz. It is causing
diesel fuel prices and gas prices to go up. That directly impacts the farming community from the
very second that they try and put their crop into the field or they have to get their cattle ready
for market to when they take it to the market. And it's having a horrific effect on the economies.
The Trump administration has tried a couple of things. They've talked about limiting the export
of diesel fuel, which could have about a 15 or 20 cent per gallon of gas. But still,
it's up $2.60 since the war. So this would do very little between now and when people go to the
voting booth. Yeah. Chris, if you're in Iowa, if you're in Minnesota, if you're perhaps in Alabama
and you're listening to President Trump later on today, what is life like for you in a rural
community when you are going to fill up the gas tank and it's like this? I mean, what is it like
as a rural person who has been red up until now? Well, first of all, let's talk about a little
breaking news, I think maybe you're already to be interested in. We heard today that the
Republicans are giving up on North Carolina, essentially taking their money and moving to
Kansas, which is a big agriculture state. So maybe some of the things that Mark is talking about is
having a real political effect in a state where Democrats haven't won a Senate race in a long,
long time. So I think there's some evidence of all this theory about why things have been bad
for President Trump and the Republicans. We're starting to see that's come true.
So listen, farming is very difficult. Farmers are in a different kind of business because
it's so perilous. They have to depend on the weather. They have to depend on a lot of factors
that have nothing really to do with the economy. And so the situation that we face now is really
hurting them more than a lot of people who are just kind of living a day-to-day life.
Yeah. Mark, you grew up in North Dakota. What was that like in a rural community? What was
the relationship like that people saw themselves having between the government and their everyday
lives? We want the government out of our lives, for the most part, unless it brings up something
like subsidies for our agricultural products or that sort of thing. But I think that it's about
70-30, 70 percent of rural Americans support Republicans right now. But as Chris said,
specifically in Kansas, for example, they're having troubles when it comes to the production
of their livestock and getting the cattle moved to market and then processed. Because,
not just because of the cost of diesel fuel, but also because of immigration,
it's getting people that can do these jobs. So while Republicans might say,
we want a strong and sturdy border, we don't want the cartels coming in from Mexico,
they do want those workers. Right now in North Dakota, they're about 500 jobs short for what
they need to do to do their harvest this year. Now, 500 jobs doesn't sound like a lot, but a
population of 800,000 people that needs those 500 new workers to come in, work six weeks, work three
months, get the product out of the ground into the marketplace, that's going to be a difficult thing.
So some ways it's good what we see what's going on when it comes to immigration, and then there's
the challenges of that. In Kansas specifically, they are moving those resources because Roger
Marshall, who's the incumbent, right now is behind a Democratic opponent. But we're also
seeing that the Republican candidate for governor is still ahead. So people might split their ballot.
They might go, I like my Republican governor, but in Washington, D.C., I'm not supportive of what
they're doing. They're still not convinced by a Democratic platform. No, I think that's right. I
mean, both parties are very unpopular, right? We live in Washington. We're both very unhappy with
Washington. I mean, as Americans, right? So we understand that. The question is, you only have
two choices. And Mark, you bring up a good point when you talk about governor. I think a lot of
Republicans or people that might vote Republican are trying to send a message to President Trump
and the Republicans in Washington, not necessarily turning on the Republican Party. But if I could,
you know, Mark was talking about things that could make a difference. One of the things I'd
like to give Mr. Trump credit for as a Democrat was he passed what we call the Farm Bill, which
is a big bill, which is a trillion-dollar bill, ultimately when it's all spent. It's supposed to
be passed every five years. Mr. Trump passed it in his first term. It hasn't been passed this year.
It was passed in the House, but not in the Senate, and it's been laid off till after the elections.
That's something Mr. Trump could have done. He could have made that a priority. Instead of
talking about the things he talked about throughout this whole year, he could have helped pass the
Farm Bill, and he did not. And just to explain to our viewers who will not perhaps be familiar with
intricacies of the bill, for an everyday rural farmer, what did that do for them that they would
have turned around and said, I've got it? A lot of financial incentives, insurance, easy credit,
a lot of financial things help them with getting through rough times, and very important. And the
other side of the Farm Bill, which is also important, is it helps feed people who are
needy in the United States. So the food that goes to the needy is attached to the Farm Bill.
It's usually passed in a bipartisan way very easily, and this time it's failed to pass,
and that's one thing Mr. Trump could have done to help farmers.
Mike, do you know how many family-owned farms there are of a smaller level in America at the moment?
Unfortunately, less and less, because they tend to be purchased by the large agribusiness companies.
And you're seeing that the politicians that are actually working to find solutions might be
rewarded, and the people that are helping the farmers, for example, in North Dakota, my home
state, the Republican governor has had an executive order where he's ending the diesel tax
on many of the of the farmers. So they get about 19 cents per gallon relief. It's up 260
since the war, so it's just a part. But in Washington, D.C., they're out of town. They're
gone. They had an opportunity to do things when it came to gas tax relief, or a holiday for the gas
tax, or the diesel tax. That would have brought it down a great deal, but it could have brought
it down a couple of nickels, a couple of dimes, so it wouldn't be as bad. And every new cent that the
gas and the diesel prices go up means it might switch another couple thousand rural voters in
these areas. And that, in case, is all that the Democrats really need in these marginal House
districts and these marginal Senate districts that are so difficult and so close right now.
Can we go back to talking about the numbers? Because at the last census in 2020, there were
1.6 million small farms or family-owned farms and falling. You heard those numbers in Heidi's
package. Costs for farmers, meanwhile, have gone up across the board since the start of the war
with Iran. Diesel prices have increased by more than 70 percent from this time last year,
recently hitting all-time highs. Fertilizer prices spiked in April at almost a third higher than the
pre-war costs. They've eased slightly since then, but are still up by more than 8 percent.
And cattle feed, including items like hay, grain, and corn, is up by 4.7 percent. After buying all
of that, the farmer has to then try and turn a profit while competing against mega corporations.
I mean, you're trying to anticipate what costs are and, you know, right now the price of corn
has been going up some, so that concerns us, because with high cattle prices to begin with,
since high-priced cattle are already bought, if our cost of feed starts creeping up too,
then that just compounds the problem of the higher-priced cattle.
It's not a new problem, Chris. They've experienced this through Republican presidencies,
through Democratic presidencies. Why has it been so hard for administrations of the past
to serve those people who are still farming the land in America?
Well, I mean, some of it is the globalization and the way our economy works. The smaller farms have
been bought by bigger corporations. That's a trend that's continued both through Democrats
and Republicans. And also, I think that farming itself has gotten so difficult for small farmers
that they were willing to kind of give it up, sell to a big corporation, and move on. And that's
really been to the detriment of our country. Although there is a little bit of a movement to
get back to family farms, farms where we know where our food is grown, but it's not like it
used to be, certainly, 30, 40, 50 years ago, when agriculture was such a big part of the American
workforce. But these are Republican voters to lose, right, Mark? Part of it is generational
as well, and you're right. You want to turn your farm over to your children and your grandchildren,
but that's the difficult thing. And then farming is very, very hard work. I grew up in Wishek,
North Dakota, population of about a thousand people. And the people that farm those lands,
they didn't have days off. The cows still had to be milked, the crops still had to be
hoed, and the combine still had to go out. So it's a very difficult job. And the challenge is that
it's easier to buy the bulk fertilizer. It's easier to rent out or to have your combine used for a
multiple amount of acres. And so in some ways, it's been more difficult to keep those family farms
and those family livestock markets in place so that you could turn them over to your children,
your grandchildren, which is what every farmer wants to do. And sometimes, because of our society
and our economy, the desire for a young person to stay on the farm and continue that operation,
sometimes they're pulled to another vocation. Can we talk about the changing use of land
in America? Obviously, there is a lot of talk at the moment about the rise of AI,
data centers needed to power that AI. Is that a bad thing for people living in these areas, Chris?
Well, the question is, is it a bad thing for all of us? It could be, partly because once you give
up a farm, it'll never come back. The other thing that if you're in a farming community,
we're starting to learn that data centers take a lot of resources. So water, which is scarce in
the West, in a lot of farming areas, data centers could use a lot more water than people anticipate.
And therefore, even if you wanted to keep your farm, if you have a data center there,
it could be in peril because of that. So it's a consideration. I just want to make one quick
political observation, which is very sad for me as an American. Farmers have gone through tough
times. During Reagan, farmers went through a tough time. And even Democrats were very supportive of
farmers because they know they voted for Reagan, but they still felt close to them. Now, I went
online to learn a little bit more about farming and was watching some YouTubes in anticipation
of this show. And I see a lot of farmers saying, you know, I'm starting to hear on social media,
people are mad at me for voting for Trump. And that's never happened before. You know,
we're so divided in this country that even people like Democrats who supported farms
and small farmers over the years are starting to give up on them just because of politics.
And that's a really, really sad development. And I don't think it helps farmers going forward,
either. Yeah. Can we get back to the data centers, though? Do you think it's a bad idea?
As a general rule? Yeah. If they're just like AI itself, if there's guidelines,
if we understand what they are, if they're done with zoning and there's some sort of controls
that make sense, then it's doable. If they're left to the free market to put anywhere they want,
I think we're going to have a big problem. OK. The rapid growth of AI means lots of land
is needed for all of the data centers that are waiting to be built at the moment.
Pre-existing facilities in more urban areas have been converted for data center use,
but 67 percent of the planned future construction is in rural areas. Mark,
there is a strong sentiment amongst Republicans. Obviously, there's a heavier weighting here for
Democrats. Fifty percent of Democrats say they're bad for the environment. A third of Republicans
say they're bad for the environment. Twenty four percent are worried about the quality of life if
they live in a rural area and a data center is built next to them. Given we've been talking
about farmers and those numbers are shrinking, but the number of people affected by a data center
will be growing. Is this something the Republican Party, which has been criticized for its stance so
far, should be looking more closely at if it wants to keep hold of that rural base?
I think so. And I think that they will have to as we get into this next presidential race.
This is obviously the new issue that has been cropping up. As long as we want a phone in our
hands that tells us everything that we ever wanted to know and control everything of our lives,
we're going to have to have data centers as well. That's the challenge we have.
So it's going to be the need that these data companies and these tech companies
work collaboratively with these communities. Don't come in and say, OK, here's the way it's
going to be. We're going to start building soon. But they have to work out a relationship
with the local people. A lot of the rural areas, they need some of the resources. They need some
of this land that can be used effectively and efficiently. It's not all great grazing land or
great soil for some sort of agricultural product. So there are some areas. And then if you
have like where I'm from in North Dakota, it's very cold a lot of the year. So the data center
is perfect because it's a very hot installation and there's a lot of land there. So where it's
appropriate, those communities should work collaboratively with these tech companies
instead of them coming in with their big foot and saying, this is the way it's going to be.
We bought the land and it's going to be built. They should work. How are we going to keep the
schools strong? How are we going to keep the hospitals open? How are we going to keep the
roads paved? We, the data center, want to be part of your long term community. That's the only way
this is going to be successful between a relationship with a with a big corporation
and a rural community that wants to survive. And how do you keep your job right? Is this
not an opportunity for Democrats? And if so, where are they? Oh, absolutely. This is it's
going to go from a sort of environmental issue now to a huge labor issue and the future of society.
And we're going to see which party will emerge as having the best answers. And I don't really
know what that's going to be. It's interesting, though, today I saw that Mr. Trump understands
that data centers are a problem, not for Republicans. And he's changed the name. He
doesn't call them data centers anymore. He's got a new name, just like he's got a new name for AI.
So I think the president recognizes that data center is a losing argument right now for
Republicans, and he wants the Americans to think about it in a different and better way.
This is not a marketing challenge. So Trump looks at it as a marketing challenge. I'll change the
name. The name will be more pretty and it'll flow off the tongue better. This has to be something
that the next generation of politicians in this next Congress, the next people that are running
for president, Republican and Democrat, have to get their arms around it, have to start listening
to people going out into the communities and saying, what is your concern and how can we help
to make your life more fulfilling and more successful? The challenge of creating that
wealth internally for your own family. That's what really Democrats and Republicans have not
focused a great deal on. Donald Trump, he thought he was doing this with this big, beautiful bill
to get some tax relief for seniors, for overtime, for tipped employees. He thought he was going to
sell that this election cycle. Then Iran happened. Now data centers are happening.
The next politician is the one that figures out how to actually communicate and listen to the
people, hear their concerns, and then find some solutions from Washington, D.C., because right
now there aren't any. But isn't that the problem? This is populist politics. It is about marketing
at the moment. Isn't that where we are at and why we see the apathy from farmers who say,
well, are the Republicans helping me? Not really. But the other side is worse. I mean,
I'm glad Mark admitted that the president sees this as a marketing issue. And of course,
that's why I never voted for the guy, because everything in government is some kind of
marketing idea or a way to kind of fool people into getting them to think the way he wants to
think. So you're absolutely right. Listen, the one thing that's consistent, whether Democrats
win races in November or the Republicans do better, is Washington is horribly unpopular,
horribly unpopular. That's not going to change for a long time until Americans start to see
real results, like Mark is talking about. And whether one side is in power or the other side
is in power, it doesn't change the fact that people are horribly disappointed with their
elected officials in Washington as a general rule. Can we talk about bringing it back to,
I know it's been a talking point for a lot of shows recently, the economy at the moment.
Given that these farmers are saying, I am really struggling to make, the inputs are high,
the outputs are squeezed. I'm competing against big corporations. At the end of the day,
that has a flow on effect, Mark. That is going from the farmer all the way through to the end
consumer. How concerned are you? Because like you've said, we don't have much time now until
the election. And yet every day people are looking at that bill and going, that's more than I paid
for groceries two or three days ago. It's 30 days and Congress is out of session. So in my home
state of North Dakota, the house majority leader, Steve Scalise, who is from Louisiana, he is
campaigning in North Dakota for the house member who's a Republican, Judy Fedorchik. And here's
the thing. That's a Republican seat. The leadership from the house should not be in North Dakota.
They should be in these marginal house races. And it just means that the Republicans have a lot of
work to do. Right now, over 50% of Republican voters say that Trump is negative, view him
negatively when it comes to affordability. He and his political party have to start talking about
these issues and really providing real solutions for how they're going to help. I would say they
should be in Washington D.C. right now trying to find solutions and things to pass instead of being
in the campaign trail because they're not popular. Any of these people, Republicans or Democrats,
when they go out, they don't, they're almost seen as a negative when they're out actually
talking to people. They should be doing their job and working. They should be passing some form
of a tax holiday for diesel fuel and for gasoline. They should be stopping the export of diesel fuel.
They should be actually negotiating with the Iranians to open up the blockade and open up
the Strait of Hormuz. That's what the people voted for. That's why we pay such
an enormous amount of tax money. And when we go to the voting booth in about one month and we look
at it and we say, okay, do I want Donald Trump to control everything in all worlds of government,
from the House, the Senate, and the White House for the next two years? You want the Republicans
to be in a place where they say, I'm okay with a Johnson as the Speaker and as a Thune as the
Senate leader. If not, we're going to have a whole new world that happens in January,
and the Democrats are going to have the gavel. And that could bring about some changes in how
we operate for the next two years. It's going to be far more difficult for Trump to get his agenda
through. Yeah, that's what will change, right? It'll just be harder for the President to do
anything because at the moment, what can the Democrats do? I mean, I'm thinking about the fact
that fertilizer cost is already high. There's a second planting season coming. If you are those
farmers, all you are thinking about is that the only way here is up. Where is the Democrat
message about what actually can be proactively done, given that if they're forced into voting,
maybe it's just sunk cost fallacy. You give it back to the guy who's already in the situation
and perhaps has a better overview and says that they'll fight for you. Well, so hopefully for the
country, whether it's new Congresses, Democrats or Republicans, things start to get done because
midterms are over and some of the pressure from politics is over. So what can be done? Well,
we could pass the Farm Bill and there's a lot to help farmers, right? And so I think that there
could be a bipartisan effort to get the President to sign the Farm Bill. Maybe if Trump suffers a
loss, he may change his opinion and want to leave in a good way. We could do things like that.
But as Mark pointed out, that's not going to open up the Strait of Hormuz, is it, and end a war?
Well, that's a whole different story.
That you're trying to do something is part of it. And then it's getting that message out
that all politicians are having on the campaign trail is most of the communication happens on
social media. And I, as a politician, have 1.7 seconds to get your attention before I go like
that. The soundbite is less than eight seconds that you can actually communicate. You've given
us far more time than that today. Thank you very much. But for these politicians to actually talk
about what they care about in that 1.7 seconds or that eight seconds, that's enough time to accuse
and to assign blame. But it's not enough time to talk about a solution to actually fix the
problem that's affecting people's lives. Well, the other thing about the Strait,
which is interesting and a big problem for the president, is that Democrats and Republicans
get blamed for a lot of things. I think that most Americans now blame President Trump for
the war in Iran. And he takes direct responsibility for it and the repercussions of it.
And that's something he can't escape.
Very good. Thank you very much, gentlemen.
Well, that's all from the team here in Washington. Handing back now to Heidi
Jo Castro in Al Jazeera's global headquarters in Doha.
And that's it for us from here on the farm at This Is America. Catch more of our in-depth
exploration of the topics impacting America and the world Monday through Friday on Al Jazeera
at 18.30 GMT or 2.30 p.m. Eastern. We'll see you again soon. Goodbye for now.
