The Spartan Army at Plataea. Demography and Tribal Order
Marcello Lupi (The University of Campania “Luigi Vanvitelli”)
According to Herodotus, five thousand Spartiates, that is the youth (neótes) of the city, took part in the battle of Plataea and his testimony is probably the main information we have on the number of Spartan citizens in the age of the Persian wars (Hdt. 9.10.1; cf. 7.234.2). At the same time – and although some recent studies have largely undermined the foundations of this theory – the idea is still widely held that the Spartiates fought at Plataea divided into five battalions (lóchoi), each representing one of the five villages (óbai) alleged to constitute the city of Sparta. As this paper aims to show, once the theory of this presumed obal army has been rejected, it is much easier to assume that the Spartan army in this period was still organized according to the three Dorian tribes and their subdivisions. The implications of some ancient sources (the New Simonides; Demetrios of Skepsis fr. 1 Gaede) as well as Herodotus’ figures on Spartan demography during those years appear to support this reconstruction.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Marcello Nucchi challenges traditional theories regarding the Spartan army's organization during the Persian Wars. He argues against the \"Obata\" five-village system, proposing instead a tripartite structure based on the three Dorian tribes. Through numerical analysis of rituals and historical texts, he suggests the army was organized into 81 units (Locoi) of 100 men each.
Now it's my pleasure to introduce to you another old friend, Marcello, Marcello Nucchi.
He is at the Università della Campagna, Luigi Van Vitelli, and we've known him,
I've known him many years. He's worked in Cambridge, Cambridge, England, and he is a
Sparta expert. He's amongst a small group of hippies who work on ancient Sparta, and in 2017
he published Sparta Storia e Rappresentazione Unita Greca, which was reprinted in 2021,
and he's going to talk to us about the Spartan army at Patia, demography, and tribal order.
The floor is yours, Marcello. Thank you, Paul. I will try to share my screen. Yes, thank you,
and thank you, of course, to Natasha for inviting me to this terrific conference.
I will start recording, to myself at least, the totally shareable observation that Paul Cartledge
made yesterday about the numbers in Herodotus, and on their often dubious reliability. In the
paper on Spartan power and the units of the Spartan army, numbers are, of course, a large
part of it. You will judge if I make an acceptable use of them. Anyway, there are two figures.
There are two figures that are the basis of any reflection on Spartan manpower in what we could
call the pre-Oligantropic age, that is, the period before the mid-15th century, when the
number of Spartan citizens began to decline significantly. Both these two figures are
provided by Herodotus. In a well-known passage, the exiled Spartan king Demaratus,
immediately after the sacrifice of the 300 at Thermopylae, states that the Spartans
had had 8,000 men similar, or more, to the 300 dead, that is, another 8,000 Spartan citizens
of the military age. As Demaratus makes clear, one has to add to these 8,000 the period,
but this is a different matter. The other figure, Herodotus 9, 10, and 12,
concerned the Spartan troops at Plataea. The regent Pausanias, in addition to being the leader
of the entire Greek army, led with him 5,000 Spartiates, as well as an equal number of
helots, of which the very doubtful number of 35,000 is indicated, with 70 helots for each
Spartan. Anyway, Herodotus adds that the 5,000 Spartiates were the youth, neotes, of Sparta.
The use of the term neotes here is clearly informal and should be considered with caution.
Certainly, it does not refer only to the neots, the young people 20-29 years old.
The most widespread interpretation, with which I also agree, is that the mobilization on the
occasion of the Battle of Plataea consisted in a mobilization of two-thirds of the army.
The mobilization of this kind, in fact, is a test, because the Polynesian army,
that refers to the first ten years of the Polynesian war. And, no doubt, a mobilization
of two-thirds implies that the third-third who remained at home was made up of the oldest men,
those closer to 60 years old. On the other hand, we know from Xenophon that still in the first
the military draft was based on the age, that is, by calling up a certain number of age classes,
10, 15, 35, starting with the youngest age class, the one constituted by the 20 years old.
Thus, despite the vagueness of the term neotes, it is generally accepted that the Spartan
contingent in Plataea was made up of the all-citizens army, except the senior
conscription classes. We may have doubts about which were the age classes that constituted
the first-third and which those of the second-third. Personally, I believe that the
first-third of the army included the real Spartan youth, the 20-29 years old, that is,
those within which the elite corps of the 300 horsemen were selected, while the second-third
included the men 30 to 45 years old. But this is a secondary problem.
What is important and that the scholarship has generally emphasized is that there is a coherence
between the number of 8,000 Spartan citizens of the military age after the Thermopylae and the
fact that 5,000 Spartans, the 5,000 Spartans of Plataea were two-thirds of the mobilization
map. Although approximately the two numbers converge, hence the widespread consensus
towards this theory. I will return to the relationship between these two figures later.
For the moment, it is appropriate to go ahead and to address the question of how the 5,000
who fought at Plataea were organized, that is, within which units they were distributed.
A consensus also developed on this issue in the second half of the last century. It was
believed, as some still believe, that in the years of the Persian War, the army was organized
differently from what happened in the Archaic period, when the Spartan army fought divided
into three large units, each expression of the Tridorian tribes of the Ilaes,
the Imanes, and Pamphylos. So, in fact, a fragment of itself's energy clearly attests.
According to this theory, this tribal army was replaced, probably during the 6th century,
by the so-called Obata, that is an army built around the Obai, the alleged five-territorial
subdivision of villages, which are believed to have constituted the city of Sparta.
Each of the villages would have provided one of the five units, the Locoi, which,
according to some scholastic and lexicographic sources, formed the Spartan arch. Later, the
Obata army would then have been replaced towards the middle of the 5th century, that is after
Plataea, by a different organization of the army, which is the one we find in Thucydides and then
in Xenon. However, several recent studies have questioned this consensus, and it has become
clear that the weak point in this reconstruction is the alleged Obata army of the five Locoi.
It is not necessary here to repeat what some scholars, Nigel Kell and Hans van Derse,
have very convincingly demonstrated. It is enough to say that the names of the five Locoi
that we find in the scholastic and lexicographic sources do not recall in any way the names of the
Spartan villages, and therefore the relationship between the villages of the city and the five
Locoi is completely evanescent. In particular, we do not find among the names of these five Locoi
the Locus Pitanates, which is the only one attested by Herodotus in the relation to the
battle of Plataea, and whose existence we should add to Thucydides' denied. As is well known,
Pitane, or Pitana, was the best-famous Spartan village, but in various later archaic and
Pithecanthian sources, that is the sources previous or contemporary to Herodotus, Pitana
is just a metonymic expression to indicate the entire city of Sparta, so that the existence
of a Pitanates Locus does not mean the existence of a noble army of five Locoi.
Anyway, I do not intend to repeat here, since I have already dealt with it elsewhere,
my personal opinion on the Locus Pitane, which Natasha has kindly recalled yesterday,
nor my opinion on the alleged five Spartan villages. But since the matter of villages
has been raised incidentally yesterday, today, just before me, I just observe that no ancient
source ever attests these five villages, in the sense that no source claims that the villages
were five. This is an idea that developed in the late 18th century, and since then has been
accepted by almost everyone as a matter of fact, and never questioned. But the notion of the five
villages, believe me, has no basis. And stop here about the villages, eventually we can speak in
discussion later. What instead I would like to talk about here is the following. If in Plataea,
the Spartan army was not distributing the five Locoi, if indeed, as Catherine Crimes already
wrote over 70 years ago, the five Locoi are inconsistent with everything that can be discovered
about the Spartan military organisation, well, how was the Spartan army organised at Plataea?
Well, the removal of the five Locoi involves a relevant chronological consequence. There
is no longer any reason to exclude that the tripartite structure of the army testified
by Tyrtaeus could still constitute the basis of the Spartan military organisation in 479,
and that the Spartan army at Plataea could reflect the division of the Spartan community
in the three Dorian Fulai tribes and their internal subdivisions. About this, it's worth
to stress that it is precisely in the years of the Persian wars that we find in various
photos, as Pindar asks, a particular emphasis on the Dorian features of the city of Sparta.
In particular, its army, and this suggests that the army may have been, at the time,
still structured on the basis of the three Dorian tribes. A skillful reference to the victory of
Plataea as a libation made with the blood of the slaughtered and obtained by the Dorian spiel,
to this finds a more pregnant integration in the perpetual fragments from Simonides' poem
on Plataea. In one passage, fragment 13 West, despite the extreme incompleteness of the text,
it seems to catch a reference to the deployment of the armies in the plain Expedion of the
on the one hand, the Medes and Persians, and probably in front of them, the son of Dorus
and Heracles. In other words, the text does not limit itself to assert that the Spartans were
Dorians, but it indicates that the entire Spartan army, through an expression fitting to an army
still distributing the three tribal units of the Daemon and Pamphylos, as is known,
the son of Dorus are the Daemon and Pamphylos, whose names derive from Daemon and Pamphylos,
the alleged sons of a genius son of Dorus, while Daemon and Pamphylos descend from
Hylos son of Heracles. So in a way, Simonides is saying that in front of Medes and Persia,
there were the three Dorian tribes. I admit that a poetic fragment, moreover more incomplete,
is not enough. So let's try to go back to the 8,000 Spartiates mentioned by Herodotus.
I don't think that anyone has ever questioned the origin of this figure, yet it's a figure that
raises some questions. In the politics, Aristotle refers to the 10,000 Spartiates of the ancient
times, but it's clear that the term used, miuroi, is at best, as Paul remembered yesterday,
a very general approximation. Similarly, Plutarch's figure of 9,000 Spartiates is related
to the notion of 9,000 clergy, the plots of land which were distributed to the seed,
a notion which, however one may interpret it, could reflect the triadic division of the
Spartan institutional organization, which takes the form of three tribes, 30 elders,
300 horsemen, and precisely 9,000 plots of land to be assigned to as many Spartan seeds.
So, at best, these chief figures are just notional numbers, but just because apparently
unrelated to pre-established schemes and converging, as you have said, with the 5,000
Spartiates of Plataea, the Herodotus number of 8,100 male citizens of the military age
has seemed reliable. In my view, anyway, the question is, what are the sources that would
have allowed Herodotus to place an apparently reliable figure on the mouth of the exiled
king Demaratus? It is likely that some memory was preserved of the consistency of the contingents
that in Plataea had withstood the epic force against the Spartan invaders. Much less, however,
that memory was preserved of the Spartan forces which could be mobilized in 480. And it's true
that Herodotus visited Sparta, but he was there a few decades after these events, when a radical
demographic transformation of the Sicilian body had already begun. It is also to be excluded that
historians may have had access to something similar to a census, which certainly will never
have been held in Sparta at this time. What I intend to show, or at least suggest,
is that also the figure of 8,000 mobilizable men is a conventional figure, a notional number
based precisely on the knowledge of the Spartan military structure during the years of Persian
war. There is a text which, more than any other, can offer a valid suggestion, although it entails
that for some minutes we move away from the battle of Plataea. It is a fragment of a work
by Demetrius of Skepsis, taken from the first book of his work on the Trojan battle.
Let's take a look at this text. It says that among the Spartans, the festival of Carnea is
an imitation of military training. There are places, numbering nine, and these are called
shady places, schiades, since they bear some likeness to dance. Nine men eat in each,
and everything happens through the command of a herald, and each shady place holds three
practices, and the festival of Carnea is held for nine days. It is not easy to
assess the reliability of this antiquarian. Its chronological framework is not immediately clear.
It might be excessive to assume that the ritual described by Demetrius belongs to the period
of the origins of the festival of Carnea, which in Spartan scholars' residues belong
fixed during the 26th Olympiad in the 4th half of the 7th century BC. Nevertheless,
in general terms, the almost obsessive emphasis in this text on the number three and its
multiples, nine shady places, each containing three practices, making up a total of 27 practices
in the heat of one man, not only belongs to a Dorian ideological right, but no longer appears
by the end of the 5th century. Moreover, as an explicit imitation of military training,
the ritual can be seen as a microcosm of the Spartan organization during wartime.
Even the expression, everything happens through the commands of a herald, is a reference to
military organizations, since we know that the movements within the phalanx were given verbally
by the enomatarch, a specifically Spartan commander, if, Xenophon says, if he were a herald.
In short, this passage from Demetrius of Askeps is consistent with the
theology of Tyrtaeus previously reported in portraying a structure of the army,
which can probably be attributed to the Archaic Age, and reveals a clear military
function of the civic subdivision, both of the tribes and of the frats. We can note,
moreover, that Tyrtaeus states that the warriors of each of these three tribes fought
choris, that is, in separate raids. Since the ritual described by Demetrius is said to imitate
expressly military training, it's reasonable to assume that the people who banketed together
in each shady place also fought together. In other words, each group of three frats,
whose members shared the same intent, belonged to the same tribe.
The framework that emerges from this text is disarmingly simple, and is based exclusively
on the principle of the gradual segmentation of larger entities into smaller units.
The community of Spartans was organized into three Dorian tribes. Each of them was
divided into three intermediate units, which manifest themselves in the nine
shady places described by Demetrius. Each intermediate unit was, in its turn,
divided into three frats. There were three tribes, nine intermediate units, and 27 frats.
If all this makes sense, we must deduce that the distribution of the 81 men according to
their tribes and their frats must reflect the distribution of Spartan warriors at the time
when the festival took on the form described by Demetrius. It is certain that in the second
half of the 15th century, when the Battle of Mantinea in 418 was fought, the Spartan army
was organized very differently. But there is no reason to believe that in 479, when the number of
Spartan Caesar was still a large number, the structure of the army was no longer the Dorian
one, the tripartite structure. And here I came to the question of the 8,000 men. Why each fratric
in the ritual described by Demetrius is represented by three men and not just by one?
If we are faced, as everything seems to indicate, with a microcosm of the Spartan military
organization, the only possible answer is that each fratric would provide three army units,
each represented by a man. So it seems almost obvious to have to draw the conclusion
that these three units included men belonging to the three different moments in life,
the youngest, the oldest, and the man in the middle, according to the logic of the three
rituals that we have already illustrated. The immediate consequence of this reconstruction
is that the Spartan army in the age of the tribal order was made up of 81 units,
which, as it is known, had part subdivision, since the basic unit of the Spartan army was
the Enomotia. But what about the name of these 81 units in Spartan, and how many men each of them
include? The most likely hypothesis, in my view, is that the units were called Locoi.
We must remember that Thucydides is, in fact, the only author who refers that the Spartan Locoi
included more than 500 men. Not surprising, several scholars have pointed out that Thucydides
may have called Locoi the unit which was called, or at least Xenophon calls, Maura.
The Xenophon, the Spartan Locoi of the 4th century, as well as those which made up the army
of the 10,000 mercenaries described in the Anabasis, are always made up of 100 men.
In this perspective, the question of the Locus Orbitane, did it exist or did it not exist,
ends up disappearing. If it was a unit of 100 men, it evidently escaped the attention of Thucydides.
He believed that the Locoi were a body of a much greater number, and it can be reasonably assumed
that the Locus Orbitane consists of the 100 men generally placed to guard the king,
and explicitly mentioned by Herodotus in his 6th book. In any case, it follows that the Spartan
army had about 8,100 men, 100 for each of its units. This is obviously a conventional number,
and it's possible, for example, that the 27 units made up of the older men were not able to supply
all the men required. But this is a figure particularly close to those 8,000 Spartans
who were still available after Thermopylae. This is, in my view, the origin of the number 8,000
in Herodotus' 7234. I know, with numbers, if you use them approximately, you can prove anything.
Anything you want is more than legitimate to raise doubts. However, once put aside the notion
of the five Locoi and the five villages which never existed, the interpretation
offered here seems to me the most reasonable speculation. And allow me, in conclusion,
to go back a year, to 2,501 years ago, when he had to choose who to take with him between Thermopylae,
Leonidas selected 300 men who, Herodotus informs us, all had children. We must really imagine that
Leonidas has chosen, perhaps personally, these 300 fathers of families, or it is not much easier
to assume that he has chosen three units, three Locoi, each of 100 men. Choosing father of families
means that he selected the three Locoi not among the units of the youngest, nor obviously among
those of the oldest. Rather, he will have selected them from among the 27 units made up
of men who were over 30 years old, and therefore had, or were about to have sons, and were nevertheless
still part of the youth, the neops. With these 300 dead, Partha could still count on about 80 units,
two-thirds of them approximately 5,000 men, of 51 Locoi, if we take into account the 300 fallen
at Thermopylae, fought alone in Plataea under the command of Passania the regent. Some of them died,
but the speaker who preceded me has already written many papers about the fallen and their
and so thank you very much. Grazie mille. Thank you very much, Marcello. Lots to discuss there.
I don't see, oh I have, let me have a look in the Q&A. No, nothing there. No raised hands.
Paul Christensen, are you not dying to come back? If you aren't, I'm very happy to start off,
but I don't want to usurp. No, please get started. I'm largely in agreement with Marcello
so. Ah okay, right, well I'm not. There we go. For all sorts of reasons, including interpretation
of the wording of Demetrius of Skepsis, but I'm not going to impose my view. What I'm going to do
is impersonate Moses Finlay, and one of his tactics after hearing maybe a brilliant talk like Marcello's
would say, so what? So what? Because he was of course a New Yorker. Suppose you're right,
Marcello, that in 479 they're still fighting in three Dorian tribes. I'm not going to go into
all the issues of how many villages there were, on which I disagree with you quite strongly,
but so what? Therefore what does that tell us about Sparta? That it's massively conventional
and traditional, but it has always fought since the time of Tertius 650 to the early 5th century
in precisely the same fundamental organisation. Whereas Athens, late 6th century,
huge reform, both constitutional in the sense of political institutions, how people were appointed
to office, how decisions are made, and military, because tribal. Now my old teacher was not Finlay,
as some people have mistakenly thought, but de Sainte-Croix, and he was particularly keen,
as you saw it, on an evolutionary development, in particular later Greece, generically,
from what he called genetic tribes, that is, you claim, really, to be related by birth to
your fellow Fulitan, to political tribes, which are explicitly artificial, and they're designed
to fulfil a function which overcomes the defence of supposedly genetic relationship. And in the
case of Athens, of course, you have 10 tribal regiments to correspond to 10 new artificial
tribes. Now those of us who believe in an oval saw that as one answer to this problem that arises,
if you stick with a purely genetic model, births don't always work out brilliantly.
How do you absolutely ensure equality of numbers and equality of status,
equality of sentiment, on the basis purely of birth? Well, according to your picture,
Marcello, looking at Sparta in the round, that suggests Sparta's terrifically old-fashioned,
and that it's not moving with the times. Is that your view? That's all I'm asking.
I don't think that Sparta is a city that does not move, does not change. It changed in many ways.
And by the way, I think that the Tridorian tribes are a totally artificial construction.
They are not a memory, a survival of some very old structure. Also, the three tribes are
artificial construction. Yes, so slightly changes, but once in Athens, for example,
Calisthenes instituted the ten tribes, they stayed for a long time, until the Hellenistic
time. So I do not find it reasonable to assume that the construction of the three tribes,
in my view at least, born not before the seventh century, was still in force at the beginning
of the fifth, when the demography, the main power of Sparta was not changed significantly.
After, in the middle of the fifth century, things changed. Changed and the structure changed. So
this is at least my opinion. Fair enough. Thank you very much. So we have Yanis, please.
So Herodotus tells us that a thousand men reach and cross the Isthmus, a thousand Spartans,
before the rest of the army. And supposedly those are the youngest ones who can travel faster
without the baggage train and all. Does this number, which would be one-eighth of the whole
army or one-fifth of the army in this campaign, fit into the age group organization? Can we link
the two? Yes. It was usual that some part of the army was assigned in advance respect to the rest
of the army. So I, of course, probably the youngest, but Herodotus, unfortunately,
does not say more on this topic. Even at Thermopylae, there was a total Greek force
of 4,000 warriors, of which only 300 Spartans. But then other men should arrive,
in particular in Sparta, after the celebration of the Carneae. Anyway, yes, I think that
a part of these 5,000 were sent as an advance of the army.
Thank you very much. Natasha? Yes, thank you so much for this incredibly interesting talk,
Marcello. And I think I'm very convinced by the broad picture, sort of like your main
thesis. What I am curious about is when you say that Leonidas could just choose three loci,
so three kind of... Okay, let me see what I find interesting here. I think it actually
connects to the same conversation we have been already having in relation to Paul's talk,
because when Herodotus in Book 7, 234, which you just quoted, says that, okay, well, those 300
died at Thermopylae, but there at home, we have 8,000, which are all exactly the same level,
right? So, I mean, not Herodotus, but Demaratus. So this is, I think, what Herodotus himself
would concur. So Herodotus has this very strong egalitarian agenda for Sparta to come through.
But when you think about Leonidas and choosing people on a sort of dangerous mission,
would he be choosing just sort of like automatic division, or would he be choosing
people who are particularly good? And I'm sorry, apparently, I'm just right now a little bit
obsessed with hippies and people who would be ex-hippies, because I think it just very on my
mind. So when Thomas Figueroa was making an argument that those would be quasi-hippies,
I think what he meant is that those people could have been previously hippies. And I actually find
very interesting what Paul just said about hippies being sort of like fast track into the
sort of figures of authority and kind of close to the governmental structures in Sparta.
So I am curious how this competitive ethos would be superimposed on this very egalitarian ethos
that you have just described. Okay. Well, of course, I don't know if
Leonidas chose the triangle among the ex-hippies. I think just that there were,
as I said, there were 27 loci of a man of more than 30 years old,
until 45 probably, and probably three of them on which Leonidas had some
fiducia. He was sure about them. But I'm unable to give a real answer to your question.
There is an egalitarian ethos imposed on the Herodotus narrative that
makes it really difficult to answer. Actually, I'm super sorry to speak out of my turn,
but it suddenly occurred to me that when we say somehow good schools are in wealthy neighborhoods,
so some neighborhoods in Sparta could have been much more aristocratic and producing
much better quality warriors, combining the... Yes, yes, I would agree.
I just thought it might be worth mentioning one particular case, which I'm sure you all know,
but Plutarch's Apoplegmata, it's about Pidaritos. And when he was not selected, he said,
I'm really pleased because, you know what, there are 300 men in Sparta better than me.
Well, he might have been crap, but at any rate, he pitches up. He's a real person in Thucydides.
So there we go. So Paul, Paul Bambino. How are you doing? I guess this would make that
serpent call a lot easier to understand. Nothing else with the three tribes.
But my actual question is, did I understand it correctly that you're envisioning
locoi that are homogenous by age group, so that there are a body of locoi that are all the men
are between 20 and 30, and then other locoi, all the men are between 30 and 45? Or are they
integrated within locoi? It's interesting to me. I'll let you answer it. Exactly. I think that
there were one third of the locoi of young men until 30, one third of over 30, and one third
of the senior. Evidently, within each locoi, there was a difference of age, men of 20, 21.
Well, that's interesting, though, just because in terms of combining the manpower, having younger
men and older men in the same file, essentially, would be advantageous. And it would also make
sense when you're drawing up more age groups, that's how you get deeper files, because you're
bringing more men into the units. But the other thing is that I always looked at that as a sort
of a model for how they later would incorporate perioic units. So if you're seeing completely
distinct age groups, then we're probably talking about completely distinct Spartan and perioic
units. So that's just why I was curious if you're seeing this as completely homogenous
units within age groups. Generally, it is assumed that the perioic was integrated in the
Spartan army only in the 5th century, I think. So when the structure of the army was clearly
different from the one I have tried to describe, the Dorian one. So the perioic at Plataea,
as we accept what Herodotus says, were a different corpus of the army.
Right. So this homogenous age grouping, by then you think, breaks down throughout the 5th century?
The age group during the 5th century? Not totally, because the structure by
two turns, we find it also in Thucydides for the Peloponnesian world, and then also in
Xenophon, in several parts you find that the 10 age classes younger, or the 15,
that is 20 to 30, or 20 to 35, were sent for particularly dangerous missions.
So the logic of the age, probably in any army in the world, has always a weight.
Sure. Yeah, I guess my only concern is that either as a homogenous unit or as
part of a unit, but yeah. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you both. Chris Toppling?
Yeah, can you articulate how the phratres relate, if at all, to the loci? Because one of the
features of Demetrius' little schema is that there are things he calls phratres.
Yes, the phratres were nine for each tribe, for each age group. Yes, of course.
Of course, I also think that...
So each set of loci for each age group has three tribal subdivisions. I'm just struggling to
work out the maths and geometry, so to speak. I mean, I wonder how important would the phratres
be in terms of defining the military units, or are they in fact not important?
No, they just gave the men, they have three locus, one of different ages, but
no, just that. They were, in my view, a subdivision of the tribe, for each tribe,
nine phratres. Each phratres provided three locus. This is my reconstruction, at least.
I see. Okay.
Thank you very much, Chris. Yanis, coming back?
Yes. I would just like to remark that in yesterday's talks, in Michael Charles' talk
about the serpent, and we talked about how that looks a lot like a Spartan design of a monument,
and we wondered about not only the tribe. Okay, the tribe is, of course, linked to Apollo,
but why the serpent would have three heads? Now we hear about this connection, or possible
connection, with the Carnia, who vaguely have some connection to Apollo as well,
and the numbers three and the number nine, and then this repetition of the number three,
and what the three heads could mean. Of course, it's not actually a question, but it's a remark
that I just made. Okay. It's an interesting suggestion, Yanis. Thank you.
So you'd like to receive that with warmth, Marcello? Yes. So now we're supposedly having
a panel discussion, which I think we've already approached, but perhaps I could ask,
it seems invidious, but Paul Christensen, does your Spartan at the tier resemble Marcello's?
Yeah, I think Marcello's, I mean, I don't want to speak for Marcello, so let me tell you what I
understand him to be saying, that I think he's articulating one way the citizen body could have
been divided for military purposes, based on the idea that the Dorian tribes were constructs
that were created at the time of the Lycurgian Revolution, and that they were ramified in a
particular fashion based upon multiples of three, all of which seem entirely reasonable to me.
I don't think that has any necessary ramifications for how Spartiates interact. It's just a question
of how the citizen body is subdivided. I would say that I'm convinced about 85% of it. I guess
I'm a little skeptical about military units being formally divided on age basis.
I guess the question is, is there any obvious parallels for that on an army-wide basis in
Greece, where I think there's that more of, I think, and I would not construe myself as an
expert, more of an emphasis on distributing experience amongst the group as a whole.
But that's, I think, a relatively minor piece. What I did want to ask Marcello about was how,
and I may have, I was taking notes, I may have missed something in here,
how that works with the groups of 30 that Herodotus talks about,
the Trikades, which has always been sort of a mysterious group. I'm curious as to how that
fits together with your schema. No, no. I have no answer. I have no idea about the Trikades.
Hans Van West's suggestion could be accepted, but I have no idea. I mean, Trikades recalls
Greece, of course, but yes. Maybe Trikades could have something with
some relation with the past, but I don't want to stress this point.
Okay. Can I ask you also, and again, I may have just not connected this,
but do you see an integration between this system of organization and the Scythia?
In one way, yes. There was an integration. If the men who fought together in battle really
ate together, had dinner together in the Scythia, some relation should have been.
It's very little. We know from Plutarch that 15 people, 15 persons had dinner at the Scythia
together, and one could find this relation. Precisely, in which way, it's very difficult to
say. The reason I ask is in part because I think there's a strong sense that the Scythia were
purposefully mixed age groups, so that people were elected into them. If there's a mixing of
the age groups at the smallest unit level, then I'm not sure how the units could then be recombined
in a way that would make them age group homogenous at the larger level.
Okay, yes, but this is a xenophone in Chapter 5 of, I think, of his Constitution of Spartans,
and I have no doubt in any case that there was a... We have not spoken about the enomatia,
but surely the enomatia has all the age classes. So there was a transversal integration,
in my opinion, between the two structures.
Okay, thank you. Just to circle around it, I would say that I'm totally sold on everything
except the age group division, that the units were divided by age group. It just seems very hard
to sustain a military unit in that fashion, but we are clearly in the realm of opinion here,
and I'm willing to say that the other 95 percent I'm totally sold on.
Thank you.