Carbon credits vs sheep farms: The Growing Divide in Rural New Zealand

The Beauty Of Nature
21 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 3, 2026
In rural New Zealand, carbon credits have sparked debate surrounding sheep farms. Farmers worry that costs and environmental regulations threaten their livelihoods, while proponents argue that the carbon market helps reduce emissions and protect the climate.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedNew Zealand's reliance on pine forests to meet climate goals via carbon credits is causing significant social and economic strain in rural areas like Pongaroa. While the government views forestry as a cost-effective way to offset emissions, local residents warn that converting sheep and beef farms into forests is hollowing out communities and threatening the nation's agricultural backbone.
New Zealand has relied heavily on forests to meet its climate goals since 2008,
using trees to absorb carbon and offset emissions created elsewhere in the economy.
But in Pongaroa, a rural village around three hours north of Wellington,
residents say that strategy is coming at a cost. As beef and sheep farms are converted
into pine forests, locals say their community is being further hollowed out.
Here in the hills of the Lower North Island, pine forests planted for carbon credits are
increasingly replacing sheep and beef farms. Firms can buy those credits to set against
their own carbon emissions, creating an income stream for the forest owners.
The government says the pine trees grow well in New Zealand and forestry is a cost-effective
way for the country to meet its near-term climate goals, which it says it's on track to meet.
Supporters say it's an all-important tool for tackling climate change,
but some residents say the forests are changing the character of rural communities.
Ten minutes out of Pongaroa, Alex Renner and his wife Katie are farming the land that has
been in her family for more than a century. Now the farms around them are covered in forestry.
That was one of the things Pongaroa was well known for, is you could come in and get a start
as a young farmer, build equity and be able to move on and get into a bigger farm and unfortunately
we've seen a lot of those farms sold into clients and lost a lot of those young farmers and that
adds a lot to the community, you just get more, like it's people that make a community,
it's you get diversity and yeah, it's just people make it. Good eh?
Renner says the number of farming families in the area is dwindling as more land is converted
into forestry and he says that has meant the closure of local facilities once sustained by
young families. We had Pongaroa early years and that was a great way for you know Katie to get
back to work, like the kids could go to preschool and they just had such a good chance to interact
with other kids and stuff but unfortunately it closed down two years ago. It was fantastic but
unfortunately in the end we just had a few families move out with trees and just a few
kids aging up and not having those younger kids coming through and we ended up closing because
we only had I think 10 to 15 kids left. The local rugby club has also folded and residents say these
are all signs of the community slowly shrinking. Fiona Ransom's family have been farming this
3,000 acre station since 1971. In the last decade several of the neighbouring properties have been
planted in pine. To see pine trees on good productive farmland is very depressing because
it's wrong, it's the wrong way of farming, it's just wrong for New Zealand. I mean New Zealand's
going to pay, it's going to bankrupt New Zealand in years to come because
New Zealand sheep and beef farming as well as dairy farming is the backbone of the country
and with all those pine trees there's nothing going to be left. Ramson says the impacts go
beyond the loss of grazing land. Yes so we're burdened with all the pests that they've left
behind with the pigs and the deer and the goats as well as possums are coming back in a major
majorly so I'm very worried about the TB that might come through with our pests so
it's going to financially cripple us if we get that back in again. The expansion has been driven
partly by New Zealand's emissions trading scheme. Forestry in New Zealand has been supported by
carbon credits and policies that have made it easier for foreign companies to invest in New
Zealand. The industry says it's managing risks around pests and fire and not only does forestry
offset carbon emissions, it creates export income, jobs and timber. Among those putting in money is
Inca Investments, the investment arm of the company that operates most IKEA stores worldwide.
The firm owns almost 170 square miles of forest in New Zealand
and says forestry can supply timber and provide employment in rural areas.
We certainly recognise there's an effect, land use change has an effect with
different land uses and different work opportunities. We source almost all of our
locally so our crews are based locally we've got local staff within only about half an hour's drive
of here so even though that dynamic has shifted it's not they're not focused on say a shearing
gang anymore it's more of a planting crew or a pruning crew and thinning crew so the dynamic
shifts a little bit. But work is tied to the sheep industry so the loss of breeding farms is already
being felt. At this shearing shed near Pongaroa, Brandon Coombe-Gray says there are knock-on effects.
So fewer breeding ewes means fewer sheep to shear. In turn there's less work for the local families
I don't know how many ewes they used to have maybe 10,000 ewes so they've gone and put in
pine trees, blanket planted the whole farm. Not one single ewe is there to be seen so you think
about 10,000 ewes you're looking at 15,000 lambs and then it's a generational thing so
the next generation they'll have lambs then they'll have lambs so it's more work it's a flow-on effect.
Now policy makers face a dilemma how to protect rural communities while at the same time
meeting its climate targets which its own watchdog say are at risk.
