From Shawn Ryan Show Ep. 316: Brian Keating lays out why he is certain Apollo happened — starting with Soviet telemetry and coordination on landing day — then pushes on moon-landing skepticism, America-First contradictions, and the question every conspiracy should face: who benefits?
Standalone 16:9 master. No karaoke. No source card.
The speaker defends the authenticity of the Apollo moon landings using geopolitical and scientific evidence while addressing the psychological roots of conspiracy theories. He argues that the Soviet Union's tracking of the missions proves the landings were real and explains that the current gradual return to the moon via the Artemis program is a matter of safety and priority, not a lack of technology.
When the Artemis, uh, we should talk about lunar, uh,
landing conspiracies. Cause you, you had on this guy, uh, genteel,
AJ Gentile, AJ Gentile. That was an awesome show. I love that guy.
He's one of my favorite people. He is. He is. And he's,
he's so good at what he does. You know, like imagine how hard it is. Like,
you know, it's hard to interview people,
but then also to do like explainer content where you explain things. Um,
but you know, I was, I can never take the professor out of the laboratory.
And so he made a couple of mistakes in that episode and I would love to talk to
him sometime. Uh, maybe you can introduce me. But one of the things he said is
that, um, that the, uh,
the Soviets beat us in every possible thing.
And this is part of the conversation you guys had about how the moon landing
didn't happen, right? Or how people could say that.
I don't actually know what you believe. And this is a case where you could say,
believe, but we have evidence, right? What do you believe?
I know for a fact we landed on the moon. How do you know?
I know for a fact cause we have physical evidence.
We have eyewitness evidence. We have photographic evidence,
but the best evidence we have shown,
the best evidence we have comes from the Soviet union.
What's that Soviet union on July 19th,
1969,
the Soviets knew that the Eagle was on its way to land on the sea of tranquility.
They had launched six days earlier, a spacecraft of their own, uh, uncrewed,
no men were on it,
but they were going to go and land on the moon and they were going to take
samples and they're kind of wanting to steal the thunder,
arrive a day earlier and, and kind of get a little bit of the credit.
And they also kind of hoped that we would crash and they would all die. I mean,
the space race was insane, right? I mean, it was incredible.
The Soviets coordinated with the Americans on that very day because they were
worried that they would crash into the Eagle and they coordinated their
telemetry and we still have records of their telemetry. Um,
and the communications between the, um,
Baikonur Cosmodrome and Kazakhstan where they would do their launches and
recoveries and, uh, a NASA Apollo.
They wanted to avoid a huge PR disaster,
especially since they thought we would die.
They thought they would actually crack.
People thought the moon landers would keep going down through the surface of the
moon.
They thought it was made of like really loose talcum powder like dust and that
they would actually be unstable and would flip.
They actually, most people gave it 50, 50 odds. In fact,
Nixon had recorded a speech in case the astronauts died. And,
um, you know, and he,
they prerecorded it and say he would play it on TV and give their condolences.
They also planned for the contingency that they'd be lost in lunar orbit or that
they would miss the moon and go off into deep space and become a satellite never
to be found again. Right. So, um,
so the Russians confirmed it that would coordinate with our telemetry.
When they landed, they congratulated president Nixon. Um,
and then they also landed, uh, on, on the moon and the first landing,
they landed these retro reflectors called laser, uh, lunar laser,
retro reflectors. Um,
you run on your bicycle and you see like a bike tail light or the reflectors on
the back of a bike, right? How does that work? Um,
how does the bike know where your car is going to be?
You could be at any angle, any bearing, any distance, right?
How does it know to reflect back?
They have the specially designed retro reflectors that always will find the
target back to earth. And we bounced lasers off it. My colleague, uh,
UCS San Diego, uh, became retired recently. Tom Murphy,
he bounces lasers off these retro reflectors left by the Apollo, uh,
moon landing, um, Apollo 11.
And he can measure the distance of the moon to the thickness of a paper clip,
one millimeter or so thickness. So we know the average that was left by these
astronauts. Now the Russians left these things there too,
but the Russians also overflew both our, uh,
landing sites and their own landing sites.
And Tom Murphy and his colleagues found the Russian retro reflectors as well as
the American ones,
exactly where the American said they put it in exactly where the Russian said
they put it. And the last kind of little bit of convincing evidence, um,
one, one part. And, but I do want to get back to what Gentile said.
That's wrong because I think it's important. Um, is that, uh, is that that,
um, the, the positioning. So you could maybe sort of fake that or whatever,
but imagine right now, imagine like Artemis two,
which just went around the moon. Right. I think even, you know,
I debated Bart Sibrel on Piers Morgan the day of the launch. And he,
he was like, well, maybe they're going now, but they couldn't have gone then.
I'll get back to that in a second. Now that's totally fallacious and,
and ridiculous argument that I refuted on air with, with him.
And Piers actually piled on and called him bullshit, uh, to his credit. But, um,
these, the very day that Artemis launched and then went around the moon this last
month in April, can you imagine laying on the moon? No, we're not, not this one.
This one was just go around the moon. We're supposed to land.
No, no, no. It was always planned to do this. First one went around the moon.
No one was in it. Second one went around the moon with people in it.
Third one's going to be people in it. Uh, sorry. Unmanned landing on the moon.
Fourth one's going to be people landing on the moon. Okay. Well, let me, let me,
let me just, all right. All right.
I just want to know why don't we just land on the ******* moon?
We did it in the sixties. Okay. Right. Would you get,
why are we doing all this crazy wild ----? Let's just go back.
Would you get on with your kids and being here and your wife and your empire
that is so impressive?
Would you get on like the second flight of a,
of any kind of military hardware built by the lowest paying country ever
noticed? I'm a risk taker. No, you are. But would you do it now?
I asked Elon Musk on my podcast. Would I do it right now? Yeah.
Would you take it right now? Right. So you do things in steps.
Four or five years ago. Kitty Hawk.
Is that the first time the right flyer had ever flown?
Oh, they didn't put themselves on it the first time they did test flies,
prototype flights. That's all they're doing. There's nothing nefarious there,
but let me just get to the closure of this one argument.
A thought experiment I want you to consider April 5th,
six, when they went around the moon. Can you imagine Ayatollah Khomeini Jr.
Oh, hello. Hi. MashaAllah. MashaAllah. President, President Trump.
Congratulations. Every country on earth, including China,
which had stolen a lot of our nuclear and space secrets in the 1970s,
China, Soviet union,
all these countries called up and congratulated the United States.
Now they were our enemy.
It's hard to think of it now because we kind of like whatever, whatever. Right.
But can you imagine like the Ayatollahs right now calling us up to congratulate
us? In other words,
they would be the most glorified and happy people on earth to have us
not get there and prove that we didn't get there because that would leave glory
for them. So that's a psychological kind of component evidence for it.
There's overwhelming scientific evidence for it.
The evidence against it is minimal. You already mentioned one of them, which is,
well, how come they did it? Uh, you know, in the sixties, but we can't do it now.
I mean, you said that Gentile said that totally fallacious argument. I love you.
I love Gentile. I'm going to tell you that's a fallacious argument and I'm living
proof of it. Okay. The first person to ever set foot on the South pole,
Roald Amundsen is amazing guy. He went from the North pole.
He almost was the first person to reach the North pole. He lost,
turned around and went on a huge expedition and became the first person to land
to, to reach the South pole. The South pole nowadays, I said,
I take a C one 30 flight, a C 17 flight land in the ice.
Then I take a ski C one 30 on that. It takes me a week. Okay. Oh, poor Brian.
You'll pay it. Play the violin. It took them six months just to get there.
Then they got there. They would get there in spring.
Cause that's the only time you can really travel there.
Then they have to wait until the following spring.
They'd stay on the coast of Antarctica for six more months until our seven,
eight months before it came warm enough that they could ski cross-country ski
up 9,000 feet of ice. Okay. And then they got to the South pole.
And they had to get back before winter started.
And if they missed it by three weeks, like the British team,
Robert Falcon Scott was the second person to get to the South pole in 1912 in
January, 1912, three weeks after Amundsen got there in December, 1911,
everyone on Scott's team died. Every single one of them froze to death,
the most excruciating way possible,
10 miles from a cache of supplies that would have saved their lives.
They all died. They didn't know about it for another year.
And then they got back to England a year after the hat. Okay. We're just, okay.
So 1911, our Norwegian guy sets foot with his teammates on the South pole.
You know, when the next Norwegian to get to the South pole was strong,
I'm not expecting you to 1996. Wow.
So if you're a 90 Bart Sibro, 1995, you say, Oh wait,
how can we went there with technology, with a boat, a wooden boat,
the Shackleton we did that a hundred years ago,
but we can't do that now. It's completely fallacious. I mean,
that's not a good argument. Okay.
There are other arguments that are better like the Van Allen belts.
And so I don't think that, you know, I'm not saying that we didn't go.
Okay. Well, it sounded like, I'm not saying you're open to the hypothesis.
At least I think it's ******* weird that we haven't been back
since the sixties.
But do you know why we didn't go back to the South pole or anybody on earth?
So first of all, it was a belt thing that you just brought up.
I also think is very odd.
And there's that guy in NASA that said we lost the technology. I'm sorry.
You lost the ******* technology. Okay. There's no NASA guy at NASA.
It's like saying the guy in the Navy SEALs or something like that can mean a lot
of things, right? It doesn't, I mean, I'm just not familiar with. Yeah, I know.
But, but when you have a platform like you do, and AJ has his platform,
I'm just,
I would love the scientific rigor to kind of not you have to get a PhD in
quantum mechanics. Actually, I'm just saying, when you think about things,
what should be your default base rate hypothesis?
Should it be that this is, this is kind of fake or, you know,
as, as Candace Owens said, this is fake and gay, right?
So she's supposed to be like America first, right?
She's supposed to really love America, be patriotic.
It's not only the greatest achievement of America, but it's the,
this is one of the greatest,
I think it is personally the greatest achievement in all of human history.
And I say that as somebody who's a pure scientist going to the moon. Yeah.
Well, we did in a very short amount of time, but it took a level of,
you know, just, just incredible, incredible, you know,
cooperation and technology,
hundreds of thousands of people coordinating across decades.
And the evidence against it is so minimal.
What's frustrating as a real scientist to say, like, look,
no one would rather these things be false than a scientist, right?
Cause I get paid not to prove people. Right.
My job is not to prove fricking Avi Loeb, right?
My job is to say, no, you're fricking wrong. Here's a better explanation.
Let's go test that. And his job is a good scientist to say, thank you, Brian.
You know, you, you use your experimental technology.
I'm in a theoretical physicist. Let's work together and come closer to truth.
Okay. That's the way science should be done.
Not like the default assumption is America lied. You know,
they lied about COVID. I mean, I, you know,
for many reasons I wish COVID never happened and I've interviewed, you know,
and I'm best friends with the, uh,
one of the close friends with the director of the National Institute of Health,
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya was tortured by Anthony Fauci and, and, and,
and Francis Collins horrible thing. And, you know, he's a Christian,
he's an incredible human being. You know, he,
all this stuff that you're kind of talking about here, you know,
at the beginning,
you asked me if I thought it was a good idea for a country to lie to its
citizens. Yeah. Now we're wondering if we ******* landed on the moon,
because a lot of lies have come out of the government and you're a scientist,
you know, you understand how to sift through all this data. And I mean,
you've spent many,
many years studying all the things that it takes to know about landing on the
moon. I'm an ABCL. I spent those years fighting a ******* war.
You know what I mean? Yeah. And so what I'm saying is, you know,
you're looking at straight facts and the rest of us are looking at contexts,
you know, and when you have,
when you add in the context and you see a government that continuously lies to
its ******* citizens, citizens are no longer going to believe the government,
I guess is, is a question.
Then all these conspiracies start to happen and distrust.
And then they start digging into everything. What were you saying about Candace?
So, so Candace,
what I'm saying about Candace is that the America firsters and the American
patriots and so forth, and I'm not questioning her love of America or whatever,
just saying if this is the greatest accomplishment that a human being has ever
made,
and it happens to come from the country that you profess your love for and
allegiance to as I do. And as you do, right, that it doesn't mean they're flawless.
I mean, who's flawless, right? I mean, who do you agree with a hundred percent of
the time? Like I'll say my wife, right. But, but that's about it, right?
Sometimes you contradict yourself.
I contradict you agree with your wife a hundred percent of the time.
That's bullshit, honey. If you're watching, you know what I did?
I made her mad the other day. I said, you know, honey,
whenever I'm driving around, like I got to turn off the, the the,
the voice activated directions on the GPS. She's like, Oh, that's so romantic.
You want to listen to me? I'm like, no,
I don't want two women yelling at me while I'm in the car. No.
So you don't agree with everybody, right? You don't even agree with yourself.
I reserve the right to be wrong all the time. And in fact,
that's the best thing a scientist should do.
We should have the fricking balls to say when we're wrong,
not just when we're right from the standpoint of having skepticism of your
government and whatnot. You always have to ask the question.