The surprising truth behind Boston's half-fake neighborhoods
Oct 2, 2026
If you've ever driven through downtown Boston, you know that the streets are a chaotic maze
that make zero sense.
But there's a reason for that.
I'm currently in the heart of downtown Boston.
And what's crazy is that if I walk just a little bit this way, everything is fake.
It's all fake.
You see, back in 1630, Boston was just a tiny 780 acre blob of land, practically an island
at high tide.
So how exactly did they build one of the largest metropolises in the entire United States on
top of the Atlantic Ocean?
And more importantly, why is Boston's most expensive neighborhood sinking today?
Well, there's no better place to explain all of this than Boston itself.
Now some of you might be wondering why I'm starting in the heart of Boston, where it's
mostly just financial buildings.
But there is a very good reason for that.
I'm looking for something called Spring Street.
And well, I'll explain more when I get there.
But basically, without this one street, Boston would never have been able to start in the
first place.
Okay, so it might not look like much, but this street where I'm standing was the original
home of the original spring that literally watered Boston.
Apparently the original settlers, the original colonists who arrived here, were somewhere
nearby.
And apparently the water was terrible there.
And there was a single person who had his farmstead, his homestead here, and he had
a naturally running spring that provided fresh water.
And so eventually he convinced all of the other settlers to come over to what was then
a peninsula and use the water here.
And this is the home of where that spring was.
Now eventually, you know, the colony grew and, you know, that water supply wasn't big
enough.
And so they eventually had to find additional water sources.
And at one point, as you can tell, they paved over the spring entirely.
This is just a street.
But I wanted to come to this street, which is otherwise kind of plain and boring, simply
because this is where it all began, baby.
Okay, well, let's make our way through Boston.
So I swear this is not just going to be a walking tour of Boston.
I do have a story I'm telling, but it's so incredibly hard because there's so much history
and interesting, fun, beautiful things to see in the city.
You're just going to catch some of it.
Like for example, those statues back there are paying an homage to the Irish refugees
from the mid 1800s, which ironically enough, Alexa and I were just telling those stories
when we were in Ireland a few weeks ago.
And here we're kind of seeing the other side of it.
Apparently in 1847, over 30,000 Irish refugees arrived in Boston alone.
That's crazy.
I've managed to wander over into the Beacon Hill neighborhood.
And I feel like this is as good a time as any to talk about where Boston is actually
physically located.
So that original peninsula, that doesn't really exist today.
Not in any meaningful form anyways.
And that's because, well, it was topographically challenging.
In fact, right where I'm walking now, it was dominated by three really large hills.
And these were called the Trimount.
But as the city's population exploded in the 1800s, Boston needed more space.
I need more space.
And so they ended up doing something that's completely unhinged.
They quite literally shaved down all three hills.
In fact, using steam shovels and gravity-powered rail cars, they shaved down about 60 feet
off the top of each one of those hills.
So Beacon Hill, Mount Vernon, and Pemberton Hill simply no longer exist.
But what's really interesting is what they ended up doing with all of that land.
Because, well, you don't make new land from nothing.
But once again, before we make it over to that area, there's one tiny street I'm looking
for in Beacon Hill.
Because it's supposed to be really cool looking.
I mean, to be honest, most of this neighborhood is very cool looking.
I found it.
So this is Acorn Street.
And it's one of the more unique streets.
For one, it has the original cobblestone.
The road makes it very hard to step and walk around without tripping.
But it also happens to be a series of row houses here.
They were built more for the servants of some of the larger homes and families and wealthier
families in the area.
It just makes for, one, a very beautiful street to walk down, but two, literally a piece of
Boston history that you can walk on...carefully.
You gotta have fun when you're by yourself, you know?
Navigating Boston's chaotic streets can honestly feel like a trek.
But whether you're logging miles in a confusing city or tackling the unpredictable trails
here in Oregon, having reliable gear is essential.
That's why we're thrilled to partner with Camel for today's video.
Right now, we're exploring the Oregon woods, equipped with Camel's lightweight shell rainjacket
and their Camel hiking sports sandals.
These sandals are incredibly versatile.
They are lightweight and waterproof, making them perfect for hiking and beach trips.
But they look great for daily casual wear around the city, too.
We are constantly making our way through different environments, so being able to have a pair
of shoes that are comfortable and versatile helps us with packing for all of our trips.
The Camel hiking sport sandals are built for pure comfort, featuring a contoured insole
that gives you ergonomic arch support.
Plus, the adjustable hook and loop straps mean you can customize the fit for different
foot shapes.
We put them to the ultimate test in this Oregon river.
Thanks to the durable, tear-resistant polyester webbing, they dry rapidly and won't rub your
feet after getting them wet.
The anti-skid sole even features drainage channels and puncture resistance for rugged
terrain, while the shock-absorbing midsole cushions every step.
Knowing that we can get our feet wet without ruining our entire hiking experience is a
must while hitting the trails here in the Pacific Northwest.
If you want high-performance gear for your next adventure, click the link in our description
to shop Camel.
Huge thanks to Camel for sponsoring.
Now, let's get back to the confusing streets of Boston.
Welcome to the Charles River Esplanade, and I could not think of a better place to show
off all of this reclaimed land than, well, the reclaimed land itself.
In fact, this area used to be more of a stinking, smelly bay than anything else.
Kind of gross, right?
And unfortunately for Boston, slicing off the tops of the Trimount, all of those hills
we talked about earlier, simply wasn't enough to fill in all of this new land, all of this
water that was here.
And so by the year 1850, Boston had a massive problem, the Back Bay.
Now, originally, all of this was a tidal estuary, which means a river was flowing in and the
tides would flow in and sort of the water would go up and down depending on the tides.
And when it was down, there would be a lot more land, but then of course the tides would
come up and all that land would go away.
But all of that kind of came to a screeching halt when developers built a mill dam across
it, which accidentally stopped the tidal inflow.
And so without the ocean flushing it in and flushing it out, the Back Bay, the area that
I'm walking through right now, turned into what really amounted to a stagnant, open-air
sewer.
It was a massive, disease-ridden public health crisis, right on the back door of Boston itself.
Doesn't that just kick you in the crotch, spit on your neck, fantastic.
So city officials at the time, they decided to do something, well, pretty drastic.
They would fill in the Back Bay and turn it into housing, specifically luxury housing.
But here's the main issue with all of this.
Mud sinks.
And building on mud is a bad idea in the best of circumstances.
So how did Boston manage to convert a tidal estuary that turned into a stinking, raw open
sewage pit into one of the most expensive neighborhoods in the entire country?
To answer that, we're going to head back inland a little bit.
Of course, Boston is still an American city and not even the best of American cities can
help but choke off their waterfront by a really large highway.
It's so weird.
As I make my way through what I think is Boston Commons, I'm actually not sure where it begins
and ends, but a very big, beautiful green area here in the middle of Boston.
Let me just explain why you're only seeing me on this episode.
Unfortunately, Alexa is still visiting family and therefore she had to miss this part of
our New England trip, which also means she's not going to be there for next week's episode
either.
Just as a notification of sorts for all you Lex stans out there, you're stuck with me.
I have been walking around Boston quite a bit today, so if you don't mind, I'm just
going to take a quick seat while we talk about Back Bay.
This is basically Back Bay today or, you know, wherever that building starts is Back Bay.
And to fill in that massive, rotting swamp, trains had to run basically 24 hours a day
for over 40 years.
Sorry, what?
From 1859 to the year 1900, the city hauled gravel from the neighboring town of Needham
and dumped it into the water that used to exist right behind me.
And over the course of those decades, slowly but surely, Boston added hundreds of acres
to its original land.
It was a massive boon to a city that was originally hemmed in on all sides by its natural geography.
Now, because the land was manufactured entirely from scratch, and it was made much later,
they didn't have to follow the same pattern as the old Boston, those old cow paths that
sort of meander every which way.
Instead, they built a very precise, mathematically perfect grid.
So when you walk from downtown Boston, where I was earlier, into Back Bay, which is, again,
right there, you are literally walking through history.
That original 1630 town immediately changes into a 19th century gridded city.
And one that has some seriously beautiful, but sinking, homes.
But to tell that story, well, we actually have to head into Back Bay.
So let's go.
Most American cities just don't look like this.
These sort of grand parks, things are made to look very beautiful in a lot of ways.
Very European.
Not even New York City, I feel like, is as beautiful as Boston.
At long last, I have made it into Back Bay itself, and let me tell you, this area is
very posh.
It's very wealthy.
You can almost feel how much it costs just to live here.
I will say, they've done a really nice job with some really nice protected bike lanes
right here.
As you can see.
Nice job, Boston.
As a former city planner, I appreciate it.
Okay, so real talk.
It is really hard to imagine the Back Bay as a stinking open sewer cesspit.
Because right now, it's filled with immaculate, I mean, almost mansion-esque row houses.
They're not the typical mansions we think of, but they're just so incredibly luxurious.
But here's the thing.
You can't build a 400 ton brick mansion on wet mud.
It'll instantly sink.
Is what the thing is.
So 19th century engineers used a brutal workaround.
They took tens of thousands of massive wooden tree trunks, mostly spruce and pine, and drove
them deep into the ground to act as the foundation for all of these buildings here.
Every single historic townhouse and building you see here in the Back Bay are balancing
on what amount to a bunch of wooden sticks.
In this way, Boston is very similar to Amsterdam.
Both are built on a lot of reclaimed land, using large wooden logs to prop up most of
their buildings.
And to be honest, it's an ingenious solution to a very big problem.
But unfortunately for the people who live here, that solution has turned out to not
be as permanent as maybe the original engineers thought it would be.
Because there is a massive problem brewing right under where I'm sitting right now.
But to talk about that big problem, there's a very big building right here in Back Bay
that highlights it perfectly.
So let's go find it.
So it's getting pretty close to July 4th here in the United States, which is our Independence
Day.
And it also happens to be the 250 year anniversary of the country, which is an impressive amount
of time to be a country.
Probably not a better place other than Boston to be here for that.
Kind of where it all started.
Boston Tea Party and all that.
Okay, so here's the reality.
Despite all of the logs and all of the effort that Boston put into building an immaculate
neighborhood, this land is still sinking.
That's not good.
Which is weird because if Amsterdam's okay and they use a very similar method, then why
is Back Bay here in Boston actively sinking?
What did they do wrong?
Well, here's the crazy science of what's going on.
All of those original wooden logs were driven deep underwater in order to hold the ground
up.
And as long as those wooden stilts stay underground, they'll never rot.
But if the groundwater here in Boston ever drops, oxygen hits the wood.
And those wooden stilts, well, they do begin to rot.
And unfortunately for Boston, their groundwater has dropped.
As the city grew in the 19th century, it continued and continued to put more and more things
underground.
Sewers, subway tunnels, utilities, and even basements for the homes that are in this neighborhood.
All of these things caused the groundwater to drop because you need to extract water
from the ground in order to build them.
And after decades and decades and decades of adding more and more and more things, the
water has descended past the point of those original wooden piles, which are now beginning
to be exposed.
And there is no clearer example of this than, well, Trinity Church right behind me, which
is considered to be one of the 10 most important buildings in the entire country.
And despite that, it is built on wooden piles, and those piles have to be constantly monitored
to ensure that that building doesn't sink.
Now the good news here is that all is not lost for Boston.
While large parts of Back Bay is sinking, the city is acutely aware of the problem.
So since the 1980s, the city has worked tirelessly to replenish the groundwater here in this
neighborhood.
And of course, if you live in this neighborhood and you have the money and you have rotting
stilts, you can pay money to get them fixed.
It'll cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, but you're not going to lose your home.
Still, that's little comfort if you're living in this neighborhood right now, especially
if you don't have that kind of money.
Well, that about does it for our time here in Back Bay.
And we're almost done here in Boston.
But there's one more neighborhood I want to go to because Boston is kind of repeating
history a little bit.
And I couldn't think of a better place to end this episode.
So let's head that way.
So one of the coolest parts about Boston, in my opinion, is where I'm standing right
now, which is the Kennedy Greenway.
Now if you didn't know any better, about two decades ago or so, this right here where I'm
walking was a freeway.
And actually, that freeway still exists.
It's just underground now, I-93.
At some point, they decided to cap it and put this really nice park and some buildings
over it.
And it really reconnected downtown Boston with, well, other parts of downtown Boston
and the waterfront where I'm walking right now.
I don't say this often, but the thoughtfulness of the urban planning that has gone into Boston
in the 21st century is definitely next level.
It is a masterclass in urban planning, something that all cities, including my home city of
Portland, can learn from.
All right, we're getting closer to our final destination.
All right, this is it.
I've made it to Fan Pier Park on the other side of Boston.
But there's a reason why I wanted to come here to finish up the episode, and that is
because Fan Pier Park and the neighborhood around it are also built on artificial land.
But unlike Back Bay, this area was mostly industrial and used for ports and shipping
and all that kind of stuff, which means it didn't really have all that much on it aside
from a few buildings that were required to house things.
Today, that has changed.
There are big new glass skyscrapers all around me right now.
And so, the final question becomes, has Boston learned its lesson from Back Bay?
Will Fan Pier eventually sink or do they think a bit farther ahead this time and it'll last
permanently?
I guess only time will tell, but for right now, this is some pretty sturdy ground.
And I guess with that, this was a super duper fun episode exploring Boston and some of its
unique geographic issues.
Not every city is sinking, although a lot of them are these days.
If you enjoyed it, please subscribe to the channel.
Next week, I am up in New Hampshire where I'm going to try and visit the mountain with
the worst weather in the world, according to some.
It will be another solo episode, but it should still be a lot of fun.
So, come back next week for another geographic adventure.
See you then.

