Yankees vs Rays ALDS Preview: Aaron Judge Latest & Roster Predictions | Pinstripe Post

New York Post - Sports
11 followers
Oct 2, 2026
Hello, welcome to the Pinstripe Post.
My name is Ryan Sampson, but he's the star of the show, Joel Sherman.
Today is third Friday, October 2nd.
Joel, the New York Yankees sweep the Boston Red Sox in the A.L.
Wild Card.
They're moving on to the A.L.
D.S. to face the Tampa Bay Rays.
This feels like it's been growing and mounting.
Like we talked about it with the Red Sox series.
That was going to happen for weeks.
And then if they were to get past the Red Sox,
it was going to be the division rival in the Rays.
The team they're always chasing in the division.
And now they're going for game one on Saturday, 630.
Garrett Cole has been announced he's going to be the game one starter.
We'll dive into that.
We'll dive into what we saw from the Red Sox series
and if they can carry it over into the A.L.
D.S. before we get to any of that.
Joel Sherman, how are you doing today, buddy?
Oh, Ryan, thanks as always. I'm doing well.
I'm staying up here at MLB Network.
I got some TV to do that.
I'm on a flight going from here to Newark on a flight down to Tampa,
St. Petersburg for a couple of games.
Look, the Yankees did the important thing.
They took care of the first step.
They did it the best way possible, quickly.
Give them, you know, an extra day of rest to kind of get all their pitching
in order, not play the dangerous game three where anything could happen.
And, you know, just like another round, like it was two days
where they played really well.
I thought especially game one defensively was a game.
And I can't emphasize this enough for the two games in St.
Petersburg against the Rays.
If you don't play clean, they punish you.
And so we saw in game two Trent Grisham lollygag
a a ball that was should be a single.
I'm trying to it wasn't so good.
Who was the hitter on it?
Eaton, Nate Eaton was the hitter, you know, who never broke stride.
The scouting report on Grisham was he's going to screw around
and do style over substance.
Just keep going.
Trust me, the Rays are going to have the same scouting report.
They're going to have the same scouting report.
If Jess Chisholm is out of position, if Grisham lollygags,
if Jones can't pick up a ball off the ground,
like like all the bad things, the bunt defense that was bad
in the second half for the Yankees in particular.
Then nobody bunts with the frequency.
I mean, it's not close.
Ryan, I dug into the numbers.
We have a scouting report that will be up online
sometime on Friday and in Saturday's newspaper.
I mean, the Rays sacrifice more than anyone else.
They bunt for hits more than anyone else, and they suicide
squeeze and safety squeeze more than anyone else.
And I mean, like the second place for all of it is so far away.
And if you do not handle the ball well, that's how they punish you.
And so game one was very good for the Yankees.
Game two was OK.
But the Grisham play reminded me, you do you pull that nonsense.
You're going to cost 90 feet.
And they are a team.
A scout said something to me really interesting, Ryan.
He said the Rays are a team that's very comfortable
scoring one run in an inning.
In other words, like everybody's trying to hit a multi run homer.
The Rays will peck, peck, peck at you.
And it's like if they get a runner on second with none out
because Grisham's doing it like the Red Sox didn't move that runner over
and it didn't score against Freed.
The Rays will then bunt and then get the ball in play and score that run.
So 90 feet, every one of those 90 feet mean a lot.
You cannot screw around against them.
If you know, I've been saying this line for a long time about Grisham.
What would make Trent Grisham play hard?
Like, apparently, it's not a playoff game.
It's not a playoff game against your biggest rival, the Boston Red Sox.
So but he the the the Rays are going to probably throw all right.
The Rays are going to throw righty starters, right?
Grisham's going to play center.
I would assume Jones is OK, right?
So that's where we got to get into this, right?
Like because there's roster decisions still to be made here, Joel,
about the big one, Aaron Judge, right?
Before we get into that, how the Grisham of it all plays into this.
I feel like the judge decision could affect that maybe.
So there's no doubt I'll say this is
I still it's a I get it.
We're still under three weeks.
It's a calf.
I understand how badly the player wants to play and maybe they'll shock us.
Maybe he'll be on the roster because they're like,
we don't think he's good for one, two, right?
But there's an off day between one and two.
There's an off day between two and three.
And we think he's ready for three. Right.
And so we're going to put him on the roster
because we think maybe he could take it back in one and two.
And he's a full player, not on the turf in three.
Is that a possibility?
Of course. Like until it comes out, it's not.
What what I will point out is interesting is Grisham has
the only Yankee who has good numbers against Rasmussen.
He's literally the only I mean, the Yankees.
Rasmussen has like I think it's the sixth best ERA
since the Livewell era, since 1920 against the Yankees for anyone with 50 innings.
Now, he had one bad start against him this year where they beat him up.
I'll say this is they beat him up for six runs in two and a third innings.
In the other 10 games he's pitched against them, he's given up six runs.
So like they don't hit him.
Well, Grisham does.
Grisham also hits Nick Martinez.
Well, is Martinez the game to starter is Peralta?
Is it a scramble?
So like like on a team that doesn't hit the race starters
great historically, especially Rasmussen.
So like if judge plays, even if plays right field, is that the game?
Spencer Jones sits just because Grisham is a guy who has some history.
Or are you sticking with Spencer Jones?
Just because really we're at like two months now where the bats have been really
like I always point out, like when you strike out well,
I think that's like if you're striking out on the three to bastard slider,
I'm like, that's a good at bat.
Yeah, like you drag the bat.
And I'm like, Spencer Jones drags it back.
It's like like and he's gotten the ball and play plenty and he's gotten big hits
and he's been good lefty on lefty.
So is it that sample size or it's that Grisham hits the guy?
I still will say I I kind of think the Yankees
are probably like, Aaron, it's up to us to figure out
how to win without you for one more round.
But we'll see. We'll see.
You know, this player is dying to play.
And, you know, you admire somebody who's kind of dying
to get in there for all the right reasons.
I think it's a it's a tough road and maybe one
we don't hear about until tomorrow morning anyway.
Yeah, it would not shock me if he's on that roster.
But like you said, if they slow play him and use him in game three,
or maybe could you see him in a pinch hitting responsibility
or stand still their right handed pinch hitter that they want to go to?
But does Stanton make this roster?
That's what I was asking, because here's like a judge makes it would stay.
I come off.
Well, let's let's say judge doesn't make it, but they go to 12 pitchers.
OK, who's the two position players they're taking?
I think it would be Rosario and Stanton.
I would think in Rosario and potentially Ramos.
OK, but if judge isn't on the roster, who's who's you know,
like if you want a right hand hitter off the air with your extra outfielder?
Outfielder. Yeah.
I mean, Ryan, I think it's the one in play,
but at least the other guy in Ramos can go play the outfield.
We know it's not going to be great, but he can do it.
Stanton is literally you're limiting him right when it back. Right.
You're losing a lot of flexibility, which becomes more important
when you go from 16 position players down to 14 position players.
You need you can't just say it's in it bad.
I mean, maybe, but like he can't get in the field.
And so I think that becomes a tougher road.
And yeah, I think, you know, like I think they have tough,
interesting decisions with some which, by the way,
shows they do have some depth to a roster. Right.
Making making these decisions.
And I do think one of the things they have to do think about is flexibility
and defense.
It's why I think Rosario will be a cost here
because, A, the defense isn't good and B, there's so much righty pitching
on Tampa Bay, especially their starters,
that would you like to have Rosario sitting on the bench
if they bring in Ian Seymour or Garrett Clevenger who are lefties?
Yes, but you can do Aaron Boone has done the under the hood stuff
all year on Rosario's good under the hood against lefties.
The reality is he hasn't hit lefties like he had previously in his career.
And I think I think he's a casualty of them going down.
And by the way, not like I get it.
You know, it's kind of like an easy fan thing.
But like Rosario is important to the group
and he's traveled the whole season with them.
And I'm sure he'll continue to be a positive force on the bench.
Right. Like, like, that's not that's a tougher decision than than
the cold hearted thing.
So. Right. And I mean, look, Rosario had the big walk in game one.
I mean, after the challenge of the ABS.
So you can see he could still get that for you.
But I agree with you.
The Rosario part of that equation doesn't make sense for this roster
going into the series.
This question is that this round, sorry, the second player, though,
right, if it's Stan, I guess it's just it's the judge.
Part of this all really fascinates me.
Like, is he going to force himself onto this roster and say,
I need to be on here? I'm ready to rock and roll.
If you need me in a pinch hitting situation or if I could be a D.H.
Potentially, I don't think they would do that because you don't want to mess
with Ben Rice.
And you also want Luis Garcia's bat in at first base against all these righties.
It's a really fascinating decision.
I wonder also, like, can I throw one other thing in, Ryan?
And I, I, I think I have a thought on it.
But if you had to have an at bat, a right handed at bat
against the lefty Ray, would you rather it be Ramos or Stanton?
I mean, Stanton hasn't played a game since April 24th,
and I understand like it's John Carlson, but like Ramos has actually killed
lefty pitching this year.
And once he kind of cleared some early stuff with the Yankees,
he started killing lefty pitching overmatch, though, in their wildcard game.
That's what my concern was.
You know, emotionally, Stanton will never be overmatched.
Like Stanton, you know, like I said, there were
there were so many scouts at the first.
It was nice to see so many old baseball guys at the Yankee and Red Sox series.
And I said to a to one of them, he said, what do you think about Stanton?
And I said, you know, the one thing I actually believe about Stanton is
he can miss the first two pitches he sees by two feet
and you still might be in trouble because like he's not going to be afraid.
And if the ball hits his bat, it goes for 50.
And I'm like, not being afraid to me is a big deal.
Like you just see it with like Schlittler.
Like, like, not only is he not afraid, he's like, wow, great.
It's all on me.
And to play in our city and to play at this time of year,
you need players who are like, this is great.
I always thought it was like I said, obviously, Derek Jeter had top
of the the the the rankings like skill.
But like Derek Jeter was like, I'm not scared about
we played all year to play now.
I want to play now.
I want the at-bat to come to me.
And I thought it made him a like I thought it made a great player
greater at that time of year because he was like, cool.
Like the big at-bats coming to me instead of like, oh, I hope I hope this,
you know, so no.
And I feel that way about Stanton, like Stanton could strike out
and miss the ball by three feet.
That's just because he's overmatched against the pitching and rusty.
But I don't think he'd be scared.
I think he'd be enthused to take the at-bat is would Ramos.
I'm not sure about that.
It wasn't a great showing at the first one.
Yeah, but Ramos has been playing right.
Like, I think it's a tough.
I'll say if I was sitting in a room, that would be a tough decision for me.
And the the the tiebreaker might be the Ramos does not play defense.
Well, that's he does give you the defensive, you know, like
if I need to maneuver around, I want to pinch run here, do this here.
He does give you the potential to have someone go stand in right field.
I hear you, Joel.
But I also think like that defensive argument could also be his downfall,
like of him not making the roster,
because Caballero can go out there and play outfield.
And you don't you don't want to take any chances here against the Rays.
Like you said, 90 feet is precious to them.
They're going to take advantage of that.
The one thing I understand, I want to ask you, I was a little shocked
that Goldschmidt got the pinch hit the other night on game two.
Why didn't you stand at least off the bench to at least let him
see some kind of pitches in a game situation?
Because I think in that situation, he was saying, I do
like trying to score these runs has great value.
And I forgive me.
I think there's a runner on third and less than two outs when Goldschmidt.
Yes, that is correct about that.
That's correct.
And he's feeling like like Goldschmidt's going to get a ball into play and score.
Like runs were precious at that point still.
Right. But you hadn't gotten Bellinger's homer yet.
Am I correct about that or no?
No, I think this is after Bellinger's home run.
I'm going to double check for you right now.
OK, so so so maybe I would feel a little different about it,
but I think he's probably still thinking runs are precious.
It's the postseason.
If I could add on, let's add on.
So it's probably how he felt about it.
And and the one thing I will say about the whole Spencer Jones
versus versus Trent Grisham in center field, right?
Like if if if judge doesn't make the roster, I
I don't think Trent Grisham makes that play that Spencer Jones does.
In fact, I know he doesn't.
After striking out versus crochet out, running
Richmond's throw to first and Contreras not playing the ball correctly
and then basically creating this
cascading effect of small ball a little bit, running, stealing second,
getting the overthrow, advancing a third.
And then next thing you know, the young kid Lombard, who doesn't look
overmatched right now, slaps the ball into right field.
And now all of a sudden you're cooking.
I just I don't want to take Spencer Jones out of this lineup at all, Joel,
because I understand defensively you are a little concerned with him
and how he misplays balls out there, but he provides so much for them
in terms of competitive at bats and and just being an athlete
on the base path that just Trent Grisham does not do whatsoever.
Yeah, I think a big deal against the Rays
is you need smart, alert players who are playing hard.
If you because here's the thing is, one of the things you have to do
against the Rays is match match aggression with aggression.
Like the Yankees have more power than the Rays, right?
But the Yankees won the Red Sox series, won the wildcard series
because they out homered the Red Sox, but they also out hit the Red Sox.
A really good pitching staff like Tampa Bay, like like two strikes,
getting balls in play.
The Yankees work lefty on lefty.
The Yankees ability to match, you know, the Yankees.
We you got to watch the Rays.
They'll steal third base also.
I think Taylor Walls hasn't been thrown out stealing third base.
I think Chandler Simpson is seven for ten.
Do you know who's stolen third base the most in the major leagues this year?
The Yankees.
And they're like 34 for 37 or 35 for 38.
So and they sold, I think, like 15 bases against the Rays this year.
So like you got to make them play also.
And that's like Jones and Lombard play into that.
They're there.
They've got some springiness to them on both sides of the ball.
And I just think like the Grisham and Chisholm are free agents
at the end of the season.
The Yankees also just have to think moving forward about the type of player.
Like I don't want to get to 2027 yet, especially since we have no idea
when the first game is.
But just when you think about the type of players you want,
like you've got to like have guys who technically care about playing
well and playing hard, you know, smart and hard, have great value.
You get eliminated.
You know, the Yankees lost against the Dodgers for a lot of reasons.
No doubt. Like they might.
If the if the Yankees play clean in the 2024 World Series,
might they still lose the World Series?
Yeah. But they might have won it.
Yeah. Like the Dodgers were running out of pitching.
If you just play the game, you know, they really should have won game
one if they played clean.
If they really should have won game five, if they played clean
and the Dodgers were running out of pitching.
If you just played clean, you would have given yourself a shot.
Yeah. Against the Rays.
Like part of it is I talk to multiple people for my scouting report.
And I can't tell you how many repeated this line in some form, Ryan,
when they give you an out taken out.
In other words, if there's a bunt and there's a runner on second,
get the out at first base, right?
Limit them like limit them.
First of all, you're not sure that runs going to score,
but don't turn it into first and third.
Right. Don't like like get it out.
If they go one run at a time, let them get a run.
Don't that they
one of the people I talked to said they are not a team.
I'll get this close to verbatim.
They are not a team.
If you think of it like a heavyweight boxing match,
they're not a team that leans against the ropes.
They stand in the middle of the ring and they jab and they jab and they jab.
And eventually you lower your hands and then they knock you out.
Right. That's when Caminero hits the three run homer
because you've allowed stuff to happen.
Yeah. And they're like, let them jab.
See if you could get the outs that you can.
They're going to squeeze with a runner on third.
Get up and make it tough on them.
You know, like I'll tell you something else.
The Yankees are really good at that could go under the radar,
like the stealing of third base.
The Yankees hold runners as well as anybody in the sport.
There's they were like the fifth U.S.
stolen bases in the majors this year.
They're, you know, obviously freed as great at it.
But like a guy like Cole changes his timing all the time.
Like they do make it tough to run and you've got to make it tough.
The the Rays led the American League in stolen bases second in the major leagues.
Like that's their game.
Bunting, stealing extra bases, playing on the springy turf, et cetera.
They had the tie with Milwaukee for the best home record in the sport.
It's no surprise they play to their stadium.
It's it's something definitely to pay attention to.
It's going to be playing out all series long, especially like you said,
in Tampa Bay, Joel, they go with Garrett Cole, the Yankees for game one.
Are you shocked at all?
They did not go with Rodan considering the Rays versus right handed pitching.
They had the fourth best OPS in all baseball versus left handed pitching.
They have the twenty fifth best OPS.
And I am just fresh off of seeing Carlos Rodan pitch eight
shutout innings against the Rays not only two weeks ago,
but he has looked dominant down the stretch, unlike Derek Cole,
who has gone through it, I would say in the last couple of months
where he's had some nice performances more down than than what he is
used to being, I would say.
Are you shocked that they went with Cole, though, in game one over Carlos Rodan?
And it seems like he's being lined up, Carlos Rodan,
to just be a bullpen piece for them right now.
You know, am I shocked?
I'm not. I think I think the manager probably looked at this and said,
I've got Garrett Cole.
I believe in Garrett Cole.
Having said that, I wonder if we had the Rays on truth serum,
if they're a lot happier to see Cole than to see Rodan,
because I certainly have talked to Rays people since that September
22nd opener, which was the best I've ever seen Rodan pitch.
His fastball was not only alive, but I've never seen the precision
with which he's which with with which he threw that day.
Like he he as impressive as anything else was, he walked none.
And not only walked none, he was efficient.
Like there wasn't a ton of three ball counts.
He was on attack and hard to hit.
And I do think he becomes a factor in this series
because of that.
I do think he gets in.
You know, Ryan, it's like one of those tough ones again.
Let's pretend that between the two of us, we're manager and pitching coach.
It would be tough to not pitch Garrett Cole, right?
Like it is Garrett Cole.
He's one of the great pitchers of the generation,
and he's still an outstanding pitcher.
And, you know, he's pitched a ton of playoff games,
and he generally leaves a playoff game
having given his team a chance to win or better.
And I just think like in theory, it's easy to go, hey, Rodon's pitching.
Well, he's left handed.
Let's not pitch Garrett Cole for the first two rounds of the postseason
and see how it goes.
I think in reality, that's probably a little tougher to do.
I also still think it's not impossible
if Cole is problematic in this game.
One, that Rodon, if they get that far, starts game four. Right.
Like you could always make that, because here's the thing,
you get Cole, Schlittler in two and five, Fried in three. Right.
And because of the baked in off days.
Yeah. Four again becomes a Rodon-Cole decision.
And if Cole is home or susceptible again or doesn't pitch well,
you can go Rodon in four. Right.
And I think that now, now I don't think they'll save Rodon for that
if they are like, like tomorrow night, if game one is like
two to two in the fifth and Cole is throwing 95 pitches.
Rodon could be in that game. Right.
Like to try to bridge a few innings
because he could then do it again in game four.
If you start Cole again. Right.
I think I think the Yankee starting pitching.
So, Ryan, I made a big deal, I think, with us,
both in print and when you and I did this together, that I thought
the most important, the most important thing in the Red Sox series
was Yankee starting pitching and not only the guys who started,
but may come in relief and do their lefties hit lefties.
I do. I really emphasized it on our last show.
And those two things actually turned out to be really huge. Right.
Their two starters were great.
And I know Warren gave up a homer, but like his stuff was alive that night.
And he showed, you know what, he can maybe be a factor.
I'm lefty on lefty is not as big a deal in this series
because the Rays are going to start all righties and the two main lefties.
You would expect like Ian Seymour, who's a starter going into the pen
and Clevenger haven't done well against lefties.
Cam Boozer has, but he's kind of a journeyman.
It's not going to like get him to pull a lefty
necessarily, though, though it might try to get a righty lefty off Boozer.
So I don't think that's as important.
But the starting pitching is more important than ever for them in this series.
And again, I think Ryan Weathers is going to be on this roster.
So now you're expanding it to six.
Right. Six starters.
Yeah. Five guys and Warren.
So I think Warren and Weathers become important bullpen guys.
Rodan might become an important bullpen guy in this as well.
And they that is the strength of their team.
And and when you look like there was a winner take all game yesterday,
the Braves started an opener and they got great results from Ray Kerr.
Yeah, but like it was Ray Kerr to save your season.
And the Phillies are going with Aaron Nola on short rest
and then Zach Wheeler on short out of the bullpen because they've run out
of starting pitching and that the fact that the Yankees have not only not run out
of starting pitching, but are going to shove two really good ones
or maybe three really good ones into their bullpen at this time of year
should not.
I mean, the value of it is incredible that they have not run out.
You look around at other teams in the postseason.
The White Sox advance.
They were in a scramble for starting pitching.
Houston did not advance.
They had no starting pitching that the Yankees have.
So much of it is is their continued advantage at this time of year.
And it feels like it's the strength they're going to continue to lean on,
like you're saying, and execute these guys and put them in positions
to to help them win and limit the run.
And, you know, like we're I'm sorry, Ryan, cut you off here.
But like we're also in a period where I don't know if they could regenerate,
but they haven't had to use Hedrick a lot.
They haven't had to use Blackburn a lot.
They haven't had to use Bednar a lot.
You'd also think that their three main relievers are fresh for this series.
And it's game off the game off day.
So like you could use all the
a manager said something so interesting to me recently about the postseason.
He said, you know, the Yankees might get in position
where everyone that Boone turns to he wants in the game.
He said, I'm telling you, watch the playoffs.
That doesn't happen all the time.
There's a lot of times you're putting someone in the game
because you have no other.
You've been backed into a corner in your most important games of the season
and you're putting out a guy out there and you're covering your eyes
and hoping for the best.
Like the Yankees might fail with their pitching,
like some of these guys might fail, but like at the moment
they're brought in the game, that's who you're going to want in the game.
The Yankees are not going to have the, oh, oh, my God.
Are we bringing in this guy moment?
They're going to bring in good pitchers who the manager and pitching
coach and team believe.
Right. And they have full trust in, too, right?
Joel, there is this talk about this Yankees vibe
after sweeping the Red Sox amongst the fan base.
And I've talked to a lot of Yankees fans and my friends.
They keep bringing up 2017 just because this feels like.
And this and hear me out here.
The way they played in those two games felt very different
from how they went about their regular season in terms of small ball,
working pitches.
And when they got the timely bomb that hit the need for a home run,
they got both of those after the Red Sox went to their bullpen in both situations.
I'm not saying it's going to happen because this is going to be a very tough
series, and I truly believe whoever wins this series
is going to the World Series for the American League.
Can this team have that 2017 like run because of the young talent
of Jones and Lombard?
And you've seen what Volpe gave you the night
and you see what Austin Wells did for you against the Red Sox.
The young talent, Joel, is starting to really emerge here for this Yankee squad,
including Ben Rice and Cam Schiller.
How can anyone not talk about that?
But it feels the vibes feel different here about this team right now.
Yeah. A few things.
Be careful about putting a team in the World Series
because I know how overwhelmingly the favorite will be
who comes out of this series.
But I remember covering the 20 the 2003 ALCS
and feeling that was the World Series between the Yankees and the Red Sox.
And then the Yankees lost to the Marlins, right?
You know, you there's no sure things in life.
The Yankees should be heavy favorites if they move through this to beat
Cleveland or Chicago, you know, like like that kind of thing.
But strange stuff happens.
But they should be the over.
Whoever comes out of this Yankees or Rays is going to be the overwhelming
favorite to play the National League champion.
So I agree with that.
I see your 2017 point.
And I know that I've gone to this a few times.
Are they the Knicks?
Let me make my point.
Hmm. You got to win 13 games to win the World Series.
The Knicks went on a 13 game winning streak in the postseason.
I think we spent the entire Knick regular season saying,
aren't they the best team in the conference?
Why aren't they playing better?
And then they hit a moment in the postseason where it all came together.
And you said, oh, that's what it looks like
if we play well, all of our guys.
They started to win in blowouts.
What were the two games against the Red Sox?
And I'm going to give you one more that you haven't thought of at all.
In round two against the Sixers.
Even on the road, it was the Knicks crowd.
Who do you think is going to be filling in the seats in Tampa?
It's going to be like 70, 30 Yankees, maybe more.
So there's going to be some of that, which is the crowd
is not going to be a hostile road crowd.
They might turn the building around if they could get some leads.
So are they the Knicks?
They feel a little more to me like the Knicks than the 2017 team,
because in some ways, the 2017 team
didn't have like aircraft carriers that we knew about.
You know, like Judge became one.
Judge became one, right?
But it was Judge and Sanchez, the young players, right?
Yes. They're getting like.
So can I throw one out there that I think is worthwhile also,
as I think about it?
So I'm watching the Phillies lose last night,
and I could literally I'm going to go through this, right?
If you give me a second.
Coming off the field last night, real Muto, 36 in March.
Harper, 34 in two weeks.
Trey Turner, 34 in June.
Schwarber, 34 next March.
Knoller, 34 in June.
Wheeler, 37 in May.
That's the face.
Those six guys are the face of the last five years.
They've gotten eliminated in the playoffs.
That's it. By the way, they're all signed for a long time.
Like some of them are terrible contracts.
Some of them are fine. Right.
At the end of this, at the end of this year,
Boehm, Sosa and Arise are free agents.
Right. Like all going to have to be replaced.
Boehm was the hope was him and Stott
would be part of like a next thing.
It wasn't like him, Stott, Marsh.
Stott, Marsh, Duran and Wheeler are free agents after next season.
They already have committed for next year.
236 million dollars.
We don't know if a salary cap is coming up.
Why am I bringing this up?
Because the face of the Yankees during the Aaron Boone era
are Aaron Judge, Garrett Cole and Giancarlo Stanton.
None of those guys took a swing or threw a pitch in a in a playoff series.
By the way, right.
Stanton hasn't played since April 24th.
Judges played seven or eight games since the end of May.
Cole didn't play for the first two months of this season.
The Yankee baton pass to Schlittler and Rice has helped them.
Like if you and I were sitting here in, say, March 2025,
we'd be like, man, the Yankees better win and win quick
because Cole and Judge are getting old and so is Stanton.
And that's the face of this.
And the fact that those two guys have become superstars
and you might be getting something out of Lombard and Jones as well.
Moving forward.
I just read you what the yeah, the Phillies have been very much like the Yankees.
This has been an era where it's been frustrating in the playoffs.
They can't get over the top.
They got to one World Series and didn't win it.
And you feel the age and the expense and how do they do it?
And by the way, their young players, Painter, Crawford, Kirkering,
they all failed.
They all failed.
There's no Schlittler there.
There is no Rice there.
There's not even a Jones or.
And so, again, I don't want to start playing 2027.
The Yankees have to win a World Series this year.
But you began to see the navigation device. Yes.
Of especially if there's a salary cap coming
or something even more punitive with money, like how do you do it?
Well, you better have some young guys who are stars.
The Yankees now have young guys, the two best players on their team
in that first round.
It's only two games where Ben Rice and Schlittler.
Those were the two best players.
Jones and Lombard were really good.
You you and by the way, like what do you want out of Yankee players?
You want guys who can handle New York check.
You want guys who could beat the Red Sox check.
You want guys who aren't intimidated by this time of year check.
It's a like nobody wants to play the 2027 season moving forward.
But I was as I'm watching the end of that game last night
and I'm thinking, what is the Phillies near future look like?
I'm like, oh, by the way, I like the Mets near future better also
because Benjamin McLean, for example, did what Crawford and Painter didn't write,
which is Excel and give them some young guys or whatever.
But then I thought about the Yankees and said, wow, that the Yankee,
if I would have told you 12 months ago, the Yankees will advance
in a playoff series in which Judge Stanton and Cole don't play.
You would have went, come on.
And decidedly to decidedly win those decidedly.
And the two guys who are the two most obvious
baton passes on offense and in the mound were the stars of the series.
It just it just really hit me watching the Phillies last night.
And it's a right thought.
And it's what I had talked about after the game on on Wednesday.
I'm like, this is this is incredible what they're getting from these young guys.
And it's something that feels like an extension.
You know, they've been again.
I think it gets poo poo too much.
And you know what I said last year?
Got to get the chip this year.
You got to get the chip.
Like at some point you got to get the chip.
But being really, really special for 35 years, zero non-contending years.
You're like, when will this end?
Well, this makes you see that maybe it isn't going to end anytime soon.
They'll be playing lots.
And I know because I have plenty of friends who are Yankee fans, including you.
It's like they better win while Judge and Cole are here,
because what's it look like after they're gone?
Well, it kind of looks like Schlittler and Rice.
That's what it looks like.
And that looks OK as building block.
Joel, about the Rays pitching and a race hitting, I should say.
This is something I feel like, you know, I am interested to hear your thoughts.
They don't strike out much.
And they they are high contact team.
And they're going to work a lot of counts.
And they're going to try to get these Yankees Yankees bullpen
as quickly as possible.
How do the Yankees navigate this?
How do they as a pitching staff and in a unit instead of like you're saying,
like they're going to pack, you're going to pack you?
I think the Yankees are also going to try to.
Hey, we're going to throw gas right back right by you.
Cam Schlittler won 117 pitches the other day.
And you could see that boom was not willing to go to Hedrick in that moment.
He really, really wanted Cam to get that that next out after Contreras.
Could you see similar things happening with this Yankee staff
going into this round where I'm going to lean even further and further
on this starting rotation to go and push them to limits
they've never gone to before?
Yeah, you know, if you dig into the numbers a little,
the Rays don't strike out a lot.
Two of the pitchers who have struck them out a lot over the last two years
are Schlittler and Rodan.
So that that's one thing.
Number two, I just go back to.
You've got to limit them to 27 outs, because even if you strike out
10, 17 are in play.
Yeah, you got to get 17 more outs.
And, you know, on that turf, the ball is going to come quick with that roof.
Now, now the games are night.
The 630 start is a little tricky, but at night it's a lot easier
to see the ball against the roof.
The catwalks make things crazy sometimes.
It's it's the Rays have a distinct on the field.
It might not be in the crowd, but on the field, a distinct home field advantage.
And the Yankees have to counter that with.
Three to five clean games.
I mean, clean like you just can't it.
Having said that, I just go back to.
The Yankees have six starting pitchers healthy.
They're all really good.
I think that Weathers and Warren stuff play up even more in short bursts
to help them, and they are going to
like at least see.
I do think there'll be a moment maybe in game one
they're going to see on Hedrick.
See, like, has he regenerated a little?
And if not, I think it's now Weathers job if he's on the roster.
But like Hedrick was so good all year.
Yeah, that I think the one thing about a five game series,
it's a short series, but you can make a mistake and survive in game one or two.
Like if you give one away, you don't want to give one away.
It's a short season.
But like if head, that's why I'm saying Cole and Hedrick,
I think are going to be part of game one to decide if they're part of something else.
Makes sense, Joel. It's a good point.
Yeah, because you don't want to give it away.
Right. Like, like, especially if you could,
the Yankees cannot win the series without winning at least one on the road.
So like like if you have control of one on the road,
the last thing you want to do is let it get away.
But having said that.
Cole is going to start game one.
I my gut says Hedrick will be in the game and they'll see.
Can we trust them?
Or is he now?
This is Weathers job.
Man, I'm fired up.
Joel, a couple of quick hitters here for you.
Real quick for the Yankees fans at the end here.
Does Aaron Judge make the ALDS roster your opinion?
Yeah, you know, it's just guesswork, and I hate to do that.
I know. I know.
Like this is memorialized and like whatever you say last forever.
I just if if the normal timeline
for a calf injury that is not the the most mild
is not under a month like it's just not.
And now can a PPP shot and round the clock care
and the doggedness of the athlete change the clock?
Maybe. And I think the scenario I offered,
which is he's a bench bat for one and two and a full player for three.
Is that possible?
Maybe. But it's hard to play shorthanded.
And I just feel like, look,
everything is on the line right now.
But you don't want to start messing with next year.
You just don't.
He's such an that they've won without him, that they got to the playoffs,
that they won 93 games with with mainly without him,
that they won a round the playoffs without him.
You know, feather in the cap, kudos from the top of the organization
down that they built a more bulletproof team.
But I wouldn't want to start 2027 without him.
And at some point, you got to protect Aaron Judge from Aaron Judge.
Aaron Judge will go on the field if he was in an aircast, right?
Like he's he knows what's on the line.
He wants to be part of this.
And I nothing but respect for it.
So sometimes you have to.
You have to protect the player from the player.
And I just feel like medically, it's going to be hard to clear him.
It's just going to be hard to clear him.
And if he doesn't get medical clearance, it doesn't matter how much he protests.
The Yankees will not, you know, ultimately the Yankees write out
who's on the roster and they send it into the league.
That would be my hunch that like, let's try to get you ready for an ALCS
or even a World Series.
Yeah, get there and try to give him the Kyle Schwarber thing, right?
Like Schwarber got hurt in game four or five in 16.
Yeah. And then the incredible comeback to be able to play
in the World Series and help in the World Series, which is,
you know, like you could still be part of this.
It's our job to win without you.
And the Yankees, as we saw in the in the in the in the
Dia in the wildcard round.
And it's easy to forget this because they scored against the Red Sox.
The Red Sox are great at run prevention.
And the Yankees beat it up.
Now, I think their manager and their front office made decisions
I cannot believe.
And I'm telling you, if you were sitting next to me, like, unfortunately,
like, say, Dan Martin always is or Mike Vaccaro the other day or Johnny Eamon.
I am like when I saw Eric Miller running in again in game two, I was just like,
no matter what happens here, this is the wrong move.
Like your seasons on the the point I kept making to everyone is
the strength of your team is the starting pitching.
Like we saw Boone stick with Schliff, right?
We saw Boone push three through six.
He knew what the strength was.
Toley and Gray had dominated the Yankees this year
and even getting hit a little bit, they weren't giving up runs.
So so to me, I would have stuck with both.
But if I'm taking them out, Garrett Whitlock is coming in the game.
Like, I don't care if it's lefty righty.
Eric Miller had been playing for the Giants.
He's never pitched an important game.
He's never Yankee Stadium and in it with all the marbles.
And by the way, he's been one of the worst pitchers in baseball
for the last five weeks.
How are you putting that's a three o'clock in the afternoon decision?
Sounds freaking good.
Like your seasons on the line, you're bringing Eric Miller in again.
Like, what are you doing?
It felt very much like the Yankees previous postseason things
that they had done.
You know what I mean?
Like it felt like that.
And it to me, the fact that people watch the postseason every year
and still make this mistake, which is like this isn't July 9th.
This is everything you've got to
as much as you could limit the game to your five to seven best pitchers,
especially when it's a game situation.
You must do that.
And I'll always say the cardinal rule of managing is
do what the opposing dugout hopes you don't.
Like, trust me, when the Yankees saw Eric Miller
running in in game one, in game two, they were like, great.
No more Peyton Tolley.
No more Sonny Gray.
And by the way, that is not a Roaldus Chapman running in.
It is not Garrett Whitlock running in.
It is a guy lefty on lefty.
This guy. Fine. Fine.
You know, in part, like you're going lefty on lefty on Bellinger
also like the second best OPS in all baseball.
Let's yeah, let's go after that guy.
We'll intentionally walk right.
I don't want to go up against him. Let's go to Bellinger.
And so to me, it's it's like you must.
I would manage 162 games trying very hard
to never do what the opposing team wants me to do.
Certainly in these games, do not.
The Yankees were so thrilled.
I didn't even ask a Yankee person. I say it confidently.
They're thrilled to see that guy running into the game.
Joel, it's going to be a heck of a series.
You know, believe it or not, this is the first time
the Yankees are going to be playing in Tampa Bay for a playoff series
because the last time and the only time they played against the playoffs
was out in San Diego during the covid year.
This is the first time the Yankees were playing a playoff game in the trop.
So it's going to be fun, man.
I like you said, I look, these have been the
these two teams since the middle of April
have been wanting to in the American League in some way.
Best records.
I mean, this is the right two teams.
This should probably be the ALCS like they should have receded now.
And right now they the the Rays should be playing the White Sox
and the Yankees should be playing Cleveland and the winners will play
in the ALCS and the Yankees and the Rays in the ALCS would have been right.
But I'm glad that there is a Yankee race series
because they've been the two best teams in the league all year.
And I think it's a fascinating series.
I think that there are things that the Yankees do extremely well.
There's things that the Rays do extremely well.
And the Yankee team that played these two games against Boston,
if that team shows up, that's the best team in the American League
that they were on paper in February and March.
They were for two days to close September.
We are now flip the calendar to October.
Does the Yankee team that played those two games in the way
that that Nick team, once they got to game four,
became the Nick team we wondered all year, where is that team?
Aren't they the best team in the conference?
The Yankees are on paper the best team in the American League.
They are as close to healthy now.
Again, judges a big deal, stands a big.
But because the six starters are healthy,
this is what you would dream of if you were the Yankees.
That's the strength of the team.
If that team shows up, that's going to battle with two strikes,
is going to hit left on left and right on right.
Well, that's the best team in the American League
and is going to be very hard to beat as long as they play clean
like they did in game one and don't give it away a little bit
like they did in game two.
Grisham can't be the look at me.
I'm going to it can't happen.
Jazz can't be out of position.
Spencer Jones can't be bobbling the ball like it's got to be clean.
It's got to be clean.
Twenty seven.
If if the Yankees limit the raise to twenty seven hours,
they'll be very tough to beat in the city.
Joel Sherman, we appreciate all your time, all your effort.
I'm looking forward to your coverage down in Tampa.
Safe travels down there.
And then we'll catch up with you next week, man.
And the Yankees will be coming back to the Bronx for game three on Tuesday night.
Right. But yeah, no, no, no.
Monday's game two.
So Wednesday's game game three.
So Wednesday night in the Bronx.
Looking forward to your coverage throughout, man.
And we'll catch up with you next time.
All right. All the best.
