People very committed to MAGA beginning to question what's happening: Podcaster

US News: Connecting World
2 followers
1 Video View·Oct 2, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedPolitical analysts discuss the Republican Party's growing anxiety ahead of the midterms. The conversation focuses on Donald Trump's strategy of campaigning in traditionally \"red\" states, the lack of a consistent GOP message regarding the economy, and the potential for Democratic gains in conservative bastions.
With that, let's enter our group chat. Chris Jansing, MSNOW chief political reporter.
Mary Harris, host of Slate's podcast, What Next? And Moshe Wanunu, editor-in-chief of MoNews
and host of the MoNews Daily podcast. And Michael Schnell, MSNOW congressional reporter.
Chris, Republicans are admitting, even in public, they're saying the quiet part out loud that
they're pretty nervous about this. And then we see the president barnstorming in states like
my home state of Oklahoma. What gives here? Read the tea leaves for us.
You don't have to have murky tea leaves. These are flashing red warnings.
It's clear tea.
I mean, when you look at numbers like 17% on the cost of living and 28% on the economy,
if you look at the idea that we've all believed for a very long time and polls have shown us
that the MAGA base that never leaves Trump is right around 30% or in the low 30s,
these numbers are an indication that even the MAGA base have said,
you don't understand my lived experience right now, and it's not good.
And there's the other thing. What was it? Just a couple of weeks ago,
Trump said he was going to go to the 35 most competitive places.
Well, what's he doing in your home state? What's he doing going to my home state of Ohio?
And what in, as my dad would say, the Sam hell is he doing going to Texas
when a year ago, nobody would have believed that anything would have happened,
but that John Cornyn had a safe seat. So now you have Donald Trump basically
ripping Ken Paxton every chance he gets, including at that midterm convention that
Paxton has acknowledged in private has hurt him. And he's the guy who wanted Ken Paxton.
So you're seeing this over and over and over again. Trump says it's a PR problem.
This is not a PR problem. Karl Rove said the quiet part out loud, which is
that they don't have a message, a consistent message that if the message is let's tear down
the Kennedy Center, you have lost. And I will go back to the year 2000 and I was covering George
Bush, Al Gore, and Karl Rove was sitting up in the stands at a Bush rally. And I went up to him
and I said, one question, if you guys win, what is going to have been the difference?
Nobody knew about hanging chads back then. What is going to have been the difference?
And he said, we have consistent messaging, something that the Democrats have never learned.
And in this election, in this midterms, it's reversed.
All right. To quote my dear friend, Chris Jansing, what in the Sam hell,
Michael is going on with Republicans voicing concerns. But then you have President Trump
in red states. Is this an attempt, you know, Chris was alluding to the fact that even MAGA
is starting to experience what most Americans are feeling right now in their wallets and
kind of peeling a little bit apart from the president. So is this an effort to bring those
voters out to make sure that there's voter turnout or is this a genuine worry that Trump
shouldn't be anywhere near a swing state? Well, Ariel, I could tell you that there
are a lot of Republican lawmakers who are questioning this strategy. It's not just that
they're putting political capital and the physical capital of going to these states,
but they're also putting in financial resources. Right. We've seen millions of dollars go into
Texas. We saw J.D. Vance go to Kansas. President Trump just in Oklahoma. He's now going to Texas.
He's going to be going to Nebraska on Monday. So it's certainly raising a lot of eyebrows
in Republican circles of why the president is focusing on these red states. But if you
start to look at the crosstabs and some of the numbers, maybe we're getting an idea because
Democrats are making inroads in some of these typically conservative bastions. I'm talking
about places like Kansas, places like Nebraska, even Alaska. We are seeing very tight races and
we're seeing Democrats sort of eat into the Republican lead that they've had there for years.
So perhaps Republicans are getting a little nervous. But on the other hand,
these battleground states are still very much so toss ups and up for grabs. So a lot of folks
are wondering just why the president is doing this, though. I will say I've spoken to a number
of his allies, former aide. They say that they believe that he's right now front loading the
red states. They go to the battleground states down the road. It would be more of a story if
he was going to places like Texas, Oklahoma and Nebraska later in the cycle, closer to Election
Day rather than now. We're going to have to see if that transpires and if the president actually
ends up in those swing states. But absolutely. Right now, it's raising some eyebrows in Republican
circles. So, Mo, you know, we talked at the very top of the show about the dismal jobs report that
came out. Unemployment taking up twenty nine thousand jobs added when the estimation was
ninety thousand. What message can Republicans hang their hat on right now? What have the
accomplishments been? You know, Trump, as Chris said, is saying there's a PR problem. What can
what can they tout? Well, he he has a challenge because he was hired by the American people
for one thing, bring prices down. He also, by the way, threw in there no stupid wars.
Right. And so there's a lot of people, including in his base, who say, wait, wait a second,
prices are not down. And we got this whole Iran thing happening. And by the way, that Iran thing
is also leading prices to grow. So a basic premise of politics is like you're hired for one thing.
You don't do that thing. You got one job. You have not accomplished that job. Now,
interestingly, when you think about like his strategy and going to these places,
there is the fight for the middle, the independence, the people who sort of swing.
And then there's the base. And you have two different messages because you there are some
interesting numbers from Politico this week that still show a majority of MAGA affiliated voters
believe things are good. But how do you show empathy for those experiencing the bad economy?
Well, things are bad. You can't say that to MAGA. You got to talk about how things are great.
So when you talk about a coherent message here, Ariel, it's very difficult for him.
Plus, he's not one to acknowledge any negativity ever. Right. He and so he's like, we've got the
big, beautiful bill. We've accomplished X, Y and Z. But at the end of the day, when people
fill up their gas tanks, they're seeing the reality. So, Mary, he's saying to voters,
vote like I'm on the ballot. Is that an asset or liability?
I mean, depends who you ask. But I think what's interesting in this moment is you're seeing
problems both at 30,000 feet, right, with the polls are looking broadly and down at the granular
level. Right. You have people like Politico had this report about the front row Joes,
the people who show up at every Trump event and are there to represent and defend Donald Trump
and how a couple of those people are like, yeah, you know what would get me to show up at this
point? Another impeachment of Donald Trump. Right. So you're seeing people who are very
committed to MAGA begin to question what has just happened. And to me, that's a real break.
And, you know, you asked, is this Donald Trump sort of staying away from swing states or just,
you know, rallying where he's popular? And I'm like, well, why not both? That is what is
happening. He like it was funny to look at how the White House framed Donald Trump going to these
places that are, you know, MAGA based places. Right. They framed it as Donald Trump wants big
crowds. He wants a big rally. So that's about pleasing the boss. And oh, yeah, you know,
in these swing states, he's going to put the candidates are going to have to distance themselves.
But that is very, very difficult when the Republican brand is Donald Trump. That's all it
is. So it's very difficult to distance yourself, which is something you have in every midterm as a
challenge when your entire identity as a party is built around one person and that one person
is quite unpopular. And you and you voted with him if you're an incumbent. Ninety eight hundred
percent of the time. So to that point about incumbents, you know, yesterday in Oklahoma,
the president said that he was worried about Texas and Michigan.
You know, Texas seems like an own goal at this point. He and Ken Paxton seem to be,
you know, not on solid footing. The two of them were quite the allies. And then all of a sudden
there's kind of, you know, trading barbs under the radar. What does it signal that Trump is sort
of questioning Ken Paxton in public? Is this buyer's remorse about John Cornyn? What's going
on? He doesn't like the way he looks. I mean, he's made that very doesn't like his suits. He
thinks he dresses poorly. He doesn't think he's free for him. He likes central.
Now, having said that, it's Texas. And so when you talk to Democratic insiders, when you talk
to people around the campaign there and I'm talking about Tallarico's campaign, they're
not taking the pedal off the metal. They're looking at a couple of things. Number one,
the amount of outside money that has come in for the Republicans, for Paxton in the closing
weeks of this. There's like 300 million, right? Well, there's 145 million just, I think,
outside money now in the last couple of months, 122 million in September alone.
It doesn't matter necessarily so much in a place like Alaska or Maine. But when you have 20 media
markets in Texas, that money does matter. The second thing is they're very worried about how
they're making it harder in battleground states, Republicans, for people to vote.
Texas is a prime example of that. It's difficult to register there already. There are reports
about huge backlogs of people who put in voter registration months and months ago and still
have not gotten a response. So they're very concerned about that. Having said all of that,
when you look at the crosstabs of the Fox News poll, the net negatives for Paxton are minus 18.
The net positives for Talarico are plus eight. So they feel good, but not overly confident.
And to that point, Michael, I want to just bring you in. Chuck Schumer has cautioned that while
the outlook is good for Democrats, that they shouldn't be overconfident here. They shouldn't
let the guards down. Why do you think he seems a little timid about embracing this
windfall that everybody's predicting? Because they've been burned in the past.
There were previous election cycles. I mean, we can look at the presidential with Hillary Clinton,
where Democrats got overly confident. They believe that they had it in the bag. And then
on election night, they didn't. And they lost. So, yes, Democrats right now have the advantage
of the fact that it is a midterm election year, the first one for the president. And given that,
historically, the president's party loses seats in Congress. He also has on his side
the political environment right now. You all have said that President Trump was elected
to lower costs. That's not happening. The war in Iran is continuing. Gas prices remain up.
So the political environment right now is ripe for a Democratic takeover. But Democrats sometimes
can fumble the ball when they are on the five yard line. And Chuck Schumer wants to be very clear.
He does not want to get overly confident. That could maybe lead some voters to not turn out.
They feel like they have it in the bag. They feel like they may not have to go out
and vote on Election Day. He wants to make sure that they have a full court press until the last
second before polls close, because even though they may be close in striking distance,
they don't want to lose it at the last minute.
