An urgent breaking news broadcast from talkSPORT as senior football correspondent Ben Jacobs joins the studio to unpack a historic announcement from the Premier League. An independent commission has officially found Manchester City guilty of serious financial rule breaches spanning a nine-season period, alongside widespread non-cooperation charges. The discussion explores the damning details of the forty-page report—including concealed player and manager remunerations, inflated commercial revenues, and sham contracts—while breaking down the potential timeline for club appeals and unprecedented structural sanctions.
This is incredibly important, a little bit of breaking news actually, this has just come in.
An official statement finally from the Premier League this afternoon and it says
an independent commission has found Man City FC guilty of all charges, all charges related to
serious breaches of the Premier League's financial rules over a nine-season period
and the majority of charges in relation to its failure to cooperate with the league's investigation.
So an official statement has now been released from the Premier League confirming what was leaked
about a week ago, just under a week ago. We will of course take your calls on this from 5pm
now that we have the official word from the Premier League because a lot of Man City fans
were saying well it's not confirmed, it's not confirmed, well it is now confirmed so we will
take calls on this in five minutes time. Can we clear the switchboard, I know loads of people
whenever they're saying that. So if you do City fans it's been confirmed and football fans
03717223344, what should the next step be? What an hour coming your way. Let's get more on that
breaking news this evening, it broke just before, Toolsport broke it before anyone on the planet.
An independent commission has found Man City guilty of all charges related to serious breaches
of the Premier League's financial rules over a nine-season period and on top of that the majority
of charges in relation to its failure to cooperate with the league's investigation.
Right let's get more on this now and find out what that all means, Toolsport's senior
football correspondent Ben Jacobs joins us now. Hello Ben. How's it going? We are good, I mean
what a day this is turning into now. We were waiting from a statement from the Premier League,
we've got it now. Just bring us up to date with exactly what's happened this evening.
Yeah well I'm here in Copenhagen and Ferran Soriano has been chased all day and I'm not sure
he's going to be able to leave the building without further questions from us here because
now the Premier League have confirmed that an independent commission has found Manchester City
guilty of all charges related to serious breaches of the Premier League's financial rules over this
nine-season period and the majority of charges in relation to non-cooperation. So even the not
guilty ones are only in the category of non-cooperation. Now the independent commission
have given their full report minus some significant redactions though and it's worth
noting before we get into the details that although a sanction hearing is expected to be
the next step, Manchester City have until the 2nd of October to appeal the actual verdict itself
and we know from city sources they will appeal, we just don't know whether they'll appeal the
verdict and then any sanction hearing or wait until effectively the punishment. And some of
the highlights to tell you about, Manchester City arranged sham contracts to misrepresent
true agreements between various parties particularly a number of commercial partners
and in addition to that the club inflated revenue to the tune of 830 million. In addition the club
filed misstated accounts and concealed the true state of its finances from auditors and football
regulators. They engaged in player remunerations that were concealed. Yaya Torre one example,
Roberto Mancini another, he received one wage from Manchester City and then another inflated
number for consultancy for Al Jazeera and then you have Manchester City was and now I quote
significantly in breach of both the Premier League's and UEFA's spending limits and that's
maybe the clearest to put a punishment to because a breach of UEFA rules, a breach of PSR, we have
some precedent particularly Everton and Nottingham Forest and that tends to lean towards points
deductions. So we have a full picture now, it is a 40 page report but there are some redactions in it
and the headlines are Manchester City guilty of all these substantial charges and guilty of most
of the non-cooperation, guilty of inflating their income, guilty of breaching PSR and UEFA rules,
guilty of making player remunerations that were concealed. This is a worst-case scenario for
Manchester City and now we wait and see whether before the sanctions hearing they choose to put
in an appeal and once again if they do that the deadline is the 2nd of October.
Ben firstly great work on that, thank you for that. If they put the appeal in or if they don't
when we get to find out exactly what the punishment will be I would imagine it's going to be serious
that means I would imagine Man City will appeal it. What sort of time frame are we working on
before what punishment is given out has to be taken? So the Premier League's rulebook outlines
an appeal process and after any form of verdict or judgment you have generally 14 days and then
an appeal is supposed to start to finish after that take place within 12 weeks and a hearing
specifically will be a maximum of five days and continuous. So if Manchester City appeal now
without knowing the punishment that's obviously going to add some time. If they wait for the
sanctions hearing you're usually looking at several weeks to put that together with the
Premier League acting as prosecutor and they will then recommend in likelihood a punishment
and the independent panel will decide the severity and both parties have the ability if they don't
like the punishment to appeal. So we've got two separate time frames now, one is City block a
sanctions hearing by appealing immediately, two is we pass the 2nd of October and the sanctions
hearing goes ahead. If that's the case you would expect that to be resolved before the year is out
but again after that City can appeal again or they can wait for that and appeal for the first time
and again within the Premier League handbook you're talking about first of all 14 days post either
verdict which we've got or sanctions hearing to come and then following on from that is that 12
week period. But what's challenging here is two things, one if there is a punishment before an
appeal the punishment is usually instantaneous so then you're in a race against time to resolve any
appeal before the season ends otherwise legally it's very complicated and second of all even if
and lose both there are other arbitration routes even though they can't go to the court of
arbitration for sport and that's why Ferran Soriano has said he thinks that this is still
going to drag on but there's no doubt that now we can read the verdict it is damning against
Manchester City. So it's kind of from here on in Ben when you read out all those facts
moments ago it's incredible it's almost like damage limitation now for Manchester City the
more they prolong this then surely potentially it just gets it only gets worse for them. I'm
not expecting them to hold their hands up and say okay and the game's up but you would expect
something to be sooner rather than later in terms of the response and a meaningful response as well
not just for quoting the politicians kicking a can down the road and taking it to further
into the year surely this is now time to do something from a city point of view. Well I
think there's two things there's two things if they meet the 2nd of October deadline they will
be appealing against the verdict so they won't just be taking a punishment or waiting for a
punishment they will be challenging the verdict but there's a very narrow grounds for appeal
things like fraud the misuse of evidence the panel not being impartial but they could challenge the
very nature of the process and try and effectively get the case to be heard again and then although
you're not back to square one you're actually challenging all of these elements of guilt
which is the vast majority of all of these charges if they don't appeal from the 2nd of October
then you start to think they're going to wait for the punishment and they're going to put their
focus on trying to get something less severe more palatable which is in essence an admission of
guilt and then you start saying well Chelsea were guilty but they agreed to settlement and the
punishment was quite lenient so there's two kind of routes here city can either go all in and say
nothing in this report we believe is accurate so we're going to make them look at it again before
we even get to the sanctions hearing but if we get to the 3rd of October and they've not done that
then all they can do is wait for the punishment and then likely try and appeal that so the next
few days are going to be key. Ben let me ask you the huge difference I'm led to believe between
Chelsea in this case is that Chelsea's new owners looked at the books realised they were cooked and
then told the Premier League about them whereas in this scenario Man City still have the same
owners and they were found out rather than they admitted they were wrong right? Yeah the
non-cooperation tends to lead to a more severe punishment so that is one factor and the other
thing is that Chelsea as you say self-declared it was a new ownership regime clearly solely
reporting Roman Abramovich and immediately in May 2022 when they discovered in due diligence that
were breaches so that's why it's not a perfect comparison even though the scale of Chelsea
charges was also very high the other factor in all of this is that Manchester City and not
cooperating are less likely if they choose to then later down the line try and enter into a
settlement with the Premier League to mitigate the severity of the punishments find that maybe
the Premier League aren't prepared to mediate because ultimately a vast proportion of these
charges nearly a third are about City circumventing this investigation in the first
place so what's going to be key is if we get to the sanctions hearing next ie City don't appeal
the verdict part the Premier League's prosecutor will recommend a punishment how strong are they
going to go the independent panel will still dispassionately decide what that punishment is
but the Premier League now if we go straight to the sanctions hearing have got a number of
weeks to prepare a position on the punishment in light of this report and at the most extreme
they could choose to say Manchester City should be expelled from the Premier League so it's going
to be fascinating if we get to that sanctions hearing or if we're delayed by City finding
legal avenues to challenge the verdict itself but Chelsea's not a perfect comparison and the
punishment for Chelsea was indeed more lenient because in essence it was historical breaches
as importantly Chelsea were not deemed to have gained a sporting advantage and City are and
ultimately from day one Chelsea cooperated I'm so sorry I'm going to cut in I want to keep you
there I want to cut in but as you would imagine this story moves incredibly quickly so since we've
been talking two statements have been released one by Man City I'll read that in a moment the
first one has been released by Richard Masters he's the Chief Executive of the Premier League
so his and their statement reads as following the court decision establishes the facts of what
happened at Manchester City during this period it details how the club systematically broke the
Premier League rules for nearly a decade it also vindicates the Premier League's decision to pursue
this case against Man City while the process to date has been both long and difficult the league
has remained determined that the facts be established independently the disciplinary case
and the decision are the most significant in Premier League history there are elements of
the case that remain to be decided including importantly what sanctions must follow these
breaches that's the statement from Richard Masters the Chief Executive of the Premier League on the
back of that Man City have just released the following statement it says Man City FC is both
disappointed and surprised by the opinion of the Premier League Commission that has been published
today the club is innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League and a comprehensive
body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all its positions relating to this case
the club will therefore be relentless and when necessary proactive in any and all appropriate
regulatory and legal forms the Premier League process remains ongoing with significant elements
uncompleted now obviously Man City are going to come out fighting and that's exactly what
they've said I'll get your view on that in just a moment but let's go back to the first statement
I read out from Richard Masters the Chief Executive of the Premier League with that in
mind with everything that he said about this is the most significant decision in Premier League
history and you've got the option as well or the possibility I should say of other clubs
suing for loss of earnings for not getting into Europe for not winning certain trophies etc
how big a punishment do you think this could actually be for Man City? A significant punishment
for Manchester City because the Premier League now have the verdict and the independent panel
on side and remember when we get to the point of that punishment or sanction hearing you have a
situation where the Premier League can drive what that punishment is and for Richard Masters in
particular his reputation in how this has been handled is arguably going to be more defined by
what the final punishment is subject to any appeals rather than just a verdict of predominantly
guilty and that's because if this ended with a more lenient sanction the Premier League clubs
would not be happy the optics of it would be bad rival fans and clubs would be angry by it
and there might not be any avenues for as much or any compensation and the reality is that within
the sliding scale of punishments there's only really two expulsion or a significant points
deduction that essentially relegates Manchester City that would be deemed as on the severe end
a transfer ban City have already spent a lot of money a fine they've got plenty of money
a warning does nothing so really severe points deduction or expulsion from the Premier League
are severe enough to vindicate how long this has taken how much it has cost and remember this is
other Premier League clubs paying the legal bills as well because they contribute to a central fund
and that is why the punishment will naturally be more important for how the Premier League
have handled this than the verdict but what I would add is if you read City's statement
it's crystal clear that where they can appeal they will appeal so we may have to be patient
because if they put in a appeal on the 2nd of October and we're told from the Premier League
statement there hasn't yet been a sanctions hearing that tells you that that appeal on the
2nd of October is on the verdict not the punishment and if they appeal the verdict
as far as I'm aware you can't move directly to the punishment phase so we may have a lot more months
or even years still to run even though the Premier League's intent is to close this case inclusive of
punishment before the season ends. Ben you're a star, great work as always. Nice stuff Ben, thank you.
Thanks guys. There you go, senior football correspondent Ben Jacobs. If you're just tuning in
turning on your radio it's big, it's huge, an independent commission has found Man City guilty
of all charges related to serious breaches of Premier League's financial rules over a nine
season period and the majority of charges in relation to its failure to cooperate with the
investigation. We will take all of your calls right after this 03717223344
dial that number you can react first on the planet.