Chemistry in the Natural Aquarium reveals what is really happening beneath the sand in a natural aquarium substrate. Father Fish explains how a deep sand cap, soil, beneficial microorganisms, minerals, and aquatic plant roots work together to create a biologically active environment. Learn why a 2-inch sand cap is important, how an anaerobic substrate makes nutrients available to aquarium plants, and how iron, manganese, calcium, magnesium, phosphates, carbonates, biochar, clay, and other elements behave below the substrate surface. The natural aquarium method keeps essential nutrients concentrated in the root zone while limiting their movement into the water column.
The substrate beneath a natural aquarium is far from inactive. Father Fish explores the biochemical processes occurring underground, including how microorganisms transform nutrients and how plant roots interact with trace minerals. He explains why aquatic soil behaves differently from ordinary garden soil, why newly planted roots should remain primarily within the sand layer, and how the substrate gradually develops into a stable environment capable of supporting healthy plant growth.
You’ll also learn how the natural aquarium substrate helps control potentially troublesome compounds. Father Fish discusses phosphate binding, ammonium, carbonate buffering, substrate pH, and the prevention of toxic hydrogen sulfide. The result is a fascinating look beneath the surface at the chemistry, biology, and microbiology that allow a mature natural aquarium to function as a living ecosystem.
Lou Foxwell, known as Father Fish, is a pioneer of natural aquarium keeping and the creator of the Father Fish Method.
His approach to planted aquariums focuses on building balanced, self-sustaining ecosystems using soil substrates, natural processes, and minimal maintenance. The Father Fish Method draws inspiration from the Walstad Method and the natural aquarium philosophy of Takashi Amano.
Before entering the aquarium industry, Lou spent 25 years as a missionary, serving a congregation of deaf worshipers. He later opened a tropical fish store, where he adopted the role of Father Fish.
His passion for fishkeeping began in childhood, inspired by his grandmother from Berlin, Germany. He went on to become a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, where he helped shape its early development and leadership.
With decades of experience across the fishkeeping world, Father Fish shares practical knowledge on planted aquariums, dirt substrate systems, and natural ecosystem balance. He also provides plants, soil supplements, and tools to help hobbyists create thriving aquariums with less effort and fewer water changes.
All clips and images are used for illustration purposes only. Learn how the natural aquarium approach changed the hobby forever. This video explores the foundational book behind the method.
0:00 The sand substrate system 2:15 Mechanics of the deep bed 5:39 Trace elements and soil 8:40 Managing chemistry and pH
Because the recipe is locked down under the sand.
The plant plants put trace earth elements, what they call trace earth elements,
through their roots, their roots,
via a highly specialized underground biochemical environment.
Welcome to father fish and...
Bubble, bubble, toil and trouble.
Going on in that substrate.
It's a process called chelation,
in which chemicals are interacting with each other
energetically, which creates heat
and creates some compounds.
Well, the compounds are not the problem.
It's the interaction of the chemicals
that produce heat
that's the problem.
So we overcome that
by putting a two inch layer of sand
on top of this.
That heat rises up about an inch.
And it doesn't go beyond that.
Not very much.
It balances out to the temperature of
the water coming into the sand
and the soil temperature coming up
into the sand they meet
essentially in the middle
and it stabilizes.
It'll be a little warm getting to the top
by the time it reaches
the top, really by the time it's halfway through.
The temperature is lower to the point
where the plants are able to survive
without the roots being put up,
which is precisely why
we recommend strongly
when you're setting up a brand new tank
with this system,
you do not put the roots of the plants
more than one inch
into the sand.
The salts like urea,
epsom salts, baking soda,
ferrous sulfate,
triple superbond states,
along with the raw biological
and they're creating,
they create a highly saline environment
and they're biological
and biologically volatile
when they're first mixed together.
What generates from that,
however,
is what I want to talk about.
To prevent
this chemical process
from burning plant roots
or sterilizing the beneficial
fungus,
the completed soil mixture
of three cups of aquacryl
per five gallons
of soil mixture,
which is adequate
to set up
a 100-gallon tank
capped with two inches
of sand,
of any grain
of sand.
The roots don't have
trouble with fine sand.
It does not compress.
It's an important concept
to understand. Sand
in a, until you
get down a few hundred
feet, sand is not
compressed. It's a crystalline
product that sits like
this. It requires enough
heat to smash it,
enough, I'm sorry, pressure
to smash it for it to compress.
It doesn't smash
in an inch or two inches.
It just hangs like this.
It stays because
it's rough, because it's got
lots of facets.
It sits at odd angles and water
is able to flow through it.
Microorganisms are able to pass
through it. It's full of channels.
Everything moves, but
it doesn't move at the rate of water
below it. It moves
at the rate of the animals
that are in it pulsating
with their cells. They're moving
through it. It's moving by
the biochemical
processes and the
animal processes, the microprocesses
that are going
on in that sand environment.
So it slows
it down, which prevents
then the nutrients
from the substrate, from the soil
getting up into the water
flow. Microlife
from the worm
castings
breaks down the urea,
stabilizes the acids,
buffers the salts
in the biochar, and
cycles the worm minerals
into plant-safe forms
without damaging the plant roots.
And yet, when they do tank, plant
roots should be planted no more
halfway down into the sand.
The deep sand
also prevents the tank
from crashing in its first few
weeks. The thick path
acts as a physical and a chemical
seal, drastically
reducing water movement and convection
and forcing nutrients
to migrate
strictly through slow subterranean
diffusion.
And then to gradually
emerge, it gradually moves up. You can see
it. By the month, you can see
it moving. Not by the hour
or the day or the week.
In six months, it'll be one inch.
Separate
an inch into 60 parts.
Six months.
Six times three. 180
months. It takes
180 days for it to
move an inch. Because the
recipe is locked
down under the sand. Aquatic plants
put trace earth elements
– well, they pull trace earth elements
through their roots
via highly
specialized underground
biochemical environment.
Now, this is the nature
of that environment. How do these
trace elements behave
under the tank?
The very heavily anaerobic
zone created by a
three-inch total substrate
completely changes how trace earth
elements behave compared
to a standard terrestrial
garden. The dirt
in the water, under the water
is not like
the dirt in a garden.
It functions
in a completely different way.
By the time you get to the
bottom of a pond or a creek
or whatever, the oxygen level
right there is significantly
lower than the oxygen
level at the surface.
Significantly lower.
And as you go down then
into the sand, it continues
to drop. By the time you get
an inch into that sand,
it is anoxic. There is
virtually no oxygen.
Right there. You got
two more inches below though.
Right there. That
means that the roots of the plants
are going down deeper into
that, into an anaerobic
environment and pulling out
nutrients. There are
anaerobic bacteria that
are converting these elements
and working with the roots
of the plants to be able to
provide, through their hormonal
activity, precisely what the
plant needs. Ferrous sulfide,
an ironite under
a two-inch sand patch,
is actually ideal
for iron.
It reduces ferric iron
into ferrous iron, which is
the highly bioavailable
form that aquatic plants
break. The clay powder
in the mix binds
this iron, preventing it from
leaching upward and getting
into the work. Another element
that we use, another compound
we use, in the supplement
is basalt, volcanic
basalt and azomite.
These are dense
mineral powders, which
act as a permanent, slow
release micro-residual.
Because water flow
is highly restricted under sand,
these elements do not
dissolve into the water column.
Instead, aquatic plant
roots secrete organic
acids, which locally
dissolve and absorb the
trace elements exactly where
they are. Another element
that we use is manganese.
In an
anoxic substrate,
manganese becomes highly
soluble. Aquatic plants
require a precise
iron to manganese ratio,
usually around two or three
to one. The heavy use of
ironite and ferrous
sulfide balances
the broad-spectrum
manganese found in the
azomite. There are,
in addition, some actually
rather dangerous ingredients
that are used in this system.
Look at how they
act, what they do.
One of them is urea.
Another is blood real. They kind of
work together. Instead of
urea, nor in
water will spike the ammonia.
Instead of that
happening in the water column,
the microscopic blood
that's trapped under the sand
converts urea into
ammonia. Aquatic plants
prefer ammonia
over nitrate. And because
it carries a positive
charge, it binds
tightly to clay powder
and biochar rather than
passing through the sand
tank. So the clay powder and the
biochar, which are in this formula
in fairly substantial quantities,
locks up
some of these volatile
factors
so
that they cannot leach out.
Another element that we use
is limestone, and
we also use baking soda,
and both of these provide
the same kind of contact.
The two end sand tank
creates a boundary layer.
Carbonates
leach upward at a very,
very slow, a
microscopic draw.
They are glacial.
It provides a very stable,
slow-release buffer
of general hardness
and carbonate hardness,
thereby preventing sudden
spikes and preventing
the acidification
of the soil. For many
people who set up
traditional
wall-stead tanks with a shovel
of dirt and a shovel of
gravel, in a matter
of a month or so, they're in serious
trouble because their soil
has become acidic
and it burns everything up.
They're required to do
any number of water changes
until that process
slows down to the point
where they can actually manage.
Now that happens because
this not-old soil has
very much carbonates in it.
There are plenty of soils that have very little
and they cannot handle
the acidification process
that goes on erratically
when soil gets into work.
We also use phosphate.
The bone meal and the triple
superphosphate bond
with iron oxides from
the ironite, creating iron
phosphate. This locks
the phosphate safely
in the root zone, keeping it away
from algae spores in the
water column, which is why you rarely
get algae in
a natural tank
or substrate because
the nutrients for the
algae are kept locked down
in the substrate. Another ingredient
or a couple, calcium
and magnesium. The carbonates
in them solve a traditional
aquarium problem.
Now this system, the whole
compound, is a workaround
for the classic aquarium
problem of low pH
and ensuing hydrogen
sulfide
tests. Dolomitic limestone
and baking soda
continuously react
with any hydrogen
ions that are produced
in the anabolic zone.
This buffers the substrate
pH, keeping it alkaline
underground and prevents
the biogenetic reduction
of sulfates into toxic
hydrogen sulfide.
Absolutely fundamental.
Instead, the sulfur remains
found or
converts into non-
fossil precipitates.