As House Democrats’ new taxes on cryptocurrency, fantasy sports, sports betting, social media, and digital ads face legal uncertainty, Republicans will explain why these taxes are ineffective and should be repealed.
Rep. Weaver: "We’re here this morning because this year’s state budget included five novel tax increases passed by Illinois Democrats. These are brand new taxes passed by Democrats who cannot control their out-of-control spending habits to the point where they had to invent novel taxes to hit Illinois families even harder in their wallets."
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
State Representative Travis Weber, Leader John Cabello, and Senator Neal Anderson argue for the repeal of five new taxes introduced by Illinois Democrats. They contend these taxes are fiscally irresponsible, potentially illegal, and harmful to the state's economic competitiveness, urging the government to control spending rather than creating new revenue streams.
Good morning, I'm State Representative Travis Weber and I represent Greater Peoria in the 93rd
District. We're gathered this morning because this year's state budget included five novel
taxes cut by the majority party. These are brand new taxes passed by Illinois Democrats
who have no limits on their out-of-control spending habits, to the point where they had
to come up with five novel taxes to hit Illinois families even harder in their wallets.
What's even more egregious about these new taxes is the fact that Democrats are expecting minimal
at any revenue from them because they don't even know if the measures are legal. They are, however,
projecting costs because the lawsuits have already started and the Attorney General will
have to defend them in court. These taxes can cost more money than they take in. That's a wild
concept. The entire point of taxes, literally the only reason they exist, is to raise money for the
public good. These novel tax increases lose money for the public bad. The majority party is wasting
citizens harder money to find out if they can invent new ways to take their money. I hear the
governor talk a lot about cost of living. Well, here's an easy small fix. Stop wasting money to
find out if it's legal to take money. These novel taxes include a social media tax, targeted ad tax,
sports wagering exchange tax, and a sports wagering fantasy market tax. I have filed repeal bills on
all four of these while Leader Cabello has filed the digital asset cryptocurrency tax repeal bill
and Senator Anderson has companion bills for all five. Two of these taxes are unique to Illinois,
including the social media fee and digital asset crypto fee. Lawsuits are already pending for both.
For the digital asset tax, seven states have recently tried it in some capacity.
Just this summer, Maryland's version of the tax was struck down because it violated federal law.
As you can imagine, there's a lawsuit pending on the Illinois version as well.
For the prediction markets tax, Kentucky has imposed an excise tax on prediction market
operators and also requires prediction market companies like Kalshi that offer sports events
contracts to obtain a license. Kalshi is currently suing that state, claiming that it violates the
Federal Commodity Exchange Act. And just recently, New Jersey asked the Supreme Court to resolve a
major legal battle over whether states can regulate sports events contracts on prediction markets.
This will be a ruling to watch for sure. And for the fantasy sports tax, Pennsylvania and New York
also tax fantasy sports at the same 15 percent rate. As you would guess, a lawsuit is pending
in that state as well on the prediction market tax. Why are we wading into these very muddy,
messy waters? We know the lawsuits are coming, and that means untold amounts of taxpayer dollars
being wasted on legal fees. This is beyond ridiculous, wasting more taxpayer money
and further straining an already taxed out economy in our state. These lawsuits will be
defended and resolved by other states. There is no first mover benefit here. If this was a business,
a CEO would let his or her competitors fight the legal battles, then make a decision. That's the
most prudent decision for shareholders. It's also the clear decision for taxpayers. My hope is that
these new taxes are never levied, but at the very least, we need to let the dust of legal fees
settle before making a decision to levy these taxes or not. These repeals should be easy
wins to tackle in the upcoming veto session. We hear a lot about addressing the cost of living.
Well, eliminating this low-hanging fruit of waste is an easy place to start. With that,
I'll pass it to my colleague, Leader John Cabello. Thank you, Travis. I appreciate it.
Good morning. Illinois Democrats have a spending problem, and they keep spending the bill to the
people of Illinois. Now, they found something else. Digital assets. Apparently, in Springfield,
if you build it, invest it, or find a new way to do business, their first question is,
how much can we take? That needs to stop. I filed House Bill 5798 to repeal the digital
asset tax because Illinois businesses, investment, and jobs, we don't need another tax making this
state more expensive. Beginning January 1, this tax will apply to covered digital asset services.
And understand this, you don't have to make a profit to get hit with it. You can lose money
and still owe this tax. The broker collects it, you pay it, and Springfield spends it.
They'll tell you it's only two-tenths of 1%. Well, it's always only something when it's coming out
of someone else's pocket. Families are paying their mortgages, buying groceries, putting gas
in their cars, and trying to save for the future. Small businesses are trying to meet payroll and
keep their doors open. They don't need Springfield adding another tax. There are businesses in my
district that accept cryptocurrency. They try to move forward and serve their customers. Why are
we making that hard? And before implementing a new tax, lawmakers ought to face the people who
will pay for it. Hold a hearing. Let them testify. Explain what you're doing before it's a done deal
instead of passing it in the middle of the night without a hearing. Taking comments afterwards on
how to collect the money doesn't make up for it. Here's what Springfield needs to understand.
We are competing with other states. Businesses have choices about where they invest and where
they create jobs. We should be giving them reasons to come here and stay here. Unfortunately,
the Democrats give them the opposite. My bill is straightforward. Repeal the Digital Asset
Tax. Give it a hearing, bring it up for a vote, and let every member explain to their constituents
where they stand. And Governor, if you want to talk about affordability, here's an opportunity
to do so. Stop reaching into people's pockets. Get spending under control. Help us repeal the
tax before elections begin. And with that, I would like to hand it over to my good friend,
Senator Neal Anderson. Thank you, Leader Cabello. Good morning. I'm State Senator Neal Anderson.
I'm from Andalusia. I represent the 47th Senate District, which is made up of some or all parts
of 15 counties in West Central Illinois. I think most people here back home are pretty tired of
watching Springfield spend more, tax more, and then come back the next year asking for even more.
Families have to live within a budget. Businesses have to live within a budget. State government
should have to do the same thing. But instead of getting spending under control, this administration
and the Democrat supermajority keep looking for new places to tax and new fees to collect. This
is exactly what we are talking about today. Starting next January 1st, platforms with more
than 100,000 Illinois users will have to pay the state every single month. For the largest platforms,
that fee starts at $165,000 a month and then goes up from there. Call it a fee, call it whatever
you want. The more money going to Springfield, money that ultimately comes out of the pockets
of the consumer. Then there's Senate Bill 4230. SB 4230 would repeal the new transaction tax
on exchange wagers tied to sporting events. Sports wagering is already taxed in Illinois.
Operators can pay up to 40% on adjusted gross receipts. Then Illinois added a tax
on the online wager. Apparently that wasn't enough. Now there's another tax on exchange
wagers. It starts at 1.75% and then doubles to 3.5% after 5 million exchange wagers. So we tax
the revenue, we tax the wager, and now we found a way to tax a whole new kind of transaction.
All while not knowing if we even have the power to regulate and tax these markets.
That tells you everything you need to know about how Springfield operates.
Something new comes along and instead of asking, hey how can we make Illinois more competitive?
Their first thoughts are, how can we tax it? You cannot tax your way into prosperity.
SB 4229 and SB 4230 are simple. Repeal these new taxes and fees before they become another
permanent part of doing business in Illinois. Government needs to learn how to live within
its means. The people we represent already have to do that.