Should you clean aquarium sand, or are you actually removing something your natural aquarium needs? In a properly established aquarium, the deeper layers of sand aren't simply dirt waiting to be vacuumed. They become part of a living substrate where bacteria, organic material, plant roots, and nutrients work together to support the aquarium ecosystem.
Father Fish explains what happens inside a deep sand bed and why disturbing the lower layers can interfere with the natural processes happening beneath the surface. Instead of constantly removing organic material, a natural aquarium allows that material to be recycled and eventually made available to plants. Understanding how aquarium substrate works can change the way you think about mulm, waste, plant nutrition, and aquarium maintenance.
If you're building a natural planted aquarium, experimenting with a deep substrate, or wondering whether you should vacuum aquarium sand, this discussion explains the biology behind leaving an established substrate alone. The goal isn't a dirty aquarium—it's creating a balanced aquarium ecosystem that does more of the work naturally.
Lou Foxwell, known as Father Fish, is a pioneer of natural aquarium keeping and the creator of the Father Fish Method.
His approach to planted aquariums focuses on building balanced, self-sustaining ecosystems using soil substrates, natural processes, and minimal maintenance. The Father Fish Method draws inspiration from the Walstad Method and the natural aquarium philosophy of Takashi Amano.
Before entering the aquarium industry, Lou spent 25 years as a missionary, serving a congregation of deaf worshipers. He later opened a tropical fish store, where he adopted the role of Father Fish.
His passion for fishkeeping began in childhood, inspired by his grandmother from Berlin, Germany. He went on to become a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, where he helped shape its early development and leadership.
With decades of experience across the fishkeeping world, Father Fish shares practical knowledge on planted aquariums, dirt substrate systems, and natural ecosystem balance. He also provides plants, soil supplements, and tools to help hobbyists create thriving aquariums with less effort and fewer water changes.
All clips and images are used for illustration purposes only. Learn how the natural aquarium approach changed the hobby forever. This video explores the foundational book behind the method.
They have very shallow, delicate roots.
They sit comfortably in the plain sandcastle,
while they send microscopic brood hairs,
just deep enough to drink from the microelements
that diffuse it upwards from the boundary layers of the nest.
Welcome to Father Fish and the Natural Aquarium.
Crips and Swords are deep roots
which pump organic man-foods
in order to extract azomite and basalt.
So we have azomite and we have basalt
as supplements in our substrate.
Stem plants, they are mid-level,
adventitious roots which tap into mobile ammonia.
In other words, they're plants that have roots
that are in the water column as well as in the substrate
and they absorb ammonia.
They absorb ammonia, which our system creates.
It converts ammonia instantly into ammonia
because the chemicals are there and it's sensible for that to happen.
When that happens, the plants absorb it almost immediately.
They absorb it very easily, very quickly.
And the stem plants are absolute best for achieving that.
The carpeting plants.
The carpeting plants are very shallow mats.
They skim the top of the nutrients.
Now, in order to do that, you need a food web
because the top layer in the beginning,
in the early stages, has no nutrients in it at all.
They're down below the sink.
They're working their way up into the sink.
And the detritus is precipitating into it from the top.
In order to build that to the point where you have adequate nutrients
at the surface, you need to add to that detritus.
The way you do that is by putting food web material in it.
What is food web material?
It is the mulch from an existing pond or creek or stream or ditch
that you can scoop out and deposit in a thin layer in your tank.
We have all kinds of disciplines as to how to do that.
We do not recommend you just take a handful of mud and throw it in the tank.
We recommend you put it in a separate container first
so you can study it and see what's really in there
because there may be some things in it you don't want, like dragonfly larvae.
If you have big fish, they'll be fine.
But little tiny fish, dragonfly larvae are going to eat the fish.
So you need to be somewhat cautious about this perhaps.
And then you gradually begin putting small amounts of it in the tank
over an extended period of time so that in three to four months,
you have a rich food web on the surface of the tank.
This is all about being patient and taking your time
and not trying to do everything at once.
Some of the other shallow-rooted plants, which are actually a heavier root,
are the rosettes, the cryptocoryne, the echinodorus, and the ballast snails.
These big plants are the absolute king of the substance.
They boast massive deep roots that are designed to actively pump organic acids
from their systems into the soil.
Now, why do they do that?
Because it generates the action of bacteria,
which break down available nutrients in a form that the plants are able to absorb.
These acids are hormones, and they are very specific hormones
that attack very specific bacteria,
that convert a very specific chemical into a very specific compound
that the plant is specifically capable of.
It's, frankly, that complicated.
That is not something you can duplicate by throwing a little bit of fertilizer in the tank.
A system that has developed over millennia,
that operates automatically, symptomatically,
based on the conditions of the system it's in
and the members of that system and what they're doing and what they're looking at.
The nature of a natural tank is to free up the ancient processes
that have developed over eons that occur naturally
in an environment that is not being interfered with.
I had a young man recently said,
this old fogey, he doesn't know anything.
He's just doing dumb old stuff from a long time ago.
We know all these chemicals.
We can put it together and make it work and do exactly what we want to do.
And I simply said to him, the laws of nature have not changed,
which he probably didn't get.
But it is the issue.
When you go in and try to muck around with something that's perfect,
you make it less than perfect, and it does not work as well.
What we have attempted to do is create an environment
that is as close to a natural environment,
which is with as much elemental nutrients.
That's not dead food.
That's elemental.
It's minerals and mineralized compounds,
like worm cactus and bat guano and blood meal and bone meal,
organic minerals, as well as hard minerals,
like ferrous sulfate and iron and baking soda.
Mixing these in not massive portions,
in many ways, minimal portions.
About 5% of the total mass of the substrate
contains all of these little elements.
5% or less.
It's a very small portion, but it's thoroughly mixed,
so it gets everywhere.
Most of those minerals are used up at a glacial rate.
They're not absorbed out and gone.
Certain of them are, like iron.
We have a larger amount of iron.
Certain others require to get used up, like the buffers.
We have, I think, four or five different buffering materials
that work interactively to continue that existence
of buffering material in the system,
so it never runs out of buffers.
It's always there.
When it gets used, it kind of recombines.
It gets back in the loop that creates that buffer,
so it never becomes acidic.
It cannot become acidic.
The cricks, the echinodorus, and the ballast nodes,
kings of the substrate, with massive earths,
they localize acidification.
Those hormones unlock rare earth elements
in the azomite and the ferrous iron
by using bacteria to achieve it.
They're locked in clay.
We have clay, a powdered clay that we've been working.
It's one of the richest materials on earth
for the depth and variety of minerals and elements
that it has.
And all of that kills a very rapid and robust growth.
You'll find that the ballastary, in particular,
will just grow wide.
It will completely take everything.
So it's really an excellent early-on plant.
Once that system has matured, you
can pull some of those out, replace them
with other more delicate, more difficult kinds of plants,
because the system will be ready to nurture.
Stem plants rely very heavily on adventitious roots formed
along the lower nodes.
They skim the top edge of the nutrient layer
right beneath the sandcastle and aggressively
feed on the stable ammonium that's
trapped by the biochar plant, utilizing
this iron-iron compound to express
an intense red and orange pigmentation.
So when you see plants becoming red, it's iron.
It's iron.
It's iron that we put in that substrate
in sufficient quantities to be able to make red plants red.
The carpet plants, like Blossom stigma, Cuba, Monte Carlo,
they have very shallow, delicate roots.
They sit comfortably in the plain sandcastle
while this microscopic root here is just
deep enough to drink from the microbonance
that diffuses upwards from the boundary layer of the mix.
So as liquefaction is moved by virtue
of the activity of the microbonance,
the microbiota that are moving the water
with the pulsing little body, these animals
contain cellulose that is constantly weighted.
And that's how they feed.
They're moving the water around to their mouth
so that they can feed.
And that's also how they move.
They don't have feet.
They have these tiny cilia that propel them around.
That causes a very slow but very consistent water flow.
Given the high concentration of dense minerals
and organic binders like blood meal and urea,
this is how we maintain the tank over a multi-year life.
The first is when you remove plants from the tank,
don't just yank them out because you're
going to get a lot of dirt out in the substrate.
The thing to do is to jiggle.
And what this does is it breaks the cilia that are on the root.
The root themselves does not hold or capture nutrients or soil.
It has tiny little microscopic hairs.
You can see them.
They're not altogether microscopic.
They grow out along that root, along the entire root.
So the entire root is covered with these tiny hairs,
the cilia on the plant.
They are what absorb the nutrients.
Now, when you jiggle that root, those cilia break off.
Every one of them just disappears,
which may be why you've never seen them.
Because you've yanked the plants out,
and they've stayed down there because they're very delicate,
and they break off very easily, which prevents.
So what you do is you jiggle that plant in order to get them off.
So that when you pull it out slowly then,
you get very, very little dirt.
Not enough to make any kind of difference.
You can also pull the plant up and below the crown
until there's an inch or so of roots exposed,
and you can cut them.
And the plant will be able to survive.
It will grow new cilia, new roots right away.
It won't kill the plant at all.
It's really an easy way to be able to do that.
It's very safe, and it's not dangerous to the plant.
Have a wonderful day.
Be sure to subscribe so you can get more of this
vast and vital knowledge for your hobby.
And hit the like button because we know you love it.
And don't forget to share.
Sharing is caring.
The more you share, the more we are able to reach out.
Reach out to the world beyond
and touch many lives with the great and powerful wisdom
of Bob Fish.
Bye for now.