Should you clean aquarium sand, or are you actually removing something your natural aquarium needs? In a properly established aquarium, the deeper layers of sand aren't simply dirt waiting to be vacuumed. They become part of a living substrate where bacteria, organic material, plant roots, and nutrients work together to support the aquarium ecosystem.
Father Fish explains what happens inside a deep sand bed and why disturbing the lower layers can interfere with the natural processes happening beneath the surface. Instead of constantly removing organic material, a natural aquarium allows that material to be recycled and eventually made available to plants. Understanding how aquarium substrate works can change the way you think about mulm, waste, plant nutrition, and aquarium maintenance.
If you're building a natural planted aquarium, experimenting with a deep substrate, or wondering whether you should vacuum aquarium sand, this discussion explains the biology behind leaving an established substrate alone. The goal isn't a dirty aquarium—it's creating a balanced aquarium ecosystem that does more of the work naturally.
Lou Foxwell, known as Father Fish, is a pioneer of natural aquarium keeping and the creator of the Father Fish Method.
His approach to planted aquariums focuses on building balanced, self-sustaining ecosystems using soil substrates, natural processes, and minimal maintenance. The Father Fish Method draws inspiration from the Walstad Method and the natural aquarium philosophy of Takashi Amano.
Before entering the aquarium industry, Lou spent 25 years as a missionary, serving a congregation of deaf worshipers. He later opened a tropical fish store, where he adopted the role of Father Fish.
His passion for fishkeeping began in childhood, inspired by his grandmother from Berlin, Germany. He went on to become a founder and original board member of the National Aquarium, where he helped shape its early development and leadership.
With decades of experience across the fishkeeping world, Father Fish shares practical knowledge on planted aquariums, dirt substrate systems, and natural ecosystem balance. He also provides plants, soil supplements, and tools to help hobbyists create thriving aquariums with less effort and fewer water changes.
All clips and images are used for illustration purposes only. Learn how the natural aquarium approach changed the hobby forever. This video explores the foundational book behind the method.
Well, hello.
Right on in.
You're in, Father Fish.
Good morning.
I need to have a little talk
with my friends,
my fish friends,
fish fan friends on YouTube
about substrate.
There probably is nothing
more confusing,
bewildering,
and frustrating
than substrate.
There are those who
are firmly convinced
that it is the enemy,
and that a fear tank
is the only reasonable
way to proceed.
On the other side,
the other end of the
spectrum are those
like myself,
who believe that substrate,
a deep sand substrate,
is the absolute key
to a healthy aquarium.
Well, let's take a look at things
a little bit.
Try to figure something
out here.
When I began studying
saltwater fish
for the National Aquarium,
one of the first things
that I discovered
is research
making the case
that
the quality of
the dirt
under the coral reefs
was commensurate
with the quality
of the reef itself.
And these researchers
were not saying that
a quality reef
creates a quality substrate.
They were saying rather
the opposite,
that when the substrate
was filthy,
the reef was filthy.
Now, research
into this field
has not been going on
for a long time.
It's maybe
20, 25 years old,
if that.
The reality is that
the farming industry,
the agricultural industry,
which has the most
at stake in understanding
soil strata,
anaerobics,
chemical processes
and the likes,
never really began
studying it seriously
until about the 1960s.
For 25 or 30 years,
that information
did not make it much
into the general knowledge
of the general public.
It certainly did not make it
into the aquarium industry.
And I would argue
that it still hasn't.
There's been
substantial research
done on this very topic.
Research done...
Van Halstead
has published a book
some of you have,
The Biology of the Planted Aquariums,
that goes into
excruciating
scientific detail
on exactly what happens
in the substrate.
It is the seminal study
on aquatic substrate,
based on many years
of her research.
Suffice it to say,
Van Halstead,
in some circles,
is not a popular person.
In others,
she most certainly is.
I find her work,
her theories,
her research,
and her recommendations
to be fundamental
to what I'm trying to do
when I create an aquarium.
And it's based very simply
on the notion that,
well, let's see,
let's start with a bear tank.
Lots of people have bear tanks.
Some people have bear tanks
and no filtration.
My friend Lucas
is a good example of this.
And she has very healthy tanks.
There are also tanks
that, for the most part,
house a small number of fish
and a small number of plants.
And they are successful.
Part of what we need to understand
about the substrate
is based on understanding plants
and how they feed.
Some plants
take nutrition
directly out of the water.
That's why you can grow water spray
and duckweed
to your heart's content
in a bucket.
Other plants,
stem plants,
rooted plants,
stems are a little different.
They kind of work both ways.
Rooted plants
require substrate
in order to be able
to take up nutrition.
Now, let's look at
what happens in an aquarium
that has an inch or less
of gravel
and is planted.
For a while,
a long while,
the plants will languish.
They won't do much of anything.
Even if you put supplements in,
they're still going to be
slow to grow.
But eventually, in time,
they begin to take up nutrition
and they begin to grow and thrive.
Why is that?
In order to understand that,
you have to understand the nature
of the roots of the plant.
A plant's roots
are able to create
an anaerobic layer
around the outside of the root
that actually breaks down waste
and makes it available to the plant
as nutrition.
So, in effect,
it creates its own chemical factory.
Now, it can do this best
in an environment
that is not being constantly
washed through by moving water.
So, as an area of the tank
becomes loaded with detritus,
thick with it, heavy with it,
the roots are able to find
a better show hole there
and are able to begin
producing nutrition.
And then somebody comes along
and cleans it all out.
And this becomes
the routine for maintaining
a gravel tank.
You clean it out
over and over and over,
unendingly cleaning it out.
I would submit to you
that instead of cleaning
a gravel tank,
you add a quarter of an inch
of gravel every time
you've got the urge to clean it.
By the time it's hit
four to six inches,
it would be maintaining
an anaerobic layer
that would effectively
break down waste in the tank.
Obviously, since the grains
of gravel are larger
than the grains of sand,
water is going to flow
through gravel at a higher rate
than the grains of sand.
So three to four inches,
really two and a half
to three and a half inches
of sand is enough
to create that anaerobic layer
where waste breaks down
and plants are able
to take up nutrition.
So that's kind of the key
of the matter.
Now, on the way down
through that layer
where the water is moving
through the substrate,
there are a whole lot
of other things going on.
So the deeper that substrate is,
the more naturally
the system can develop.
If you want to have a bit
of air tank,
you're welcome to it.
And if you follow
the lead of those like Lucas
who are doing it effectively,
you will have tanks
that you will be happy with
where plants are thriving.
If, however, you want
a heavily planted tank,
with lots of hardscape,
rocks and driftwoods
and the like,
then you need to have
a substrate,
if for no other reason
than to hold it all in place.
And that's really
kind of what it does.
It holds it all in place.
I think that's far enough
to go this time around.
If we can get that much
of the message out
and understood,
then there won't be the fear
about substrate
or the insistence
upon cleaning it all the time.
People who don't like sand
don't like it because
it's hard to clean.
Well, they should not be
trying to clean it.
The whole purpose
of a sand substrate
is to do away
with cleaning.
I have aquariums
that have been set up
for 20 years
with a 4-inch substrate
of sand.
They have never once
been cleaned.
And when I start seeing
little detritus
laying on the top,
I put a little more sand in.
And that takes care of the problem.
Now, this tank behind me
has some rather fun things
going on.
I want to show you this.
There's a pair of Dempsey's
right in the middle of it
who have dug a pit to the glass
and are nesting some eggs.
Let's take a look.
They are
right down
here.
You should be able
to see the eggs.
Let's get a little more light on this.
I don't know where I was
again in front.
Can you see the eggs?
They're right on the top
of the rock.
Now, I have
a couple of hundred
Jack Dempsey fry
that are about
a half an inch long.
So, I'm not going to
try to save these.
Look at the pit they've dug.
They're all the way down
to the glass.
And the tank that has
about four inches
of substrate.
There's no dirt in here
because they've got these
beasts that dig holes.
I thought this was
kind of interesting.
Notice that there's
no aggression going on.
They're keeping people away
without much
aggravation.
Protecting the middle
of the tank
from intruders.
We'll see how it goes
when they have baby.
I thought you would enjoy
seeing that.
Take care for now.
Talk to you again soon.
Have a wonderful day.
Be sure to subscribe
so you can get more of this
vast and vital
knowledge for your
hobby. And hit the
like button because we know
you loved it.
And don't forget to share.
Sharing is caring.
The more you share,
the more
we are able to reach out.
Reach out to the
world beyond.
And touch many lives
with the great and powerful
wisdom of Bob Fish.
Bye for now.