Industry Experts Warn Collapse Imminent Without Canada-U.S. Trade Deal

World News Updates
7 followers
Industry Experts Warn Collapse Imminent Without Canada-U.S. Trade Deal
#Gjwnews #WorldNewsUpdates #Neutral #worldnews
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedCanadian SMEs in the steel, auto, and mold-making sectors are facing a critical collapse due to US tariff restructuring and failed trade negotiations. With profit margins erased and government loan programs proving inadequate or too slow, industry leaders warn of a potential industrial collapse and significant job losses if a strategic trade agreement is not reached.
They recognize that within the next three to six months,
they're going to face very dire cashflow issues.
There was no industry in Canada.
Nobody survives 25%.
My shop will not survive these tariffs.
If you're a good company,
you might last three to six months.
Now, in speaking to some industry experts,
these companies are probably going to
start their collapse in spring.
Mark Carney might be smiling
and standing in front of cameras
and wanting to take credit for things
never being so good in Canada
with this latest announcement of a pipeline
to the West Coast.
But all is not well in the true North, strong and free.
We are at a point where some of our most important industries
are about to collapse,
and that will create a domino effect
that will ricochet across this country.
This is not sensationalism.
This is reality for thousands of businesses
across this country.
And I'm going to show you exactly what's going on.
Let's take a look.
The government has introduced a number of things.
Is this a viable solution in the short term,
or do you think it's going to simply worsen your situation?
Sorry, I missed the beginning.
The loan facilities introduced by the government for SMEs,
do you think it can be viable in the short or medium term,
or do you think it's simply going to worsen
your financial situation if there's no solution?
Loan facilities.
Well, I don't want to take any more loans at this time.
I don't want the government to loan me money
and have me reimburse the money.
That's not what I need.
I don't want to take on more debt at some point.
I have to repay loans taken from the banks.
So not anymore.
My next question is for Mr. Azobadi.
What do you think about the loan program?
Do you think it will help you
or worsen the financial situation of your company?
Because I think the government has come up
with some of such facilities.
Not a good option.
What we just talked about is that we are looking
to protect our profitability.
The less profitability we have,
the less money we have to be able to pay for the loans.
And we also still have to demonstrate to the government
that we're a profitable and viable company.
And by these measures,
we will not measure up to that standard.
So the loans aren't necessarily going to help
and we'll be lucky if we get them.
And again, as I said before,
you're trying to build a business,
but somebody has to take that product, right?
Competitiveness is only going to get us so far.
The 10 to 25% that we're going to see
doesn't get us there.
And if you figure it out in 18 months from now, 25% tariff,
there is no industry in Canada
that will survive a 25% tariff.
I don't care how much you invest,
how many machines you buy,
how many things you do in your plant
to try and make your business viable.
Nobody survives 25%.
In Burlington and Hamilton,
we have thousands of people who work
in the steel and auto sectors.
Tens of thousands of people
who are indirectly employed by those sectors.
When I talked to manufacturers in my community,
they're often SMEs, family owned,
upwards of 70 to 90% of their business
is in the United States,
but they have chosen to stay in Canada.
Mr. Donnelly, what would help your members
and companies like that in my riding
who are so reliant on the US market to diversify?
Do you have some examples for us?
Thank you, through you, Chair, to MP Gould.
You know, I briefly touched on it,
but right now what the industry is facing
is a 10% tariff on finished goods.
And my members, and I can speak to Southwestern Ontario,
specifically Windsor-Essex,
they recognize that within the next three to six months,
they are going to face very dire cashflow issues.
And what that means is, as I alluded earlier,
they're gonna have to make decisions.
And those decisions may be to close their shop,
because many of the ownership of these companies
are, you know, 50s, 60s, ready to close it up.
And they've been challenged with multiple challenges
over the past decade, decades.
That being said, they are getting requested
to move to the United States.
But that is a question that is out there
and is quite regular from some of the purchasers.
Third, early tariffs on steel and aluminum
forced us to adapt quickly,
often sourcing more expensive materials
to stay compliant.
And now with additional tariffs upwards,
reaching up to 50%,
we're being faced with a breaking point.
These measures will lead to more shops closures,
job losses, and erosion of highly specialized industries
that cannot easily be rebuilt once it's gone.
My shop will not survive these tariffs.
This was an emergency committee study
at the industry committee back in April, 2026.
This was shortly after the modification
of the 232 tariffs.
Now, what am I talking about here?
Just to recap for those that may be new to this issue.
So last year in 2025,
Donald Trump implemented these 232 tariffs,
and that put tariffs on steel.
So what these companies were having to do
is they were having to pay the tariff,
roughly 10%, on the value of the steel quantity
that was used in their product
if it wasn't American made steel.
Okay.
What happened in April of this year
is Donald Trump and his government
with the swipe of a pen
completely obliterated this industry.
What did they do?
They changed the tariff,
so it was no longer 10% on the value of the steel
that was in the product.
It was now 10% of the value of the entire product
that went over the border.
So as a brief example,
let's say your product,
you're selling to your customer for $100,
and there's $10 worth of US steel in there.
Under the previous tariffs,
you'd have to pay a $1 tariff.
After the new tariffs,
you would have to pay $10 in tariffs
because you're paying the value of the entire product.
Now, when these companies make single digit profit margins,
what has happened is your entire profit margin
is now gone,
and every product you are selling is now at a loss.
This is the issue.
And these companies,
they have made these agreements
and taken these orders a year ago.
So they've already agreed on the pricing with the customer,
and they based that price and that quote
on the pricing at the time and on the tariffs at the time.
And at the time, they all said,
we will eat the cost of the tariffs.
No problem, we can deal with that.
And that was to stay competitive.
Well, now you're a year in,
these companies are now going to have to pay
this massive increase in tariffs
because that's what they agreed to with the customer.
What are they supposed to do?
Now, you've heard some of them say, I don't need a loan.
Loans don't make any sense to me.
And you heard the representative
from the Chamber of Commerce down in Windsor saying,
some of these companies need cashflow issues.
Otherwise, they're not going to be here in six months.
Heard another business owner say,
I will not survive these tariffs if they continue.
That's what was going on in April.
John Azapardi, who was the second individual that you saw,
testifying in committee there, we had him on the show.
And this was his warning.
The one thing that you were saying over and over again
in committee is, what's the plan?
And I found that interesting because I've been in business.
I've been in large corporations.
There is typically a five-year plan that you talk about.
There's your one-year plan.
And then, you know, if you're really lucky,
you have a 10-year plan.
And everything that you folks were saying in committee is,
you can't even plan the next three months.
So talk us through that.
Is this as urgent as we're being led to believe
by all of the business owners?
Is it really, you know, you need to make decisions now
and you need to understand what the government plans to do
in order to actually make those decisions?
Ryan, you answered it perfectly.
Every business has a plan.
And I like to look at government
and especially foreign affairs as running like a business.
And if they don't have a plan,
they need to tell us they don't have a plan,
which would be just embarrassing,
but maybe they don't have a plan.
But they need to tell us if that is the plan.
If you do have a plan, let's talk about it
because right now you're asking us to play
an instrumental role in your plan.
And I couldn't have put it any more blunt to them.
You're literally asking us to hold the line
against the United States in a war
that was not created by us, but we got to hold the line.
Well, you posture and position
and do these things you need to do,
but you've got to include us in the plan
because I don't know how long you're talking.
Are you going to be done by July 1st?
Because this July 1st date keeps coming up.
Are you six months into that?
Are you a year into that?
And one of the questions they asked a lot was,
what do you need from us?
Well, I plan to answer that question for you, Ryan.
But at the time I still don't have a time horizon, right?
I don't have a timeline.
So is it a three month?
Well, you know, we'll probably be okay for three months,
but if you're going to go past the past three months,
I'm telling you now 10% doesn't sound like a lot
because it's between 10 and 50%, let's be clear,
but we think we're in the 10 to 15%,
but you got to remember one,
we didn't put that into our price to begin with
because we're working on stuff that was already awarded.
But secondly, we're talking about companies
who really operate on single digit profits, right?
You're talking to somebody who's making between five
and 8%, after they pay for everything else,
they got five or 8% to manage these tariffs.
They're not going to last,
and they're likely not going to want to last very long
because every day that goes by,
every, in my case, I build molds,
every mold or every piece of equipment they ship,
they're literally writing checks.
They're taping dollar bills
to every one of those pieces of equipment.
And we're not talking low cost equipment.
The United States is very good at this.
They were smart.
They knew exactly where to hit
where it was going to hurt the most.
We're talking very expensive, very high tech equipment
that when it goes across that border,
we're talking not hundreds of thousands of dollars.
We're likely talking about millions of dollars,
which means the tariff on that is really going to hurt.
We're not talking about a little bolt or a little strap.
We're talking about expensive equipment.
That's going to have millions of dollars of tariffs.
Like in companies for us,
every time we ship a mold across, we're losing money,
which means the longer we go,
staying in Canada is going to cost us money.
Now we have to look at what are our options
so that we can stop that bleeding.
Because what I'm telling you is,
if you're a good company,
you might last three to six months.
If you're a great company,
you've probably already got something in the United States
and you'll probably weather it longer.
If you're a small to medium sized company,
you just can't afford this.
Windsor is essentially the mold making capital of Canada.
It's not the only place that we have mold makers
and tool makers and dye makers in Canada,
but it's one of the biggest.
All of them are affected.
And then you have all of the indirect businesses
that are affected.
And you have the manufacturing businesses that are affected.
And right before these 232 tariffs were announced,
Washington Post actually did a story on one of them
that was struggling and was already losing 70%.
This is the Federal Economic Development Agency's
2025 departmental plan for Southern Ontario.
So this is part of the relief that they were looking at.
And this was announced back in 2025, folks, March of 2025.
Want to just call your attention
to a couple of the points here.
Point one, responding to US tariffs
that are impacting the economy of Southern Ontario
by providing targeted and timely support
to affected small and medium sized businesses.
Now, whenever you hear the term SME,
that means small, medium enterprises.
So the main issue is that these businesses were at committee
and they were screaming for a plan.
They got no plan.
They said, don't give us loans.
We don't need loans.
What did the government do?
We just don't sit idle waiting for things to happen.
We act.
And that's why today we announced $1.5 billion
to support our steel, aluminum and copper workers.
We're in a trade war, we're on the front lines
and the goal is to protect workers
and actually keep companies afloat.
So our goal is really to make sure ultimately
that the businesses keep their workforces
and that we can help them pivot.
Here's the problem.
So all these loans that they announced,
they're getting to some companies,
but it's taking forever to actually get there.
This is the main problem with this program.
You can argue whether or not it's a good idea
to give money in the first place.
Let's just say it is for the sake of argument.
Let's just say it's a good idea to give loans
and to give this money.
But when the money is taking forever
to actually get to these companies,
remember what that federal page said.
It said, in a timely manner.
What does timely mean to you?
Because I guarantee you,
it means something completely different
to the government that is actually managing this relief.
That company was forced to actually close some of their mills
and lay off 80% of their workforce in some cases
because they didn't get a response.
These mold, tool and dye industries
were counting on that trade deal to get done in August.
They were kind of holding their breath.
They were optimistic because of everything
that they had heard from the president and from Mark Carney.
And then it fell through.
No deal for tariff relief industries
and companies in Windsor react.
The Canadian Association of Moldmakers estimated
a few months ago that companies could write out
the US tariffs for another three to six months,
said Nicole Vlanich, the organization's executive director.
A collapse last week at the talks
that many had hoped would bring tariff relief
means companies will need government support
beyond loans if they're going to survive,
she said.
Quote, this is the first time that I haven't seen
overall optimism across the board
or a general feeling of we've gotten through worse,
we'll be okay, end quote, said Vlanich,
whose organization represents nearly 100 members,
that's 100 companies, around 60% of which
are in the Windsor-Essex area.
Quote, I think the overall hope is that both countries
get back to the negotiating table
because it is in the interest of both sides, end quote.
Some Windsor area businesses have been waiting months
for a reply from the federal government
after applying for financial help to deal with tariffs.
Companies were waiting since May
and had not received a response.
These are programs that are supposed to address
urgent concerns, address these tariffs.
Canada's Regional Tariff Response Initiative, or RTRI,
was launched in March 2025, and it's been expanding,
accepting business applications for both repayable
and non-repayable funding.
This funding is designed to help businesses respond.
While some money has been paid out locally,
like 20 million to 14 area companies back in May,
some say it's not flowing fast enough.
The local Chamber of Commerce head estimates
that over 100 local businesses
have applied for RTRI support.
The government did not answer questions
about how long applicants can expect to wait
for a response or how many applications it's reviewing.
The fascinating thing is that recently,
the Canadian Association for Moldmakers
actually had a meeting.
And at that meeting, they had a representative
from the federal government and the agency
that was responsible for distributing this funding.
We've received a copy of the, well,
the memorandum that went out after this meeting
to summarize what was actually spoken about.
We can't reveal who we received this from
for confidentiality purposes,
but this is where this video gets real, folks.
So this round table occurred on September 10th, 2026.
Purpose of the meeting,
CAM convened industry representative,
government officials, and support organizations
to provide an update
on current federal tariff response programs
and to hear directly from manufacturers
about the impacts of ongoing Canada-US trade uncertainty.
Several participants raised concerns
about applications that have already been submitted
and have remained under review for extended periods.
A key question was whether applicants
should withdraw and reapply
following the recent program enhancements.
FedDev subsequently clarified the following.
If an applicant is not changing its existing pivot project,
it does not need to submit a new application.
The applicant should advise FedDev
that it wishes to continue with the existing application.
If an applicant wants to add the new liquidity component,
that's basically cash,
the existing application must be withdrawn
and a new application submitted
using the updated application form.
The new application should include
both the pivot project and the liquidity request.
FedDev also confirmed
that withdrawing an existing application
specifically to add liquidity
will not result in the applicant being moved
to the back of the application queue.
Applicants should not maintain
an existing pivot application
while filing a separate second application for liquidity.
What does that mean?
Well, the government changed their program
in the middle of the program,
in the middle of people trying
to actually apply for the funding.
And so people are saying, so what do I do?
Do I have to submit a new application or what?
And they're saying, well, you know, in some cases, no,
in some cases, yes, but don't worry.
We're the government and we won't make,
we won't put you to the back of the queue
for the applications if you happen to do that.
Application processing times.
Processing times were a significant concern.
So this isn't just anecdotes people,
this is actual business owners providing this feedback
directly to government officials.
Participants reported existing applications
that had been outstanding for several months
with examples discussed of approximately five to six months.
FedDev acknowledged that processing times
have been too long in some cases.
The agency indicated that it has been directed
to look for ways to streamline the application
and assessment process and accelerate decisions.
No firm processing time commitment
was provided during the meeting.
Participants emphasized that the usefulness
of financial support is diminished
if companies experiencing immediate tariff-related pressure
must wait several months for a decision.
Challenges for small and medium-sized manufacturers.
This is the SMEs folks.
Participants emphasized that many small
and medium-sized manufacturers
do not have dedicated internal government relations,
funding or grant application teams.
Preparing a government applications
can therefore create a considerable
administrative and financial burden.
Steel tariffs and availability.
Steel was one of the most significant issues
raised during the round table.
Naturally, because that's where it's hitting them.
Mold makers explained that many of the specialized grades
of steel required to manufacture injection molds
are not produced domestically in sufficient quantities
or specifications, aka they can't get Canadian steel.
Companies therefore rely heavily on steel
originating from Europe or the United States.
What does that mean folks?
That means the counter tariffs that Mark Carney
just put in is crushing their industry.
Steel supply constraints.
Concerns were also raised about the availability
of steel produced in Ontario.
Participants reported that US demand for Canadian steel
is placing pressure on domestic supply.
Manufacturers in other segments
of the metalworking industry reported
experiencing material shortages
and having to redesign products
around whatever steel is available.
The discussion suggested that steel supply constraints
could continue into 2027.
Participants emphasized that tariffs and supply constraints
cannot be examined separately
because both ultimately affect manufacturer's ability
to quote, produce and deliver product.
Current business levels do not tell the full story.
Major concern raised during the discussion
was that the current shop activity
may create a misleading picture of the industry's health.
Remember what I told you about their working on products
that they've actually been quoted a year ago
and they were ordered a year ago.
Many mold makers are currently completing projects
that were quoted months ago,
awarded before the current tariff environment
and designed and engineered long before production began.
As a result, many shops may currently appear busy.
However, participants reported that new quoting
and future activity are significantly more concerning.
Companies described customers delaying
or withholding future projects
because the final landed cost of Canadian tooling
cannot be predicted.
That's that certainty issue.
Canada-US trade relationship.
Participants repeatedly emphasized the importance
of achieving a negotiated trade outcome
with the United States.
The prevailing industry view
was that escalating retaliatory tariffs
that Mark Carney just put in,
create additional costs for manufacturers
on both sides of the border
and do not provide the certainty businesses need.
Participants emphasized that the United States
remains Canada's largest customer
and an essential part
of the North American manufacturing supply chain.
The preferred outcome expressed during the discussion
was certainty, stability and a negotiated agreement
that allows Canadian and US manufacturers
to continue doing business together.
Canadian company described pressure from a US customer
to relocate production to the United States
because of tariffs.
We've heard this discussed in committee earlier.
However, moving production would also require
transferring Canadian developed intellectual property,
technology and proprietary know-how.
Participants noted that this represents a broader risk
than simply losing individual sales.
Trade measures could contribute
to the migration of IP, manufacturing processes,
technology, proprietary designs, technical knowledge
and product production capability
from Canada to the United States.
Now, in speaking to some industry experts,
here's the good news.
The good news is that these companies
are probably going to start their collapse in spring.
Why is that good news?
Because they're not going to lay their workers off
before Christmas.
That's the good news.
And what happens after that?
Well, as we've been warning folks,
we've been warning since April,
if there is no trade deal
and these companies start to go down,
this is the trunk of the tree.
When you remove the trunk of the tree,
the branches and the leaves start to die.
So the estimates I've been given
is about six months after that,
basically a year from today,
you're going to start to see all of the supporting
and all of the manufacturing industries,
they will start to go down.
And by go down, I mean go out of business
and move to the United States
or go out of business permanently.
That's 2.1 million jobs in this country at risk.
This is not me making this stuff up.
This is coming directly from people
that live in this industry every day,
that manage this industry every day,
that support this industry every day.
Spring and then fall.
All they want is a trade deal.
They need certainty.
They need to know what they're dealing with.
They need to know what their costs are.
And they need it now.
