Akoya Pearls and The Story of Mikimoto ft. Certified Pearl Expert Matt Harris

Secret Life of Pearls
4 followers
Oct 2, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video features pearl expert Matt Harris, who explains the differences between natural and cultured pearls, focusing specifically on Akoya pearls. He clarifies common misconceptions about pearl origins, discusses the quality factors that determine value, and explores the historical legacy of Kokichi Mikimoto, the pioneer of cultured pearls.
I get people all day long saying,
hey, do you have any Nicky Modos?
And then my first question to them is,
do you mean Nicky Modos or do you mean Akoya?
Why are some pearls more expensive than others?
How do you know if the pearls you're buying are real pearls?
And why is that so different
from shopping for natural pearls?
What are Akoya pearls?
And what makes them so slap-ya-mama fantastic?
Today, pearl expert Matt Harris from Matt Harris Designs
is going to help us understand the OG of cultured pearls,
the legacy of Nicky Modo himself.
Many customers and sometimes even jewelry professionals
may ask this question about a strand of pearls.
Are these pearls freshwater or cultured?
And the truth is, those are not opposite things.
Most freshwater pearls being sold today
are in fact cultured.
What someone might mean to ask
when they say are these pearls cultured
is actually are these pearls Akoya?
Cultured pearls are real,
but they're not technically natural.
Natural pearls are real.
They're both real pearls.
Natural pearls are pearls that are made well naturally
without the assistance of a human.
That is kind of an accident of nature,
a mollusk that has whatever irritant come inside
and create a pearl.
So that's a natural pearl.
When you talk about cultured pearls,
now there's freshwater and there's saltwater in general.
So freshwater pearls are,
this is really easy on this one.
There's pearls that are made in lakes or streams,
where saltwater pearls are pearls
that are grown in saltwater, so oceans.
Now we're talking about Akoya in the saltwater world.
It's generally broken up into Akoya, South Seas,
and Tahitian.
That doesn't mean they're not level.
There's just three of them.
I'm not putting one above the other
and the Akoyas are gorgeous,
but those are three types of saltwater pearls.
So then what is an Akoya pearl
and what makes them so darn special?
Akoya is the common name of the mollusk
that produces the pearl, right?
And these are mostly from Japan, some in China.
They tend to be about six to eight millimeters in width.
If you get above 10, it's really rare, really expensive.
I just saw a strand today.
Somebody sent me a picture of 11 millimeters,
which is unheard of.
Grading is kind of a weird thing in pearls.
You might want to check out my video,
How Not to Buy Pearls, featuring Jeremy Shepherd,
where we explain that most pearl grading is crap,
garbage, useless.
But pearls do have value,
and that value has to be based on something.
The quality factors that give a pearl its beauty, rarity,
and ultimately, its price.
When examining Akoya for quality,
you must consider size.
When all other factors are equal, the biggest pearl wins.
Luster, shape, surface, color,
nacre quality, and how well the strand is matched.
Anyways, on Akoya, it's all about the luster.
So the luster is unreal.
It's like mirror-like.
And when it comes to Akoyas,
the luster is king on those, right?
So a lusterous Akoya pearl
that is maybe slightly blemished,
that's the same size as a non-blemished,
less lusterous pearl,
is gonna be more expensive and more sought after.
And that's the beauty of these Akoyas.
They're so incredibly lusterous.
And it's interesting, with the Oyster II,
they only produce once.
Once you harvest a pearl, you can't put it back.
You know, Tahitian oysters,
you can take sometimes, if the oyster's in good shape,
another nuclei and put it back in the oyster
and make a pearl again.
If you've learned something you didn't already know,
please smash that like button.
And if you want to deep dive into pearl nerddom,
you can take CPAA's
Pearls as One Educational Online Course for free
by clicking the link in the description
and using the code JOT at checkout,
J-O-T-T, for Jewels of the Trade.
But you can't talk about Akoya
without talking about Mikimoto.
What happened here is Mikimoto is known
kind of as like the grandfather of cultured pearls, right?
So he was really one of the early pioneers
of cultured pearls.
And he figured out how to create cultured pearls
in the late 1800s.
But when he was doing it,
they were like hemispherical shapes.
So they were Mabe pearls.
So he's using the Akoya mollusk
and creating Mabe pearls, not round pearls.
And he was successful at it.
And he was the only one that was.
And they were so successful that he even opened a store.
They say that he had over a million oysters by 1902.
Pearls were natural before then.
They weren't cultured.
People weren't making them or farming them.
And so this was the beginning of a huge change
in the pearl industry.
So to step four.
So he, in 1905, succeeded in growing a whole pearl, right?
And instead of inserting the nuclei
into like different parts of the mollusk,
he wrapped the nucleus with mantle tissue
from another mollusk and inserted it.
So he was onto something.
But he had some patent issues, worked it all out.
And I think the date was 1916
that he was full process making mass-produced
Akoya round cultured pearls.
He opened a store in Tokyo in 1899,
was selling the pearls successfully.
And then as he developed these round pearls,
he started opening stores all over the world strategically
in luxury places like London, Paris, New York, Chicago.
A lot of these stores opened after World War II.
Very popular with a lot of the American servicemen.
A fantastic marketer.
But he, by 1938, was producing 11 million pearls a year.
They became extremely popular
and they were sold in every luxury market you can imagine.
And so no wonder he's kind of considered
the grandfather of cultured pearls.
Now, what that did, though, to the marketplace,
and again, this is an hour video on itself,
which is really interesting,
is the natural pearl industry suffered a little bit
because of this, well, a lot because of this.
And prices went down because now you can buy cultured pearls
and there's so many of them.
As a matter of fact, it got to the point
where there was actually a problem
that there were so many cultured pearls.
So it really hurt the natural pearl market
and the valuation of natural pearls.
If you're enjoying Matt's pearls of wisdom,
be sure to check out his YouTube channel
and visit his website, link in the description.
This is the important thing to know as a consumer.
Mikimoto is a brand, right?
And a koi is what we've been talking about.
It's a type of pearl.
So Mikimoto used a koi of pearls.
However, you can buy a koi of pearls
without having it in Mikimoto.
So that means you're not buying it from a Mikimoto shop
or you're not buying an existing strand
that has a little Mikimoto with a little M clasp on it.
You can absolutely participate in a koi of pearl fashion
without buying a Mikimoto
and probably save some money doing so.
But then there's a lot of people that say
they just got to have that Mikimoto strand.
He passed away, I believe, I might get this wrong, 1954.
I'm almost certain that's what it was.
Mikimoto is a company still around.
Now he was always known for using not just a koi
but like high quality koi.
And I read a story once, haven't fact-checked it,
but it sounds kind of fun about him.
Even on a public display, I think it may have been Paris
burning a pile of not quite up to par koi of pearls
to show that he didn't use the bad stuff.
However, over time, there has been,
Mikimoto is known for using
like very high quality Mikimoto pearls.
There have been brands that have done,
that have been made under the Mikimoto name,
like Sea Magic, for example,
that have been lesser quality koi.
And there have been some brands in Mikimoto,
believe it or not, that have been freshwater pearls.
Yeah, and in some of these brands,
they were brands that were like sub-brands
that were made to put into the marketplace
like the big mall retailers.
So if you're buying a Mikimoto,
if you're going on eBay and looking for Mikimoto,
just because it says Mikimoto
don't necessarily pay the high price,
see what kind of Mikimoto it is.
We could easily make a hundred videos about Akoya pearls.
There is so much to discuss in the realm of Akoya,
whether it's science, history, keshi pearls,
Mikimoto, Hanadama quality, treatment, sustainability,
the list goes on.
Luckily, many of these topics are covered in the forum,
pearlguide.com, it's pearl-guide.com,
where you can chat with pearl industry leaders
about all the nitty gritty details
surrounding the world of pearls.
Here's Matt's advice for buying Akoya pearls.
Be careful buying online.
Oh my goodness.
I saw the other day a company on Facebook
selling colored Akoyas,
and they were coming out like bubblegum pink and blue.
And there's a video of somebody reaching into a stream
and pulling out this mollusk and opening it up.
And they were selling them as Akoyas.
There's a lot of that stuff going on.
So I would say, you know, buy from a reputable dealer.
How do you determine a reputable dealer?
Do some research, kind of Google.
You'll figure this out and watch people like you
because you're only gonna interview people
like that are reputable.
Or buy in person from a reputable store.
There's nothing like seeing a pearl in your hand.
Oh my gosh, I forgot to show you this.
I just grabbed a lot of Akoya, for example.
I mean, they're the most beautiful things ever.
This is all just Akoya out of a drawer.
In person, you just can't beat seeing an Akoya in person.
