#BronzeAgeCollapse#AncientHistory#Hittites Around 1100 BC, an Assyrian king taxed a ruler he called the king of the land of Hatti, a century after the Hittite empire was gone. What came after the collapse of the Late Bronze Age, and why did some places carry on while others never came back?
This episode tests four answers that are often given (scale, the palace, trade and an old name) region by region: Ugarit, Hattusa and the Greek palaces; Tiryns; Carchemish and the Neo-Hittite kingdoms; Taita, king of Palistin, and the debate at Tell Tayinat; Cyprus; the Phoenician cities and the alphabet; Lefkandi; the highland villages of Canaan and Megiddo's "New Canaan"; Assyria and Egypt. The close gives one reading of the evidence, never a proven cause.
Chapters 0:00 The king of a land that was gone 2:33 The ones that did not come back 4:11 The heirs of the Hittites 10:56 Cyprus 13:49 The cities by the sea 16:31 Villages, a hall, and the old empires 21:06 What the tests suggest
Sources (a selection of the fact-check's entries) Hawkins, J. D. (1988), Anatolian Studies 38: Kuzi-Tešub and the "Great Kings" of Karkamiš. Hawkins, J. D. (2011), Anatolian Studies 61: the inscriptions of the Aleppo temple. Weeden, M. (2015), "The Land of Walastin at Tell Tayinat", NABU 2015/2, no. 44, pp. 65–66. Janeway, B. (2013), PhD thesis, University of Toronto: the Aegean-style pottery at Tell Tayinat. Goedegebuure, P. et al. (2020), Anatolian Studies 70: TÜRKMEN-KARAHÖYÜK 1. Tiglath-pileser I, the royal inscriptions (RIMA 2, A.0.87), via ORACC. Meyer, N. and Knapp, A. B. (2021), Journal of World Prehistory 34: Cyprus in the transition to the Iron Age. Erb-Satullo, N. (2019), Journal of Archaeological Research 27: the early iron evidence. Morpurgo Davies, A. and Olivier, J.-P. (2012), "Syllabic scripts and languages in the second and first millennia BC", in Parallel Lives. Finkelstein, I. (2013), The Forgotten Kingdom (SBL, open access): the highlands and "New Canaan". The Oxford Lefkandi project: the Toumba building.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video analyzes the aftermath of the Late Bronze Age collapse (c. 1200 BC) in the eastern Mediterranean. It examines why certain societies vanished while others endured, testing theories regarding settlement scale, independence from centralized palace power, the maintenance of maritime trade, and the use of traditional titles to establish political legitimacy.
About 1100 years before Christ, an Assyrian king, Tiglath-Pileser I, marched west to the
Mediterranean. His inscriptions still speak of Carchemish of the land of Hatti, and on his way
home, by his own account, he taxed a ruler named Eni-Teshub, whom he calls the king of the land of
Hatti. Hatti was the land of the Hittites, but by then the Hittite empire had been gone for about a
century. Its capital, Hattusa, stood empty. So why was there still a king of a land that
no longer existed? And why, when so much around it had fallen, did this corner of the old world
carry on? Four answers are often given. Was it scale? Did small places outlast big ones?
The palace? Did life that did not run through a palace carry on? Trade? Did those who could still
move goods recover first? Or an old name? Did a title from the old world help a new ruler hold on,
like that king of Hatti? This episode puts those four answers to the test, region by region.
In each place, did life carry on, did it rebuild in a new form, or did it never come back?
First, the collapse itself, in one minute. In the decades around 1200 BC, the great palaces
of the eastern Mediterranean were destroyed or abandoned. Hattusa in Anatolia, Ugarit on the
Syrian coast, Pylos and Mycenae in Greece. In Greece, the palace script, Linear B, went out of
use with the palaces. Writing then disappears from Greece for about four centuries. Some historians
use one year, 1177 BC, as a symbol of that end. It is a date chosen as a symbol, not the day a world
stopped. The collapse itself was the subject of an earlier episode on this channel. The historian
Erich Klein, who has written about both the collapse and what came after it, describes the
aftermath as a collapse and a transformation at the same time, depending on where you look.
Some societies in his framework endured, some transformed, some failed. That is his framework,
and this episode borrows its question, not its answers.
Start with the places that did not return. Ugarit, on the coast of Syria, was destroyed
early in the 12th century BC and it was never rebuilt as a city. Hattusa, the Hittite capital
in central Anatolia, was not stormed in a single great battle, as far as the evidence shows.
Its court abandoned it. And in Greece, the palaces at Pylos, Mycenae and elsewhere never came back.
No palace was built in Greece again. All three had one thing in common, their power ran through
a palace. When the palace went, much of what depended on it may have gone too. That would
fit the second answer, dependence on the palace, but it is only the first test.
Now look at a town where the palace fell and the town did not. At Tiryns, in the Argolid,
the palace on the citadel was destroyed around 1200, but below it, people rebuilt their houses
on top of the destruction debris. The lower town grew to some 20 to 25 hectares,
by the estimate of its excavator, the archaeologist Joseph Maron, and archaeologists
see new leading families there, organizing the place without a palace. So at Tiryns,
life below the palace carried on and a smaller, looser organization replaced a great one.
That fits both the palace answer and the scale answer.
Now back to the king on the Euphrates. Carchemish was a Hittite city on the
great bend of the Euphrates. In the days of the empire, a Hittite king,
Suppiluliuma I, had installed his own line there to rule the region for him.
At a site called Lida-Heryuk on the east bank of the Euphrates, excavators found two impressions
of one seal pressed into lumps of clay. The seal names two men, Kuzi-Teshub,
king of the land of Carchemish, and his father, Talmi-Teshub, king of the land of Carchemish.
Talmi-Teshub was the last known king of the line the Hittite emperor had installed. His son,
Kuzi-Teshub, was a king of Carchemish in the empire's own time.
Then the empire fell, and his family did not fall with it. Later, his descendants,
who ruled at Malatia, carved inscriptions that call him a great king.
That was the title of the Hittite emperor himself.
That may be the old name at work. Two separate records point the same way.
His descendants' inscriptions give Kuzi-Teshub the emperor's title.
And around 1100 BC, the Assyrian Tiglath Pileser I still wrote of Carchemish of the land of Hatti,
and taxed a ruler he called the king of the land of Hatti.
Whoever that ruler was, the empire's name had outlived the empire.
Around Carchemish, a group of small kingdoms grew up that historians call the Neo-Hittite states.
Carchemish itself, Malatia, Gurgum, Hamath, Tarbal, and others.
For centuries, their kings went on writing Luwian, a language related to Hittite,
in the old hieroglyphic signs of the empire.
Small states and an old name. So far, the Neo-Hittite kingdoms fit two of the answers.
Then, in 2003, excavators in the Temple of the Storm God, inside the citadel of Aleppo,
exposed a long inscription carved beside the image of the king who made it,
a dedication to the Storm God.
The king was Titer, and the inscription names his land.
The name is Red Palestine, or Walestine.
By the shape of its signs, the inscription is dated to about the 11th century BC,
a time once thought to have left no written records in this region at all.
Palestine sounds like Philistine, and the Philistines were the Peleset of the Egyptian
records, one of the peoples we now call the Sea Peoples, later living on the southern coast of
Canaan, at Ashkelon, Ashdod, and Gaza. So was Palestine a kingdom of Philistines, far to the
north. The epigrapher who published Titus' inscriptions, David Hawkins, writes that the
region's archaeology shows an influx of people of Aegean connections, bringing a distinctive
pottery with them. Others, such as the historian Trevor Bryce, stress that a link between Palestine
and the Philistines remains a hypothesis. To test it, go to where Palestine was probably ruled from.
Its capital was probably at Tell Tayinat, a mound in the Amuq Plain in the northern Levant.
Here, the answer to this episode's question is plain. Surveys of the Amuq found that almost
every site lived in during the Late Bronze Age went on being lived in during the Early Iron Age.
The most notable exception was Tell Atshana, the old city of Alalak. Tayinat, its sister site close
by, appears to have taken its place. What was Tayinat just after the collapse? Brian Janeway,
who studied the pottery of the Tell Tayinat excavation, writes that renewed excavations
suggest a rudimentary village settlement may have been constructed. In it they found a painted
pottery in the Aegean style, the style archaeologists call Late Helladic 3C it was made on the spot,
not imported, in what Janeway calls a hybrid style that fused Aegean shapes and motifs
with local traditions. Who made it? Here the evidence divides, and both readings are argued
by people who have studied it. The survey archaeologist Jan Forstrater proposed a new
taste. When the palace economies and their trade broke down, local potters made Aegean-style wares
for a wider market. The other reading is newcomers. Janeway concludes that the nature and relative
amount of this pottery favors a traditional migration model, and he adds other clues.
Aegean-style loom weights, clay figurines, and potters marks in the old script of Cyprus.
And in 2015, the Hittitologist Mark Whedon, publishing a new join of two inscribed fragments
found at Tayinat, wrote that connections with the Philistines of the south
remain hypothetical and difficult to envisage. So this episode leaves it there, Palestine and
Philistines, a hypothesis argued both ways. The inscriptions do show a kingdom with a new name,
writing in the old Hittite hieroglyphs in the 11th century, most likely ruled from this valley.
Later, Palestine was succeeded by a kingdom called Patina, or Unki, which lasted until
the Assyrians conquered it late in the 8th century. One more old title. In June 2019,
archaeologists surveying a large mound in the Konya plain, Turkmen-Qara Huryuk, found a block
of stone carved with Luwian hieroglyphs. It names Great King Hartapu, son of Mursuli, and it claims
that he conquered the land of Muska, which its editors identify with the Phrygians, and that the
gods delivered 13 kings to him. When did Hartapu rule? That is debated. The scholar David Hawkins
had placed the Hartapu inscriptions soon after the empire's end, in the 12th or 11th century.
The new stone's editors, the Hittitologist Petra Gudugaburra and her colleagues at the
University of Chicago, date it by its script to the 8th century. Either way, a king was still
calling himself Great King, in the old Hittite manner, in a land far from the old capital.
Cyprus had been a source of copper in the late Bronze Age. Most of the copper on the Uluburun
shipwreck from the first episode of this series came from the island. Its answer to the collapse
was not one answer. Around 1200, some of its centers were abandoned abruptly, without any
apparent destruction before. Others were abandoned after destructions. But at the same time, at
Kittion on the south coast and at Pallipafos in the west, people started new monumental buildings.
Some places emptied, others grew. Cyprus was also among the early users of a new metal.
In an 11th century cemetery near Pallipafos, at a place called Skales, archaeologists found
blades of iron, some decorated with gold and silver. Iron is often given as an answer of its
own. An older idea, going back to the archaeologist Gordon Child, held that iron democratized,
access to metal. The evidence now tells a slower story. Iron's first major spread came in the late
2nd and early 1st millennium BC, and early iron objects often copied the shapes of bronze ones.
A recent review of the evidence calls the democratizing idea a common refrain,
and warns against confusing what an invention later changed with why people first took it up.
Iron did not suddenly remake these societies. In one of the Skales tombs, tomb 49, lay a long
bronze spit. On it are signs written in the island's old Bronze Age script, yet they read
as Greek, Ὁπελετὰ οὐ Ἀβοφέλτης. It is one of the earliest Greek names written on Cyprus,
from a tomb of about 1000 BC. Did Cyprus' later kingdoms grow out of this transformation?
Scholars disagree. The archaeologist Maria Iakovou argues that the process that led to them
began no later than the 12th century. Others, the anthropologist Nathan Mayer and the archaeologist
Bernard Knapp, argue that the island's Iron Age is not simply a continuation of its Bronze Age
forms, and that its people negotiated something new. What both sides agree on is the pattern.
On Cyprus, some places vanished while others grew in the same generation.
And the island's story joins the next one. In the 9th century BC, Phoenicians from the mainland
coast established a settlement at Kittion. The cities by the sea were reaching out again.
On the coast of what is now Lebanon, three old cities came through the collapse as cities,
Tyre, Sidon, and Byblos. When the Assyrian king Tiglath-Pileser I reached this coast
around 1100, his inscriptions describe what he found. He marched to Mount Lebanon and cut
beams of cedar for his god's temple. Byblos, Sidon, and Arwad paid him, and among the payment,
he lists a crocodile and a large female monkey. He even rode, he says, in the boats of the people
of Arwad out on the sea. These cities still had ships, cedar, and goods to give. Whatever
had happened to the palaces inland, the harbor towns were still working. A later Egyptian story,
The Tale of Wenamun, is set in about 1070 BC. It is a literary text, not a report, but it shows
the prince of Byblos bargaining hard with Egypt's Env over timber and making him wait.
In Eric Klein's framework, the Phoenician cities are among those that did well under the stress of
the collapse. The evidence here is consistent with that. These harbor cities, which could
still move goods by sea, are among the places that carried on. At Byblos, a stone sarcophagus
carries an inscription for a king named Ahiram. The sarcophagus may be older than its inscription,
but the inscription on its lid, usually dated around 1000 BC, though some date it much earlier,
is one of the earliest known examples of the fully developed Phoenician alphabet.
It has 22 letters, and they write only consonants. Those letters traveled. In the 9th and 8th
centuries, Greeks adapted the Phoenician alphabet, using some of its letters to write vowels. Among
the earliest Greek alphabetic inscriptions is a line scratched on a jug found in Athens,
the Dipylon jug, from around 740 BC and another on a cup from Pithecusae in the Bay of Naples.
After about four centuries without writing, Greece could write again with borrowed letters.
And the two worlds met in one stone. At Karatepe, in the hills of southern Turkey,
an 8th-century ruler named Asatewada set up an inscription in two languages, Phoenician and
Luwian, side by side. Found in 1946, it helped scholars read the Luwian hieroglyphs of the old
Hittite world. Greece had no palaces and for a time no writing, but it was not empty. At Lefkandi,
on the island of Euboea, archaeologists found a building from the middle of the 10th century BC,
about 50 meters long. Under its central room were two shafts. In one, a man had been cremated with
his weapons, and his ashes placed in a large bronze mixing vessel, a crater. Beside him lay
a woman, buried with remarkable jewelry. In the other shaft were four horses. The crater had been
made in Cyprus around 1100 BC. By the time it held his ashes, it was already old, and the grave
around the building held goods imported from the eastern Mediterranean. So even in a Greece without
palaces, someone at Lefkandi could still reach across the sea for luxury goods. Trade again
lines up with the places that came through. Now one map and four different answers.
In the central highlands of Canaan, surveys suggest that the number of settlements grew
from about 30 in the 13th century BC to about 250 by the early 10th. They were small,
unwalled villages, with houses of a common plan, the four-room house, and storage jars with a
raised ring below the neck. By the archaeologist Israel Finkelstein's figures, their built-up area
grew from about 50 hectares to about 220, which means, he writes, that the settled population grew
to at least four times its size, perhaps 45,000 people by the early 10th century. Who they were
is debated. Finkelstein reads them as local people, some long-settled, some former herders.
Most of these villages went on without a break into the time of the Kingdom of Israel,
and in his reading, this wave of settlement gave birth to early Israel. These were not palaces or
cities, they were many small places living without a palace. That fits scale and the palace answer.
In the valleys below, something else happened. At Megiddo, the late Bronze Age city was partly
destroyed, but early in the Iron Age it was fully resettled, and within a few decades it had grown
into a large and prosperous city again. Finkelstein finds it strikingly similar to the
late Bronze Age city before it, about the same size, with a palace in the north near the gate,
and the same great temple still in use. He calls this revival New Canaan. Its prosperity, he writes,
stemmed from the stability of the rural sector and from vibrant exchange with Phoenicia.
Here, in Finkelstein's reading, an old city system may have come back, and trade came back with it.
It did not last. Late in the Iron Age period, the cities of New Canaan burned. At Megiddo,
the fire was so intense that the mudbricks turned red. Its excavators in the 1930s called it the
Red Brick City. Who destroyed it is still argued. A major earthquake, the conquests the Bible gives
to King David, and the campaign of the Egyptian pharaoh Shoshenq I have all been proposed.
Assyria is the opposite case, a large state that bent but did not break. Tiglath-Pileser I fought
the Arameans again and again, groups he pursued, he says, from Tadmar in the Syrian desert down
the Euphrates. He claims that he crossed the Euphrates 28 times, twice in one year, in pursuit
of them. By the 8th century, there would be Aramean kingdoms beside the Neo-Hittite ones.
After him, Assyria's power declined for a long time. Then, in the 10th century, two kings,
Ashurdan II and Aded-Nirari II, rebuilt its power. That was the start of the Near-Assyrian Empire.
So here a large state did come back. Size alone did not doom it.
Egypt came through too, but divided. Around 1070 BC, the new kingdom ended. The country was then
ruled from Tanis in the north, while in the south, at Thebes, the high priests of Ammon held power.
So what do the tests suggest? Here is one reading of this evidence, and only one. The places whose
life ran through a palace, Ugarit, Hattusa, the palaces of Greece, did not come back as they were.
The places where life did not depend on a palace, the lower town of Tiryns, the villages of the
highlands, carried on or grew. And in the Ammuk, almost every old site went on being lived in.
The places that could still trade by sea, the Phoenician cities, parts of Cyprus, left Kandy,
reached out again early. And in the valleys of Canaan, a revived city system traded with Phoenicia
until it burned. An old title seems to have helped some new rulers hold on.
Khuzi Teshub's descendants remembered him as a great king, and a century later an Assyrian
still wrote of the land of Hatti. And size alone does not explain much. Small places vanished,
and Assyria, a large state, came back. That fits Eric Klein's resilience argument.
That smaller scale, trade outside the palace and flexibility helped some societies through.
But it is one proposed answer, not a proven cause. The evidence is patchy. It is region by region,
and in many places we still cannot tell why one town lived and the next one died.
By the 8th century BC, the map was full again. A new Assyrian empire, Phoenician cities trading
across the sea, Greek towns writing with an alphabet, Neo-Hittite and Aramean kingdoms,
Israel and Judah, the cities of the Philistines. Some were old cities, some were new kingdoms.
But the palaces of Ugarit and of Greece never came back. And on the Euphrates, for a while,
the name of a vanished empire went on being used,
in the inscriptions of its heirs and in the records of an Assyrian king.