Music Chat: The World's Most Beautiful Melodies (No. 3) Brahms and Gluck

Tender Tones
140 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello friends, this is Dave Hurwitz, Executive Editor at ClassicsToday.com here with our
most beautiful melodies in the world. This is the third in an ongoing series and I've tried to
do a bunch of them all at once just so I can get it started and so that I can mention some of your
picks and of course start the whole ball rolling here for the following year, for 2021, because
today is Christmas Day 2020 and I want to wish you all the very, very best for the holidays
and if you're watching this in July of 2375, what can I tell you? You know when we did this
historically. What a dismal year it's been, has it not? My goodness, the pandemic is raging and
everybody is sequestered and basically miserable, but we have each other, we have our music,
we have our families, we have our pets, right people? I know, go have fun over there. She's
sitting over there watching us and you know, things could be worse, what can I tell you?
I'm just so delighted to be able to be here and present these chats and I am so grateful, as I've
said before, for the fact that you've joined me in these and that you've submitted your own
suggestions for the most beautiful melody in the world, in your opinion, and there is no right or
wrong with this. They are quite an assortment and I'm going to talk about two of them. Now,
the first one comes from Dale Hurwitz. Well, this was sort of a parental obligation one because Dale
Hurwitz is my mother and I really have to do this, not just because her birthday is coming up in a
few days and I'm not going to say how old she is, but because if I don't do it, I'm going to be in
big, big trouble and you should all know this. You know, my mother watches every single video that I
do and she reads every single comment. You know, when we talk about these things, she doesn't talk
about the videos, she calls me up and she talks about the comments. So, watch out because if you
aren't nice, you're going to have to deal with mom and you don't want that, believe me. My mother,
let me just tell you a few things to get started here. My mother is the coolest mom probably that
ever lived. I mean, and of course, everyone says that about their mother unless they were like,
you know, evil and horrible, but I'm not kidding. My mother was like the mother that everybody went
to even if she wasn't their mother because she was everyone's mother. You know what I mean?
There's always like one of those in the neighborhood. That was my mother. She was
the mother of us all, as Virgil Thompson said in his opera by Gertrude Stein. And what an
astonishing life she's had. I mean, my mom, my mom was a teacher for her entire career.
She got another master's degree while she was teaching in history. She became an adjunct
professor for Southern Connecticut State College where she was responsible for running the teacher
certification program for the state of Connecticut, basically, you know, really.
And with all of that, you know, going on, she raised three kids and had dinner on the table
every day at six o'clock. You know, we don't credit, I think, women particularly for their
unbelievable competence and ability to juggle things and organize life and just really,
really a remarkable person. And not the least of which was of her accomplishments,
if accomplishment it was, was that my mother really got me into classical music.
If you saw the video I did about my dad, who was actually the musically talented one,
he played the piano, but hated it and didn't want to have anything to do with it because of the way
it was forced on him when he was a kid. My mother taught me to love this stuff.
And she did it in the best way possible. I mean, my mother was an educator,
an educator down to her toes and fingertips and in everything she did. And it was just
such a natural, natural thing. And the way I picked up classical music was from her record
collection, mostly when she did housework. For the most part, we had classical music
always to housework. Dusting was always the can-can from Offenbach's Gete Parisienne.
You could not dust without the can-can going. And the other two big pieces were Schubert's
Unfinished Symphony, which, you know, she taught me the words, you know, I'm sure some of you know
them, you know, this is the symphony that Schubert never finished. Now that was, that was vacuuming
or straightening up in one way, but major, major housework, long projects was Brahms' First
Symphony. This is my mother's favorite piece of music. It really is. And she wrote to me,
she wrote to me as a comment and asked that I, that I present the big tune from the finale of
Brahms' First Symphony. And I am not going to say no, no way am I saying no. Let me, let me read to
you what she wrote, because I think, I think it's very, very telling. She writes, I feel a
certain measure of entitlement as David's mom. My favorite tune is the finale of Brahms' First,
which I played almost every day. I think it goes well with household chores and grading papers.
It has a special finish to it that I love. Well, I can only agree. I mean, that was my experience
growing up. But I think the thing that separates her vision of the classics from a lot of peoples
that I know is that growing up, they were such a normal part of our life. And when she talks
about grading papers and doing housework, I know some people would go, oh God, the classics,
you know, they're supposed to be listened to with complete attention, with folded hands,
you know, sitting there with monumental silence. Certainly you're not running the vacuum cleaner
while they're going. But the point that she made was that this is just a wonderful part
of our normal existence. And that's how it's always been for me. And that's what I try to
convey in doing these chats with you too, that this music is, yes, it can be a special occasion.
Yes, it's high art. It's all of those things. But, but to make it a part of your life,
you have to adopt a certain attitude of normalcy to the whole, the whole enterprise. And that's
what, that's what mom always had when it came to this music. Listening to Brahms first was as
natural for her as, as going to, you know, a football game wrapped in a blanket and watching
my brother play football in the snow up at Colgate University where he was on the football team.
I mean, my mother was a sports freak. She knew more about sports than anyone in the world. That's
my father married her and she still is. She can talk about Brahms just as easily as she can talk
about baseball and football statistics. There's no difference. It's all just, just part of,
part of life, part of living a good life of seeking out the best, the most enjoyable,
in the most natural way. And that's, that's what mom gave me. And I don't think there's
a more precious gift that, that any parent can give a child. I really don't. I, I can't even
imagine where I would be had it not been for her. And it wasn't just classical music. She
liked all kinds of music. She liked Randy Newman. She liked Harry Belafonte. She listened to the
Weavers. We listened to Peter, Paul and Mary. She really loved Broadway musicals. I mean,
in addition to Schubert's Unfinished, I mean, we had to listen, we couldn't imagine Housework,
a normal day of Housework without the roar of the grease paint or Paint Your Wagon or Pippin.
Just, just one wonderful and life-enhancing experience after another involving music.
And because it was just such a, a normal part of our lives, when I started to get into it,
I mean, it was my mother's record collection that got me into classical music. The first
piece that really hit me being the Steinberg Pittsburgh recording of Beethoven's Pastoral
Symphony, which a bunch of you have mentioned, I've noticed. So maybe we'll do some of that too
in the future. But wow, I mean, what a, what a wonderful gift. So, so I have to say thank you,
Mom. And it is with enormous pleasure that I play this recording featuring the Czech Philharmonic
under Carol Anscherl on superfund of the finale, the big tune at the start of the finale, the first
subject from Brahms' First Symphony. I know we all know it. Let's listen to it with some of the,
the love and naturalness that I grew up believing that this piece always had. I have to tell you
one particular story about this tune that was quite wonderful. When I was a kid, my, my parents
took me to see the Israel Philharmonic under Zubin Meder. They came to New Haven.
They were playing in Woolsey Hall at Yale University, which is a wonderful hall, by the way,
for any of you who've been there. And, and they were doing Brahms' First. And the program,
because it was the Israel Philharmonic, it was a, it was a concert that was done in association with
like, you know, the United Jewish Appeal or some sort of charitable thing. I mean, I was a little
kid. I don't remember all of that part clearly, but it was like a big event in, in, in the Jewish
life of, of the greater New Haven area. So everyone showed up, even people who were really
not terribly into classical music, just because it was the Israel Philharmonic under Zubin Meder.
It was a big deal. And they began the program with some really kind of terrible modern piece
by an Israeli composer. I even remember the title. It was called In Aeus Memoriam.
And I don't remember who wrote it, but I remember the title. And I remember it. Why?
Because as a nascent percussionist, it had a thunder sheet. And looking at the back of the
orchestra was this enormous piece of metal hanging up on the back wall. And of course you'd shake it,
it would go, you know, it was, it was one of these Holocaust memorial pieces that, you know,
people are now doing like 9-11 memorial pieces, and they're already starting to write pandemic
memorial pieces. You know, they're all, they're all sort of equal opportunities for music of,
of extraordinary pretense and, and minimum of, of artistic value. I mean, how do I say
it better than that? I mean, if you ever listened to like John Adams Pulitzer prize winning,
winning thing that he did for the 9-11 thing on the transmigration of souls, horrible. I mean,
you know, there's, there's, there's no way that people are going to successfully capture
the horror of those events in a tidy little musical piece that opens a concert. And this
piece, in addition to having the thunder sheet at the climax had a siren, like an air raid siren
that went off. And when that siren went off, a bunch of people got up and ran for the exits,
which I thought was hysterically funny. But anyway, during the Brahms first,
because there were lots of people there who don't normally attend these things,
they, some guy fell asleep. I don't know where he was exactly. I think at a balcony.
And he woke up in the middle of the slow movement and started applauding madly,
having no idea where he was and thinking he was missing out on it. And of course, the applause
immediately horrified everyone who was sitting there. Zubin Mehta turned around and stared up
at it with like daggers in his eyes. And I just remember the first violin section, just cracking
up. They all just lost it. They didn't stop playing, but they were all laughing. And it was,
other than that, quite a memorable recording, recording performance, live event. My first
live encounter with the first symphony of Brahms. So let's move on to the next selection,
because this is a double header. I wanted to give you something that's extremely familiar
with something that may be less so. And that less so comes, let me get this here,
from Mr. Magnus Crook. Magnus Crook, yes. And his suggestion is,
O malheureuse effigienie from Gluck's Effigienie in Tauride, Effigienia in Taurus. He writes,
this is a soaring, wistful, and yet luxuriously caressing melody, which is almost like a folk
tune in its apparent simplicity. And I want to stress something. I want to tell you something
about this tune and this piece. It is amazing. I mean, the title, of course, means, O unhappy
effigienia. And so that's all you need to know about the words. It's about how miserable she is.
But Gluck got this tune originally from his earlier opera, at Opera Seria, called La Clemenza
di Tito, which you all know because that was Mozart's last opera. He set the same basic
libretto, although Mozart claimed the libretto was taken in hand and de-Baroque-ized to turn it
into a real opera. I actually like the Baroque version better because it actually gives more
characters more opportunities to sing good stuff. And one of the great arias, I mean a smash hit
from Gluck's La Clemenza di Tito, was an aria called Si mai senti sperarti sul volto, which
basically means, let me get rid of this glare thing here, I don't have to read anymore,
which basically means when I feel your breath on my face. That's the aria. And it was a classic
Baroque Opera Seria aria, a da capo aria, in ABA form. And the melody, which became O malheureuse
effigienie when Gluck reused it for the 1779 Paris version of Effigienie en toile, that melody
was the A section of the aria. But even back then, it was I think in the 1750s when he originally
wrote La Clemenza di Tito, that aria took the musical world by storm, blew everybody away.
And first of all, because of its harmonic audacity, but more to the point, the main aria,
this melody that Mr. Crook has so wonderfully suggested that we play, I'm so happy to see this,
and that I have a recording that I can play you. The amazing thing about this piece is that the
melody has an amazing structure. Apparent simplicity is what Magnus said, and Magnus is
right, because this is a completely non-repeating tune. It begins at the beginning and goes on
and never, ever repeats anything at all. It's one continuous melody. It is as potent and compelling
an example of endless melody as Wagner ever wrote. It really is. It's astonishing that in 1779 someone
was doing this. The result sounds absolutely timeless and in its way extremely modern.
It's amazing. And in this setting, in recasting this as a single number without the B section
that the Baroque opera Syria had, what Gluck did was add a chorus of priestesses at the climax,
the women's chorus comes in behind the voice in an absolutely thrilling, thrilling sonic panorama,
and voice and chorus, eventually just the chorus, bring the piece to a close. It lasts about three
and a half minutes, and as I said, it is one continuous non-repetitive melody. I can't even
begin to describe how astonishing that is and how amazing it still sounds. So I'm thrilled to have
this opportunity to play O Madre Reus et Virginie. This is the Orfeo recording, which I have sitting
here, there it is, featuring Pilar Loringar, who is not, or Loringar, if you can call it that way,
Pilar Loringar, who is really not the best voice for this part, but it's okay, you'll get the idea,
with Lamberto Gardelli on Orfeo. The other people in this recording are Franco Bonassoli
and Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau. It's an excellent cast. Gluck's operas are still not really well
understood, not performed as often as they should be, certainly not fully appreciated in the way
that they were back in the day. People talk about their revolutionary qualities, you know,
because he banished the conventions of opera seria in favor of this sort of continuous melody,
the Wagnerian ideal, which he was already doing back in 1770. And Wagner, of course, knew it
and tried to co-opt the Gluckian aesthetic by making an arrangement of Gluck's other Iphigenia
opera, Iphigenia in Aulis, you know, because Iphigenia really got around, you know, she was,
she's all over the place. You know, you can find her in Mozart's Idomeneo too, I mean,
where there is not an Iphigenia, there is no Baroque opera. But anyway, you know,
this is really magnificent music. And what gets me about it is not the, you know, revolutionary
qualities. It's, it's, it's, it's what Magnus says. It's expressivity, the just exquisitely
beautiful, ongoing lyrical outpouring. It's astonishing. So here it is. That was Gluck's
Aria O Madre Euse Iphigenie from Iphigenie en Tauride, the French version. There's a German
version too. There's, there's Iphigenie of Tauris. Anyway, an incredible, incredible piece of music
that I am thrilled to have the opportunity to share with you in this chat about the world's
most beautiful melodies. Keep sending me your suggestions. I know they're piling up,
but we're going to work our way through the pile. And I still want to know what you all think,
especially those of you who have not had the opportunity to send in anything. Please,
please do. Please participate in this. It's just wonderful fun, I think, for all of us. And if you
look at that amazing list of melodies of tunes and suggestions that we got, there's material here
for the next several years. And I'm going to take great joy in working through both the familiar
and the unfamiliar. And, and we can all talk about it together. So keep on listening, folks.
Thanks again. Happy holidays. Let's look forward to 2021. Take care.
